Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Overprotective over deep water or is this a common fear?

35 replies

Plantpot45 · 28/05/2022 11:54

i have always had a massive fear of my children drowning. To a point where I think if I leave them to it, and adopt a more relaxed attitude around open water then it will 100% happen. This I realise is a bit irrational. My older children have learnt to swim and are old enough to know not to just jump into a deep flowing river or an open quay for example… so they I don’t have any fear over. They are safe in my eyes with an adult present but no need to hold them back I can just suggest they move away from the edge…

but my 4 year old (and when my others were little) just sent/sends me into a frenzy. I could cry around it and just hate it. It doesn’t help that he is really busy and active and just thinks he’s invincible.

This morning I took them to feed the ducks at the quay. Very dark and murky water and very strong undercurrents. I have no idea how deep it is but because I don’t know it’s worse. I tried to stay calm but said can we all just stand away from inches toward the edge please and eventually he was just closer and closer and I just said right all the seed is gone let’s go and tried to pull him back but he struggled to get away from me. This ramps up my anxiety because he’s more likely to fall in this way. Everyone else and their kids are just casual and relaxed. I think I must look mental worrying about it and being so overprotective but it scares the life out of me. He carried on trying to get away from me and ended up tripping over my foot, grazing his elbow and crying. Cue the staring.

Am I being overprotective/unreasonable or is this a rational and normal fear? How much fear do you all have around young children and deep water?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
superplumb · 28/05/2022 16:58

I'm exactly the same. I'm still terrified of water. In pools I need to be by the edge or the shallow end. I didnt learn until I was 11. My mum is also terrified and cant swim. I was desperate not to pass on the fear so mine both have lessons. I went mad when my youngest ran around the pool ( deep end). I must've looked manic

Bunnycat101 · 28/05/2022 15:03

I am hyper vigilant by water: I grew up by the sea and it was drummed into me. I think many people are just idiots with water so I don’t think you’re unreasonable to be protective but if the location is causing you to feel so anxious I wouldn’t be making it a trip with an unruly 4 yo.

My 3yo is unpredictable and until she becomes more sensible there are certain things I just won’t do with her. My eldest was generally much more compliant but went through a phase in her swimming lessons where she wasn’t listening and was jumping in the pool once I’d got out. She had some very big tellings off from her teacher but still had to be watched like a hawk around water.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 28/05/2022 14:13

I live near canals and find it very stressful if we go a walk near one, my youngest who is the same age will get far too close and still doesn't have a sense of balance and danger so I have to hold onto them the whole time.

However I'm not sure why youd take your spirited, thinks he is invincible 4 year old anywhere near deep murky water!^^

FruitToast · 28/05/2022 14:08

Well you're probably more relaxed than me as there would be absolutely no way I'd be feeding the ducks off a deep quay with strong currents with my DC (6&4). DD(6), who can swim, already has float to live drummed into her and I'm on full alert feeding the ducks at fairly shallow ponds with DS(4) because he's a bit of a menace! I wouldn't be fussed going crabbing though as long as it was somewhere relatively sensible, although again I'd be on full alert at all times. I do feel that many people are too lax around water.

lljkk · 28/05/2022 13:52

how strong are these currents?

Vsirbdo · 28/05/2022 13:50

I feel like that; in a large part because I’m not a strong swimmer

Plantpot45 · 28/05/2022 13:36

So it seems my concern is rational but my anxious behaviours are not so. I obviously know that or I wouldn’t be posting asking as an underlying feeling that the way I’m handling this is not normal.

we go here maybe once every month or so. The reason I go is because I don’t want them to feel like they’re missing out because of my anxiety. Feeding the ducks is a cheap (practically free) activity and there are lots of swans there and it’s beautiful… but… usually we go on the other side where the water is very shallow as the quay sort of starts if that makes sense. This time we walked this way and they saw a load of swans and said ‘can we feed them here’. I didn’t assess the risk at that moment appropriately and should have said no let’s go where we normally go. It just brought to light further my anxiety. They also absolutely love crabbing but this is even worse and the area where we go crabbing is even more dangerous so I literally avoid it like the plague. My husband on the other hand is just rediculously laid back and it makes me feel so uncomfortable so I just avoid doing it. Even as a strong swimmer some weather and sea conditions make it stupid to even attempt going to these places

OP posts:
SweetPetrichor · 28/05/2022 13:34

Seems pretty sensible. I work in a role that requires us to have a ‘working over water’ training certificate which we renew every 5 years. The risks associated with water are no joke. We have it emphasised constantly that you never get in water to try to rescue someone otherwise you are likely to become a victim yourself. The company who train us are nominally a water ‘rescue’ team but the guy explained that unless he’s there when you get into difficulties his job is more realistically ‘recovery’ of a body. Never take chances with water!

RedRec · 28/05/2022 13:20

You are not being unreasonable, OP. I remember feeling like this when going over a bridge with a low wall! My children are 21 and 18 now.

BiasedBinding · 28/05/2022 13:11

“If people are gawping at you maybe they should be looking at their own laissez-faire attitude to water safety and not yours.”

if you read the OP they were staring after the OP’s child fell over and hurt themselves whilst trying to get away from her after she tried to pull them away. I’m vigilant around water with my 4yo and 2yo but I’ve never had anyone staring at me because of the way my vigilance is applied. If this outcome for the OP isn’t unusual then I don’t understand why she would continue to take them to a supposedly fun activity in a place where her anxiety levels are so high that the result is everyone upset and/or hurt.

Singleandproud · 28/05/2022 12:58

People are too lax around water, people climb over the barriers or sit on the sea wall to crab where I live, it's insane as it's a really dangerous bit of sea.

However it sounds like your actions made it more likely to fall in so that might be a thing to think about too and how you deal with it.

There are things that you could do to mitigate your anxiety though. If feeding the ducks is a very regular thing that you do at this venue, buy a buoyancy aid for the non swimmer. A small one will fit in the back of a rucksack. They aren't expensive and it'll put your mind at rest and you can all enjoy yourself.

DD and I can both swim but if we go out in our kayak or paddle boat we both wear buoyancy aids as its the sensible thing to do.

MrsRuggles · 28/05/2022 12:52

Even a strong swimmer can have difficulties in a strong current or if in shock from the cold. Your caution is wise.

SagaNorenLansrimMalmo · 28/05/2022 12:51

And I should say, I am a laisse faire, relaxed parent. But not around water.

CorpseReviver · 28/05/2022 12:50

This morning I took them to feed the ducks at the quay. Very dark and murky water and very strong undercurrents. I have no idea how deep it is but because I don’t know it’s worse

This is a strange choice of activity given your (rational) fears.

SagaNorenLansrimMalmo · 28/05/2022 12:49

You’re anxiety levels might be a bit high, but it is not an irrational fear. Water and kids is dangerous. I am always in high alert around water with my kids and I’m a strong swimmer and I’ve made sure they can all swim. We filled the pond in as soon as we moved to our house (within days) because I couldn’t safely let them out in the garden if I didn’t! (I had a toddler at the time)

The danger feels particularly real because I’ve been present twice when children have been saved from drowning. Once around a lake, kids playing on a summer day, a child around 5 or 6 got into difficultly, his own parents were completely oblivious but my BIL spotted him and dashed in and pulled him out.

The other time, I was sitting by a pool on holiday watching my kids because they were both playing by the water - both were competent swimmers. They were fine, but because I was watching I saw someone else’s toddler tumble in. 2 or 3 years old, no flotation device on him, playing by a pool that was over 2m deep at that point. I saw him fall, so I immediately dived in, and was able to get him out - but it took surprisingly long for me to get to him. No one else saw it happen - this was a busy pool with a lifeguard! The lifeguard must have been looking the other way when he fell in - but once a kid is under the water, people don’t see. That child would have died in minutes if I hadn’t been watching. Water is dangerous. You are not being unreasonable.

Notanotherwindow · 28/05/2022 12:47

I'm a pretty relaxed guardian as it goes but I'd be the exact same as you. 4 year olds near water have as much sense as a squirrel on a motorway.

TinaYouFatLard · 28/05/2022 12:43

I think this is a sensible thing to be very concerned about. At least while your DC is so young and a non-swimmer.

balalake · 28/05/2022 12:43

Regardless of depth, there is the possibility of cold water shock. Perfectly reasonable to me sensible even if it looks cautious.

Bakedpotatoesfortea · 28/05/2022 12:38

Other people are so lax with water and their kids. I'm definitely on the anxious side and I feel no shame on that, because it only takes a moment. Children are unpredictable, water can be unpredictable too in the sense of hidden currents, hidden objects, tidal patterns and riptides (at the beach). I'm so vigilant even in the swimming pool, or the bath, padding pool, etc. I could never have a pond or a hot tub or swimming pool at home with young kids, I just feel it's too great a risk. And holidays with an unguarded pool, it all makes me feel very anxious.

I am a very anxious person around a lot of things, but around water I am only anxious with children and non swimmers. I've done a lot of outdoor swimming and sea swimming, surfing, body boarding and kayaking and the water has always been a really happy place for me, maybe that is why I am so vigilant though because I know you have to be. I think a lot of people are pretty naïve about the dangers of water. So as much as I know in some other areas I'm OTT in my anxieties, actually with water I think it's totally reasonable. Not being incredibly vigilant around water with young children is like not strapping them in their car seats in the car. It's a normal safety measure. If people are gawping at you maybe they should be looking at their own laissez-faire attitude to water safety and not yours.

BiasedBinding · 28/05/2022 12:33

I’m very vigilant around water, my two are small and not yet able to swim or fully understand safety around water so if we eg go to the river near my house to paddle I only go if we have a one adult to one child ratio.

in your situation though I don’t understand why you would take them to feed the ducks in such a place if it causes you such anxiety? It’s easily avoided as an activity and they aren’t missing out on much.

PurpleFlower1983 · 28/05/2022 12:29

I wouldn’t have taken my child to feed the ducks there, just the local pond for us, my anxiety wouldn’t have allowed it!

trevthecat · 28/05/2022 12:26

I'm like this over any body of water. Even if it is shallow. It is something I am working on but it's very difficult to rationalise for me so I completely get this

Luckystar1 · 28/05/2022 12:18

Sorry autocorrect lax

WakeWaterWalk · 28/05/2022 12:17

I think it's drilled into some of us by parents. Understandable really.

Luckystar1 · 28/05/2022 12:16

I take the view when it comes to these things, that people might think I’m over the top, but I would be the one to lose everything of anything happened to my child or children so I will do all that I can to keep them safe.

I have found some peoples approaches to these things very lack, but again, that’s on them.

And no, I think you are absolutely right. Something can happen in a split second that could change lives forever.

Swipe left for the next trending thread