Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think of you’re slim and pretty you’ll never “get it”?

295 replies

drivetosurvive · 28/05/2022 21:09

Just to preface by saying I know we all have hang ups and insecurities- especially now with social media and filters etc

I have two close friends. One always asks me what I’m going to wear when we meet up. I hate my body and I’ve gained a lot of weight (size 14 now 20/22 so never been slim) I rarely buy clothes and just wear whet I fit into that day. I’ve been so blunt as to say “I’m fat so whatever I can find that I don’t hate” when I got fed up of that question … yet she still asks even now.

Other friend is very pretty, she gets a lot of attention and always has. I don’t want to date right now due to feeling very down about my looks and weight and she says “well men should like you for you” … which the sentiment is true but I don’t like me for me so why should a man? And it’s not easy to put yourself out there and she’s gorgeous so she’s never really had an issue of men not finding her attractive.

Aibu to think that both of them are slim and pretty and therefore having experienced what I’m going through?

OP posts:
Ecclesfreckles · 30/05/2022 09:30

Not really sure what the point of the thread has been but YABU to think people who aren't exactly like you, don't get how you feel.

It's called empathy. Some are better at it than others. I may not have grown up in a broken home but I can empathise with friends who have. Similarly, my friends may not be my skin colour but I fully expect them to be able to empathise with me. All because we communicate and share experiences and lives. That's how human connection is formed.

However, no one can read your mind and just know what will upset you. Plenty of overweight, insecure women will like being asked what they are going to wear and plenty of women will like their friends being positive about dating. If you don't like something, tell them? I know plenty of overweight people who are perfectly content - others who aren't - the only way to know who is what - is people speaking up. Instead of just fuming quietly.

The chip on your shoulder is coming through but only you can manage your feelings and what you do with them. But your friends can and will empathise with you and get if you just shared with them what you've shared with us.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 30/05/2022 09:13

It should be treated as the addiction it is.

All addiction has the same emotional attachment, drug addicted people, alcoholism, food addiction, smokers, its whole life consuming.

The battle must be fought everyday, my uncle 20 years sober still takes 1 day at a time, it's a constant reminder for the reasons why you need to abstain he can't say feck it I'll get back on the wagon next time or I'll start next week, some addicts never find the strength to break the mould of self soothing with their drug of choice.

There is highly addictive additives in processed food.

Doctors need to recommend group therapy without the god 12 steps, shaming people won't help anyone, it's reprogramming years of learned behaviour instead of quick fix drugs that won't help the emotional connections longterm.

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 30/05/2022 09:12

Redouble · 30/05/2022 09:09

I think those doing a lot of exercise and saying they ate under 2000kcal a day but were still overweight are likely underestimating their calorie intake.

I remember an episode of Secret Eaters where a guy was genuinely bewildered why he was obese. He was eating Special K with jam and double cream - over 2500kcal just on breakfast. He was so shocked as he thought cereal was healthy and it was just a bit of cream.

Extreme example but its easy to underestimate kcal!

That was a great program; it’s amazing how many extra calories people can be eating through a few bad habits.

We had a sleep nurse when our first child was young, and she was explaining how she ate very little but still weighed over 100kg. Her dinner was “just a bit of pasta”, which was actually about 250g, with a sauce, onto which she grated about 200g of cheddar.

HarlanPepper · 30/05/2022 09:10

@Kennykenkencat No doubt you were fit, but you were either eating many more calories than that, or you were doing much less exercise than you say.

220 floors on the stairmaster would burn about 500 calories I'd say? One hour on the treadmill, assuming a steady 10km/hour pace - maybe another 600 calories. Then you've got to swim for 30 mins and cycle for 30 mins on top of that. So another hour of cardiovascular exercise, let's conservatively estimate 400 calories. Every day. No rest days.

1500 calories total (obviously an estimate, give or take 300 or so cals in each direction). Which would mean you're eating just to fuel your exercise and would have hardly anything else left over for pesky things like tissue repair, recovery and general physiological processes involved in, you know, staying alive.

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 30/05/2022 09:09

TorringtonDean · 30/05/2022 00:13

I don’t believe it’s just about calories in and calories out. There are other treatments for those who struggle to lose weight - Saxenda is the latest. They are just not offered by the NHS unless you push massively. I don’t even particularly want to go down that route but I’m not sure calorie counting will work any more for me. I think science could come up with more solutions. There’s a jab for Covid - there could be a jab for obesity? Actually, there IS a jab for obesity but medics would rather victim blame.

I’ve been fat all my life. Sometimes I’ve battled it and sometimes I’ve said to hell with it and given up the fight. But I never had a chance really because this seems to be my body type. Or the type my body will revert to given the chance - if I eat more than 1,000 calories a day and don’t do a heap of exercise. That is what I think thin people do not get.

Yes, poverty is an issue but some people use food banks and are also obese and I expect don’t want to be.

There’s some interesting research around satiety, gut biome, and so on, but it’s still true to say that calorie balance is the dominant driver of obesity. Saying this is not victim blaming.

Redouble · 30/05/2022 09:09

I think those doing a lot of exercise and saying they ate under 2000kcal a day but were still overweight are likely underestimating their calorie intake.

I remember an episode of Secret Eaters where a guy was genuinely bewildered why he was obese. He was eating Special K with jam and double cream - over 2500kcal just on breakfast. He was so shocked as he thought cereal was healthy and it was just a bit of cream.

Extreme example but its easy to underestimate kcal!

Kennykenkencat · 30/05/2022 09:01

When I was a child in the 70s a lot of growth hormones were added to animals farmed for meat. I wonder about whether I absorbed those. My generation are the ones who were considerably taller than those before us - and wider too

I seemed to have missed those growth hormones. I must have been storing them up for Dd who is head and shoulders taller than me.

Kennykenkencat · 30/05/2022 08:54

HarlanPepper · 30/05/2022 08:37

@IvyM

"Every day of my life since I was about 15 I’ve run for an hour, swam for an hour and lifted weights for another hour. I never in my life had more than 1600 calories all in one day."

This is such obvious bullshit. Every day of your life you've run for an hour, swam for an hour AND lifted weights for an hour? So three hours a day of intensive cardio and resistance training on not more than 1600 calories? You'd be dead, mate.

Before getting pregnant I would be in the gym each morning. My routine was run for an hour, cycle for 30 minutes do 220 floors on the stair master, and swim for 30 minutes.

I would eat between 1500-1800 calories per day. I was quite chunky

When I went for my first pregnancy appointment at the hospital the nurse took my blood pressure. She thought she had done it wrong as I had the heart rate of an Olympic athlete. 40 beats per minute.

i was very very fit

Piglet89 · 30/05/2022 08:45

@TorringtonDean have you read “Why we eat too much” by Andrew Jenkinson? His take on this stuff is really interesting.

HarlanPepper · 30/05/2022 08:37

@IvyM

"Every day of my life since I was about 15 I’ve run for an hour, swam for an hour and lifted weights for another hour. I never in my life had more than 1600 calories all in one day."

This is such obvious bullshit. Every day of your life you've run for an hour, swam for an hour AND lifted weights for an hour? So three hours a day of intensive cardio and resistance training on not more than 1600 calories? You'd be dead, mate.

TorringtonDean · 30/05/2022 08:27

I believe there is a lot more to what causes obesity. Historically, our ancestors were starving a lot of the time. So it is genetically programmed in for us to maximise calories. We all need to eat! That’s what’s different from quitting smoking or drinking.

We have gone from a world where everyone walked or at best rode everywhere and spent their days doing manual tasks in the cold to now driving and doing sedentary tasks in centrally heated homes and offices. So we need fewer calories but have the same appetites and on top of that food is abundant. It’s not surprising so many of us struggle with weight issues.

Hormones drive appetites and also tell us when we are full. I seldom feel full after a meal but I am obese. Something’s wrong there.

When I was a child in the 70s a lot of growth hormones were added to animals farmed for meat. I wonder about whether I absorbed those. My generation are the ones who were considerably taller than those before us - and wider too!

And of course food is satisfying and enjoyable and so hard to resist. I am very overweight yet feel faint and hungry and frankly miserable if I have to cut down to the amount that will make me the right weight.

I am not stupid. I am well educated. I’m not lazy. I work hard, do long hours and support a household single handed. Enough of those tropes please! And I am not the only one!

I’ve only been close to the right weight a couple of times in my adult life.

Redouble · 30/05/2022 07:39

I'd have little patience with a friend getting upset about me asking what she was wearing....ffs, it's so trivial and ridiculous

Also - remember it's not top trumps in terms of what someone is allowed to be upset about.

You may consider something trivial in your perspective but it is unkind to dismiss someone else's pain.

I really hope you have good news this week RE your hospital appointments.

Redouble · 30/05/2022 07:33

pixie5121 · 29/05/2022 23:53

@TorringtonDean what kind of serious help needs to be out there? It's never been easier to find out what calories are in foods, plan healthy meals/diet plans and make exercise plans. It's all available online, for free. The issue I see is poverty, with the very poorest people unable to eat well because they don't have the cooking facilities to prepare healthy meals and are relying on food banks, but that's not the majority, is it?

You have a very simplistic, judgemental view of weight loss. Which is very common, unfortunately.

It's really not as simple as just eating less. I eat more now as a size 8 than when I was a size 22.

The obesity issue is a complicated one, and individually those who are obese can struggle to lose weight for many reasons. Factors like: past trauma, lack of education, residential location, parental example, can be real, huge hurdles.

Can they be overcome? With the right therapy, support, education, yes.

But assuming an obese person just needs to eat less highlights that you have a narrow viewpoint of the issue individually and as a whole. This ideology needs to shift.

Dinotour · 30/05/2022 07:17

On a biological level it is about calories in vs out for the vast majority of people. But it's not that easy, there are often factors that complicate that and make it challenging. Binge eating disorder, food as an emotional crutch etc all need to be addressed to have a proper chance at losing weight long term. It's really hard to access support though as its underfunded, and also many people don't believe these things to exist so there's a stigma. Whilst some people will be overweight simply because they want to eat a load, the majority it's for other reasons. Lack of money, resources and time, lack of understanding about nutrition, trying to change habits built in childhood can take time, BED etc, mental health can play a part too- with depression for example it's hard to be motivated to get out of bed and cook good meals.

If it was that easy people would just wake up and decide to lose weight, many who do put it back on because again the underlying cause hasn't been addressed.

elevenspowers · 30/05/2022 01:10

pixie5121 · 29/05/2022 23:22

I just find it tiresome how some overweight people are so utterly obsessed with their weight and how people see them. It's very self absorbed. An acquaintance I follow on Twitter has been posting a load of self pitying waffle today about not fitting into a plane seat and someone apparently looking at her with a disgusted expression and I do just think, for fucks sake, either do something about it or find a different way to travel. She posts stuff like this on a regular basis.

We all have problems. I've got multiple hospital appointments this week for something potentially serious and am really stressed out. A close friend has just been diagnosed with a terrible life limiting disease. I'd have little patience with a friend getting upset about me asking what she was wearing....ffs, it's so trivial and ridiculous. Some fat people seem to think that all thin people live in this alternate universe where everything is amazing and works out great and is perfect, and only they are uniquely put upon and disadvantaged. It's so weird.

Don’t you sound like a peach. You seem to have an awful lot of time to be continuously posting on this thread. Go outside and touch grass. You are not a good person.

TorringtonDean · 30/05/2022 00:13

I don’t believe it’s just about calories in and calories out. There are other treatments for those who struggle to lose weight - Saxenda is the latest. They are just not offered by the NHS unless you push massively. I don’t even particularly want to go down that route but I’m not sure calorie counting will work any more for me. I think science could come up with more solutions. There’s a jab for Covid - there could be a jab for obesity? Actually, there IS a jab for obesity but medics would rather victim blame.

I’ve been fat all my life. Sometimes I’ve battled it and sometimes I’ve said to hell with it and given up the fight. But I never had a chance really because this seems to be my body type. Or the type my body will revert to given the chance - if I eat more than 1,000 calories a day and don’t do a heap of exercise. That is what I think thin people do not get.

Yes, poverty is an issue but some people use food banks and are also obese and I expect don’t want to be.

pixie5121 · 29/05/2022 23:53

@TorringtonDean what kind of serious help needs to be out there? It's never been easier to find out what calories are in foods, plan healthy meals/diet plans and make exercise plans. It's all available online, for free. The issue I see is poverty, with the very poorest people unable to eat well because they don't have the cooking facilities to prepare healthy meals and are relying on food banks, but that's not the majority, is it?

TorringtonDean · 29/05/2022 23:45

Self absorbed? Whereas thin people who spend all day obsessing about their health readings on their apple watches are not? We humans are all fairly self absorbed.

Of course other people have serious health issues too. It’s not a zero sum game - one person having an illness does not mean others can’t have problems too.

Unfortunately obesity is a health issue people love to be judgey about. Yet one third of the population will soon be obese. I wish there was serious help out there instead of judgement. Calorie counts on menus is one big step forward.

pixie5121 · 29/05/2022 23:22

I just find it tiresome how some overweight people are so utterly obsessed with their weight and how people see them. It's very self absorbed. An acquaintance I follow on Twitter has been posting a load of self pitying waffle today about not fitting into a plane seat and someone apparently looking at her with a disgusted expression and I do just think, for fucks sake, either do something about it or find a different way to travel. She posts stuff like this on a regular basis.

We all have problems. I've got multiple hospital appointments this week for something potentially serious and am really stressed out. A close friend has just been diagnosed with a terrible life limiting disease. I'd have little patience with a friend getting upset about me asking what she was wearing....ffs, it's so trivial and ridiculous. Some fat people seem to think that all thin people live in this alternate universe where everything is amazing and works out great and is perfect, and only they are uniquely put upon and disadvantaged. It's so weird.

TorringtonDean · 29/05/2022 23:16

Also, it’s not about clothes for me. It’s about health. I wish I wasn’t worried about my weight. I wish food could actually be made with fewer calories. I’d like to be healthy.

TorringtonDean · 29/05/2022 23:14

I’ve been very overweight a lot of my life and also have had times when I have battled it and lost a lot of weight. At that stage people told me how well I had done - which also confirmed in my mind how fat they thought I looked before (and how shallow it is to think someone is a different person on the inside because they are thinner on the outside). I got down to merely overweight but could not maintain that. I found it extremely time consuming to spent five days a week or more exercising and other things needed my attention.

Now I am heavier again and sad about that. Nobody chooses to become overweight but day by day it becomes harder and harder to starve yourself and exercise like mad and turn away all food pleasures. Tomorrow and tomorrow and tomorrow, creeps in this petty pace from day to day, as Shakespeare said.

I think of all the work I need to put in - all the time in fact - and I don’t believe I can do it again.

I’d just like to eat what I want and remain a healthy size - like most people seem to. I do think people have different metabolisms. I often eat between 800 and 1000 calories a day and yet I just get bigger. I can only lose weight if I rigidly stuck to 800 cals max day in day out plus exercise and frankly it’s something like trying to hold your breath for days on end.

Yes smaller friends have dragged me round clothes shopping and can’t understand why I don’t pick things out and try them on. Because I’m afraid they won’t fit! Duh!!

It’s a pain being fat. I’ve recently found myself thinking of surgery but I’m afraid of that too and what can go wrong.

Jacopo · 29/05/2022 20:16

OP you say you’re depressed and you do sound depressed, and that’s not a good place to be in if you want to lose weight. People telling you just to go on a diet are missing the point of what’s possible for you at the present moment I think. Could I suggest that just for now you accept the size that you are, and have a look for a small number of outfits that fit your present shape and help you feel a little more confident. I think that a few more classic items would help, rather than things that are “in fashion” for a brief period of time. A lot of fashionable clothes are flimsy, too revealing, made of thin fabric and are pretty unflattering on even the average-sized woman. Can you get a hair style that’s flattering, a good manicure, new shade of lipstick etc to boost your confidence in ways that are completely unrelated to your size.
I hope these suggestions are not annoying, I’m trying to suggest things that will give your confidence a boost without the need for a big diet. Then if you start to feel a bit less depressed you can begin to think about sensible eating for the sake of your health, not your clothes size.

Didododo · 29/05/2022 19:19

I don’t think that you can get it if you’ve not been overweight so YANBU

BUT I also think that some overweight women make massive assumptions that slim women are confident, and happy with their appearance and also a presumption that they are judging them for being overweight. That can translate into bitchiness towards them. Which I think is the case here tbh, your friends sound perfectly lovely!

I’ve been everywhere on the slim-fat scale and I found that when I was fat it was men who made shitty comments. When I was slim it was women who made the shitty comments.

SleepingStandingUp · 29/05/2022 19:15

Just talk to your friends op

"what are you wearing tomorrow?"
"whatever I feel OK in tomorrow, but I hate it when you ask that question because it makes me feel X, Y, Z"

"so have you signed up on Tinder yet"
"I've told you, not at this weight"
"men should love you for who you are"
"of course, but I don't want to date until I feel happier in myself. That's my focus right now"

BagOfGin · 29/05/2022 18:58

5128gap · 29/05/2022 16:51

Having been both fat and slim, my life is immeasurably easier slim.
Yes I get harassed by men, more so than when fat. Yes, it's unwelcome and can be intimidating. But there is literally no comparison between having men whistle from vans and shout 'hello sexy' to being called a fat bitch, a dog, being laughed at when jogging, or having chips thrown at you.
Sometimes now I find it hard to find clothes that fit me on my waist. Sometimes I think my legs look skinny. So I take my waistband in or wear trousers. Does this equal the misery of hours in changing rooms trying to fit into clothes not made big enough for my body, and then spending a fortune on a 'flattering cut' and still not liking how i look? Not evenly slightly.
As a slim woman, do I suffer insecurity? Of course. I worry about health, aging, whether I'm good enough at my job, a decent parent, partner, friend. When I was a fat woman I worried about all that too, but also about my weight.
All the 'slim women suffer too' posts remind me of the money doesn't equal happiness claims, that are equally annoying. Of course being rich or slim doesn't make you immune from problems. But it does mean they're not compounded by the added challenges of being poor or overweight.

Very well said

Swipe left for the next trending thread