Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Say Well Done Suella Braverman.

295 replies

AnonIsUsuallyAWoman · 28/05/2022 00:32

Of course I'm not and I'm going to applaud her. Well Done and Thank You! Brava!

OP posts:
TalkingCat · 29/05/2022 10:46

pointythings · 28/05/2022 19:39

@Jott you are so right. My youngest started questioning their identity in Yr11. Their 6th form fully respected their pronouns. It gave them a sense of safety at school and a sense of belonging. How the fuck is that a bad thing?

The problem with accepting pronouns is that it's the first step to allowing males into female spaces. They will think, ok, you accept me as a she, so why can't I go to the female toilets?

It's the old give an inch, take a mile. As we can see, dehumanising language around women (menstruators, uterus-havers', bleeders, etc) is the first step to changing the narrative. That lead to enforcing pronouns. Pronouns are basically redundant anyway, you don't say "hello she, how are you?" Pronouns are rarely needed, it's a status contagion. Then, from pronouns we had 'I have the right to use the changing facility that matches my pronouns.

It's a slippery slope. And using female pronouns for a question male, but not allowing them to go to the female toilets will only confuse them.

It's far easier to have a uniform blanket just say no to it all approach. You can't allow pronouns and not allow bathrooms.

Though admittedly I have no problems with them wearing girls uniforms. But, I guess the AG sees it as 'one in all in' so it has to be 'no in' approach.

I don't see why kids can't just be kids and be questioning or whatever at home.

Babdoc · 29/05/2022 10:45

Quite apart from the unanswerable safeguarding and preservation of single sex spaces issue, most secondary schools have over a thousand pupils. How the hell can a teacher remember a thousand permutations of pronouns from fae to ze, along with the children’s names? Let alone the “fluid” ones who change daily? The whole thing is a ridiculous indulgence.

Tanith · 29/05/2022 10:44

I’m cynical about mediocre politicians jumping clumsily into the trans debate in the hope of bolstering up their flagging popularity.

I’m glad that the grip of Gender Identity politics on school children is being addressed, but I’m dubious that Suella Braverman really cares about it. She saw it working for Liz Truss, I suspect.

I wish TRAs would stop the daft comparisons to Section 28! I think it’s so disrespectful to appropriate the struggle for gay rights. If the TRA claims weren’t so weak, they’d stand by themselves.

ReadtheReviews · 29/05/2022 10:40

@MrsWooster The current situation is bordering on active conversion therapy, whereby gender non conforming children are cemented into a trans identity. If children are supported via watchful waiting, then >80% will grow up to not identify as trans and the majority will be gay or lesbian.*

Really well put.

TalkingCat · 29/05/2022 10:38

Jott · 28/05/2022 19:51

clearly evidenced by the fact that it is overwhelmingly teenage girls who are wanting to transition

I'd say that's more to do with how girls and women are treated by society and the idea that it would be better to be a boy and benefit from male privilege rather than being a girl and subject to it.

I'd say that's more to do with how girls and women are treated by society and the idea that it would be better to be a boy and benefit from male privilege rather than being a girl and subject to it.

I wonder why that is? MRAs and TRAs are saying girls and women don't deserve safe spaces, we don't deserve dignity or privacy, that what a male-bodied person wants, they get.

And YOU SUPPORT THIS! You enable this! @Jott

TomPinch · 29/05/2022 10:36

I think that after having taken a dump in the hallway Jott left the building and won't be seen again.

ReadtheReviews · 29/05/2022 10:36

I think it's focusing on red herrings really. Who cares what uniform a child wears, who really cares about pronouns as long as a teacher isn't forced to use them? By enforcing uniform for the sex that the child is, they're reinforcing the idea that clothes = sex. A boy could wear a schooldress and call himself Evie and still be a boy - that is the more valid gender critical point.
What needs protecting is a teacher being allowed to disagree with gender ideology and phrase all references to such as 'some people believe'. And the times when sexed bodies really matter ie. in school toilets, changing rooms and sports.

MarshaBradyo · 29/05/2022 10:33

I don’t agree on uniforms, pronouns issue is complex and needs consideration, generally we’re seeing women’s rights being revisited and I hope safe spaces and sports are kept and the school situation is looked at carefully.

I don’t have enough info to back the words by Braverman but I am pleased girls are now on the agenda in terms of balancing how to move forward.

TalkingCat · 29/05/2022 10:31

And comparing the treatment of gays (who weren't seeking to victimise women and take anything away from anyone) to trans is emotionally manipulative and absolutely dishonest and absurd. They are nothing alike. @Jott

TalkingCat · 29/05/2022 10:29

Jott · 28/05/2022 19:01

And a big old fuck you to the children caught in the crossfire of your transphobia, yeah?

@Jott What about your femphobia?

If children are caught in the crossfire, didn't it ever occur to you that it is a direct result of the Mens Rights Activists/Trans Activists who actually working to deliberately remove all the safe spaces women have?

Maybe blame the PERPETRATORS, not the victims (women). What you're doing is gaslighting women and victimising women all over again. That children are caught up in MRAs/TRAs methodical and deliberate act to remove all our safe spaces, our facilities, our sports teams, our RAPE CRISIS CENTRES! That is ALL the fault of MRAs/TRAs. Don't you even dare blame that on women!

SidewaysOtter · 29/05/2022 10:29

Schools do lose their shit over uniform, for some reason - it wouldn't kill them to just let kids wear the version they feel most comfortable with.

Or maybe it does kids good to learn boundaries and that sometimes you do have to conform to an extent, rather than being told that their personal preferences are more important.

And I find the argument that “kids have been through Covid so cut them some slack” a bizarre one, as if getting what they want is some sort of consolation prize. Surely boundaries would give a greater sense of security and comfort than being able to behave how they please.

MarshaBradyo · 29/05/2022 10:28

spirit20 · 29/05/2022 09:51

She is horrible and it's a really scary sign of what the world is coming to. It's based on complete misinformation, there are trans pupils in the school I teach and I have never heard of a person assigned male at birth sharing facilities with people assigned female at birth.

This mangling of language is concerning.

TalkingCat · 29/05/2022 10:23

pointythings · 28/05/2022 18:52

I think we need single sex spaces and the architecture of public spaces needs to change to accommodate everyone. But I think that refusing to acknowledge pronouns is just plain unkind, and as for uniform - just ditch it already and let people wear what they want.

Transphobia is popular right now, that's what Braverman's statement was all about.

@pointythings Transphobia is NOT popular right now, it is Femphobia that is popular and all the rage right now. Transgender are the MOST POPULAR and most POWERFUL group there is. Even more powerful than men.

Notgoodatpoetrybutgreatatlit · 29/05/2022 10:17

Most schools at least decent ones, have an awareness that bullying happens and have zero tolerance no matter what the "reason" the bullies give.
For what it is worth in my long experience in secondary schools in London the most common reasons are homophobia and transphobia. Although the sexism many girls are subjected to is a nasty still underaddressed undercurrent.
Schools reflect the values of society. However this might surprise some adults, the majority of young people currently in school are pretty left wing. In our last mock general election the vote split between Labour and green. With a few charming mavericks writing SNP onto their ballot papers. We are a London school.

balalake · 29/05/2022 09:57

Suella Braverman is prepared to be in a government by a man who has no respect for women and should have faced criminal charges for some of the things he has done.

The broken clock analogy is a fair one.

MrsWooster · 29/05/2022 09:56

Jott · 28/05/2022 18:57

Her article reminded me immensely of my school days when Section 28 was in full effect. My best friend and his boyfriend were suspended for being openly gay, our head of year also rang both sets of parents and outed them to their families. The boyfriend's family were fine, my best friend's family not so much and his dad beat him before throwing him out of the house. Teachers would call boys who were being weak or pathetic (in the teacher's opinion) nancies/nancy boys. A female teacher was made to resign after pupils found out she had a girlfriend and was a regular at the local gay bar (and most gay bars had a policy of no photographs on the premises because such photos could be used against people). A friend tried to talk to her form teacher as she thought she might be gay, she was bluntly told "I can't discuss this with you and I suggest you don't tell anyone".

That's the sort of environment she's advocating a return to. Regardless of where you stand on the issue (and I'm not getting into that), do you really want children to be told that the way they're feeling doesn't matter, that any struggles or issues they're having in that area aren't real, that they should just ignore it and carry on as normal?

While I thought the article was clumsily phrased, particularly the use of the word “pandering” for children who are experiencing confusion and /or distress, this is NOTHING like Section 28.
The current situation is bordering on active conversion therapy, whereby gender non conforming children are cemented into a trans identity. If children are supported via watchful waiting*, then >80% will grow up to not identify as trans and the majority will be gay or lesbian.

(*for me, this would mean acceptance of gender non conforming presentation, but a consistent and clear rejection of the idea that it is possible (or desirable)for a human being to change sex. )

DecayedStrumpet · 29/05/2022 09:55

No i would not vote bnp if they promised to remove the GRA. Or ukip. It probably is their poilcy, to be fair, I've never read their manifestos.

spirit20 · 29/05/2022 09:51

She is horrible and it's a really scary sign of what the world is coming to. It's based on complete misinformation, there are trans pupils in the school I teach and I have never heard of a person assigned male at birth sharing facilities with people assigned female at birth.

Badqueen · 29/05/2022 09:50

ReformedWaywardTeen · 29/05/2022 09:42

In my DC case, as obviously they approached me and I was at first surprised, they had very definite reasons
This wasn't something done because another mate was doing it.

They are female presenting. They had come out as gay 2 years before. We fully supported this- no reason not to.

Their attitude is women are treated, to put it bluntly, like shit. They feel that all anyone ever sees is female or male. Men are able to do as they wish. Women are placed in two columns- sexy, fit Love Island influencer and thus "worthy and wanted" and everyone else. They said they didn't want to be a body, a vessel of good looking or everything else. That they don't subscribe to female led beliefs and although they also don't feel male, they prefer to be in the middle.
They dress like most teens now in hoody and skinny jeans. They have a short floppy Bob and describe themselves as "alternative". They use the shortened, more associated with masculine version of their feminine name but then, they are named after two family members and both used the more male associated name as a nickname but were and are very much still female.
They were respectful when we hit a bump in that I was getting married and I asked them to be involved, they agreed to be a bridesmaid, with the agreement that at the reception they could get changed into casual clothes- all my bridesmaids did this as it was hot and I didn't wear my wedding dress for long after either

I can accommodate their wishes for as long as this lasts. They've been through some pretty shit times due to the pandemic. Their school has a club for LGBTQ+ where allies are welcome. School is making a safe space for changing for PE ready for next term.

I've explained that in my view, I would rather females in their generation did stuff to make things better for girls rather than declaring themselves neither. That many have already become politically aware and stuff far earlier than my generation did and some kick ass females smashing the patriarchy would be cool. Their attitude was they understood this but felt that it was too much to achieve, too ingrained, too big a task.

Obviously that's my teen, I can't comment for others and their choices. Mermaids is not in their school. School asked me if it was fine to refer to them by their preferred name.

They are happy and as a parent that's all you can hope for, right?

You sounds like a wonderful parent. I can certainly empathize with a girl looking at all the problems in the world that females face and wanting to identify out of that and feeling like it's too big to change by themselves.

Ironically suella could absolutely do something about changing some of those things but she actively votes against it.

Badqueen · 29/05/2022 09:47

Braverman isn't just a little bit right wing. She's consistently voted against equality for gay people and women. She voted against gay marriage.

But she's your poster girl now. People on this thread are outright celebrating her and saying "thank God for suella".

You're like turkeys celebrating Christmas. She doesn't give a shiny shit about you any more than she does gender non conforming children.

ReformedWaywardTeen · 29/05/2022 09:42

SidewaysOtter · 28/05/2022 22:10

In schools up and down the country, young people are questioning their gender.

Dows anyone stop to ask why? Unlike homosexuality, where people in older generations came out as gay when it became more socially acceptable, changing gender seems to be mostly the preserve of younger people. I’m not aware of a rush of older people coming out as non binary/trans all of a sudden. Which does tend to indicate that there is the least an element of a) an underlying issue particular to younger people and/or b) social contagion.

In my DC case, as obviously they approached me and I was at first surprised, they had very definite reasons
This wasn't something done because another mate was doing it.

They are female presenting. They had come out as gay 2 years before. We fully supported this- no reason not to.

Their attitude is women are treated, to put it bluntly, like shit. They feel that all anyone ever sees is female or male. Men are able to do as they wish. Women are placed in two columns- sexy, fit Love Island influencer and thus "worthy and wanted" and everyone else. They said they didn't want to be a body, a vessel of good looking or everything else. That they don't subscribe to female led beliefs and although they also don't feel male, they prefer to be in the middle.
They dress like most teens now in hoody and skinny jeans. They have a short floppy Bob and describe themselves as "alternative". They use the shortened, more associated with masculine version of their feminine name but then, they are named after two family members and both used the more male associated name as a nickname but were and are very much still female.
They were respectful when we hit a bump in that I was getting married and I asked them to be involved, they agreed to be a bridesmaid, with the agreement that at the reception they could get changed into casual clothes- all my bridesmaids did this as it was hot and I didn't wear my wedding dress for long after either

I can accommodate their wishes for as long as this lasts. They've been through some pretty shit times due to the pandemic. Their school has a club for LGBTQ+ where allies are welcome. School is making a safe space for changing for PE ready for next term.

I've explained that in my view, I would rather females in their generation did stuff to make things better for girls rather than declaring themselves neither. That many have already become politically aware and stuff far earlier than my generation did and some kick ass females smashing the patriarchy would be cool. Their attitude was they understood this but felt that it was too much to achieve, too ingrained, too big a task.

Obviously that's my teen, I can't comment for others and their choices. Mermaids is not in their school. School asked me if it was fine to refer to them by their preferred name.

They are happy and as a parent that's all you can hope for, right?

ImAvingOops · 29/05/2022 09:33

Pronouns should be solely about grammar. If I had a girl in front of me wanting to be called Aaron, I'd agree (with the consent of her parents) because I want the child to feel comfortable. And changing a name has no meaningful consequences beyond that. However, I should not have to use grammatically incorrect pronouns, to affirm a belief I do not share. I might, as a social nicety, but I shouldn't be compelled to. Reality does matter.

Schools do lose their shit over uniform, for some reason - it wouldn't kill them to just let kids wear the version they feel most comfortable with. And there should be some rejigging of loos and changing areas so that all kids can enjoy privacy. This would remove a lot of the areas of contention in school.

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 29/05/2022 09:25

Notgoodatpoetrybutgreatatlit · 29/05/2022 08:22

I am a teacher and I am always amused by the way government ministers think schools react to every piece of nonsense that falls out of their heads. I worked in schools during the days of clause 28 and we ignored that quite happily.
Braverman isn't even education secretary so even less likely anyone will take any notice.
If this morally bankrupt government did change the law or issue direct instructions to harm children's mental health, as other governments have done, many schools will not enforce the harm. Its just what we do. Or don't do.

Just like that school that allowed the young girl to be bullied out for questioning the trans agenda…

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 29/05/2022 09:20

BigGreen · 29/05/2022 08:04

I have a gnc 7 year old who asked if I could change his pronouns at school. I said 'not yet' because I felt at that the time that was a notable act of gender transition. I was relived in the interim cass report that they considered social transition not to be neutral. Don't get me wrong, I buy my kid dresses and all the sparkly things he loves.

But kids identities are in flux at this age and we need to reinforce the message that any one can like any thing, since gender stereotypes are so present and easy for kids to hold on to. If my kid wants different pronouns when he's a little older then great. But yeah, this stuff has to be worked out with the specific child and their best interests in mind. Not by some activist on Twitter and not by Braverman either in a culture war.

What possible relevance have pronouns to do with which clothes he likes?

This is so messed up. Boys can like sparkly clothes, what sort of 1950s regressive shit makes anyone think that they are therefore a girl?

Does he have a penis? If so, he’s a boy. If he likes dresses, he’s a boy who likes dresses.

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 29/05/2022 09:17

ilovesooty · 29/05/2022 00:35

It might make her academically qualified. It doesn't make her intelligent.

I really don’t think you’ve thought that through. You don’t get those degrees without having some intelligence to call on. How many of her critics actually have any evidence that they are more intelligent?