Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of Which? recommending everything

54 replies

Lilaone · 28/05/2022 19:04

Every product/service and advert seems to have a 'Which?' recommended sticker slapped on it at the moment. If it's not Lidl advertising they're Which?'s cheapest supermarket it's Jet2 saying Which? thinks they do the best holidays. Is there anything Which? DOESN'T recommend?

Also where did Which come from? Apparently you have to pay a tenner a month to see their reviews but hello... there are millions of free reviews online?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Cyclebabble · 14/07/2022 17:27

Love which,makes buying things so much easier. YABU.

AResearcher · 14/07/2022 17:18

I'm an ex Which? researcher (nc because massively outing otherwise!). Which? tests hardly anything in the way you might think. Product reviews are mostly based on desk research and comparing specs on paper. You're paying for a bit of saved time and someone else's opinion. Which? actually doesn't have labs or anything. Sometimes it comissions tests to an overseas lab (usually for baby products, sunscreen and cars, because that stuff would be more dangerous to guesstimate)
I believe brands pay W? big money to use the Best Buy logo. I imagine there are certainly more lucrative brands who could be awarded with Best Buy status...

One other thing. Which? has moved away from charity work under the current CEO. It's focused on churning out product reviews, which it sells for a profit. Interestingly, it still promotes itself heavily as a charity though?

Ultimatelty, YANBU. Which? Best Buy isnt without flaws and how w gets to its decisions is questionable in some cases. Takes 10 mins nowdays to do some Google research for the right product for your personal needs.

Userforever · 08/06/2022 18:28

I have subscribed to Which for years and always check before a purchase.

Abra1d1 · 08/06/2022 18:17

Which? and Good Housekeeping are my go-to places for recommendations. I’m surprised you haven’t heard of Which?.

GrimDamnFanjo · 08/06/2022 18:15

I love Which! Don't make any large purchases without looking up online.

Chaoslatte · 08/06/2022 18:09

YABVU. Which? is great. I subscribe temporarily every time I need to make a big purchase. I find their reviews really helpful - they are much more thorough and in depth than Bob who posts a review on Amazon saying 5* arrived quickly and nothing about the actual product.

Lilaone · 08/06/2022 18:02

PAFMO · 29/05/2022 15:11

Are you very young OP?
"Which" has been going for donkey's years and is a reliable consumer trade mag/platform.
It's not exactly "Yvonne up the street says her sequinned pants are just the best"
Actual experts in the field put products etc through rigorous testing.

Not really, I'm 34. I know Which is a magazine but most magazine product endorsements are dubious imo. I don't know about everyone else but I'm not buying new appliances or tech gadgets several times a month, maybe once a year if that, so doesn't seem to be worth a pricey subscription.

I even saw a Which endorsement for a cup today!

OP posts:
Notjustanymum · 30/05/2022 09:19

Unless you purchase everything that Lidl sells, and have compared the price of everything with every other supermarket, you can’t, (and even if you had done that, why would I believe you over a trusted product surveyor?)

2bazookas · 29/05/2022 16:02

If you're making a big purchase then WHICH reviews are invaluable. They are so detailed, and verified from real owners/users. I use them.

DorritLittle · 29/05/2022 15:54

Are you bored OP? Odd thing to feel aggrieved about.

Wotrewelookinat · 29/05/2022 15:50

Which is well worth subscribing to. Saves loads of time and money in the long run. Every other person around my area drives one of those bubble style Fiat 500s. Which has done a safety rating on them (and many other cars) and it’s dreadful. Why people don’t research the things they spend hard-earned cash on, I don’t know…

WeAllHaveWings · 29/05/2022 15:48

We cancelled our subscription when they refused to publish a negative but factual review of one of their trusted traders.

We decided if those reviews were sanatised and biased the rest of the site could not be trusted either.

DilemmaBlah · 29/05/2022 15:41

Which? are reliable and honest.

We’ll agree to disagree on that.

HereIAmBrainTheSizeOfAPlanet · 29/05/2022 15:32

Calm down, op.

Schmz · 29/05/2022 15:27

Doh !! 🤣
that’s like saying RAC should stop telling us they do breakdown cover !!!!
very funny OP !

IsThePopeCatholic · 29/05/2022 15:23

Which? Is a brilliant consumer campaigning organization. I never buy anything of value without consulting them. They have exposed all sorts of cons and dangers, including how Amazon rigs their reviews. Which? are reliable and honest.

Stephenthesupersquirrel · 29/05/2022 15:12

One thing I don’t agree with them on is some of their car seat testing. They rate extended rear facing seats poorly because they are belted rather than isofix, because they are up to 25kg so they can’t be isofix!!

PAFMO · 29/05/2022 15:11

Are you very young OP?
"Which" has been going for donkey's years and is a reliable consumer trade mag/platform.
It's not exactly "Yvonne up the street says her sequinned pants are just the best"
Actual experts in the field put products etc through rigorous testing.

DilemmaBlah · 29/05/2022 15:07

riesenrad · 29/05/2022 14:56

They asked Which for evidence of their testing methods and what lab they used and received some photos clearly showing incorrect testing methodologies

would a customer use it in the way the manufacturer did though, or the way Which? did?

They claimed they had conducted the industry standard safety tests for that sort of product. They did them incorrectly. Lawyers etc all had to get involved. They nearly ruined the product owners business due to their incompetent methods.

riesenrad · 29/05/2022 14:56

They asked Which for evidence of their testing methods and what lab they used and received some photos clearly showing incorrect testing methodologies

would a customer use it in the way the manufacturer did though, or the way Which? did?

riesenrad · 29/05/2022 14:56

RoseAndRose · 28/05/2022 19:18

I always consult Which? for major purchases. They actually test things, and tell you what they've done and what the results are. Way more useful than online reviews

Yes - save on loads of "life admin". Well worth a subscription (my mum buys me one as a Christmas present each year).

AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair · 29/05/2022 11:17

Lilaone · 28/05/2022 19:21

But I could have told you all that Lidl is the cheapest supermarket, and for free!

I need a new washing machine, would you mind buying all the ones on the market and testing them for me? Be sure to include all the different cycles and stains

DilemmaBlah · 28/05/2022 20:13

MagnoliaPrimrose · 28/05/2022 19:07

Of course - they test things, independently, and publish the results for subscribers. There are loads of things they don't recommend and actively advise you not to buy.
I wouldnt buy a big appliance without checking the which reviews. They aren't like random reviews online because you can be sure they're genuinely independent and they are far more thorough in most cases.

I don’t trust their testing methods anymore after they incorrectly tested an acquaintance’s product and then slandered it saying it was unsafe, which led to retailers pulling it from their shelves. The product owner then produced a litany of independent safety certificates that they regularly pay high prices for as they are so safety conscious and their product was thankfully reinstated. They asked Which for evidence of their testing methods and what lab they used and received some photos clearly showing incorrect testing methodologies. They didn’t even get an apology from Which.

FictionalCharacter · 28/05/2022 20:10

It’s their job! They test stuff and make recommendations. You have to be a member to get the detailed reports (I’m a member) but they make a lot of reports available free of charge.

Hugasauras · 28/05/2022 20:07

Ooh I love Which! I check it before I buy anything big. And I like the magazine too Blush