Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Say Well Done Suella Braverman.

295 replies

AnonIsUsuallyAWoman · 28/05/2022 00:32

Of course I'm not and I'm going to applaud her. Well Done and Thank You! Brava!

OP posts:
Highlyquestionablehoumous · 28/05/2022 20:31

It's such a tricky one - a really important lesson for children to learn is that you cannot control how others see you, and you cannot force people to see you as something you are not. Continuing to perpetuate the idea to young people that you can do this, probably isn't going to help them in the long run.

But on the other hand, the teenage years are so tricky, and for children who have been brought up with gender bullshit, to suddenly be told that their pronouns and identity is completely meaningless will be very difficult to deal with and will cause further identity issues.

I really hope this pronoun crap and the importance that young people have attached to it is over by the time mine are teenagers. TRAs have a lot to answer for.

TullyApplebottom · 28/05/2022 20:29

VladmirsPoutine · 28/05/2022 19:53

I'm convinced there are people who celebrate Eva Braun for being the first girl boss feminist.

If you are genuinely convinced about this, it might be an idea to get out more.

LondonWolf · 28/05/2022 20:26

But not having their pronouns respected doesn't help them. It doesn't help anyone.

It helps those who don't want to use compelled speech and be forced to partake in someone else's very recent belief system. We will never agree on this but I genuinely hope things go well for your child.

ilovesooty · 28/05/2022 20:19

And nobody should have to put up with being told that because they're a child it's OK not to listen to them.

This is populist bullshit - Braverman doesn't care about anyone let alone children.

pointythings · 28/05/2022 20:19

@LondonWolf my youngest is also autistic. They do not know whether or not they want to transition (I deliberately use 'they' because it's nobody's business what they were born). They have a lot to work out in therapy and they know it. But not having their pronouns respected doesn't help them. It doesn't help anyone. The people currently pushing back are just as bad as the TRAs. Everyone on the extreme needs to give their head a good slap and start thinking about what's the best thing for our young people. As always it will lie somewhere in the middle.

willingtolearn · 28/05/2022 20:17

I disagree with several statements here and have read The Times article.

Those who state it is necessary to 'use requested pronouns' in order to be kind are wrong. You can be kind and respectful without actually entering into their belief system. It is unkind to demand that someone must agree with them and practice their beliefs - in fact it is intolerant to other's beliefs.

Whilst many young people experience mental distress, the way in which they express this can be socially problematic - self harm, refusing to eat, refusing to attend school, misuse of alcohol and drugs. We can empathise with them but we do them no good in always agreeing with them that they know best. We may in fact do them harm. The demands of gender ideologists are particularly harmful - to individuals and to society.

School is an area to learn, and to be kept safe - that's it. It's not an arena for you to express yourself or to have your belief system reinforced.

This is not about sexuality, this is about belief. But both of these require consent of others to participate - no-one should be forced to participate in someone else's belief system - not in school or anyone else.

TangyTangerine · 28/05/2022 20:15

Yes you are being massively unreasonable. It's easy to say the right things (and the tories excel at saying things the public want to hear: it's called populism) but dig a bit deeper and I ok at her voting record. She is no friend of children.

ilovesooty · 28/05/2022 19:54

Just respecting how a child wants to be addressed is the decent thing to do. It doesn't mean you're encouraging them to transition. Why should someone not be treated with kindness and decency just because they're under 18?

VladmirsPoutine · 28/05/2022 19:53

I'm convinced there are people who celebrate Eva Braun for being the first girl boss feminist.

LondonWolf · 28/05/2022 19:52

pointythings · 28/05/2022 19:39

@Jott you are so right. My youngest started questioning their identity in Yr11. Their 6th form fully respected their pronouns. It gave them a sense of safety at school and a sense of belonging. How the fuck is that a bad thing?

I sorry but not many people care about these young people now. It was the inevitable outcome of the relentless, bullying, authoritarian approach of trans rights activists. It's no good getting angry at those pushing back on it. The responsibility lies in one place and as the mother of an autistic girl - the demographic most affected by this damaging ideology - I am relieved that the push back has arrived but worried about those kids who have been sacrificed to it.

Highlyquestionablehoumous · 28/05/2022 19:52

Jott · 28/05/2022 19:51

clearly evidenced by the fact that it is overwhelmingly teenage girls who are wanting to transition

I'd say that's more to do with how girls and women are treated by society and the idea that it would be better to be a boy and benefit from male privilege rather than being a girl and subject to it.

Yes exactly - social contagion. Its a social issue rather than something inherent.

Jott · 28/05/2022 19:51

clearly evidenced by the fact that it is overwhelmingly teenage girls who are wanting to transition

I'd say that's more to do with how girls and women are treated by society and the idea that it would be better to be a boy and benefit from male privilege rather than being a girl and subject to it.

AgathaMystery · 28/05/2022 19:50

ImAvingOops · 28/05/2022 19:37

Schools should be sensitive to children who are in distress for whatever reason and treat them with kindness and care. But I'm not sure that unquestioning acceptance is the way to go. A lot of children go through gender confusion as a temporary phase or because something else is going on (like undiagnosed autism in girls) and I don't believe it's right to automatically agree that they are definitely trans and start treating them as if they were the opposite sex.

The pronoun thing is just stupid anyway - 'she' denotes female and 'he' denotes male. Language has meaning, as much as TRA might like to pretend otherwise.

I can't read the linked article but I would be very surprised if it was as blunt as 'suck it up'. But I'll be honest, too much time has been spent indulging TRA at the expense of everyone else. It's dangerous and it has no place in schools

Exactly this.

SidewaysOtter · 28/05/2022 19:45

TopKnotch · 28/05/2022 19:41

I find the drawing of parallels with section 28 baffling.

Gender ideology is inherently incompatible with same sex attraction. Much of GI rhetoric is extremely homophobic. See the ridiculous comments made in the Allison Bailey trial this week about lesbians who do not want to consider transwomen in their dating pool for example.

Being gay didn't require anyone to do anything. No one else had to give up any rights to enable gay and lesbian people to have the same. No one had to deny or lie about their own material reality for gay rights. Gay rights were won through discussion, debate, disagreement and conversation - #nodebate for transrights and their implications is a very very different kettle of fish.

I quite agree.

But apparently there must be #nodebate on the matter because to do so is transphobia 🙄

ReformedWaywardTeen · 28/05/2022 19:45

Sorry but my DC is non-binary and that's their choice. No one else's. If it's a phase then fine.
We've pandered far more to other groups in school than teachers being asked to use they/them or whatever pronouns make a kid happy. And after the shitshow of the last few years frankly she needs to get a grip and show some respect to kids.

TopKnotch · 28/05/2022 19:41

I find the drawing of parallels with section 28 baffling.

Gender ideology is inherently incompatible with same sex attraction. Much of GI rhetoric is extremely homophobic. See the ridiculous comments made in the Allison Bailey trial this week about lesbians who do not want to consider transwomen in their dating pool for example.

Being gay didn't require anyone to do anything. No one else had to give up any rights to enable gay and lesbian people to have the same. No one had to deny or lie about their own material reality for gay rights. Gay rights were won through discussion, debate, disagreement and conversation - #nodebate for transrights and their implications is a very very different kettle of fish.

Highlyquestionablehoumous · 28/05/2022 19:40

Sorry, I have said 'Bannerman' several times, I mean Braverman!

Highlyquestionablehoumous · 28/05/2022 19:39

Unfortunately a lot of people who know absolutely bollocks all about child development have pushed the trans agenda to the point where now there is definitely a social contagion going on in schools (partly clearly evidenced by the fact that it is overwhelmingly teenage girls who are wanting to transition).

These people, such as Mermaids, went into schools and told children that if they identify with Barbie they have a girls gender identity and if they identify with GI Joe they have a boys gender identity. They also gave schools advice to teachers including telling teachers that if a child tells them they are trans they should tell the child that they will keep that information secret for them - a safeguarding red flag.

I think we are now seeing the backlash against all this and, as these things so often do, it's going to the other extreme.

I think Bannerman is right about female spaces and the twisting of the EA to gaslight schools and the females within them into thinking they have to accept males into their spaces. I don't agree that schools should just tell kids that their pronouns are horseshit and their identities are not valid. These children have grown up with this crap, we can't just abandon them now. Suella Bannerman is another who probably knows nothing about kids.

I do think that we need to start working on undoing some of the damage that the likes of Mermaids has done with regards to gender stereotypes, start hammering it home to girls that being a female doesn't mean they have to act like a Kardashian, that they can identify however they like but no one can actually change sex and that they are perfect the way they are, no cross sex hormones or mastectomies required.

pointythings · 28/05/2022 19:39

@Jott you are so right. My youngest started questioning their identity in Yr11. Their 6th form fully respected their pronouns. It gave them a sense of safety at school and a sense of belonging. How the fuck is that a bad thing?

ImAvingOops · 28/05/2022 19:37

Schools should be sensitive to children who are in distress for whatever reason and treat them with kindness and care. But I'm not sure that unquestioning acceptance is the way to go. A lot of children go through gender confusion as a temporary phase or because something else is going on (like undiagnosed autism in girls) and I don't believe it's right to automatically agree that they are definitely trans and start treating them as if they were the opposite sex.

The pronoun thing is just stupid anyway - 'she' denotes female and 'he' denotes male. Language has meaning, as much as TRA might like to pretend otherwise.

I can't read the linked article but I would be very surprised if it was as blunt as 'suck it up'. But I'll be honest, too much time has been spent indulging TRA at the expense of everyone else. It's dangerous and it has no place in schools

Jott · 28/05/2022 19:25

pointythings · 28/05/2022 19:21

And I think it's unacceptable too. It's a giant leap to take from respecting someone's pronouns to saying we must all support physical/hormonal transitioning under 18. I have two trans young people in my household and neither is taking the process lightly or taking irreversible decisions - and both are adults. A lot of the anti trans debate seems to be about putting people back in their box and pretending they don't exist. Very like gay young people when Section 28 was still in force, in fact.

I have a child who is questioning their gender identity too. They don't want to change their pronouns yet or outwardly present as a different gender but they're trying to pick through these feelings and make sense of them. They don't want to go chopping anything off or taking drugs, they just want to be able to process it all, they want to be their own self, and - most importantly - they want to be loved and accepted for who they are.

How would my child be able to do any of that in a school environment where they're told that these issues and feelings are irrelevant and unimportant? Where they're forced to keep quiet and not mention it?

Holly60 · 28/05/2022 19:23

She sounds disgusting and yes it sounds just like section 28. Awful transphobia

TheLadyDIdGood · 28/05/2022 19:23

www.bayswatersupport.org.uk/

The Bayswater support group is for parents of children with identity issues/dysphoria who need support and information.

TheLadyDIdGood · 28/05/2022 19:21

This is the story that the op didn't link to and assumed everyone knew what they were talking about:

www.google.com/amp/s/www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/attorney-general-transgender-pupils-schools-b2089298.html%3famp

Jott · 28/05/2022 19:21

Highlyquestionablehoumous · 28/05/2022 19:11

Why would you be replacing 'gay' with 'trans'? They are completely different things?

Being gay never required teenage girls to have to share changing rooms with their male peers. It never required children to be pumped full of puberty blockers, or get their breasts removed before they have even reached their 20s. It never required people to chant mantras that are not true like 'transwomen are women'.

The trans movement piggybacked onto LGB exactly so that they could credibly use comparisons like Section 28 to force people into accepting males in female spaces and kids being prescribed powerful drugs and having body parts routinely chopped off.

Hate is hate and her anti-trans rhetoric is exactly the same way gay people were discussed and treated in the days of Section 28 policies.

Telling children to shut up about their gender identity issues, that they won't be "pandered to", that how they're feeling isn't real, and that their school has a firm line on not accommodating them is bullshit. It will push a lot of affected children into a mental health crisis. Ignoring something and taking a firm line against it is not the way forwards. Children (and adults for that matter) who are questioning their identity need support and acceptance, how can they work through their feelings if they're being told those feelings don't exist?