Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ex and his baby?

40 replies

vrrroooom · 29/05/2022 01:52

Haven’t posted in ages on here but I’ve lurked for a long time and don’t have anyone in real life I can speak to about this so thought I’d come here.

I've just found out that my ex (5 years broken up) has had a child. I’ve been in a relationship since this and I don’t hold any feelings for this man whatsoever. I don’t currently want a child in this current world and I don’t have any sort of “it should’ve been me” feelings, I'm truly happy for him and I congratulated him as I know he’ll be a great father. Here’s where I guess I need advice or to be told I'm being unreasonable I'm not sure I guess?

We stayed friends after our split and he was a big part of my life and we talk amicably often. It was my first long term relationship. When he told me today over text I don’t know why but I immediately became emotional and burst into tears? I’m so confused why and I feel like I just can’t speak to him anymore. I told him this and since then he’s accepted that, told me to take time to process my feelings and said when I’m ready I can see the baby if I want to and that he hopes I’ll be okay. Why am I feeling like this? I feel like a terrible person but I truly don’t understand my feelings at all.

Sorry if this isn’t the right place to post this I just didn’t know who to talk to about it because I just feel like nobody will understand and I’m quite embarrassed I’m affected this way about it :(

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AnneLovesGilbert · 30/05/2022 21:34

Have you told your partner about all of this? That your ex has become a dad? How hard you’ve found it and that you’ve told the ex you’re no longer staying in touch? I’m sure you have given how you wanted your ex to be open with his wife, so what’s his take?

fridaRose · 30/05/2022 17:23

I can’t understand what you’re implying though? I said I don’t want to associate with him anymore since he has a child with someone else as it’s not appropriate! *
*
But it was 'appropriate' before he had a kid, and you had a purely platonic friendship? A true platonic friendship you described would not succumb, if one party had a child and suddenly things because 'inappropriate'.

OP I'm glad you're moving on. And cutting contact Flowers

aSofaNearYou · 29/05/2022 17:40

I think it's more that saying "I think it's best we don't communicate anymore" is inherently an odd response to this news from someone you supposedly have a platonic friendship with. It instantly implies you have feelings for him.

Testina · 29/05/2022 17:38

I’m not trying to imply anything, I am trying to be straightforward in just saying what I think.

In your OP you said this:

“I’m so confused why and I feel like I just can’t speak to him anymore. I told him this and since then he’s accepted that, told me to take time to process my feelings and said when I’m ready I can see the baby if I want to and that he hopes I’ll be okay.”

All this telling you to process feelings and hoping you’re OK and waiting until you’re ready… that sounds like my initial reading of the situation: that there were histrionics. Even if via text.

But now you say that you simply said it wasn’t appropriate to stay in touch now he has a child? Why would that prompt any of the stuff about hoping you’re OK and you needing to be ready? Doesn’t make sense.

Why we’re you OK with being friends before the baby, if not now? Either it was an appropriate relationship between the two of you, or it wasn’t.

You know it wasn’t - hence the emotional outburst now.

BadNomad · 29/05/2022 17:32

Is it that "end of an era" feeling? He was a big part of your life for a long time. But having a baby has put him on a new life path, one that you're not on yet.

vrrroooom · 29/05/2022 17:22

Testina · 29/05/2022 16:53

Right. That poster was me. So I can confirm that poster said nothing about you wishing the child ill will - not anything that could be misconstrued.

As the mother of this child, I would think, “what the fuck is this woman playing at* telling my partner that she’s upset and can’t see him because he’s had a baby”

*playing at = the games

You may not know what game you were playing, but you were trying to do something. Otherwise you’d have said, “oh that’s lovely - congratulations” - then phased him out. I would very much wonder, as the mother, why you decided to share your histrionics with him.

I can’t understand what you’re implying though? I said in my initial post I congratulated him when he told me and then said I don’t want to associate with him anymore since he has a child with someone else as it’s not appropriate!

I didn’t decide to share histrionics with him, he told me, out of the complete blue, completely off topic that he had a child and I became emotional for whatever reason I don’t know and promptly told him I think that now I know this it’s for the best we don’t speak anymore. He didn’t know I cried, didn't see me, didn’t comfort me, all I did was tell him wow I’m shocked, I think it’s best we don’t communicate anymore then. I feel like you’re implying he had to soothe me like some spoilt brat when it was a single text exchange. As I said I’m probably not going to answer anymore as I’ve explained the interaction multiple times now

OP posts:
Testina · 29/05/2022 16:53

vrrroooom · 29/05/2022 15:56

This was in response to the poster who said if they were the mother they wouldn’t want me/‘my games’ around the baby. I was just confirming that there are no ‘games’ and I don’t want anything to do with him or the child. Sorry if this was misconstrued.

Right. That poster was me. So I can confirm that poster said nothing about you wishing the child ill will - not anything that could be misconstrued.

As the mother of this child, I would think, “what the fuck is this woman playing at* telling my partner that she’s upset and can’t see him because he’s had a baby”

*playing at = the games

You may not know what game you were playing, but you were trying to do something. Otherwise you’d have said, “oh that’s lovely - congratulations” - then phased him out. I would very much wonder, as the mother, why you decided to share your histrionics with him.

ladydimitrescu · 29/05/2022 16:33

I still think it's harsh that you have made the birth of his child about you.
If you no longer want to be around him, you just say congratulations and ignore him
And move on.
Not tell him you can't speak with him anymore and that's the reason why, that's completely unnecessary and absolutely makes it look like you're playing games.

vrrroooom · 29/05/2022 15:56

Testina · 29/05/2022 15:29

”I don’t want this painted as some sort of ill will towards the child because that’s not what it is whatsoever hence why I told him I can’t speak to him anymore.”

That’s a really odd thing to say. Literally nothing on this thread, no-one, has suggested you have ill will towards the child!

This was in response to the poster who said if they were the mother they wouldn’t want me/‘my games’ around the baby. I was just confirming that there are no ‘games’ and I don’t want anything to do with him or the child. Sorry if this was misconstrued.

OP posts:
Testina · 29/05/2022 15:31

“When we initially reconnected I wasn’t aware he was in a relationship and when I found out”

Definitely sniffing around then.

Testina · 29/05/2022 15:29

”I don’t want this painted as some sort of ill will towards the child because that’s not what it is whatsoever hence why I told him I can’t speak to him anymore.”

That’s a really odd thing to say. Literally nothing on this thread, no-one, has suggested you have ill will towards the child!

diddl · 29/05/2022 15:26

The thing is it's unlikely that anyone can tell you why you feel like you do.

Some of it does read as if you were happy to just take any crumbs he gave you.

If you're not going to have anything to do with him anymore then none of it matters really.

Don't waste headspace on him!

vrrroooom · 29/05/2022 15:21

diddl · 29/05/2022 14:14

After we split we went no contact for around 2 years and it was him who reached back out to me and that’s how we came to speak again.

You didn't have to re connect though just because he wanted to or continue it when you knew he had a gfriend.

When we initially reconnected I wasn’t aware he was in a relationship and when I found out he was I made sure he told her we were communicating. Admittedly it’s my fault for continuing casual conversation which I accept. I probably won’t respond to anything more on this thread as I feel slightly like I’m being bullied for something I already admitted to being unreasonable for. I was just looking for advice/clarity on the situation.

OP posts:
vrrroooom · 29/05/2022 15:19

Testina · 29/05/2022 14:02

He’s really an arsehole though, isn’t he?


  • comes sniffing back round you when he has a girlfriend

  • won’t tell his girlfriend about that (like I said - reluctant to? No shit 🙄)

  • handily doesn’t mention he’s having a baby

  • and then tells you basically you can meet the baby when you’ve calmed down? Hmmm. Do you think his girlfriend would like you round him and her child, given your reaction AND your decision to tell him about it. I’d be telling the pair of you to keep your little games away from me and my baby

I cannot express enough how much I don’t want to be around him or the child. I was prepared to be told I was being unreasonable because I said in my opening post I was and I posted this so I could try understand why I was feeling the way I am, not to be told off for it because ultimately I know my reaction is disproportionate. There’s no games whatsoever as I’ve said before I’m in a happy relationship and despite the fact he said to me I can see the baby when I want/feel ready I have no desire to see his baby which he’s had with somebody else. I don’t want this painted as some sort of ill will towards the child because that’s not what it is whatsoever hence why I told him I can’t speak to him anymore.

OP posts:
diddl · 29/05/2022 14:14

After we split we went no contact for around 2 years and it was him who reached back out to me and that’s how we came to speak again.

You didn't have to re connect though just because he wanted to or continue it when you knew he had a gfriend.

Testina · 29/05/2022 14:02

He’s really an arsehole though, isn’t he?


  • comes sniffing back round you when he has a girlfriend

  • won’t tell his girlfriend about that (like I said - reluctant to? No shit 🙄)

  • handily doesn’t mention he’s having a baby

  • and then tells you basically you can meet the baby when you’ve calmed down? Hmmm. Do you think his girlfriend would like you round him and her child, given your reaction AND your decision to tell him about it. I’d be telling the pair of you to keep your little games away from me and my baby

Testina · 29/05/2022 13:39

Some bloke you haven’t spoken to for 2 years after a split comes sniffing around and is reluctant to tell his girlfriend (no shit!) that he’s doing so. Why did you bother with him?

No, it’s not “normal” for the person in your role to push the person in his into reluctantly telling his girlfriend. Normal is to walk away from that shit show.

So how do you know if he ever did tell her? Did he? Because you say it’s even more important now they have a child.

Are you not hurt that this guy didn’t tell you about the pregnancy?

Sounds like he was keeping it quiet for a reason 🤷🏻‍♀️ (Refer you back to my comment about sniffing around)

Aprilx · 29/05/2022 13:39

vrrroooom · 29/05/2022 13:26

This is important actually as it was me who pushed for him to make her aware of our contact which he instigated. I can’t stress enough I told him that if he didn’t I’d tell her myself despite absolutely nothing romantic happening and she is aware that we speak/spoke when we do.
After we split we went no contact for around 2 years and it was him who reached back out to me and that’s how we came to speak again. I don’t think I view him as some sort of ‘special’ friend since I’ve got plenty other friends of both genres I speak to within the same dynamic. Maybe it’s just shock I truly don’t understand

I have an ex that broke my heart, went on to have a family and I found I could not (I am now 52 so never will). But I have never felt remotely upset that he has a family because I was over him by the time I heard. So I immediately thought you cannot be over this man, your update makes me think this even more.

I find it strange that you seemed to want to force him to tell her off this innocent friendship, I think maybe you want it to be something that it isn’t. Your response to his news was also out of place.

For your own well-being, you need to cut him loose properly and move on.

vrrroooom · 29/05/2022 13:34

Testina · 29/05/2022 13:31

So how do you square “big part of my life and we talk amicably often” with someone who doesn’t bother to tell you they’re have a baby?

And you didn’t stay friends after the split as you said - you were no contact for two years!

I still think that you just see yourself as more important in his life (historically and now) than you actually are. Hence having to “push” him and insist that his girlfriend knows he’s friends with you. Sort of honourable, but also sort of patronising and not your business to push. That’s you putting yourself in the position of “special” again. And, again - apologies for being brutal - you’re not, if he didn’t even tell you they were expecting a baby.

I don’t think it’s honourable I think it’s normal. I wouldn’t want my partner talking to his ex without me knowing and his reluctance to tell her annoyed me so I don’t think I’m unreasonable to push for that, even moreso now they have a child?

OP posts:
vrrroooom · 29/05/2022 13:31

theobligatorynamechange · 29/05/2022 07:18

I don’t hold any feelings for this man whatsoever.

I don’t currently want a child in this current world

I know he’ll be a great father.

By any chance, do you want to have a baby, but your personal circumstances aren't right and you don't feel like you should bring a child into the world because the world is a flaming pile of crap right now? I wonder if it's less about your ex having a baby and more about the injustice of how you don't feel like you can, even thought you know you'll be a great mother too.

I'm not saying have a baby or don't have a baby, I'm questioning whether you're fed up with the state of the world and this disillusionment/anger has found a way out.

5 years broken up

I’ve been in a relationship since this

he was a big part of my life

It was my first long term relationship.

You've dated since. But you haven't really had the same grand love affair again, have you? So your ex still represents idealistic love for you - even if you don't want him, you want that kind of love with someone again, and seeing him move on and tick all of the 'normal' milestones is going to hurt, not because you want them with him, but because you want them.

Incidentally, your ex owes you nothing. His status as your ex will always trump his status as your friend. He has a family now, and if his partner doesn't wan't you around because of your ex status, he'll dump you in a heartbeat, because his family takes priority. Maybe on some level you realise that, and that's been part of what's so upsetting, but even if you haven't seen that, you need to be less reliant on him.

Friends aren't aways permanent, but exes who are friends are even more likely to suddenly fall out of our lives. He might have been a big part of your life once, but you cannot keep him as such by talking to him often. It's not doing you any good.

That’s the thing and why I’m so confused! I do want a child just not right now because I’m still relatively young. I don’t think it has anything to do with romantic feelings lingering though as I’ve been in a relationship for 4 years and love my current partner who I do see myself having a child with dearly?

OP posts:
Testina · 29/05/2022 13:31

So how do you square “big part of my life and we talk amicably often” with someone who doesn’t bother to tell you they’re have a baby?

And you didn’t stay friends after the split as you said - you were no contact for two years!

I still think that you just see yourself as more important in his life (historically and now) than you actually are. Hence having to “push” him and insist that his girlfriend knows he’s friends with you. Sort of honourable, but also sort of patronising and not your business to push. That’s you putting yourself in the position of “special” again. And, again - apologies for being brutal - you’re not, if he didn’t even tell you they were expecting a baby.

HugoTheBoss · 29/05/2022 13:31

Testina · 29/05/2022 10:01

of course, you feel what you feel… but it was really weird - and unfair - to dump that on him.

I agree. Why did you tell him? It makes it seem like you still have feelings for him (which I'm not convinced you don't).

If my husband had told his ex that he'd burst into tears when he found out she'd had a baby I would be really annoyed. It comes across like 1. You still have feelings and 2. You want him to know you still have feelings.

Of course you can still have feelings on it, that's uncontrollable but I don't think you should have told him. That's unfair on him, the mother of his child, and your partner imo.

vrrroooom · 29/05/2022 13:30

clumperoo · 29/05/2022 09:20

I think you should just cut ties and move on. There's no point being friends with an ex. Be civil and friendly if you see them out ajd about bit don't keep in touch. You dont need to see the baby

Yeah I said in my message I can’t speak to you anymore, apologised and I don’t plan to speak to him again. When he said I could see the baby when I felt ready I jus decided I don’t want to but it would probably have felt too rude to say that so I just left it

OP posts:
vrrroooom · 29/05/2022 13:29

Thing is even though we have history I wouldn’t really consider us to be ‘best friends’ or anything more regular than a friend. We barely see each other (I’m talking less than 3 times a year, lives in a completely different area etc) and communicate mostly over text so it’s just strange I felt emotional since it’s not even like it’s being thrown in my face or anything

OP posts:
vrrroooom · 29/05/2022 13:26

This is important actually as it was me who pushed for him to make her aware of our contact which he instigated. I can’t stress enough I told him that if he didn’t I’d tell her myself despite absolutely nothing romantic happening and she is aware that we speak/spoke when we do.
After we split we went no contact for around 2 years and it was him who reached back out to me and that’s how we came to speak again. I don’t think I view him as some sort of ‘special’ friend since I’ve got plenty other friends of both genres I speak to within the same dynamic. Maybe it’s just shock I truly don’t understand

OP posts: