Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is anyone else slightly disappointed their DC didn’t turn out to be quite as amazing as I thought they were when they were little?

282 replies

meanmama · 27/05/2022 16:29

DS was naturally very academically advanced at an early age. He basically taught himself to read, was years ahead of the rest of the class in maths, drew pictures like a 7 year old at age 3, wrote chapter books with punctuation in reception, learnt musical instruments with ease. You name it, he could do it. This was completely without any pushing from myself or DH - we have another DC who is much more academically ‘normal’ and have treated them both the same.
I couldn’t help but have extremely high hopes and dreams for DS who is now 16. But although he’s still very bright he’s also quite lazy so achieves above average but nothing like when he was little. I sometimes wonder if I should have been more pushy about made sure he pushed himself but I’m just not that type of parent.
I feel bad for feeling like this, I know IABU and obviously I do massively appreciate the fact that DS is doing pretty well academically, has lots of friends a good social life and is happy. But part of me can’t help but feel just a bit disappointed that he didn’t grow up to be the genius I thought he would.

OP posts:
LuciusMeowFoy · 27/05/2022 18:53

My primary aged DS is very bright academically and picks up learning instruments with ease. He pretty much taught himself to read at a young age and is doing incredibly well at school. However, he struggles with social situations and anxiety. We go out of our way to not put pressure on him and to just do what he can and enjoy school.

As a child I was always told to do ‘THE best’ and actually found that quite damaging and caused me huge anxiety.

I’d much rather a happy son who has strong friendship groups than one excelling in education.

LifeInsideMyhead · 27/05/2022 18:52

pixie5121 - same here! Stupid high IQ, read before school, Mensa as a kid but not a great childhood. Oxbridge... then one side of the family pretty much disown me for not being successful in society.

I am trying to get my dr to refer for asd/adhd and am in the middle of a breakdown. mental health has always been tricky.

I often see people wanting their little children to be geniuses and really think life is simpler sometimes if not.

Penguinevere · 27/05/2022 18:50

It sounds like your son is doing very well. Well done op.

If it makes you feel better-being “the best” at every class in school isn’t always all it’s cracked up to be. Eventually school ends and you need to be successful in real life, and that’s different.

SophieJo · 27/05/2022 18:50

I feel very sad for your son that you come across as disappointed in him. Must be many who would love to have a healthy son.

Jellicoe · 27/05/2022 18:49

It's disappointing to see a child that you believe "could be so much more" - my DD2 is like that with the violin. She has won prestigious competition learning the piece for a couple of months and swanned in to take the trophy. HOWEVER the message has been sent and I suspect you child is the same that she didn't need to put in that much hard work to win therefore don't need to try that much. My DD2 is happy loving and balanced and I cherish her for that. I don't need her to be the next Heifetz.

pixie5121 · 27/05/2022 18:47

He sounds possibly neurodiverse. Hyperlexia (reading/writing at a very early age) is a sign of that. I could read at 3 and was reading novels in both English and Spanish by the time I was 6 or 7 and writing books with chapters, like your son. Started to completely fall apart in secondary school because I struggled so much with focus and the social aspects of school. I appeared normal and sociable but was masking heavily. I was called lazy many, many times and that made it all worse. Ended up with anxiety and depression, had a breakdown around 30 and was diagnosed with autism and ADHD.

Being a 'gifted child' can be a real curse. You feel like absolute shit for not being able to live up to everyone's lofty expectations. Even though I was still a good student and still got straight As at A Level, despite horrific mental health difficulties at the time, people were expecting me to be the next Mozart or Einstein. Whatever I did was never going to be good enough.

Psychonabike · 27/05/2022 18:46

There are a couple things that we aren't really honest with parents about (in order to get everyone to buy into the population -rather than individual- based concept and structure of the school system as it is, probably?).

  1. Primary school children really vary -some arrive already reading, some take more time. But the majority end up in the same place. A lot of primary school is just waiting for them all to get to that same place. The "bright" ones at the beginning are not so different from the majority by the end. They just got there quicker. Exceptions are a small minority.
  2. Real mastery of anything takes 10,000 hours of practice. The idea of natural talent is mostly untrue. So the earlier an aptitude can be identified, to get in the 10,000 hours, the better (and logically this would mean focusing on a smaller range of subjects from an earlier stage). In the same vein, early demonstration of aptitude means very little without the hours of practice. An approach based on individual aptitude for specific subjects could be really effective and keep children motivated and involved (provides a more positive learning experience) but it can be hard to deliver.
Timeandtune · 27/05/2022 18:45

I admire your bravery. My DS1 turns 30 this year. He wasn’t a prodigy but was a good all rounder and did well at school until 14.

He didn’t do anything awful ( no crime , drugs etc ) but he did stop trying and eventually left school with no qualifications.

He has never not worked but always in low paid hospitality jobs. He has no savings or chance of a mortgage. But he is also debt free which is great.

On the other hand he is a marvellous son- kind, loyal ,empathetic.

His dad and I both wish he had some qualifications - academic or vocational- to his name . He hasn’t fully achieved his potential .

Cait33 · 27/05/2022 18:39

You could be describing my DD (now almost 23) but I feel the opposite to you. I'm massively relieved she isn't a genius overachiever and is instead bright, funny, lazy, medicated and able to score above average without any real effort. Sure, it'd be lovely to have her end up mega rich and able to give me a jetset lifestyle but to me, the fact she's here, relatively happy and tells me her secrets is massively more important.

MarshaBradyo · 27/05/2022 18:39

What sort of grades is he getting?

lightisnotwhite · 27/05/2022 18:37

I wish I had a pound for every mother who’ve told me a similar story. I know loads of people whose (usually first child) bright spark fell short of their potential and the somewhat overlooked subsequent child went on to do really well. It’s an interesting common occurrence in my view.

I agree.

I

Restawhile · 27/05/2022 18:36

There's so much that can change in a blink of an eye. I've learnt happy and healthy is the greatest success to ever want for your child.

FoggySpecs · 27/05/2022 18:35

I'm so proud of mine, I try and tell them to follow their own paths manage themselves. I just want them to be happy and not compare themselves to others.

Antarcticant · 27/05/2022 18:35

Antarcticant · 27/05/2022 18:27

'Child prodigy syndrome' is a known issue. Essentially it's depression and apathy that can set in when everyone else catches up as they grow older and the child is no longer exceptional or special because they can do calculus or write poems or whatever. Perhaps your DS has reached that stage?

Sorry, when I say no longer special I know he will always be special in the eyes of his loved ones.

musicviking1 · 27/05/2022 18:34

Annoying autocorrect. Wish we could edit! *His

Mymoneydontjigglejiggle · 27/05/2022 18:34

As a secondary English teacher this thread doesn't surprise me. The amount of parents I've had come to see me all guns blazing over the years is ridiculous. 'My child was reading at the age of 2'; 'My child has been reading novels since the age of 6'; 'My child has a GIFT for creative writing...' and so on and on, usually in response to their child not being placed in the top set, or getting a lower than expected mark in an assessment or generally struggling in secondary after thriving at primary school. I have my own DC now and my oldest has started reception - I'm determined to take all feedback with a hefty pinch of salt. Everything can change very quickly in the teenage years! Incidentally, I was an early reader, "gifted & talented", top of the top sets, straight As and I'm now a perfectly average teacher and mum.

Mariposista · 27/05/2022 18:34

hitrewind · 27/05/2022 16:52

This post really did make me want to throw up in my mouth a bit – and that's speaking as an adult who was one of 'those' children.

How much higher should your hopes be than a bright, happy, sociable teenager? Or were you hoping for a performing sea lion who would make you feel special by proxy?

You have hit the nail right on the head!

Brightbluebell · 27/05/2022 18:33

I’ve been a primary school teacher for 25 years. The children who I taught in my early years are now in their early to middle 30s. My experience has shown me that the vast majority of those children who shone at school academically or were gifted in the arts or sport have quite ordinary jobs and lives now (absolutely nothing wrong with that - my life is very ordinary and I love it!).

Very few people go on to live extraordinary lives and, although we should encourage children to reach high and focus on doing something they love, teachers and parents should share with children the joy and satisfaction of living an ordinary, happy and comfortable life.

I know so many pushy parents who are convinced that their children are going to be stars that it must be hugely disappointing and dissatisfying for both the parents and the children when it doesn’t happen.

Musicaltheatremum · 27/05/2022 18:32

Josephsrose · 27/05/2022 16:36

My cleverest child, so academically gifted, has become a roofer. He loves the danger, the physical toil, and working out on top of the world.
It's disappointing for me, but he's doing so well, and he is happy.

@Josephsrose if he's a good roofer he will be snapped up! So many cowboys out there!

If he's clever he will use his skills to develop a good thriving business. Academia isn't everything. He could earn very good money and be happy. As long as he is decent and kind and a solid worker he will go far in my eyes. I'd be very proud of him. And I'm an academic myself as was my first husband, their dad.

meanmama · 27/05/2022 18:30

Thanks for the perspective. I know I am incredibly lucky and am very proud of the lovely boy he is. It’s just slightly jarring to know he absolutely could be excelling academically still as he gets good grades without the minimum effort. He is happy, healthy and has friends so actually what more could I want?
You’re absolutely right that it probably is too early to say how things will turn out. My DH didn’t work hard at school, got a mediocre degree but eventually in his 30s decided to apply himself and is now incredibly successful. Maybe DS will follow in his footsteps.
Glad I started this thread as it’s given me a reality check.

OP posts:
MatildaJayne · 27/05/2022 18:30

I get you, OP. My amazing self taught reader and brilliant mathematician just learnt that he didn’t really need to work that hard, which was fine until exams came along. He’s still lovely to me of course and will do fine in life. Conversely, my poor reader who had speech therapy and had to work hard to compete with his friends ended up doing really well due to his good work ethic.

I also have another DS with SN, but I’m allowed to worry about my other children as well, so stop with the mean comment to the OP.

HereIAmBrainTheSizeOfAPlanet · 27/05/2022 18:29

what a bitchy post
Is there any need really?

Yes

musicviking1 · 27/05/2022 18:28

My DS 14 is bright but since covid he's results have dropped by two levels . I'm not disappointed but I do feel frustration because I know he has the potential and opportunities to do so much better than he does. He has just come home with his year 10 PPE results and he's results are not great which I put mostly down to covid but I also know he just isn't competitive and too laid back.

Antarcticant · 27/05/2022 18:27

'Child prodigy syndrome' is a known issue. Essentially it's depression and apathy that can set in when everyone else catches up as they grow older and the child is no longer exceptional or special because they can do calculus or write poems or whatever. Perhaps your DS has reached that stage?

TortieQueen · 27/05/2022 18:27

I have 2 highly intelligent DC, both with ASD/ADHD. One was sent to all the prospective Oxbridge student groups at uni but ended up having a breakdown and way underachieving. Now happily working in care. The other was known as the "naughty" kid at school who nobody expected anything of until they got an EHCP & suddenly were able to learn. Currently in final year of a degree (studied online) and on for a first. I couldn't be prouder of both of them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread