Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the recent changes to Air BnB will mean fewer people will book with them?

362 replies

Movinghouseatlast · 29/05/2022 10:14

Have you looked at Air BnB in the last 2 weeks and noticed the changes they have made to the website?

I ask because I have a glamping business and since the 'summer release' I have had no bookings at all. Absolutely there are issues with the cost of living/ energy crisis but it seems a bit of a coincidence that I was getting plenty of bookings before the changes happened.

I just wondered if from a consumer point of view if the changes are making a difference? I just think it's not user friendly any more!

I do have my own website but I have stuck with Air BnB as I have always had a lot of bookings and to me as a business they work out cheaper than other platforms like Canopy and Stars etc.

Thanks!

OP posts:
Movinghouseatlast · 29/05/2022 15:51

locok · 29/05/2022 15:29

We clean to a much higher standard than you would typically at home - how often does the average person remove every crumb from the toaster or wash out the cutlery drawer? Clean the oven and the oven racks? These are routine changeover tasks.

But that's my point, not everyone would clean to that standard & guests are different. We never used the oven in our last stay because we ate out call the time. I would expect a cottage to take a couple of hours not a hut though.

What you 'expect' and the reality of a job I've been doing for 6 years are different. I wish it took less time, that would be more time on the beach for me! I have to clean a hot tub, barbecue, fire pit, 2 sets of garden furniture and a bathroom, kitchen, oven, fridge, windows inside and outside, hose down the patio, weed the garden.....

OP posts:
Movinghouseatlast · 29/05/2022 15:44

francesfrankenfurter · 29/05/2022 15:00

By the way I do regularly clean my cutlery drawer. It takes very little time if done regularly

Christ you are contrary aren't you!!! You are giving me a good laugh now actually. You seem to know so much about it all. We can all breathe a sign of relief you won't be darkening our doors eh?

OP posts:
Ormally · 29/05/2022 15:44

I've always been a fan of Booking.com, mainly because there is a fairly generous cashback offer that is connected to it, with a child savings account and scheme I use. For a week, that has occasionally put £15-£35 'back' into the account. However, one flat I booked through there this summer was a very convoluted process, that seemed to have been placed on the site by a company operating from France (but were all UK flats/cottages). It had all of the passport related uploading and cross checking, and no useful information was given until the very last minute, such as the key safe details and location. The actual number of the flat was also concealed and given last minute (they had entered a different one for the site, and even that was only findable in advance on the map page once booked). Reviews were good, and it was a nice flat, but a couple of people had commented that blankets had been moved from the beds (they were folded on top of the duvet) to the lounge, and they had been charged because of that. So all of this made me a lot more on edge and I think this could really spoil a stay,

For Airbnb, I would tend to try there first if I need somewhere on my own for work or shortish visits where I would be out most of the time, as long as I got a good feeling about the host. I'd be looking out for a double room for the price of many hotel singles, with a nice bathroom and perhaps a quieter night than a hotel.

Tubbytenbums · 29/05/2022 15:35

Hathertonhariden · 29/05/2022 10:35

Perhaps because more people are seeing Airbnb as having a negative impact on the local community? Whether that's raucous partying or depriving locals of somewhere to live so that they can do tourist industry jobs. Obviously a glamping site is less likely to be an issue

I live in the rural Highlands. The communities have been decimated by AirBnB. It's the new Highland clearances.
My valley has about 15 houses, on 7 have full time residents. The rest are Air BnB. The community has been destroyed

pixie5121 · 29/05/2022 15:30

I actually am a fan of glamping and would love a two-night break, but I wouldn't want to pay a lot for it because it just feels like poor value for money. At the end of the day it's a glorified tent in a field. I paid over £100 per night last year because I was desperate to be somewhere other than my flat and London, but that's no longer the case.

locok · 29/05/2022 15:29

We clean to a much higher standard than you would typically at home - how often does the average person remove every crumb from the toaster or wash out the cutlery drawer? Clean the oven and the oven racks? These are routine changeover tasks.

But that's my point, not everyone would clean to that standard & guests are different. We never used the oven in our last stay because we ate out call the time. I would expect a cottage to take a couple of hours not a hut though.

Firkinhavinalaugh · 29/05/2022 15:26

@bellac11 it is likely to be because we aren’t a 52 week proposition, therefore (glamping under canvas) we don’t operate between October-April as it isn’t a viable proposition.

That is why the algorithm is screwing us (that came straight from the horses mouth) so glamping has been hit by this (from what I understand).

We worked really hard last year to set up a name for ourselves, I was furloughed and depressed and it gave me some purpose. The success we had was really helpful mentally and financially and so this totally lack of interest (after a busy last season) is demoralising :)

PriestessofPing · 29/05/2022 15:21

Well perhaps the loaded people who want to spend crazy money on something which compares quite negativity with other destinations aren’t seeing your listing as you say then. But perhaps you’d get a better range of people who’d like to stay in a little hut but don’t fancy paying through the nose for it if you priced it differently.

FWIW i’d stay in one of those huts if it wasn’t so expensive as i quite like camping. I just wouldn’t pay more than the cost of a lovely holiday abroad. Or anywhere near the cost. And since we are in a cost of living crisis I expect people who feel similar will grow as time progresses. 🤷‍♀️

Firkinhavinalaugh · 29/05/2022 15:18

@francesfrankenfurter we agave had repeat business through previous clients who came directly to us. Which is great and we are happy about ☺️ But no new enquiries which is frustrating.

What we aren’t is a week long glamping vacation, we are long weekend/one night stays - get out of the city etc. it’s really strange that no one has expressed any interest for the super short break (bearing in mind it’s a nightmare to use some airports for a “mini-break”) although I too would prefer to go abroad AND having attempted to book a week in the UK know how ridiculous some prices are 🤦‍♀️

I almost wonder if people think it’s going to be crap to stay with us as we aren’t expensive enough……

bellac11 · 29/05/2022 15:15

Firkinhavinalaugh · 29/05/2022 15:10

@bellac11 yup the cleaning charge will either go up (it’s incredibly low currently) or I will make it far lower and the customer will have the option to do their own cleaning of the facilities.

But as I say, it’s not the glamping that’s the issue, or the location, or the price, it’s the algorithm that’s the problem.

We have other avenues for marketing which don’t seem to have a problem (with pricing or filling the dates)but part of the attraction of Airbnb is the marketing/support etc that you receive from them which means for me it is easier to run as a side income in addition to a full time job.

I dont necessarily say glamping is the issue as I know people like different things

But as others are saying, if particular owners on airbnb are booked out for months and months, then its not the algorithms surely otherwise no one would be particularly successful

What would change about the algorithm to make it likely that you get bookings, what would be different for me the customer if I was looking for your property?

francesfrankenfurter · 29/05/2022 15:13

But share your listing and we can tell you if it seems nice and is simply air bnb

francesfrankenfurter · 29/05/2022 15:11

@Firkinhavinalaugh I booked in uk last year and left a good review. The place I stayed was lovely. But this year I can get a better deal abroad.
If air bnb does not work for you, try another site to advertise on. But surely you would be getting people rebooking who have been before if it was just about algorithms?

Firkinhavinalaugh · 29/05/2022 15:10

@bellac11 yup the cleaning charge will either go up (it’s incredibly low currently) or I will make it far lower and the customer will have the option to do their own cleaning of the facilities.

But as I say, it’s not the glamping that’s the issue, or the location, or the price, it’s the algorithm that’s the problem.

We have other avenues for marketing which don’t seem to have a problem (with pricing or filling the dates)but part of the attraction of Airbnb is the marketing/support etc that you receive from them which means for me it is easier to run as a side income in addition to a full time job.

CoralPaperweight · 29/05/2022 15:10

I like AirBNB as it allows you to book shorter stays. So many of the more 'traditional' holiday / cottage companies expect you to book 7 days and the customer service is appalling. I'm not as keen on booking.com as I find the descriptions / photos misleading at times and you have to read the small print very very carefully to be sure of what you are getting.

Just been on AirBNB and see that the listings have changed - to be honest I prefer the shortened titles - some people advertise 'luxury' but it isn't luxury IMO or 5 star when it clearly isn't.

OP I think the problem is that a lot of owners put their prices up massively post Covid and frankly it is hard to justify in some cases. IMO some of the glamping sites are way overpriced when they don't have what I class as basic facilities (eg washing machine / driers) available for guests. Not saying yours is like that but you might want to review your prices

AlistairCamel · 29/05/2022 15:08

Also to add to my last post, their Shepherds Hut property is starting from £200/night but sleeps four. It’s typically fully booked. I’ll have a look at bookings tonight and see if bookings via Air B n B have gone down like you’ve seen.

bellac11 · 29/05/2022 15:08

Movinghouseatlast · 29/05/2022 15:00

These are the changes I'm talking about! The owners probably have a nice title, but Air BnB have taken those away and it makes it confusing for guests.

If you click the map function in your search this is how you see the exact location. It shows the map with all the properties as a square with a price. Then scroll along the bottom of the map to look at all the properties. It's the best function on the website now!

Map - yes i use the map all the time, its the only way I have ever viewed the site. The properties are not shown in their location, they're not far from it but not on the exact location which is important sometimes if you're wanting to know what side of a busy road the property is on, on a particular side of the village or not.

Description - well some owners clearly have more precise descriptions than others. So right now looking at a 'guest suite in North Scarle' so that tells me that the accommodation is in a particular village and that its a self contained section of an annex/house etc. Another one says 'apartment in Melmerby'. But other respective descriptions are 'tiny home in Nottinghamshire' or 'tiny home in North Yorkshire' which is far far less descriptive for the customer

So yours should be Shepherds Hut in Padstow, or wherever it is.

francesfrankenfurter · 29/05/2022 15:06

That one is booked out for months so is doing something right.
OP is not getting bookings. So it is not as simple as air bnb.

AlistairCamel · 29/05/2022 15:06

What else do you do from a marketing POV? I market four properties (owned by the same people) and they have always been on air B and B. However they’ve tried to push sales through their own website as it’s better for them and their customers. It’s maybe worth doing similar. So use your own website, social media, online ads, e.t.c, and boost your sales that way.

Movinghouseatlast · 29/05/2022 15:05

PriestessofPing · 29/05/2022 14:49

But that one is over £100 even in November. God only knows what’s being charged in the summer months but from what I can make out from similar properties, very likely to be at least £150 per night.

Even in November, that hut is more expensive than a whole villa next to the sea in Sardinia, in season.

I just think U.K. prices have become crazy when booking airbnb type accommodation. Yes, that shepherds hut has a hot tub and looks nicely kitted out but at the end of the day it’s still a shepherds hut, tiny, and you’d probably freeze your ass off in November.

If people want a beach holiday and access to the great outdoors why would they choose the hit and miss u.k. weather, when you can go abroad and enjoy amazing wildlife, scenery and beaches for similar or even less money?

Because people like it? Because they want a short break and not get on a plane? Because they are loaded and £150 a night is nothing to the.? Because people are different and like different things?

Did you read the reviews? The people who booked and paid £150 a night loved it, even in November!

OP posts:
Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 29/05/2022 15:03

garlictwist · 29/05/2022 14:56

Although I did see a tent in someone's garden being advertised on AirBnB for £80 a night. I wonder if they got any bookings...

Sounds like greed to me. I would be expecting breakfast, lunch, dinner and a bottle of champers for that price. Along with full access to bathroom and changing facilities.

pixie5121 · 29/05/2022 15:03

Firkinhavinalaugh · 29/05/2022 14:51

Op I’m with you - literally not a whiff of interest!

We have glamping on Airbnb. we also charge separately for cleaning - I think I undercharge and will be reviewing this going forward. Especially as we have a composting toilet and I literally have to pick up peoples shit. Unbelievably people can’t crap in a loo, they can around it, on top of it etc but not actually IN IT. If someone wants to complain about the cleaning charge, they’re welcome to clean up their own shit 🤣.
I also have to do several loads of washing, ironing etc and it takes me far longer than 1 hour 🤦‍♀️

You're not entitled to interest.

Going abroad is far better value and is what the vast majority of people would much rather do. We were all trapped here last year because of travel restrictions and insane covid test prices and desperate to go anywhere at all after three horrendous lockdowns.

I went to the south coast early last summer and it was the worst holiday and biggest rip off of my life. No way am I paying those prices again for mediocre accommodation, dodgy weather and bad food. I'll get on a Eurostar and have a break in the French countryside or a quaint little town with amazing bistros and cheap wine.

Bit weird how your solution to nobody booking with you is to charge even more for cleaning, as if it's somehow your guests' fault that you have to actually do the work involved in running a glamping site.

Firkinhavinalaugh · 29/05/2022 15:02

@francesfrankenfurter we were fully booked last year, even when everything opened up. We also had lots of enquiries - we’ve had born.

as it is you don’t know how much I charge for the night or the cleaning so perhaps ask those questions first?

also you’d be surprised about how happy our guests have been with the facilities - just because it’s not for you doesn’t mean that being off grid isn’t for everyone. we’ve had amazing reviews and never had any complaints about our pricing (under 3 figures).

It isn’t to do with the current state of the economy, it’s well known that it’s to do with how the algorithms have changed, it’s depressing that after working hard at it for the last year this algorithm has meant we have to try and start all over again, but this time with no clear access to guests.

Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 29/05/2022 15:01

I don’t book with Air Bnb because I’m my opinion it is taking homes out of circulation. There are loads of them in my home town and locals are finding it hard to buy and landlords are turfing out tenants and properties bring let as holiday homes instead. Rents have become sky high too.

bellac11 · 29/05/2022 15:00

Firkinhavinalaugh · 29/05/2022 14:51

Op I’m with you - literally not a whiff of interest!

We have glamping on Airbnb. we also charge separately for cleaning - I think I undercharge and will be reviewing this going forward. Especially as we have a composting toilet and I literally have to pick up peoples shit. Unbelievably people can’t crap in a loo, they can around it, on top of it etc but not actually IN IT. If someone wants to complain about the cleaning charge, they’re welcome to clean up their own shit 🤣.
I also have to do several loads of washing, ironing etc and it takes me far longer than 1 hour 🤦‍♀️

So you've had no interest but you think you'll put the prices UP?

How is that likely to pan out (no pun intended)

Perhaps its better to re build if you can and put a property that is attractive to people and easier to clean anyway

Movinghouseatlast · 29/05/2022 15:00

bellac11 · 29/05/2022 13:53

I dont really know how its set up that the description is written. But it seems that some owners dont do themselves justice. For example Im looking for a stop off on our way to Scotland and back again

So Ive put in the location of North Yorkshire, I want options either side of the A1M

So looking around sort of Ripon I see some options and one in particular, self contained little place. In the description which is the first thing I read, it makes no mention of a couple of local pubs. It doesnt mention whether there is any bike storage so Im going to need to contact them for that but one might say thats not a standard thing although more and more families now have bikes for them and the kids.

Also the listing lists it as Guesthouse North Yorkshire rather than the village that its in. I wondered if there were restrictions to only mentioning geographical area but there are a couple in Ripon, one says private room Ripon and one right next to it says private room North Yorkshire. If I were an owner I would want to make sure its a precise as possible.

And as we have said on the thread, it wont confirm where it is exactly until booking so Ive had to use google maps to look at the satellite images to see where it is, easy in the countryside when theres only a few properties but that would be harder in the city.

These are the changes I'm talking about! The owners probably have a nice title, but Air BnB have taken those away and it makes it confusing for guests.

If you click the map function in your search this is how you see the exact location. It shows the map with all the properties as a square with a price. Then scroll along the bottom of the map to look at all the properties. It's the best function on the website now!

OP posts: