Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not want to donate money but instead donate things?

64 replies

12yearsinazkaban · 29/05/2022 10:07

Just thinking about how food banks get food donations. People are actually putting food into a box.
Charity shops get donations of items.
But the school fund for example, asks for monetary donations.
HOWEVER they just had a party and one class teacher asked for food rather than £2 for the party food. We were chatting and she said she gets more 'donations' for food rather than money.
it reminded me of my children's old nursery) and they asked for seasonal items to be donated for activities (conkers collected for free, but also Easter chick's and stickers for crafts, mini pumpkins for Halloween activities, Xmas bits and bobs for Xmas crafts etc) and they always got loads of donations. Whereas their school now always ask for 1 or 2 pounds and sometimes the activity is cancelled due to lack of donations.

I think it goes further too where people find it easier to buy a homeless person food rather than give them money

I'm just wondering if people find it easier to donate items rather than money? I think the feeling of giving something is more powerful than giving money. i wouldn't ever donate money,I just don't have it spare, however while I'm shopping I do have space in my shopping trolley for bits and bobs asked for. I don't know why it feels different but handing over a bag of party food or craft items feels more helpful, more tangible, rather than sending in a pound.

Does any one else feel this way? I know it seems stupid but if a food bank or the school ask for money it feels sort of cheeky, but asking for donations of xyz seems different somehow.
perhaps its related to the 'you don't ask for money for a wedding or birthday' thing people do.

OP posts:
OversBo · 29/05/2022 19:41

Another thing, the food banks asking for individual packets to distribute easily. I know it makes sense but a big bag of pasta from farm foods is £2.50, you would have to pay 10x that amount to buy the same amount of food in 500g packets. so I don't trust their judgement. surely I could donate 10kg of pasta and it could he distributed in jars people bring or plastic takeaway boxes. but that's a health and safety risk so instead just donate 2x 500g bags instead. I just couldn't give away my money for so little value.

Completely impractical. If you give a giant bag of pasta to a food bank to distribute to users, you are in effect asking them to source, purchase and store large takeaway containers or jars. They are expensive!

You are asking them to create legally compliant labels With the knowledge of what that entails plus labelling equipment. You’re probably also looking at an elastic band around each one to avoid it falling open…a cost and admin burden on the food bank.

GlamorousHeifer · 29/05/2022 13:46

I don't like giving money to large charities full stop....it mainly lines fat cats pockets and I am dubious as to how much filters down to those that need it.
On a smaller local scale like schools or local food banks I would be happy to give what they asked for.

12yearsinazkaban · 29/05/2022 13:33

Another thing, the food banks asking for individual packets to distribute easily. I know it makes sense but a big bag of pasta from farm foods is £2.50, you would have to pay 10x that amount to buy the same amount of food in 500g packets. so I don't trust their judgement. surely I could donate 10kg of pasta and it could he distributed in jars people bring or plastic takeaway boxes. but that's a health and safety risk so instead just donate 2x 500g bags instead. I just couldn't give away my money for so little value.

Also as others have said, asking for non value items (this is personal to me) in an area where most people are on the bread line anyway is extremely tone deaf. If people are hungry (and some aren't we are allowed to mention that, my own family members and some friends included in that) they won't mind having a crappy tin of beans. in fact I prefer the aldi ones to hienz.

some nasty comments about people changing their minds after asking for help, they probably borrowed some money off their mates instead. it's shameful asking strangers for food, it's absolutely embarrassing as hell. use your brain for a second please. what did you want them to do, dampen your toes with their tears of joy?

OP posts:
woodhill · 29/05/2022 13:04

I think you have a valid point and sometimes I feel the same

YouHaveYourFathersBreasts · 29/05/2022 12:50

I’d rather donate cash to school, preferably on parent pay as I don’t often have cash in my purse.

The food bank is different- I’m at the shops
anyway so I can grab some stuff while I’m there. Charity shop is again not the same- we’re doing each other a favour. I have stuff to get rid of, they want stuff to sell. Win win.

riesenrad · 29/05/2022 12:33

Testina · 29/05/2022 11:42

” i wouldn't ever donate money,I just don't have it spare, however while I'm shopping I do have space in my shopping trolley for bits and bobs asked for.”

You’re contradicting yourself. If you have 50p for an extra packet of pasta, you have 50p in money. You just get more of a kick from giving A Thing.

No, I get what the pp means. If they donated cash they'd probably have to donate £5 minimum depending on the context. But if you donate a couple of tins, it has only cost say £1. It's much less money.

Loopyloopy · 29/05/2022 11:57

Unfortunately, for many charities, things rather than money can be worse than useless. As pp have mentioned, things cost money to store and move, and whatever it is that you want to donate often isn't what is actually needed.

User65412 · 29/05/2022 11:54

I'm a teacher and tbh we lean more and more towards asking for money. Our parents can donate online though.
I asked for items to refill our school play costume box recently (list of items eg hats and made it clear nothing was expected and just anything you might donate to charity anyway) and it was mostly stuff not good enough to donate to chariry that I had to throw away (like dad's old work t-shirt with car oil on it). Even if I'd had £100 donated (600 children at the school) I could have been to the charity shops myself and got a good selection of bits.
We also asked for food for a jubilee party and despite suggesting specific things for each year group (eg. savoury ks1, sweet ks2) we just ended up with hundreds of packets of chocolate bourbons which say 'May contain nuts' so we can't use them (whole other thread needed for that rule!) so in that case money for us to buy a picnic may have nene better.
I do understand that times are very hard for our families though so hate asking for money. It's such a shame there's no budget for these kind of things anymore, especially in schools in deprived areas.
It's not that I want be 'controlling charity'. I'm just trying to be more cost efficient to get the best for our children.

TooBigForMyBoots · 29/05/2022 11:50

I dont mind money or giving it as a present. If I'm going to give, then it's about what's most needed/wanted by the recipient, not about my warm and fuzzies.

dontgobaconmyheart · 29/05/2022 11:44

It strikes me as being a bit like when people don't want to give cash or gift cards as gifts to other people and would rather spend the same amount or more buying something that ultimately they want to buy, that leaves them feeling in some way good or more thoughtful or they enjoy that experience of choosing and buying or whatever it is it does for people when the recipient would much rather the cash or gift card (teen DNiece and Nephew as prime examples!).

When I realised this and realised it was only about what was being asked for and what was needed was not mine to judge and it wasn'y an opportunity to indulge my own need, I just stopped. I'd just provide whatever was being requested by the school/food bank/whatever and assume those running it were best able to judge which resources and what format would be of most practical use, and what they currently have the staff to handle and deal with.

Botoxbotox · 29/05/2022 11:43

I'd be delighted to ping the school a fiber on the app,rather than send in endless bloody milk bottle lids, conkers, things that a yellow, and other random shit they want.
Some people value time over money, some don't need the warm fuzzy glow of actually putting a box of cornflakes in the foodbank basket. I'm happy to take the path of least resistance, which is usually money.

Testina · 29/05/2022 11:42

” i wouldn't ever donate money,I just don't have it spare, however while I'm shopping I do have space in my shopping trolley for bits and bobs asked for.”

You’re contradicting yourself. If you have 50p for an extra packet of pasta, you have 50p in money. You just get more of a kick from giving A Thing.

Kendodd · 29/05/2022 11:40

I really struggle morally donating to food banks. In that I hate the things and think is shames every single one of us (especially x a million those in positions of power in the country) that there is such extreme poverty in the country. If I donate, i worry that that perpetuates and condones the need for them instead of addressing the root cause.

I remember about ten years ago my local supermarket had a collection bin for the local animal shelter, I used to happily put stuff in there. Sometimes I'd buy milk drops or some other treat for them. So yes op, donating 'stuff' did make me a lot happier in that case than donating money. It was replaced with a food bank donation bin. Donating to a food bank just makes me angry, no warm fuzzy feeling in that.

PeopleAllergy · 29/05/2022 11:39

So if someone donates a bag of food to the food bank, they walk away feeling good about themselves and the food bank has food. So 2 good things.

As long as the food bank is requesting food, then there’s nothing wrong.

But say for example the food bank says ‘we do not need pasta or rice, thank you’. Food banks have limited storage, so if everyone continues to gives them pasta and rice, so that they feel they have done a good deed, that actually pretty shitty as it has consequences for the food bank. Continuing to give them pasta and rice just says they should be grateful for anything they get, which isn’t a nice attitude. They try to ensure people get a balanced diet from what they have in stock and if their storage is full of things they already have enough of, they won’t be able to store and provide people with other foods.

Thatswhyimacat · 29/05/2022 11:38

I prefer to donate money and normally assume that it is more useful to a charity or homeless person who knows their needs better than I do, or in charity or food bank cases can leverage mass buying to get more things for my money than I can.

Schools asking for the odd quid though, that's annoying because I don't carry cash and haven't for years. I'd have to go to a cashpoint, go to a shop to break a note and then have a load of change I won't use.

Switchin · 29/05/2022 11:35

12yearsinazkaban · 29/05/2022 11:29

Well what's wrong with that? why do you have to donate the right way?
I don't want people to think I cam only afford 50p, but I have 3 packs of unopened stickers in the drawer from Christmas, so I'll give those... why? because it suits me. If the teacher said 'actually only cash please' I'd give nothing.

There was an episode on friends where phoebe is trying to do a selfless act of kindness and she can't do it. because giving or being kind made her feel good. but what is wrong with that? So if someone donates a bag of food to the food bank, they walk away feeling good about themselves and the food bank has food. So 2 good things.

it does feel cheeky asking for people to do charity in the proper way.

The only thing I don't agree with is people donating clothes to send to Ukraine. money would be better to send over seas.

That being said, I have been on the receiving end of 'controlling charity' refused obviously as its embarrassing and it didn't feel nice, but I'd still rather people give with strings than not give at all.

I think you have it all backwards to be honest.

Donating something useless because it makes you feel good isn't just failing to be selfless, it's actively inconveniencing another person. If you try to donate something and they turn it away, it's because it's not a useful donation and you're essentially just giving them a job to do (to throw it away) rather than actually helping.

Sometimes donating items is just as, if not more, useful than donating cash. But, if it's not then it's not - trying to donate useless items to a cash drive is done purely for your own ego and makes other people's jobs harder.

With Ukraine, the reason we needed to donate stuff and not money is because they could just go and buy clothes, could they? What use is money when you're freezing cold all the shops are empty? People weren't driving truckloads of clothes to Ukraine because no one told them how money works.

onlywork55 · 29/05/2022 11:33

I don’t personally feel like this OP (because I’m disorganised and find it easier just to give money!) but at a population level I think your theory is correct and I find it really interesting.

When the war in Ukraine started, some local organisations stopped accepting donations and asked for money instead and a few people got quite nasty about it on Facebook. They genuinely didn’t seem to understand why the money would be more practical and seemed to see it as greed.

I also think we all accumulate a lot more stuff these days and people like to have an easy way to offload it which also makes them feel good. I used to volunteer in a charity shop and so many of the donations were absolute rubbish and not sellable. I know that’s a really cynical viewpoint and obviously not everyone behaves/thinks like this but it is a factor!

12yearsinazkaban · 29/05/2022 11:29

Well what's wrong with that? why do you have to donate the right way?
I don't want people to think I cam only afford 50p, but I have 3 packs of unopened stickers in the drawer from Christmas, so I'll give those... why? because it suits me. If the teacher said 'actually only cash please' I'd give nothing.

There was an episode on friends where phoebe is trying to do a selfless act of kindness and she can't do it. because giving or being kind made her feel good. but what is wrong with that? So if someone donates a bag of food to the food bank, they walk away feeling good about themselves and the food bank has food. So 2 good things.

it does feel cheeky asking for people to do charity in the proper way.

The only thing I don't agree with is people donating clothes to send to Ukraine. money would be better to send over seas.

That being said, I have been on the receiving end of 'controlling charity' refused obviously as its embarrassing and it didn't feel nice, but I'd still rather people give with strings than not give at all.

OP posts:
PeopleAllergy · 29/05/2022 11:22

12yearsinazkaban · 29/05/2022 11:17

right but isn't it better to have 20 people donating stuff because they enjoy it than 4 donating cash because they are oh so selfless

Not always. Storage can be an issue in some cases. Some things can’t be used. Some people just donate shit they want to get rid of and then it can cost to dispose of it. It’s better to just donate what is asked for.

Switchin · 29/05/2022 11:19

Xfox · 29/05/2022 10:33

"i wouldn't ever donate money,I just don't have it spare, however while I'm shopping I do have space in my shopping trolley for bits and bobs asked for."

But unless you are shoplifting it, you are spending extra money anyway. However I do get that giving a "thing" makes it less obvious how much you have donated compared to someone donating 50p Vs the next giving £5. Also on a selfish level it is often a more enjoyable experience buying something than just handing over the cash.

This was my thought too. Does OP think supermarkets are free!?

In my opinion, I think:


  1. People are less skeptical when they're donating an item - like when giving food to a homeless person, you know they aren't spending it on drugs or alcohol or gambling, which many people have judgements about.

  2. A lot of the things OP mentions are free (like conkers or feathers) so, yeah, people are more willing to give away things that cost them nothing.

  3. With charity shops etc, people give away stuff that they don't want anymore - money doesn't go out of fashion and children don't grow out of money. It's not really comparable.

  4. Also, when you donate an item, often you can look more generous than if you donate cash - for example if you got the item on sale or got cash back when you bought it or you're re-gifting something.


So, yes people prefer to donate stuff rather than donate money - but it's pretty obvious why.

12yearsinazkaban · 29/05/2022 11:17

PeopleAllergy · 29/05/2022 11:08

I donate whatever is asked for as I trust those asking to know what is needed better than I do.

This. It’s not about what you find more powerful or enjoyable.

right but isn't it better to have 20 people donating stuff because they enjoy it than 4 donating cash because they are oh so selfless

OP posts:
12yearsinazkaban · 29/05/2022 11:14

Xfox · 29/05/2022 10:33

"i wouldn't ever donate money,I just don't have it spare, however while I'm shopping I do have space in my shopping trolley for bits and bobs asked for."

But unless you are shoplifting it, you are spending extra money anyway. However I do get that giving a "thing" makes it less obvious how much you have donated compared to someone donating 50p Vs the next giving £5. Also on a selfish level it is often a more enjoyable experience buying something than just handing over the cash.

I know! It just is easier for my brain to let go of the thing than to let go of the money.

I suppose also, lots of people use cards not cash so if the school need money i need to go to a cash point (all cost £1.85 to withdraw or I have to get the bus (which is more!) to withdraw £10. then I have to spend some to get change. So giving the school £1 actually costs me closer to 5.

Another thing is sating the have to donate to charity selflessly. Well I can't. if it doesn't feel good I won't do it I think. I don't give to charity or donate to food banks by the way. But I do give my old stuff to charity shops and try to give the children however much for their school fund raising schemes. I don't think it's bad to wait to control the help you give? you control what presents you give for Xmas. Christmas shopping is fun isn't it?

I agree with the poster saying they don't know why they bother with bake sales when it costs more to bake the cakes than they sell for. I think maybe it's because you can control it better.

I think my point Is that if you want 100 people to give donations but you only ask for money you might get 50.
But if you ask for 100 people to donate and you ask for tins you might end up with more because some people find it easier to give things rather than money. I'm rambling.

OP posts:
girlmom21 · 29/05/2022 11:14

I don't mind giving a homeless person money rather than food. They might not need food but might need a new hat or want to buy a hot drink later in the day or whatever.

I'd rather give nursery an item donation because I never know how much I should donate money-wise and it can be as cheap or expensive as you want to make it without feeling like someone might judge you if you're having a skint monthS

PeopleAllergy · 29/05/2022 11:08

I donate whatever is asked for as I trust those asking to know what is needed better than I do.

This. It’s not about what you find more powerful or enjoyable.

motogirl · 29/05/2022 11:04

It depends, our food bank accepts both because random donations don't always fill the shelves evenly, the monetary donations can buy items to fill the gaps