Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think of you’re slim and pretty you’ll never “get it”?

295 replies

drivetosurvive · 28/05/2022 21:09

Just to preface by saying I know we all have hang ups and insecurities- especially now with social media and filters etc

I have two close friends. One always asks me what I’m going to wear when we meet up. I hate my body and I’ve gained a lot of weight (size 14 now 20/22 so never been slim) I rarely buy clothes and just wear whet I fit into that day. I’ve been so blunt as to say “I’m fat so whatever I can find that I don’t hate” when I got fed up of that question … yet she still asks even now.

Other friend is very pretty, she gets a lot of attention and always has. I don’t want to date right now due to feeling very down about my looks and weight and she says “well men should like you for you” … which the sentiment is true but I don’t like me for me so why should a man? And it’s not easy to put yourself out there and she’s gorgeous so she’s never really had an issue of men not finding her attractive.

Aibu to think that both of them are slim and pretty and therefore having experienced what I’m going through?

OP posts:
5128gap · 29/05/2022 16:51

Having been both fat and slim, my life is immeasurably easier slim.
Yes I get harassed by men, more so than when fat. Yes, it's unwelcome and can be intimidating. But there is literally no comparison between having men whistle from vans and shout 'hello sexy' to being called a fat bitch, a dog, being laughed at when jogging, or having chips thrown at you.
Sometimes now I find it hard to find clothes that fit me on my waist. Sometimes I think my legs look skinny. So I take my waistband in or wear trousers. Does this equal the misery of hours in changing rooms trying to fit into clothes not made big enough for my body, and then spending a fortune on a 'flattering cut' and still not liking how i look? Not evenly slightly.
As a slim woman, do I suffer insecurity? Of course. I worry about health, aging, whether I'm good enough at my job, a decent parent, partner, friend. When I was a fat woman I worried about all that too, but also about my weight.
All the 'slim women suffer too' posts remind me of the money doesn't equal happiness claims, that are equally annoying. Of course being rich or slim doesn't make you immune from problems. But it does mean they're not compounded by the added challenges of being poor or overweight.

Iwonder08 · 29/05/2022 15:53

OP, if they are your friends, what is stopping you plainly and openly tell them not to talk to you about clothes as you find it upsetting? Also you can dress size 6 horribly and size 20 beautifully. As an interim solution as I gathered you want to lose weight for health reasons, you should buy some nice clothes in your size from a decent shop that targets your sizes. Not as a last minute emergency reaction to whatever invitation, but as a planned shopping with no specific agenda. Maybe you will find it less frustrating.
I think you are probably right.. Someone who has never been fat will struggle to fully comprehend what you are going through. Even though I know full well there are miriads of serious and valid reasons why people are obese I still sometimes think they just need to put more effort in.

SisterAgatha · 29/05/2022 12:55

@Goatinthegarden perfectly put!

Your post is exactly why I also lost 5 stone and got healthier. It wasn’t ever to look better, it was entirely for health reasons and you are so right it is a constant struggle not to go back to old habits. Every weight and every look and every person has their own problems.

AbsolutelyLoveIy · 29/05/2022 11:53

To be honest, I think in a lot of people’s eyes, once you’re fat, its just fat. It’s like infinity fat cells

it works the other way too, i put in a stone and nobody noticed which was actually really depressing 😩

anyway, back the cake…

40andlols · 29/05/2022 11:00

Just to add... I recently lost 7 stone (now size 14 so not "skinny")and my friends absolutely flat out don't believe it because they "didn't even think I was fat"... they don't get it at all

40andlols · 29/05/2022 10:58

No I really don't think they'll ever get it. I think it's because they don't really see you as any different to them. They probably genuinely want to know what you're wearing... like they ask each other.

You feel like a different breed, your friends see you as the same.

But what they won't understand is how strangers treat you differently, and media etc etc. Maybe try to explain?

Redouble · 29/05/2022 10:01

The replies are mostly negative, but the poll is much more balanced, with 53% agreeing with OP.

Personally I don't see any rudeness in OPs posts, but I definitely see her frustration with posters completely missing the point making twisting things out of shape.

pixie5121 · 29/05/2022 09:56

It's true, though. OP has been really rude to some posters on this thread. You don't get to abuse others just because you're feeling low.

The question in the OP was if it's unreasonable to think if you're slim and pretty you'll never get it, and yes, many people think it is unreasonable. Why ask the question if you just want to get defensive and be rude to anyone who doesn't agree?

Nobody is entitled to friends. If OP keeps treating people this badly, she's going to end up alone on top of everything. Part of being an adult is accepting that sometimes you're the problem.

Redouble · 29/05/2022 09:33

You sound really bitter and nasty and not great to be around.

Projecting much? What a horrible post.

Goatinthegarden · 29/05/2022 09:31

I’m sorry you’re feeling bad OP, and yes it’s true that someone slim may not understand what it is like to be very large, but one could argue that very overweight people don’t understand the struggle that some people have to stay thin.

I used to be about three stone over my healthy BMI and couldn’t run ten steps. Two years later, I’m nearly four stone lighter and in good shape. It’s not easy though. I regularly say no to food and drink that I would love to inhale. I cycle a nearly 20km round commute every weekday in wind, rain and shine, even when I feel knackered or a bit shit. On top of that, I do four HIIT sessions a week, run, climb mountains and mountain bike (I leave for work at 7am and get home just before 6pm). I meal plan and cook from scratch every day so I eat fresh, wholesome food. I get derogatory comments from people all the time about how much energy I have, how I don’t stop moving, how I’m ‘wasting away’ and how I should just eat the cake in the staffroom.

I choose to push myself like this because my (previously fit and healthy) dad spent the last three years of his life suffering from numerous debilitating illnesses (which are all potentially hereditary) and could barely leave the house. Whilst he was housebound, he used to love me sending him photos from the tops of mountains. I will not waste time sat on the sofa when I could be out enjoying my good health and fitness.

I don’t think anyone is unattractive and if people choose to be overweight, that’s up to them. I do find it difficult however, to listen to people bemoan being unhealthy and unfit when they don’t want to put the effort in to change. If though you have a health issue, which means you cannot lose weight, then I do sympathise.

stopthepain · 29/05/2022 09:30

I wouldn’t be surprised if your friends started to make excuses not to see you again. You sound really bitter and nasty and not great to be around.

Your first friend just wanted to know the dress code. She didn’t want to hear your rant about being fat. You second friend was being friendly and asked about your dating life.

I am naturally very slim despite what I eat. I am body shamed and used to cover up in my early 20s and teens. I’m now in my mid 20s and I don’t care about what other women think. Let them shame me. Let them give me dirty looks. Those women sound like you.

Knittingchamp · 29/05/2022 09:26

OP what are they meant to say? They sound like nice friends who want you to feel happy. And if you say 'whatever I won't hate' every time they ask, and they still never comment, that's actually really nice, as it's a depressing comment to hear over and over again! They won't know what it's like to be you, and you won't know what it's like to be them, that's just how life is.

Naunet · 29/05/2022 09:19

Your friends don’t know what it’s like to be you, no. And equally, you don’t know what it’s like to be them. None of us know what it’s like to be another human and drawing lines in the sand that states anyone thin must be having a more positive experience of life is stupid and ignorant. It’s projecting your problems out into the world rather than looking at yourself and making changes to improve your life. You’re not helpless in this, you can make changes if you decided to.

I was abused as a toddler, if fucked me up, but I don’t spend my life feeling bitter that my friends will never know what that’s like to experience or how it’s impacted me, how I’m left with PTSD that means just getting a smear is traumatising.

Ask your friend to stop asking you what you’re wearing, simple as that. No need to get irritated that she doesn’t know it’s something you’re sensitive about.

collosalbrainbearer · 29/05/2022 09:08

For a slim person, choosing an outfit is about what you fancy wearing that day, what's appropriate etc. For a bigger person, it's also that but also about finding something that just bloody fits and looks even half okay and hides all the worst bits you dislike about yourself, only to stand in front of the mirror feeling utterly hopeless realising there's no magic outfit that will hide the size you hate that you are.

I agree with this but want to add that big and thin (not slim) women are in the same boat. Those with model type figures can also struggle. I have to give away clothes because they are too short on me or don't fit right. They make me look like I'm on stilts, some trousers. And it can be upsetting when you can't wear anything above the ankles without looking ridiculous.

So those who are on the opposite end of the scale, very thin, do understand. Her friends were just trying to be supportive.

Dinotour · 29/05/2022 08:57

drivetosurvive · 29/05/2022 00:32

I don’t want sympathy, I don’t tell anyone any of this in real life. I pretend to be happy. I think a lot of people with depression do.

Reach out to people. Tell friends how you feel. Im sure if they're decent people they'll be mortified by how they're making you feel- if you haven't spoken to them about it then how would they know.

forinborin · 29/05/2022 08:55

Unattractive women and attractive women won't ever understand lived experiences of each other, they might as well be different biological species. Your friends probably mean well, OP, but not from a very informed point.

Redouble · 29/05/2022 08:36

A lot of nasty, bullying posters on form I think I this thread. At no point has the OP been rude, she's been nicer than I'd have been! Sorry you've had this pile on, OP. Some just enjoy being knobbish. Ignore.

Anyway - lots of people missing your point, which is simply that people who have always been slim/pretty have no idea how it feels to be overweight. I've been at both ends of the scale, and you're right.

You're not saying that slim/pretty people don't have any problems ffs, or can't suffer with awful self esteem or dislike how they look - of course they can.

But there are definitely experiences that an overweight person has, that someone slim just won't have.

Can you be blunt with your friend and say "it makes me feel shit when you ask what I'm wearing."?

For a slim person, choosing an outfit is about what you fancy wearing that day, what's appropriate etc. For a bigger person, it's also that but also about finding something that just bloody fits and looks even half okay and hides all the worst bits you dislike about yourself, only to stand in front of the mirror feeling utterly hopeless realising there's no magic outfit that will hide the size you hate that you are.

It erodes your confidence and self esteem even further.

Although I'm slim now and I might still 'feel fat' in an outfit or have a bad day, it's nothing compared to when I was a size 22 crying in the changing room when a top I liked on the hanger looked bloody awful over my supersize boobs and overhang stomach.

Self-hatred is not limited to overweight people, but there are experiences a bigger person will have, like being called names in the street, declining invitations because you really have nothing to wear, the stares from strangers when you're at a restaurant, being immediately judged as lazy and greedy when you meet someone, to name a few.

My confidence has improved since losing the weight and getting fit, but not only because I look better - people treat me better and no, it's not because I feel better and giving off better vibes, it's because people don't make those judgements anymore and they're nicer to me. Slim people won't encounter that. They may well encounter other judgements, of course! But not due to their weight.

You can't 'know' unless you've been there.

ugifletzet · 29/05/2022 08:28

IvyM · 28/05/2022 23:54

Sorry in advance and trigger warnings all around but I honestly never understood what slim people aren’t supposed to get. I’m usually a size 4 and when “fat” a size 8. Most of my money came from modeling in my 20s. It’s not luck, it’s not good genes, it’s hard work. Every day of my life since I was about 15 I’ve run for an hour, swam for an hour and lifted weights for another hour. I never in my life had more than 1600 calories all in one day. What exactly don’t slim people get? You have 2 choices, either work at it or be a size you don’t like. Slim people who can eat whatever they like are just as rare as overweight people who are overweight due to health issues OP. If you don’t like your size just diet, exercise and take control of your happiness. Life is too short to hate your body and lose friends over petty jealousy.

1600 calories a day won't meet the nutritional needs of many women, even without exercise on top. 1600 calories plus three hours of exercise every single day isn't healthy, full stop, and it's a sign of how normalised disordered eating is in our society that anyone would describe it as "hard work", as if starving yourself is like a being landscape gardener. In the weeks before I was discharged from the eating disorders unit a lot of the therapy groups focused on how hard it is to maintain recovery as an anorexic woman when anorexic behaviours are normalised in society, and this is exactly the kind of thing they meant. Thinness is idealised to the point where women don't even realise that their habits are unhealthy, because they mistake thinness for health.

And to all the posters asking if OP is aware of the sexual harassment her thin friends go through: harassment is about power, not attraction, and fat women get harassed too. Often over their weight. Some men just love to make women uncomfortable in the street and will say whatever they can to achieve that. I don't understand this defensive urge to minimise OP's problems - we don't have to resort to anecdote, there is a lot of empirical evidence to demonstrate weight stigma exists, and whatever other problems thin women might have from misogyny etc., this isn't one of them.

AllAloneInThisHouse · 29/05/2022 07:54

brighteyesburninglikefire · 29/05/2022 00:22

Agreed

Strange, I found most of the comments to be rude, not the OP.

Oysterbabe · 29/05/2022 07:27

Maybe your friend is asking because you told her you almost skipped her BBQ because you had nothing to wear. She knows it's a big deal for you and she's checking that you've got it sorted and will be coming. More communication is needed here. Tell her explicitly to stop asking and the reasons for that.

People who have always been slim and pretty will never completely get it but I'm sure most are emotionally intelligent enough to have a fair idea.

AllAloneInThisHouse · 29/05/2022 07:06

YANBU, at all.

But women (at least average/pretty one’s) don’t want to talk about pretty privilege.

There have been few threads about this, this subject is a taboo.

They want to believe that it’s the ’inner beauty” that counts.
Bless.

Marvellousmadness · 29/05/2022 06:56

They dont 'get' what you are "experiencing"?

Girl. You say you are fat. And gained a lot of weight. But this is something you can change. If you are not happy then change. It is really that simple. Stop being jealous and petty

Kennykenkencat · 29/05/2022 03:11

drivetosurvive
A line from your first post I think indicates the issue.
I don’t like me for me so why should a man

Until you are comfortable and happy with who you are. Looks and weight aside. Then you will end up focusing on things that don’t matter and pointing to those issues as the reason you feel as you do.
Take away those issues and things will still feel the same as the real problem is still there.
Confidence is what I think makes you attractive to other people and confidence is not comparing yourself to others, or being slim and pretty. They can give you a boost but real confidence is not thinking about any perceived imperfection but knowing you are who you are and knowing that is a person you like.
Accept that you are losing weight or are going to lose weight but that is a long term goal and not put your life on hold whilst that is happening by throwing yourself into every evening out with your friends. You will have a better time and probably lose more weight as you will be happier.

For me I ask what people are wearing as I do have a habit of not understanding unwritten dress codes.(I am diagnosed ADHD but my Dd thinks I am also autistic)
I dress more like my teenage Ds than an old woman in her 60s

I have done things like turn up to a dinner out in Pizza Express in a ball gown or dressed as a pirate (definitely an Adam and the ants phase) going to a wedding. Dh does sometimes raise an eyebrow but I never process the eyebrow with thinking about what I wear not being appropriate until I am walking into a tea dance in running gear because I thought it was an aerobics type class.

Friends know I never know what to wear outside the usual combats, hoodie and trainers. So just because someone asks what you are wearing I think it is a huge possibility they want a clue as they have no idea what is or isn’t appropriate or need reassurance that the outfit they are going to wear is along the lines as to what someone else is wearing.

I have been a size 22 for much of my 30s, 40s and 50s because of pregnancies, a back injury which left me in constant agony and unable to do any exercise for 7 years before being diagnosed and put right and the menopause. All came one after the other.

I don’t ever let my weight or my age get in the way of doing stuff. Although the 7 years in agony were a particularly low point but I would force myself to take every opportunity to go out
I knew I was fat and looked terrible but for me that was a separate issue to going out and having a good time with friends. The more time we spent laughing the less time there was for me or anyone else to care about what I thought or what other people thought of me..

ladydimitrescu · 29/05/2022 02:31

@myammus I've reported you now. You are actively bullying the op, you aren't helping at all, just making cruel comments for your own entertainment. You should be ashamed of yourself.

drivetosurvive · 29/05/2022 02:29

This reply has been deleted

Trollhunting

Maybe have a look in the mirror and think why you’re getting off on the pain of other people. Why you can’t let things drop (because you’ll 100% post again) because you have to kick others when they’re down. Best thing about me is that I’ll never be anything like you. You also won’t have anymore of my attention.

OP posts: