Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be fed-up of non-drivers seeking lifts?

607 replies

GoldfinchTart · 28/05/2022 12:03

Disclaimer: this post is not about people who for whatever reason — sight problems, epilepsy, disability, poverty etc — cannot drive. It's about people who could learn to drive but don't want to.

Earlier this week I had a knock at the door and it was a couple asking if I could lend them some gardening equipment. They're in the process of buying a property a few doors along from me. It's a probate sale and it's taking ages, so they'd come down (with the vendors' permission) to start tidying up the garden which has become quite overgrown. They wanted a rake and a spade and loppers 'Because it's difficult to carry a rake on the train'. I invited them in and made them tea while I went to unlock the shed and find the tools. Turns out neither of them drive. He has a licence but found driving stressful and she prefers to be driven.

Our houses are a half-mile walk to a bus stop which isn't much fun when it's pouring with rain. I raised an eyebrow and asked if they cycle? Electric bikes are getting popular around here. We're 11 hilly miles from the nearest major town for shopping and transport links. No, they don't cycle. Long silence. I said that was a pity: taxis were very expensive because they had to come out from the town. She said that they have very nice neighbours where they currently live and they help out with lifts. Apparently the nice neighbours had run these two to the station that morning and would pick them up on their return. And then she asked 'I don't suppose you'd be going into town around 4pm, would you?' Fortunately I had a full afternoon's zoom meeting booked and showed them my diary. My partner and I try to be good neighbours but surely this was a very large red flag?

Next week I'm going to a book festival. I'm going in the camper van my partner and I share. A friend who doesn't drive is coming by train and will be travelling with a tent and camping gear. We arranged that I would be at Hereford station to pick her and her gear up at a certain time. It was planned to give us time to drive to the festival campsite and then for me to go and attend one of the events, which I've booked and paid for in advance. Today she's contacted me to say that she can't get anyone to give her a lift to the station at her end in order to catch the train required. Someone can give her a lift later to the station later in the morning, so she'll be arriving in Hereford two hours later than planned. She still expects me to pick her up from Hereford. I've told her she'll have to catch the bus from Hereford and she's responded that she has far too much gear to get on a bus. She fancies herself as a bit of a green crusader, always knocking me and my partner for having two vehicles and yet she's totally dependent on drivers to get her around.

In August my 28-year-old nephew and his girlfriend are coming to stay. They hope to go walking in the area and to visit several out-of-the-way places. They live in London and don't drive. It's become clear while we've been making arrangements that if they're to do half of what they've planned, I'll need to ferry them around almost every day. They're my relatives, they're here for a week and I'll do it without grumbling. But they'd have far more freedom and independence if they learned to drive and could hire a car for a week.

It strikes me that driving is one of those life skills that all eligible adults should be capable of, even if they choose not to own a car. AIBU?

OP posts:
Topseyt123 · 30/05/2022 10:55

Lets rephrase something that is very often trotted out on here.

Driving is a useful life skill, but not necessarily an absolutely essential one. That can all depend on your personal circumstances and where you live. If you don't want to drive and own a car then it is best not to live in the arse end of nowhere or you will be very isolated.

I drive. Mostly locally and on my patch. I don't particularly like it and will (with some planning) get public transport for longer trips. I drive to do my shopping and run local errands because we don't live in a city so I need to. As we get older and want to drive less the plan is to downsize our current family home (kids are all grown up now) and move to somewhere smaller, with better public transport and closer facilities.

As I say, I do drive, but I also occasionally use our admittedly fairly limited local bus service and even more occasionally, a taxi.

I go to my mother's house several hours away by train and we use taxis when I am there. She no longer drives due to age related medical problems so me coming up and us using the local taxi firms helped her to realise (after my Dad died) that it was still possible to get out occasionally, albeit a bit more challenging than it used to be.

Frazzledmummy123 · 30/05/2022 10:53

GoldfinchTart · 30/05/2022 10:00

I live in a busy area in a city and I work around not having a car by having my doctor, dentist, and vet (if I had a pet) nearby. If I had a dog with diarrhoea I'd walk it with them (carrying cage if the dog can't walk). Anything else further afield (with no situations involving diarrhoea) I'd take a taxi. Simple!

I'm five, maybe six miles from a vet: too far to walk with a sick dog/ carry it in a cage/ push in a wheelbarrow along narrow lanes without a footpath. The non-driving poster who wrote about living in a national park and being able to get the dog to the vet would have been more rural than me.

You still haven't solved my problem. Dog with terrible diarrhoea, at least five miles to the vet. No taxi would take him, I'd be mortified if he lost control on a bus (and so would he and the bus company). I'd have to ask a friend or neighbour, wouldn't I?

Lucky you aren't me then, and I don't have a dog with diarrhoea? 😊.
Why would I need to solve your problem? I don't have a dog with diarrhoea, or live several miles from a vet. I don't have a dog because I live my own life with my own choices, nor do I have anything to do with you or your life (thank goodness!)

Somethingneedstochange · 30/05/2022 10:47

Tell her to get a taxi to the station then you can still pick her up. Who waits around for people to give them lifts? I don't drive had to struggle on the train and then bus with a large suitcase a backpack and shopping as well as keeping hold of my adult disabled son who has epilepsy. I couldn't get a taxi to where we were staying. I actually did start learning to drive. But was put off when we were in a taxi on the way to the airport to come home from holiday and my son nearly caused a crash. He reached over the driver to get something let me tell you my life flashed before my eyes. That was an experienced driver he managed it really well. Luckily it was a 7 seater so we moved him and I sat with him. I'm not sure what I would have done if I was a new driver in a 5 seater.

Badyboo · 30/05/2022 10:26

My vet has an animal taxi, so problem solved!

Which just goes to show how pointless it is to ask what I'd do in your area which I don't know. My answer would be: get the animal taxi. Or more likely, walk, since it's only a mile.

CruCru · 30/05/2022 10:26

I think part of the problem is that people don't realise how different others' lives are to theirs. The nephew lives in London and probably says things like "What do you mean it's seven minutes until the next tube?!? That's outrageous, what's going on?" He hasn't realised that the OP lives in a place where there's only three buses a day. It would be kind to tell him - sometimes it's more polite to be direct.

Having someone come to stay and then look surprised that they will need a car or be dependent on lifts is quite irritating. It's like having a friend wear suede boots to the beach.

On the other hand, if you live somewhere where you really don't need a car, having people be aghast that you are going to walk or get the bus is also quite irritating. GoldenOmber summed it up well:

”Would you like a lift?”
”No thanks, I’m fine.”
”But how will you get home?”
”It’s fine, I’m walking/getting the bus/whatever.”
”Oh you can’t WALK! It’s RAINING!”
”I like walking, I don’t mind.”
”Oh I wouldn’t hear of you walking in the rain. I’ll take you.”
”Really, no, thanks.”
”Oh don’t be so silly!” etc etc etc.

I grew up in the centre of a city and remember people virtually restraining me as I tried to leave a friend's house because I was going to walk the few blocks home. It's weird and awkward when people do this.

Robinni · 30/05/2022 10:23

GoldfinchTart · 30/05/2022 10:00

I live in a busy area in a city and I work around not having a car by having my doctor, dentist, and vet (if I had a pet) nearby. If I had a dog with diarrhoea I'd walk it with them (carrying cage if the dog can't walk). Anything else further afield (with no situations involving diarrhoea) I'd take a taxi. Simple!

I'm five, maybe six miles from a vet: too far to walk with a sick dog/ carry it in a cage/ push in a wheelbarrow along narrow lanes without a footpath. The non-driving poster who wrote about living in a national park and being able to get the dog to the vet would have been more rural than me.

You still haven't solved my problem. Dog with terrible diarrhoea, at least five miles to the vet. No taxi would take him, I'd be mortified if he lost control on a bus (and so would he and the bus company). I'd have to ask a friend or neighbour, wouldn't I?

@GoldfinchTart

Most people I know with animals who can’t drive make sure they either a) are within walking distance of a vets b) have a partner/family member who can drive…. Which is not an issue as said family member is as responsible for the dog/cat as they are….. Your neighbours are unusual in not considering their access to local amenities, perhaps because their previous neighbours were “yes” people with no backbone…. Arguably the root cause of the problem.

I hope the diarrhoea issue is resolved for you.

ConfessionsOfAShopper · 30/05/2022 10:23

I don’t drive. I don’t expect lifts, ever.

If I go and visit a friend in the country, she comes to pick me up from the station, because taxis are extortionate. I always offer petrol money, and she always says no, so I buy her a bottle of wine as a thank you. It’s not a big deal.

I get around absolutely fine in my city without the use of a car and I don’t need it.

Robinni · 30/05/2022 10:16

GoldfinchTart · 30/05/2022 09:03

After reading all the comments here from non-drivers who feel insulted and assailed by drivers offering them lifts I'll never again stop when I'm driving into town on a cold wet morning and offer some shivering person waiting under an umbrella at a bus stop a lift. I had no idea how many proud non-drivers feel so oppressed by people offering them lifts.

@GoldfinchTart

Picking up random strangers at bus stops is about as sensible as letting random people into your house to have a cup of tea, peruse your diary and then high tail it with your gardening equipment.

You need to draw up some boundaries.

And stop imposing your value system on others. If they are taking a bus mind your business and drive on!

GoldfinchTart · 30/05/2022 10:00

I live in a busy area in a city and I work around not having a car by having my doctor, dentist, and vet (if I had a pet) nearby. If I had a dog with diarrhoea I'd walk it with them (carrying cage if the dog can't walk). Anything else further afield (with no situations involving diarrhoea) I'd take a taxi. Simple!

I'm five, maybe six miles from a vet: too far to walk with a sick dog/ carry it in a cage/ push in a wheelbarrow along narrow lanes without a footpath. The non-driving poster who wrote about living in a national park and being able to get the dog to the vet would have been more rural than me.

You still haven't solved my problem. Dog with terrible diarrhoea, at least five miles to the vet. No taxi would take him, I'd be mortified if he lost control on a bus (and so would he and the bus company). I'd have to ask a friend or neighbour, wouldn't I?

OP posts:
Dashdotdotdash · 30/05/2022 09:52

Frazzledmummy123 · 30/05/2022 09:32

Yes, but why do people HAVE to drive just because YOU think they should? Non-drivers might have less freedom than drivers in certain ways, however isn't that their choice. It only affects you when they expect you to ferry them around anywhere.

I live in a busy area in a city and I work around not having a car by having my doctor, dentist, and vet (if I had a pet) nearby. If I had a dog with diarrhoea I'd walk it with them (carrying cage if the dog can't walk). Anything else further afield (with no situations involving diarrhoea) I'd take a taxi. Simple!

I would be a nightmare behind a wheel. I have a short attention span and panic easily. Isn't it more responsible to not put myself behind a wheel than drive because some people in society think I should.

So you come within the category that OP has expressly said her post is not directed to. She made it clear that she recognises that there are people who cannot drive for good reason.

GoldfinchTart · 30/05/2022 09:50

Pliudev · 29/05/2022 18:32

OP, someone might already have said this. If it's Hay, I envy you because I'm just back. It's heaven. There is a regular bus service between Hereford and Hay and the festival are also running coaches to and from. I'd suggest she gets one of those. Have a great time.

It's lovely, isn't it? I've been going every year since it started. Originally going there was part of my job and I'd take a van full of the publishing company I worked for's books to display and sell. I was there for 10 days in 2019 as a volunteer steward. It's one of those fenced-off bits of my life. Late May Bank Holiday is always Hay time.

OP posts:
Dashdotdotdash · 30/05/2022 09:48

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 29/05/2022 22:28

It's a life skill and not having a licence disadvantages you in not dissimilar ways to being unable to read or being scared of computers.

I can’t believe anyone is this stupid. Even jobs where you don’t have to be able to read (e.g. labouring) usually require you to complete an application form - often online, meaning you need computer skills.

Driving? Unless you need to do it for the job, it’s irrelevant. I earn £50k a year, which I think is pretty decent - and none of that money goes on a car I don’t need.

Yes, I’ve had to turn down jobs based on industrial estates in the arse end of nowhere. But the company has lost out
just as much as I have.

Driving isn't relevant for every job, but it does improve your choices, as you yourself have demonstrated. When I had DC1 I looked for part time jobs and what I could find were in places that would take me well over an hour by public transport but 20-30 minutes by car. Cycling wouldn't have been practical. I had learnt to drive but didn't have a car at that point. In the interests of finding the right job, buying and running a second hand car was still cheaper than public transport and was simply a no-brainer.

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 30/05/2022 09:37

My sister never learnt to drive. She lives 50 miles from me and the amount of times I’ve had to go a long way out of my way drop her home after events is kind of annoying.

she could have learnt. We have a family member who is a driving instructor and taught all the siblings and my kids for free. She just couldn’t be arsed and now everyone has to run around after her. I love her dearly, but it is annoying.

GoldfinchTart · 30/05/2022 09:33

GoldfinchTart · 30/05/2022 09:33

Until they realised there was bigger and better and more interesting stuff going on behind Newquay.

Beyond Newquay!

OP posts:
GoldfinchTart · 30/05/2022 09:33

Momicrone · 29/05/2022 19:25

Xingming - I would imagine a 17 year old living in Newquay could have a nice social life

Until they realised there was bigger and better and more interesting stuff going on behind Newquay.

OP posts:
Frazzledmummy123 · 30/05/2022 09:32

GoldfinchTart · 30/05/2022 09:21

Not saying everyone should drive everywhere all the time. I'm saying that driving is a basic skill of modern life that I think most people would benefit from. Doesn't mean you have to own your own car: you can belong to a car share scheme or hire a car when you need it. I agree with those saying that basic literacy, the ability to use a computer and driving are three skills that would make everyone's life easier and more enriched. Also with the person who learned later in life (like my mum) and has written about how even in small ways, life has become more flexible and varied.

Various people have commented on people who drive being dependent on their cars. I'd love to know how the person who gets their dog to the vet on public transport copes. My dog's been eating cow poo and has dreadful diarrhoea at the moment. We have a vet appointment this afternoon. I'd be terrified of trying to get him onto a bus and have him shitting everywhere.

Yes, but why do people HAVE to drive just because YOU think they should? Non-drivers might have less freedom than drivers in certain ways, however isn't that their choice. It only affects you when they expect you to ferry them around anywhere.

I live in a busy area in a city and I work around not having a car by having my doctor, dentist, and vet (if I had a pet) nearby. If I had a dog with diarrhoea I'd walk it with them (carrying cage if the dog can't walk). Anything else further afield (with no situations involving diarrhoea) I'd take a taxi. Simple!

I would be a nightmare behind a wheel. I have a short attention span and panic easily. Isn't it more responsible to not put myself behind a wheel than drive because some people in society think I should.

Dashdotdotdash · 30/05/2022 09:30

GoldenOmber · 29/05/2022 10:00

I’m not sure putting virtual-reality driving machines into schools and expecting the curriculum to drop however many hours of academic stuff to train teenagers in them, is really the best use of public money.

Why? You presumably wouldn't teach it till they're 17, and a couple of hours out of their timetable at that age needn't involve dropping anything academic at all. In FE colleges they're often on a three day timetable anyway. And it would be an excellent skill for them to have in employability terms, whatever their planned career. If it reduces the number of NEETS, you're saving a fortune on benefits. Win-win.

ManyBooksLittleTime · 30/05/2022 09:29

You come across as someone who exaggerates massively to prove their points.

I'm off to catch a bus and read 'Where the Crawdads Sing'. Which is excellent by the way. I'll leave you to your judgemental attitude and shitting dog

GoldfinchTart · 30/05/2022 09:21

suckingonchillidogs · 29/05/2022 19:09

If every adult could and did drive imagine the amount of traffic. It's a bloody good job not everyone does!

Not saying everyone should drive everywhere all the time. I'm saying that driving is a basic skill of modern life that I think most people would benefit from. Doesn't mean you have to own your own car: you can belong to a car share scheme or hire a car when you need it. I agree with those saying that basic literacy, the ability to use a computer and driving are three skills that would make everyone's life easier and more enriched. Also with the person who learned later in life (like my mum) and has written about how even in small ways, life has become more flexible and varied.

Various people have commented on people who drive being dependent on their cars. I'd love to know how the person who gets their dog to the vet on public transport copes. My dog's been eating cow poo and has dreadful diarrhoea at the moment. We have a vet appointment this afternoon. I'd be terrified of trying to get him onto a bus and have him shitting everywhere.

OP posts:
tiktokontheclock · 30/05/2022 09:16

Argh! You showed them your diary to prove you had a 4pm Zoom? You don't owe them anything. I would make it clear if it is convenient to you you will be offering a lift, otherwise no, you won't.

I can see both sides of this. I didn't pass until 28 as I failed so many tests but I had to do it because I wanted a kid and I can't get around my area and run errands without a car. But I would rather wait for a bus, taxi, walk than ask anyone for a lift.

ManyBooksLittleTime · 30/05/2022 09:15

OP you are hilarious. As if you are the type of person to offer shivering strangers at bus stops lifts! Now you are typing anything to prove your weird point....

UnsuitableHat · 30/05/2022 09:15

Perhaps people are trying to point out that non-drivers don’t always make the assumption that they’ll be given lifts.
I enjoy giving lifts, see it as something I can do to help people (often people who have helped me in other ways, or would do) and am sometimes surprised when an offer is declined, perhaps because someone had already planned how they’d get somewhere.

GoldenOmber · 30/05/2022 09:13

I had no idea how many proud non-drivers feel so oppressed by people offering them lifts.

I don’t think anyone said that, did they? Admittedly it’s a long thread, I might have missed some - but are you perhaps mixing that up with people getting annoyed when drivers are really pushy and insistent about they accept lifts?

“Would you like a lift?”
”No thanks, I’m fine.”

vs

”Would you like a lift?”
”No thanks, I’m fine.”
”But how will you get home?”
”It’s fine, I’m walking/getting the bus/whatever.”
”Oh you can’t WALK! It’s RAINING!”
”I like walking, I don’t mind.”
”Oh I wouldn’t hear of you walking in the rain. I’ll take you.”
”Really, no, thanks.”
”Oh don’t be so silly!” etc etc etc.

People do actually do this and it’s really irritating.

Frazzledmummy123 · 30/05/2022 09:12

GoldfinchTart · 30/05/2022 09:03

After reading all the comments here from non-drivers who feel insulted and assailed by drivers offering them lifts I'll never again stop when I'm driving into town on a cold wet morning and offer some shivering person waiting under an umbrella at a bus stop a lift. I had no idea how many proud non-drivers feel so oppressed by people offering them lifts.

So you are now complaining about non-drivers who DON'T want lifts?

GoldfinchTart · 30/05/2022 09:03

Divagal · 29/05/2022 20:54

I don't think it's unreasonable to be fed up with people asking for lifts per se but it does depend on circumstances. I didn't learn to drive until my late 30s because I just didn't have the money to buy and run a car. A work colleague used to drive past me at the bus stop and never stopped to pick me up. It used to really upset me. In those circumstances I would stop to pick the person up. If it was someone elderly or disabled and they had no-one to drive them to a hospital appointment or the shops I would take them. However, if I found that someone had the expectation I would be their personal taxi service i would definitely not agree to giving them lifts.

After reading all the comments here from non-drivers who feel insulted and assailed by drivers offering them lifts I'll never again stop when I'm driving into town on a cold wet morning and offer some shivering person waiting under an umbrella at a bus stop a lift. I had no idea how many proud non-drivers feel so oppressed by people offering them lifts.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread