Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think of you’re slim and pretty you’ll never “get it”?

295 replies

drivetosurvive · 28/05/2022 21:09

Just to preface by saying I know we all have hang ups and insecurities- especially now with social media and filters etc

I have two close friends. One always asks me what I’m going to wear when we meet up. I hate my body and I’ve gained a lot of weight (size 14 now 20/22 so never been slim) I rarely buy clothes and just wear whet I fit into that day. I’ve been so blunt as to say “I’m fat so whatever I can find that I don’t hate” when I got fed up of that question … yet she still asks even now.

Other friend is very pretty, she gets a lot of attention and always has. I don’t want to date right now due to feeling very down about my looks and weight and she says “well men should like you for you” … which the sentiment is true but I don’t like me for me so why should a man? And it’s not easy to put yourself out there and she’s gorgeous so she’s never really had an issue of men not finding her attractive.

Aibu to think that both of them are slim and pretty and therefore having experienced what I’m going through?

OP posts:
pixie5121 · 30/05/2022 11:44

TorringtonDean · 30/05/2022 11:04

@pixie5121 I mean everything except fruit, veg and lean chicken and fish - which is what I ate. Everything else that lots of people (including thin people) regularly eat as meals - prepared or part-prepared - is too calorific.

I almost never eat prepared meals but I don't really understand how something can be 'too calorific'. Surely it depends on how much of it you eat? If I buy a giant bag of tortilla chips, I don't eat them in one go, I eat them over about a week, in small portions alongside sandwiches.

What you're saying doesn't make sense. You can't possibly know how many calories thin people consume.

AnnHedonia · 30/05/2022 11:41

OP I'm large too, and broadly speaking (no pun intended) I get what you're saying. However (even though I find the 'what are you wearing' question irritating - grown adults should be capable of choosing their own outfits without needing to consult the hive mind), I think I'd actually feel worse if my friends asked each other what they were planning to wear but not me - I'd feel very 'othered' if they thought the question didn't apply to me because I was large. It'd feel like 'Oh, no point asking AnnHedonia what she's wearing, poor thing just has to grab whatever will fit'.

I do think you're being too hard on yourself/putting yourself down too much, though. 💐

elevenspowers · 30/05/2022 11:37

riesenrad · 30/05/2022 11:31

I’d just not like to be questioned about what I’m going to wear. I actually feel like cancelling social plans at times because I have nothing to wear

If I am going out I want to know if people are dressing up, wearing jeans, etc. I don't want to be wearing jeans if everyone else turns up in a posh dress! Or vice versa. Nothing to do with weight - or lack of it.

In what situation would you turn up in jeans if people were wearing posh dresses?

elevenspowers · 30/05/2022 11:34

pixie5121 · 30/05/2022 10:25

Not a good person? Because I'm sick to death of reading someone's self pitying rants about their weight, including how other people treat them? Mutual friends she's talking about and subtweeting, who I know are good people doing their best, and have been nothing but good to this person? When all she gives out is bitterness and resentment towards people she perceives as being better looking or slimmer?

Imagine how vile you'd need to be to say this to someone with serious health issues going on. You're an absolute monster.

Nah you’re the monster. You want pity yet you sit there mocking and slating someone else’s struggles. Why follow an acquaintance when you have such hatred for them? Only bitter and hateful monsters do that.

riesenrad · 30/05/2022 11:31

I’d just not like to be questioned about what I’m going to wear. I actually feel like cancelling social plans at times because I have nothing to wear

If I am going out I want to know if people are dressing up, wearing jeans, etc. I don't want to be wearing jeans if everyone else turns up in a posh dress! Or vice versa. Nothing to do with weight - or lack of it.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 30/05/2022 11:18

@TorringtonDean 💐Biology and hormones along with genetics cause a lot of the problems.

I have 2 DC 1 is skinny 1 is chunky with rolls.

The bigger DC runs all day every day,
doesn't eat much more than his sister, he'll never be slim and will have a battle with his weight.
He was born above 99.99 off the scale and has continued growing up and out.

My slim child is very inactive and hates moving anywhere.

There is no moral attachment or greatness about being slim.

I genuinely don't care what weight friends are, maybe I should show more concern based on this thread but it's a non issue as they are the people I love slim or fat.

TorringtonDean · 30/05/2022 11:08

I wouldn’t say thin people are picking on fat people. It’s a long time since anyone openly taunted me like they did when I was a child. I’d say biology appears to be against fat people and I’m rather sick of it. Maybe if I was reincarnated thin I might mess up that perfect body with my greedy ways - that’s what thin people think! But I started off fat in the first place and feel I never had a chance.

TorringtonDean · 30/05/2022 11:04

@pixie5121 I mean everything except fruit, veg and lean chicken and fish - which is what I ate. Everything else that lots of people (including thin people) regularly eat as meals - prepared or part-prepared - is too calorific.

pixie5121 · 30/05/2022 10:51

5128gap · 30/05/2022 10:16

There's no denying serious problems can affect slim attractive people. Bereavement, life threatening illness, loneliness, lack of self esteem and that by comparison, worrying about looking nice in clothes seems trivial. But, this isn't a thread comparing looking fat in your clothes to life and death problems. It's a thread comparing the day to day, all other things being equal, experience of being fat and being slim. There is absolutely no doubt that for the vast majority of people in our society, the former is the more challenging. I don't understand the defensive race to the bottom element on this thread from some slim people. No one is negating the problems of slim people, merely pointing out that being fat isn't one of them.

Yes, obviously.

But some overweight people seem to genuinely believe their life is much harder and much worse than that of any slim person, and that slim people are constantly picking on them. It's like an obsession. The OP is like this.

My acquaintance posted some really nasty sub tweets about a mutual friend, because the friend didn't sponsor her on some sponsored walk she did at the weekend. The friend has just been diagnosed with a very serious illness and is devastated. She can barely get out of bed she's so shocked and upset. It doesn't seem to occur to this woman that other people also have challenges and problems and serious issues going on. She literally seems to believe her life is the hardest in the world and everyone should applaud everything she does and if someone forgets to text her back or doesn't invite her to something, it's because she's fat.

It's exhausting.

DilemmaDelilah · 30/05/2022 10:51

I agree with the OP. Those who have not experienced the issues that other people have do not usually understand them. I am fat - very fat. I once received a very nice birthday present from my co-workers, chosen by a very petite and slim person, of a top which was not only 2 sizes too small (the biggest size that shop sold so not even exchangeable) but also a shape that was extremely unflattering for somebody my shape. She had absolutely no idea that it wasn't big enough as her little brain couldn't compute that there were people who were too fat to fit into something that HUGE!

Also - many years ago my siblings and I arranged a party for my parents' Ruby wedding anniversary. I was flat broke without any savings, so I set out right from the start what food I would provide (which wasreed with them) and I agreed to do all the admin, finding names and addresses for the guests, finding B&B s nearby, designing and printing the invitations etc. The party went great, but one of my siblings had decided, without any consultation, to get a dressed salmon in addition to what had been agreed. After the party she called me and our other sibling into a room and told us what we owed her for the salmon. Neither of my siblings was particularly well off, but they weren't actually on their uppers like me. They couldn't imagine that I didn't actually HAVE that money at all, in fact I was living off my overdraft and had no savings. My bursting into tears in front of them gave them a clue though!

So - yes... I agree that those that do not have particular issues do not generally have any idea of how difficult it is for those of us that do. It is up to all of us to educate ourselves and to try to understand how others feel, regardless of whether we think they should be doing something about it or not. We feel the way we feel, regardless of whether you feel that way too.

Notbeinfunnehbut · 30/05/2022 10:46

Some of these comments are clueless

in a society where plus size women are treat as different species it’s absolutely a different life experience, to someone who isn’t

I think your friends do mean well but your almost getting annoyed at the wrong thing OP they sound like nice ppl

also slim doesn’t always equal attractive there are friends I have who have better bodies than me but less attractive faces, it’s just genetic lottery really.

pixie5121 · 30/05/2022 10:45

TorringtonDean · 30/05/2022 09:45

@Piglet89 thanks for the book advice. I shall look into it.

You can’t treat food like an addiction because the entire planet is addicted! M I am tired of the whole issue. I just want to live my life without thinking about calories etc. I did for a short while when I was close to the right weight and now I am fat again.

This is fast going to be a majority issue. The numbers who are obese are relentlessly increasing. I realised previously when following my extremely strict regime that almost all foods at the supermarket contain too many calories. We are all eating all wrong but some people metabolise it better than others. My theory.

How can all foods contain too many calories? That makes no sense. What do you mean by 'foods'? Prepackaged, processed meals? Junk food?

TorringtonDean · 30/05/2022 10:45

One thing I can say as a fat person is I don’t smoke, barely drink and have never taken illegal drugs. Some of the young, lean, attractive people from my youth now seem totally knackered compared to me. The truth is all of us have a sell-by date. Sometimes those virtue signalling about their low weight seem to forget that.

pixie5121 · 30/05/2022 10:37

Redouble · 30/05/2022 09:09

I think those doing a lot of exercise and saying they ate under 2000kcal a day but were still overweight are likely underestimating their calorie intake.

I remember an episode of Secret Eaters where a guy was genuinely bewildered why he was obese. He was eating Special K with jam and double cream - over 2500kcal just on breakfast. He was so shocked as he thought cereal was healthy and it was just a bit of cream.

Extreme example but its easy to underestimate kcal!

100%. They almost always are. Most people have absolutely no idea what a normal portion size is. I can never get over how much pasta some people seem to think is a normal serving. I was out to dinner with a friend a few weeks back and ordered ravioli. The serving was a standard six pieces and a rich, buttery sauce. She looked gobsmacked and asked me if I wouldn't be starving afterwards. No. This is a normal portion size.

I think this is where a lot of people go wrong. They think they're not eating junk food and the stuff they're choosing is 'healthy' but they're eating far, far too much of it.

I also see a PP saying they never feel full after a meal. You are not supposed to feel full after a meal. You're meant to eat until about 80% satisfied, as the Japanese say. It's also normal to feel hungry before meals, even for a few hours. I have friends who don't seem to realise that being hungry is OK. The first hunger twinge and they're reaching for a chocolate bar or biscuits. They don't ever let themselves get properly hungry. One said to me 'no, you don't understand, my mouth is like watering and my tummy is rumbling', as if she was starving to death. That's literally what being a bit hungry feels like. Some people seem to be so used to stamping out those initial hunger pangs that they've lost the ability to tolerate being hungry.

HarlanPepper · 30/05/2022 10:37

@IvyM I tracked calories for about two years, and I exercise 5 days a week. About an hour of heavy weights and conditioning (I am a powerlifter) but some cross training too. I was competing in the under 64kg category and I wanted to try moving down a weight bracket. I weigh around 63 kg at five foot 9, I wear size ten clothes, and I eat around 2500 calories a day. I lost weight easily on 1800 a day.

So I understand pretty well about BMR and TDEE. I still think you're talking pish. What professional athletes are you talking about? What sport? Some might train for 5-6 hours a day but it will be varied training and they'll be eating a sight more than 1400 cals per day.

AchatAVendre · 30/05/2022 10:30

TorringtonDean Self absorbed? Whereas thin people who spend all day obsessing about their health readings on their apple watches are not? We humans are all fairly self absorbed.

Please don't assume that all people who do sport do that. I've been a sporty, competitive athlete all my life and I don't even possess a heart rate monitor, never mind an apple watch. I don't use Strava. Most people serious about their amateur level sport don't post attention seeking posts on social media. Its generally what I refer to the "born again" ones that do that.

Of course those that post obsessively on social media will stand out more than the many others who just get on with it and enjoy the doing rather than the boasting about it or the attention seeking. I find attention seeking of any kind quite irritating, whether it comes from thin, fat, or middling people.

pixie5121 · 30/05/2022 10:25

elevenspowers · 30/05/2022 01:10

Don’t you sound like a peach. You seem to have an awful lot of time to be continuously posting on this thread. Go outside and touch grass. You are not a good person.

Not a good person? Because I'm sick to death of reading someone's self pitying rants about their weight, including how other people treat them? Mutual friends she's talking about and subtweeting, who I know are good people doing their best, and have been nothing but good to this person? When all she gives out is bitterness and resentment towards people she perceives as being better looking or slimmer?

Imagine how vile you'd need to be to say this to someone with serious health issues going on. You're an absolute monster.

IvyM · 30/05/2022 10:24

@HarlanPepper I’ll do you a kindness and explain how counting calories and exercising works, as you’ve clearly not tried it.
You calculate your basal metabolic rate. For a slightly underweight woman it’s usually 1600 calories. You calculate the amount of energy you expand during a 3 hours long session of cardio. For someone who’s body is very used to that level of activity it’s usually around 1000 - 1200 calories. And there you have it, if you want to maintain a size 4 figure and be healthy while clinically underweight this is one way to do it - consume 1600 calories on the days you’re not exercising, and add the required extra calories on the days you are exercising. If you want to lose a kg per week you actually need to have an 800 calorie deficit per day. If you’re basal metabolic rate is 1600, that leaves you with 800 calories
3 hours of cardio isn’t actually a lot, most professional athletes train for at least 5 -6 hours a day. Yes, nobody trains on every day of their life, everyone takes a day off now and again, but the gist of it mate is that it’s hard work, some people do it, and people who choose not are ignorant of their efforts and restful of their results.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 30/05/2022 10:22

*You can’t treat food like an addiction because the entire planet is addicted! M I am tired of the whole issue. I just want to live my life without thinking about calories etc. I did for a short while when I was close to the right weight and now I am fat again.?

It's a vicious cycle.
I sympathise with you.
My friend has been through the paces with her weight, she opted for surgery a gastric sleeve it was a horrible 10 months however the change is amazing, she is more open about the pain and suffering she's been through, she now claims she was addicted to eating.

She couldn't focus on anything until she had a fix, she'd hide food on family and friends, wake at night to binge, her mood lifted when she entered sweet food Isles in the shop, she'd be gleeful thinking about eating as much as possible in the evenings, it was making her sad and constantly berate herself afterwards.

It's sad to watch.

Everything in moderation when something drugs/alcohol/unhealthy food is not moderated its becomes addiction, you won't beat addiction without the strength to fight.

purplesky18 · 30/05/2022 10:16

I have never ever been slim, I’ve always been anywhere from a 16 to a 20. I used to get so down about being the fat one and getting no attention, I used to envy skinny and beautiful people. Now I realise actually when I dress up and put a full face on and a great outfit I look amazing. I have a condition where my legs are stupidly fat but I just don’t care anymore. Instead of feeling envy when I see a slim beautiful woman I instead go up to her and say how amazing she looks. It’s just about confidence and your own securities.

5128gap · 30/05/2022 10:16

There's no denying serious problems can affect slim attractive people. Bereavement, life threatening illness, loneliness, lack of self esteem and that by comparison, worrying about looking nice in clothes seems trivial. But, this isn't a thread comparing looking fat in your clothes to life and death problems. It's a thread comparing the day to day, all other things being equal, experience of being fat and being slim. There is absolutely no doubt that for the vast majority of people in our society, the former is the more challenging. I don't understand the defensive race to the bottom element on this thread from some slim people. No one is negating the problems of slim people, merely pointing out that being fat isn't one of them.

artisanbread · 30/05/2022 09:54

As a person who is genetically slim (but not pretty!) I think I agree with OP. There does seem to be more judgment of larger people. Slim people still worry about their appearance (I have a big nose for example) but I do feel my slim build gives me more confidence. I feel bad because I see my larger colleagues, for example, making more effort with diet and exercise than I do. However, looking at my DC I do think there is less judgment about size amongst them and their friends than in my generation.

TorringtonDean · 30/05/2022 09:49

BTW on the issues of clothes and dating….I’ve been various sizes and I have discovered the golden rule of shopping - whatever your size it’s guaranteed to be out of stock. I’m not very interested in clothes. Dating - nope, I’m not doing that. See no point at all in being treated like a cut in the meat market. I’m happier on my own.

BestDove · 30/05/2022 09:46

My SIL is very fat. She also always wears the most gorgeous clothes (all high street). I think some people are just inherently stylish!! Her make up, hair and accessories are just perfect too. She always looks so well turned out.

I’ve always been slimmer than her, but I’m not in the slightest bit stylish. Actually I should probably ask her to buy all my clothes for me.

So I don’t think it comes down to size so much, but maybe confidence too.

TorringtonDean · 30/05/2022 09:45

@Piglet89 thanks for the book advice. I shall look into it.

You can’t treat food like an addiction because the entire planet is addicted! M I am tired of the whole issue. I just want to live my life without thinking about calories etc. I did for a short while when I was close to the right weight and now I am fat again.

This is fast going to be a majority issue. The numbers who are obese are relentlessly increasing. I realised previously when following my extremely strict regime that almost all foods at the supermarket contain too many calories. We are all eating all wrong but some people metabolise it better than others. My theory.