Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not want to donate money but instead donate things?

64 replies

12yearsinazkaban · 29/05/2022 10:07

Just thinking about how food banks get food donations. People are actually putting food into a box.
Charity shops get donations of items.
But the school fund for example, asks for monetary donations.
HOWEVER they just had a party and one class teacher asked for food rather than £2 for the party food. We were chatting and she said she gets more 'donations' for food rather than money.
it reminded me of my children's old nursery) and they asked for seasonal items to be donated for activities (conkers collected for free, but also Easter chick's and stickers for crafts, mini pumpkins for Halloween activities, Xmas bits and bobs for Xmas crafts etc) and they always got loads of donations. Whereas their school now always ask for 1 or 2 pounds and sometimes the activity is cancelled due to lack of donations.

I think it goes further too where people find it easier to buy a homeless person food rather than give them money

I'm just wondering if people find it easier to donate items rather than money? I think the feeling of giving something is more powerful than giving money. i wouldn't ever donate money,I just don't have it spare, however while I'm shopping I do have space in my shopping trolley for bits and bobs asked for. I don't know why it feels different but handing over a bag of party food or craft items feels more helpful, more tangible, rather than sending in a pound.

Does any one else feel this way? I know it seems stupid but if a food bank or the school ask for money it feels sort of cheeky, but asking for donations of xyz seems different somehow.
perhaps its related to the 'you don't ask for money for a wedding or birthday' thing people do.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
12yearsinazkaban · 30/05/2022 18:38

See, I agree in a way. But on the flip side, most people go to the shop, most people have stopped using cash. If those big boxes for foodbanks in the supermarket had a little sign saying 'we don't need beans or pasta but we do need uth milk and baby food jars please' and then someone changed it if they got too many donations of the same thing? to stop the confusion

our school had maybe £100 worth of food donations or craft donations or whatever else they asked for, but for monetary donations they receive fewer, maybe £50. I just thought it was so interesting that people gave actually things over money. I don't know if it's because giving 70p would look cheap but putting 2 tins of 35p beans in the box isn't cheap, or embarrassing. So if you can afford to put one tin of beans in even.

I know that in the party thing for the class people were spending on average less that 1 pound for an item to bring. There was a list to check off and everyone contributed. Some did extra. so what was asked for was given and them some. However when people were asked for money (please god bare in mind I am talking about a low income area, a school for mostly deprived children) hardly anyone contributed. Especially when they were asked for £2 or £3 which Is loads! Especially if you have multiple children (generally people have 3/4 but some have 8 and even 9!) so giving things can be done easily.

obviously when I give to charity shops though I shit in bags and call it gold.
I think charity shops should do the same thing, ask for things.

I mostly donate children's clothing, not shit. and I put all the unwearable bits and bobs in for rags.

Perhaps the difference In charitable habits comes down to income? imagine going to set up a monthly payment of 70p to the local food bank. you wouldn't bother.

But people in deprived areas tend to be deprived and people in affluent areas tend to be affluent so the people in the deprived area ends up with nothing being donated because they are all in the same boat? but the rich people up the road have their boxes filled and their school fund is regularly donated to and so the school dies better their children do better while ours have to say good bye to our TA and get told off for using too much glue. But if they asked for coloured paper and gluesticks I stead of setting up a time consuming fund raising scheme they could have saved the faff and had a bring a glue stick or pack of white board pens to school day. if the habits of people tend to be that way. I know what i mean

OP posts:
HandyGirl76 · 30/05/2022 18:07

As someone who runs a charity we always put money to better use than "things". We can get more bang for our buck with cash. So if you donate 4 cans of beans we'd probably get 5 cans for the cash equivalent.

What you're describing is about the giver getting what they need rather than thinking about what the receiver needs. I understand your point that it's more tangible though.

LouisRenault · 30/05/2022 17:59

With Ukraine, the reason we needed to donate stuff and not money is because they could just go and buy clothes, could they? What use is money when you're freezing cold all the shops are empty? People weren't driving truckloads of clothes to Ukraine because no one told them how money works.

Shops in countries adjoining Ukraine are open. Many of them sell clothes, possibly cheaper than in the UK. With cash, relief organisations on the spot could get what they needed within a few hours, without the added time and expense of transporting everything across Europe, and then finding it might not be what was wanted by the time it got there.

12yearsinazkaban · 30/05/2022 17:32

myammus · 29/05/2022 22:09

you remind me of those people on Facebook who film themselves giving a homeless person a sandwich

lol I've never given to a food bank my post was originally written because of my child's school asking for food donations rather than money and it's got a lot more parents giving. it was supposed to be about how people prefer to donate xyz money or things. I only mentioned food banks because they are a place where it is common to give physical items.

I don't think I'd ever give to a food bank because I can't afford it and even if I could why the fuck should we be feeding people who work aswell! instead of them being paid a fair wage and/ or benefits. I think its letting the government off the hook. in fact I don't give to any charity, not one. But I will bung a quid in the box for a manky cake at my kids school if they moan about it enough. And I begrudge that.

OP posts:
caringcarer · 30/05/2022 12:11

I find it easier to donate money as then don't have to run around collecting things.

DaisyDozyDee · 30/05/2022 12:09

I think the mindset is “I don’t want to feel guilty about waste and landfill, so I will pass that problem on to someone else”.

Ragwort · 30/05/2022 08:14

balalake but how can you be sure things you are donating are actually used, as I said earlier, I receive lots of donations in my charity shop .. people like to think they are doing a good thing by donating but if the items cannot be sold then I just have the task of throwing them out ...someone said to me last week 'these clothes have moth holes in but I've washed them and sprayed them with moth killer- I am sure you can find a use for them' Shock Shock. I refused to accept them and she got quite stroppy and said 'but I've carried them all the way into town'!!!

balalake · 30/05/2022 08:09

I'd rather things be donated and used than thrown away or hoarded.

ElephantsFart · 30/05/2022 07:39

Also giving goods distracts us from the awfulness of food banks existing by making us feel good. Food banks shouldn't need to exist and everyone who supports their local food banks should write to their MP to tell them so. People on benefits got a 3.5% rise this year when inflation is running at a 40 year high.

ElephantsFart · 30/05/2022 07:36

Oh yes, @Mooda is absolutely spot on. I give £10 a month to my local FoodBank because it’s what the food bank finds most useful. That way, they can also spend it on their bin collection or some other essential that they need to operate within the law.

Those baskets for collecting donations in the supermarket just make more profit for the supermarket.

DaisyDozyDee · 29/05/2022 23:01

Mooda · 29/05/2022 22:54

It depends if you think the giving is about your feelings or about the benefit to the person receiving it.

This is so absolutely right.

Mooda · 29/05/2022 22:54

It depends if you think the giving is about your feelings or about the benefit to the person receiving it.

Ragwort · 29/05/2022 22:51

You say you like to donate your 'old things' to charity OP ... do you consider what you are donating ... I manage a charity shop and you would be amazed at the absolute rubbish we get donated (along with some very nice donations of course). Less than about 25% of what is donated is actually saleable and the shop and volunteers are left with the problem of sorting through soiled clothing, broken toys, dog eared paperbacks etc etc. and trying to recycle responsibly.

Similar to food bank donations .. not all food banks want yet more tins of beans, pasta or sanitary products (disclaimer - some FBs might want these items but you do need to check with your own local FB)

DaisyDozyDee · 29/05/2022 22:39

User65412 · 29/05/2022 11:54

I'm a teacher and tbh we lean more and more towards asking for money. Our parents can donate online though.
I asked for items to refill our school play costume box recently (list of items eg hats and made it clear nothing was expected and just anything you might donate to charity anyway) and it was mostly stuff not good enough to donate to chariry that I had to throw away (like dad's old work t-shirt with car oil on it). Even if I'd had £100 donated (600 children at the school) I could have been to the charity shops myself and got a good selection of bits.
We also asked for food for a jubilee party and despite suggesting specific things for each year group (eg. savoury ks1, sweet ks2) we just ended up with hundreds of packets of chocolate bourbons which say 'May contain nuts' so we can't use them (whole other thread needed for that rule!) so in that case money for us to buy a picnic may have nene better.
I do understand that times are very hard for our families though so hate asking for money. It's such a shame there's no budget for these kind of things anymore, especially in schools in deprived areas.
It's not that I want be 'controlling charity'. I'm just trying to be more cost efficient to get the best for our children.

It’s alarming how little people seem to think about what they are donating to schools. We get bags and bags of donations of baby books and adult books. Too often, even if they’re age appropriate, the donations are scribbled on, ripped, chewed, dated, faded or otherwise unsuitable.
Sometimes the donations are absolute treasure though - when pristine copies of recently published popular books appear, it’s like a beautiful miracle.

YetiTeri · 29/05/2022 22:28

MissTrip82 · 29/05/2022 10:16

It comes from a desire to control and a belief that the people you’re helping are feckless wasters who will make poor choices if given the dignity of a choice to make.

So no. I don’t feel more like I’m giving if I give what I want to give under the conditions I want to give it rather than giving the equivalent monetary value, no matter how small, and always within what I can afford, to the person in need or the informed people managing these charities who surely know far far more than I ever will.

This.

fUNNYfACE36 · 29/05/2022 22:27

OversBo · 29/05/2022 10:51

Sleeping rough must be grim, I agree.

Bake sales in theory work because you are taking inexpensive ingredients and donating your time to create something that sells at higher value. Or that’s the theory anyway!

i often see bake sale items priced lower than the cost of the ingredients, let alone cooking costs

Dazedandconfused10 · 29/05/2022 22:26

The amount of charity Ceos on 6 figure sums make me not want to give physically money to charity.

Shelter doesn't provide housing to people, and is single handedly ruining the rental sector so housing will be in even more of a crisis. They deserve no funds whatsoever.

myammus · 29/05/2022 22:09

you remind me of those people on Facebook who film themselves giving a homeless person a sandwich

carefullycourageous · 29/05/2022 22:05

MissTrip82 · 29/05/2022 10:16

It comes from a desire to control and a belief that the people you’re helping are feckless wasters who will make poor choices if given the dignity of a choice to make.

So no. I don’t feel more like I’m giving if I give what I want to give under the conditions I want to give it rather than giving the equivalent monetary value, no matter how small, and always within what I can afford, to the person in need or the informed people managing these charities who surely know far far more than I ever will.

Agree with this.

I like to give money because then the person or organisation receiving can spend it as they see best, and they know better than me.

Thestoppedfan · 29/05/2022 21:58

I prefer stuff. I never carry cash so if they asked for £1 I would have to go out of my way (and remember to) draw out a tenner and spend some to get the change. Whereas add it to the shopping list and it’s easy, it’s not about the amount it’s about the convenience of it for me. Same for the food bank if it’s part of something I’m already doing then it’s easier for me to do.

WarmSausageTea · 29/05/2022 21:50

I would much rather give money. We got some stuff for our local food bank while we were at the supermarket last week, and there was so much to think about… what might they want/not want? Is it better to get more of a cheaper product, or get less of something higher quality? Larger bags to be decanted, or smaller packs? Plus our local place uses gift aid, so they’ll get more from a monetary donation, and they might be able to get more goods for their money than we can.

So for me, giving money is my strong preference, but there’s no right/wrong way to give; people do what’s right for them, and I wouldn’t presume to tell anyone how to do it.

Luredbyapomegranate · 29/05/2022 21:39

How it the name of Christ is a food bank asking for money cheeky?

Obviously donating (most) food is helpful, but money if you have it is better as they can control their stock, and the same is true for most charities.

If you have unwanted stuff that someone else could use, great. But giving isn’t primarily to make you feel good.

DownToTheSeaAgain · 29/05/2022 21:34

Surely if it is a charity or cause that you want to support and they ask for money you give money. If they ask for stuff you give stuff. It is the opposite of helpful to do what you want to do rather than what they ask. Charitable giving shouldn't be about making you look good or satisfying your desires it is about supporting the charity.

hedgehogger1 · 29/05/2022 21:21

I prefer to donate money. Properly with gift aid. So they get even more of the donation

TooBigForMyBoots · 29/05/2022 21:10

I think you should just not donate if you're that bothered 🙄@12yearsinazkaban.

Swipe left for the next trending thread