Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the recent changes to Air BnB will mean fewer people will book with them?

362 replies

Movinghouseatlast · 29/05/2022 10:14

Have you looked at Air BnB in the last 2 weeks and noticed the changes they have made to the website?

I ask because I have a glamping business and since the 'summer release' I have had no bookings at all. Absolutely there are issues with the cost of living/ energy crisis but it seems a bit of a coincidence that I was getting plenty of bookings before the changes happened.

I just wondered if from a consumer point of view if the changes are making a difference? I just think it's not user friendly any more!

I do have my own website but I have stuck with Air BnB as I have always had a lot of bookings and to me as a business they work out cheaper than other platforms like Canopy and Stars etc.

Thanks!

OP posts:
Confuseddotcombo · 29/05/2022 13:55

Why don’t owners get together and create their own booking platform, then reduce their prices undercutting the agents? It must be pretty cheap to run a booking website.

My DH has a similar online cooperative in his industry. It could be done on a local basis.

locok · 29/05/2022 13:54

Isn't there a lot more competition though? the stamp duty pause caused a surge in 2nd home sales. More people let out accommodation & anyone with some space can pop up a bell tent or a pod or hut.

bellac11 · 29/05/2022 13:53

I dont really know how its set up that the description is written. But it seems that some owners dont do themselves justice. For example Im looking for a stop off on our way to Scotland and back again

So Ive put in the location of North Yorkshire, I want options either side of the A1M

So looking around sort of Ripon I see some options and one in particular, self contained little place. In the description which is the first thing I read, it makes no mention of a couple of local pubs. It doesnt mention whether there is any bike storage so Im going to need to contact them for that but one might say thats not a standard thing although more and more families now have bikes for them and the kids.

Also the listing lists it as Guesthouse North Yorkshire rather than the village that its in. I wondered if there were restrictions to only mentioning geographical area but there are a couple in Ripon, one says private room Ripon and one right next to it says private room North Yorkshire. If I were an owner I would want to make sure its a precise as possible.

And as we have said on the thread, it wont confirm where it is exactly until booking so Ive had to use google maps to look at the satellite images to see where it is, easy in the countryside when theres only a few properties but that would be harder in the city.

francesfrankenfurter · 29/05/2022 13:51

I agree four stars for doing what you want is rubbish.
I hate the air bnb rating of guests as it can be so misused. And I have only had good ratings so this is not personal,

Doubleraspberry · 29/05/2022 13:48

Frannyhy · 29/05/2022 13:22

I will only take guests with verified ID and a photo for insurance reasons. Airbnb discourage third party bookings, so I must be sure that the person at the door is the person who booked. Any problems and they won’t pay for damage.

I include cleaning charges in the cost. I do not ask guests to strip beds or take rubbish out - I wear a mask and gloves and do that myself. However, the one in about a hundred who does this unasked get five stars, everyone else get four. Four stars is not a criticism it just means that the room and bathroom was left as I would expect.

The price some hosts charge for their spare rooms is bonkers. No matter what energy costs are doing, a spare room or SC accommodation is only worth what guests will pay for it. I have had rude messages from other hosts for undercutting, but they need to get real and not be so greedy.

This is what I mean about the review! I would be wracking my brains over the 4 star. If you want sheets stripping and rubbish taking out, then say so and I’ll do it. Your approach is a bit passive aggressive. Some hosts might actually not want the beds stripping (I had one in a holiday house years ago who asked us not to as people often piled them up in a room furthest from her machine) or the rubbish taking out (eg if it were put in the wrong place).

TalkSomeSense1 · 29/05/2022 13:44

'I wouldn't go Glamping if you paid me' So don't go Glamping then! I wouldn't stay in an all inclusive 3* resort in Marbella but I wouldn't come on here to dismiss the whole idea as it works for some people.

OP I also have a glampsite & holiday cottage (not a second home so not depriving anyone of housing stock. And we didn't hike our prices AT ALL over the last few years despite increased costs to us for laundry services, heat and light and so on) and the bookings for this year are coming in much later than they normally would. We're top spec with all 5* reviews too - we've done it for about 10 years - so I have my fingers crossed it picks up as it is our only income.

MissStarry · 29/05/2022 13:41

i dislike being charged a cleaning fee, but expected to strip sheets and clean everything to a very high standard before you leave sort of negates the need for said fee. (Which along with other fees, add a significant proportion to the price above the base rate)

There’s one extreme of trashing the place, but the other is having to leave it polished and immaculate.

I also strongly dislike the demand for ID and profile pictures and mutual reviews as it feels unnecessary, judgemental and intrusive.

It’s not a social media site; it’s a holiday booking site.

HolidayLetter · 29/05/2022 13:38

booking.com are a nightmare for owners, too... VRBO is the best of them.

HolidayLetter · 29/05/2022 13:37

IrisVersicolor · 29/05/2022 11:35

I really hate Airbnb, much prefer VRBO.

The site has evolved far away from its original premise, now it’s just a money making exercise on the part of the owners. The service charges have risen and risen as they get more and more greedy.

They don’t look after their owners and they don’t look after their travellers. They just look after themselves.

Agree with every word of this.

They don't care if guests wreck the property, so long as they get their money (bitter experience speaking).

billy1966 · 29/05/2022 13:32

I wouldn't go near AirbNb after multiple experiences of family and friends during the past couple of years.

Multiple early bookings, cancelled last minute, undoubtedly because of price increases.

Simply wouldn't trust them for a booking again.

Fizbosshoes · 29/05/2022 13:32

Air bubbles?? Air bnbs

Fizbosshoes · 29/05/2022 13:31

But surely where ever you stay it is still depriving a local of a home and the cottage could be on Airbnb as well.

I thought the same? Confused

infact I'd imagine the holiday let's through sykes/cottages etc are probably full time holiday rentals whereas some people use air bubbles to rent out the house they live in when they're not there.

I've used both and had mixed experiences. For last minute bookings or if I only want to go for a few days air bnb seems more flexible.

I'm unsure what I think the solution is to second homes and towns where holiday let's outnumber the residential homes? It is obviously a growing problem, especially in places like Cornwall. But people still want to go on holiday. (Even people living in holiday towns might go on holiday themselves) For almost any type of holiday accommodation, the land or building could be repurposed to make an affordable home. And if you go abroad you could potentially be contributing to the same kind of situation

lurchermummy · 29/05/2022 13:30

Airbnb in itself is just a portal, most people who own holiday let's a will list the same property on multiple different sites including booking.com. I agree it's not as user friendly but it's still very popular.

ElfinsMum · 29/05/2022 13:26

We used air BnB yesterday for the first time in ages. The new ID process was a complete nightmare as someone booking from abroad. Horrible. Not surprised your bookings are down, we were v close to giving up.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 29/05/2022 13:25

It does sound like ABNB have changed their search options which is causing yours to drop out because it’s not picking up your USP. Are there other platforms as an alternative?

I do think people are steering clear of ABNB though, we all saw the stories last year of price hikes and stays being cancelled because the owner could get a higher price. NOT that I’m saying that’s what’s happening here OP, but a general downturn on the platform might be exacerbating things.

Frannyhy · 29/05/2022 13:22

I will only take guests with verified ID and a photo for insurance reasons. Airbnb discourage third party bookings, so I must be sure that the person at the door is the person who booked. Any problems and they won’t pay for damage.

I include cleaning charges in the cost. I do not ask guests to strip beds or take rubbish out - I wear a mask and gloves and do that myself. However, the one in about a hundred who does this unasked get five stars, everyone else get four. Four stars is not a criticism it just means that the room and bathroom was left as I would expect.

The price some hosts charge for their spare rooms is bonkers. No matter what energy costs are doing, a spare room or SC accommodation is only worth what guests will pay for it. I have had rude messages from other hosts for undercutting, but they need to get real and not be so greedy.

Jofergo · 29/05/2022 13:20

@notanothertakeaway i think I worded my comment badly.
I’m worried about the impact of short term lets so I try to avoid self catering in general and use more “traditional” type accommodation.
in some parts of the country self catering would have been traditional so I try to book somewhere that hasn’t come out of the local residential property pool to become tourist accom but is either purpose built/converted. These properties are generally more readily available/ identifiable to me on the “cottage” websites.
I have also stayed in a former seaside boarding house that had been converted into an aparthotel by it’s current owner.

This seemed smart to me as it appealed to modern accommodation trends and kept the building in use for it’s original purpose.

i’m from edinburgh and have seen the city centre communities decimated by self catering accommodation.

Elphame · 29/05/2022 13:19

TheNoteIsEternal · 29/05/2022 10:41

Another who won't use them any more for the same reasons given. Last time a tried to book I found an affordable place, but they then hiked the prices by one third at check out once fees were included.
They need to be upfront about costs.

They are moving slowly that way.

Owners can opt to pay the guest charges which means that the price you see is much more reflective of what you will actually pay. A lot of owners don't like it though so it's very much a minority at the moment. It's mandatory for some though who use certain booking software so I don't think it will be long before Airbnb prices are much more transparent across the board.

Personally I look on Airbnb and then try and find an owners own website. It's generally cheaper there as the owner isn't paying any fees or commissions

francesfrankenfurter · 29/05/2022 13:18

The issue is that it is now easier to compare shepherds huts against other property at the same location.
Loads of holiday properties are by the beach and near restaurants. It is not a general use.

Stevie77 · 29/05/2022 13:17

Movinghouseatlast · 29/05/2022 12:54

I'm not too expensive, I don't believe I've said how much I charge.Believe me there are people who are too expensive, who charge double what I do!. I just had a review in which said 'worth every penny' This issue is happening for everyone not just me.

If people want a shepherds hut, they search for shepherds hut on the whole. I used to be able to differentiate myself with my title, it's pretty unusual to have a Shepherds hut so close to restaurants etc but now I can't advertise that unless they click on my listing! Obviously that's the same for everyone.

Change the name to ‘beach-side hut’ then?

BorisJohnsonsvomitbucket · 29/05/2022 13:16

I've only booked once with AirBnB. The place was great, close to everything. No hidden charges. But the messages from the host were timed and they seemed irritated about me asking impromptu questions. I'm an anxious soul! I much prefer booking.com but I must try VRBO too, I've heard good things.

francesfrankenfurter · 29/05/2022 13:16

So this is typical of shepherds huts. Over £100 a night for a weekend in July for a hut with no electricity, lanterns provided,patchy wi if, and shower and toilet in a separate hut. The interior does not even look that special. It is the location that looks attractive. But I would rather pay more and get something better at the location.

https://www.airbnb.co.uk/rooms/43721801?sourceimpressionnid=p3165382627665BaN75vq6B7j%2B6cp&guests=2&adults=2&checkin=2022-07-16&checkk_out=2022-07-18

bellac11 · 29/05/2022 13:14

SweetMystery · 29/05/2022 13:09

You are right OP.

I've just tried to filter my search to look for :
A Shepherds hut
By the sea
5*

I can search for either a shepherds hut or beaches but not both together.
The only way of doing it is through google search.
For example:
'Shepherd's hut, by the sea, Wales, 5*, Air B&B'

Air B&B's own search engine is crap.

I looked UK
then used the filters to choose shepherds hut, then by the beach, a huge number have come up, some are very clearly in places where there would be restaurants nearby but without knowing whether I want Padstow or Devon or somewhere else as they're dotted all about the UK, its difficult understanding what the issue is

When Im looking for holidays I tend to choose location first, for example I might want to go to Padstow, I tend to look for cottages/houses/apartments or tiny homes. I dont want a room in someones house unless its self contained. So once I put in Padstow I use the map to look at whats there.

starlingdarling · 29/05/2022 13:13

thecatsthecats · 29/05/2022 13:03

I'm always being told by owners that it's cheaper to book direct, but whenever I check their website, I find that the prices listed are the same.

And frankly, I'm happy to use booking.com for the convenience and flexibility of booking choices unless I've stayed somewhere before.

I've found the same. If I'm not saving money I'd rather go with a known website. I'm not such a fan of Air BnB these days. The hidden charges make it difficult to compare prices so I stick to booking.com which is easier to navigate and has some real hidden gems.

SweetMystery · 29/05/2022 13:13

Fifi0102 · 29/05/2022 13:03

It's not really surprising is it op. UK tourist accommodation providers hiked their prices massively last year as people were stuck here. Now people can go abroad with guaranteed good weather and it's vastly cheaper. I got 2 weeks in Crete for 1350 flights included. The UK holiday sector had a chance to make the market more popular but they have shot themselves in the foot by massively increasing prices. It's a hut not luxury accommodation the smoke and mirrors thing is annoying.

I agree with the price hike thing last year definitely.

Last year, our favourite place (log cabin) shot up from the usual 1100 pw to 1950 pw. For the same weeks. Unbelievable!

I didn't even bother looking this year.

Swipe left for the next trending thread