Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Say Well Done Suella Braverman.

295 replies

AnonIsUsuallyAWoman · 28/05/2022 00:32

Of course I'm not and I'm going to applaud her. Well Done and Thank You! Brava!

OP posts:
LondonWolf · 29/05/2022 09:13

I really wish her teachers hadn't fallen over themselves to show how accepting they were of her new identity. It actually seemed like they were delighted to be able to prove how great they were at equality.

I'm seeing this play out at my child's school, it's excruciating to observe.

Where on Earth does this idea come from that you have to agree or disagree with 100% of someone else’s views, and that there can be no nuance of “I agree with them on X but I disagree on Y and Z”?

Social media. It's a relative new phenomenon.

Notgoodatpoetrybutgreatatlit · 29/05/2022 09:00

I think this topic as applied to schools is a complex one. I and my colleagues deal with complex matters in a nuanced case by case way. We don't knee jerk react to every idea. Mostly the problems I think you envisage don't occur. We are talking about actual young people here who have personalities and friends not abstract concepts.

Smileyaxolotl1 · 29/05/2022 08:26

Notgoodatpoetrybutgreatatlit

do you think telling girls and boys that they can change sex and that the world must see them as they see themselves despite the evidence of their eyes is positive to their mental health then?

Smileyaxolotl1 · 29/05/2022 08:25

TullyApplebottom

Thanks for pointing out the ridiculousness of these people who thinks The daughter of immigrants who went to Cambridge is a
‘half wit.’
Ayou say it comes straight from the leftie playbook of ‘everyone who doesn’t agree with me is stupid, despite all tangible evidence to the contrary.’

Notgoodatpoetrybutgreatatlit · 29/05/2022 08:22

I am a teacher and I am always amused by the way government ministers think schools react to every piece of nonsense that falls out of their heads. I worked in schools during the days of clause 28 and we ignored that quite happily.
Braverman isn't even education secretary so even less likely anyone will take any notice.
If this morally bankrupt government did change the law or issue direct instructions to harm children's mental health, as other governments have done, many schools will not enforce the harm. Its just what we do. Or don't do.

Smileyaxolotl1 · 29/05/2022 08:21

Big Green
What is your 7 year old child watching /exposed to that he even knows anything about pronouns?(other than what they are grammatically)

if he wants to use female pronouns it’s almost definitely because he has been told that dresses etc are for girls.

You are obviously doing the right thing in letting him wear whatever he wants etc

”If my kid wants different pronouns when he's a little older then great”

can you explain why it would be ‘great’ rather than just ok or fair enough.
why would it be great for your child to be suffering from a medical condition/ subjected to life long medication etc?

TullyApplebottom · 29/05/2022 08:17

ilovesooty · 29/05/2022 00:35

It might make her academically qualified. It doesn't make her intelligent.

are the universities of Cambridge and Paris in the habit of admitting stupid people?

BigGreen · 29/05/2022 08:04

I have a gnc 7 year old who asked if I could change his pronouns at school. I said 'not yet' because I felt at that the time that was a notable act of gender transition. I was relived in the interim cass report that they considered social transition not to be neutral. Don't get me wrong, I buy my kid dresses and all the sparkly things he loves.

But kids identities are in flux at this age and we need to reinforce the message that any one can like any thing, since gender stereotypes are so present and easy for kids to hold on to. If my kid wants different pronouns when he's a little older then great. But yeah, this stuff has to be worked out with the specific child and their best interests in mind. Not by some activist on Twitter and not by Braverman either in a culture war.

itsgettingweird · 29/05/2022 07:07

SidewaysOtter · 28/05/2022 21:17

Ok so i will ask again. You have Amelia in front of you, 16 years old and vulnerable. She tells you she wants to be known as Aaron and he/him. You're going to say... What?

That she needs to understand why she feels that way. Is she feeling pressured to conform to a gender stereotype of hypersexualised Kardashian-looking “femininity”? Then she needs to be helped to understand that “woman” is not that rigidly defined. Is she struggling with puberty? Are there underlying mental health problems? Is something else going on? If she’s vulnerable, then she absolutely needs the reasons for her feelings addressing.

If after all that Amelia genuinely feels that she wants to be Aaron, then she needs understand that with her rights come responsibilities, and those responsibilities include accepting that your rights have to be balanced with those of others.

Love this response.

It's exactly how I feel.

I've always said to the statement they "identify as a woman"

"What is identifying as a woman" - funnily enough no one can answer because there is no actual definition. And you can't identify as a female sex as that's a biological classification based on actual genetics.

It's often a belief they aren't good enough as they are. They aren't being a proper woman.

And that's really sad.

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 29/05/2022 06:38

TullyApplebottom · 29/05/2022 00:23

Braver man has an u dergeaduate law degree from Cambridge and a masters from the Sorbonne. Would be interested to know how many of the people here insulting her intellect had a comparable academic background.
the left has struggled for a long time to accept that disagreeing with them politically does not necessarily equate to stupidity. Helps to explain why it is so unsuccessful electorally

Refusing to answer Emily Thornberry's question in Parliament and then going off on a rant about flags is hardly a display of towering intellect.

TomPinch · 29/05/2022 02:08

Badqueen · 28/05/2022 21:54

Exactly.

In which case you should applaud Suella Braverman for saying that the law allows the school the choice to use, or not to use, the child's preferred pronouns.

I'm sure teachers are intelligent and sensitive enough to decide what is best without being bullied by Stonewall.

ilovesooty · 29/05/2022 00:35

It might make her academically qualified. It doesn't make her intelligent.

TullyApplebottom · 29/05/2022 00:23

Braver man has an u dergeaduate law degree from Cambridge and a masters from the Sorbonne. Would be interested to know how many of the people here insulting her intellect had a comparable academic background.
the left has struggled for a long time to accept that disagreeing with them politically does not necessarily equate to stupidity. Helps to explain why it is so unsuccessful electorally

ilovesooty · 29/05/2022 00:05

LauraNicolaides · 28/05/2022 23:56

The woman is an overpromoted, incompetent halfwit who is devoid of professional ethics. She got to be Attorney General because she has a legal qualification and will do what she's told by Johnson rather than performing her constitutional role as she should. In a government of the most useless dimwits in my lifetime she still stands out as awful. That's an achievement I guess. Well done.

Elegantly expressed. Couldn't agree more.

LauraNicolaides · 28/05/2022 23:56

The woman is an overpromoted, incompetent halfwit who is devoid of professional ethics. She got to be Attorney General because she has a legal qualification and will do what she's told by Johnson rather than performing her constitutional role as she should. In a government of the most useless dimwits in my lifetime she still stands out as awful. That's an achievement I guess. Well done.

Highlyquestionablehoumous · 28/05/2022 23:29

lifeturnsonadime · 28/05/2022 23:28

I'm sick of this being played out as a Labour v Tory issue. It isn't one.

It's fundamental to the human rights of women to be able to describe ourselves as separate from men.

That is what the Labour Party is putting on the line.

That's on them. As a life long labour voter I'm horrified by the stance of the Labour Party on this.

What the Tory party does is irrelevant to the way I feel betrayed by Labour.

Yes, this.

lifeturnsonadime · 28/05/2022 23:28

I'm sick of this being played out as a Labour v Tory issue. It isn't one.

It's fundamental to the human rights of women to be able to describe ourselves as separate from men.

That is what the Labour Party is putting on the line.

That's on them. As a life long labour voter I'm horrified by the stance of the Labour Party on this.

What the Tory party does is irrelevant to the way I feel betrayed by Labour.

Highlyquestionablehoumous · 28/05/2022 23:22

ilovesooty · 28/05/2022 23:18

And Lisa Nandy is not in government.

Why aren't you concerned about the fact that the current government has done nothing to promote women's safe spaces?

To be honest, I am pretty depressed that absolutely no one seems to give a fuck about women. Sad

The Tories have thankfully kicked GRA reform out the window for now, which is a huge relief, but it's only because they know which way the wind is blowing, not because they actually care about women.

SidewaysOtter · 28/05/2022 23:20

This is what you want to ally yourselves with?

I don’t need to “ally” myself with someone to agree with one thing they’ve said. Where on Earth does this idea come from that you have to agree or disagree with 100% of someone else’s views, and that there can be no nuance of “I agree with them on X but I disagree on Y and Z”? The world is not divided into those with whom we completely agree (good) and anyone with whom we even fractionally disagree (bad).

ilovesooty · 28/05/2022 23:18

Highlyquestionablehoumous · 28/05/2022 23:14

How does what affect me? Being told a woman can have a penis?

Well, for a start I want to use a space that is labelled 'female' and know that it is only going to have females in it. If I don't mind sharing with males (and some people don't) then I can use spaces that are clearly labelled as mixed sex.

I also don't want females in prison to have to share their space with a male rapist and their 'lady penis'. Lisa Nandy of the Labour Party disagrees with me on this and is on the record as saying that she believes that a male rapist should be allowed to go to a female prison if that's what they want. I also want females who need to use a woman's refuge, or a hospital, for a example, to be able to know that it is a single sex space. Free of penis.

What's so bad about any of that?

And Lisa Nandy is not in government.

Why aren't you concerned about the fact that the current government has done nothing to promote women's safe spaces?

lifeturnsonadime · 28/05/2022 23:17

Lindy2, my autistic 12 year old daughter is , like your daughter, a tom boy.

Autistic girls are susceptible to this trans fashion because many autistic girls have sensory processing issues which makes 'traditionally boys' clothes more comfortable and given that autistic girls have social communication difficulties it's unsurprising that they find the social 'chit chat' of girls of a similar age challenging. All of a sudden our girls are told that they belong to a trans club which is very popular, hey presto a cool identity. Why wouldn't they?

It's highly disturbing that given the Cass report has demonstrated that the influx of girls identifiying as trans is predominately made up of autistic girls or girls with other developmental or trauma responses that any adult who stands up to this is called a bigot.

Given that our girls are being conditioned to believe that sterilisation is the cure I really do believe that eugenics has a part to play in this. At least in the silence of the professionals who know exactly which kind of girls are affected most by this ideology.

Highlyquestionablehoumous · 28/05/2022 23:16

Odessafile · 28/05/2022 23:10

@ilovesooty clumsy sarcasm intended

Probably not a great idea to do that tbh - it will be screenshotted out of context on Twitter by TRAs before you know it.

ilovesooty · 28/05/2022 23:16

Odessafile · 28/05/2022 23:10

@ilovesooty clumsy sarcasm intended

Apologies! Thank goodness for that 🤣

Highlyquestionablehoumous · 28/05/2022 23:14

lechatestsurlemat · 28/05/2022 23:06

Highlyquestionablehoumous
How does that affect you personally?

How does what affect me? Being told a woman can have a penis?

Well, for a start I want to use a space that is labelled 'female' and know that it is only going to have females in it. If I don't mind sharing with males (and some people don't) then I can use spaces that are clearly labelled as mixed sex.

I also don't want females in prison to have to share their space with a male rapist and their 'lady penis'. Lisa Nandy of the Labour Party disagrees with me on this and is on the record as saying that she believes that a male rapist should be allowed to go to a female prison if that's what they want. I also want females who need to use a woman's refuge, or a hospital, for a example, to be able to know that it is a single sex space. Free of penis.

What's so bad about any of that?

Odessafile · 28/05/2022 23:10

@ilovesooty clumsy sarcasm intended