Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is anyone else slightly disappointed their DC didn’t turn out to be quite as amazing as I thought they were when they were little?

282 replies

meanmama · 27/05/2022 16:29

DS was naturally very academically advanced at an early age. He basically taught himself to read, was years ahead of the rest of the class in maths, drew pictures like a 7 year old at age 3, wrote chapter books with punctuation in reception, learnt musical instruments with ease. You name it, he could do it. This was completely without any pushing from myself or DH - we have another DC who is much more academically ‘normal’ and have treated them both the same.
I couldn’t help but have extremely high hopes and dreams for DS who is now 16. But although he’s still very bright he’s also quite lazy so achieves above average but nothing like when he was little. I sometimes wonder if I should have been more pushy about made sure he pushed himself but I’m just not that type of parent.
I feel bad for feeling like this, I know IABU and obviously I do massively appreciate the fact that DS is doing pretty well academically, has lots of friends a good social life and is happy. But part of me can’t help but feel just a bit disappointed that he didn’t grow up to be the genius I thought he would.

OP posts:
Luredbyapomegranate · 27/05/2022 22:02

What you are describing is very human (despite the chippy responses from some), everyone wants their kids to use their talents, and get the best out of life etc.

things to remember -

The main thing is he is happy and healthy and doing well enough to get him through life

He was never a genius, just an early developer

He’s 16, as he emotionally matures he may well apply himself more academically, or to whatever else he decides he wants to do

Be supportive and you’ll probably be able to gently encourage him to stretch himself as he matures

Thinking about this might be a sign you need to build up your own life.

FirewomanSam · 27/05/2022 21:59

He turned to me and said "Mom, will you still love me if I turn out to be average?" He was completely serious. It stopped me in my tracks. It really changed how I parented. I had been giving them the message that I loved them more if they were the best at everything.

@momtoboys that genuinely made me well up a little bit. Well done for realising that and changing how you approached things with your boys. You’ve probably saved them years of therapy!

You’ve made me realised this is exactly how I’ve felt for so much of my life, even though my parents are wonderful and I know they’ve only ever tried their best. I live in such fear of disappointing them even at nearly 40 years old. I would have loved to hear ‘it’s ok for you to be average’ once in a while!

JulieBeds · 27/05/2022 21:58

It's very normal to want your child to do well.

I guess he's got no impetus to grow beyond where he is. He's comfortable.

The thing is, I look back and think I could have gone to Oxbridge if I'd know it existed.

have you ever been OP?

Sometimes we need to visualise ourselves in a place to understand that it could be for us. So if you want him to aim higher, book a day trip or a weekend to Cambridge or Oxford and see what he thinks. Don't mention uni but you could have a tour just for fun perhaps or go punting. He'll soak up the atmosphere etc.

It may put him off completely which is fine. But I wish someone had taken me on a day trip to one of these places and made me realise that it was a possibilty for me. You don't know what you don't know.

But in the end, if he's happy and getting on well in life otherwise, that's good enough. Maybe let him find his own path.

but yes, the key to ambition is exposure and it sounds like at the moment he's not exposed to anything much to light his fire.

Working hard comes from intrinsic or extrinsic motivation. Have a google.

You want him to feel inspired to work hard, not work work because he's living in fear of not being good enough. So how do you inspire? Take him places, expose him to new ideas and thinking...

RedPlumbob · 27/05/2022 21:57

hitrewind · 27/05/2022 16:52

This post really did make me want to throw up in my mouth a bit – and that's speaking as an adult who was one of 'those' children.

How much higher should your hopes be than a bright, happy, sociable teenager? Or were you hoping for a performing sea lion who would make you feel special by proxy?

Snort laughed at this, I’m also an adult that was one those children, my mother remains aggrieved that her sole reason for boasting and being a cunt to other mothers was ripped from under her when I had a breakdown mid Y13.

Im now a mother of one of those children and believe me she knows that her “achievements” are the last on the list of things I give a fuck about. Mental health, well being and happiness are the priority.

Threeboysandadog · 27/05/2022 21:57

I’m so lucky that my three sons have turned out to be amazing, inspiring and thoughtful individuals. They are each so different in their academic achievements, lifestyle choices, the difficulties they have faced so far on their journeys and the ways in which they have dealt with them. If I had different aspirations for them at the start of their lives then they have taught me that’s not the way it works. I can honestly say I wouldn’t want them to be anything other that the way they are.

PerkyBlinder · 27/05/2022 21:55

Being able to coast GCSEs means they get to enjoy being kids without the huge pressure and stress some kids have just to pass.

He probably just needs to find his thing but the really important things are friends, family and relationships which are what really make for a happy successful life.

My eldest was super bright similar to your son but seriously coasted through GCSEs with ok grades - nothing below 5 but only a few 8s and 7s. It’s only been since she went to uni that she started to really work. She desperately wanted to go to California for the year abroad and knew that it’s competitive to get her chosen place so worked for the first time ever and is now top of her year and off to California in a few months. I genuinely wouldn’t mind though either way. I just care that she’s happy and healthy with good friends.

There’s so many pressures on teens now with social media and pressures to succeed way more than we had at their age. Plus they’ve had covid to deal with so if they’re surviving without any major mental health problems then I’d count that as a win! 😃

SwishSwishBisch · 27/05/2022 21:55

Considering the nature of one of the other trending threads in here today, this thread isn’t really very tasteful.
Be grateful if you have a happy child. That is all that matters.

samyeagar · 27/05/2022 21:54

LuckySantangelo35 · 27/05/2022 21:29

@Waxonwaxoff0

of course those things are important too. But it’s silly to pretend that doing well at school isn’t important as well.

There is a difference between not doing well at school and doing poorly at school.

Roastonsun8 · 27/05/2022 21:43

@LuckySantangelo35 what is slightly silly is you and many others failing to realise its many things and qualities that carry you through a career it's not just how intelligent you are at school FFS.

MorganSeventh · 27/05/2022 21:34

I think that disappointment is just a function of growing up and only having one life to live.

A baby has the potential to be anything, or do anything. They could cure cancer, or be an astronaut, or win an Oscar, or win an Olympic medal. Realistically though, 99.9999999999999% of people won't manage any of those things, and even the most exceptionally talented and lucky could probably only manage one of them.

(With the exception of Kobe Bryant who won an Oscar and an Olympic medal. But he hasn't been an astronaut.)

Waxonwaxoff0 · 27/05/2022 21:32

LuckySantangelo35 · 27/05/2022 21:29

@Waxonwaxoff0

of course those things are important too. But it’s silly to pretend that doing well at school isn’t important as well.

It isn't, necessarily. It all depends on what you want out of life and what type of work you want to do.

My ex husband earns £60k a year and has no education past GCSE level.

DogsAndGin · 27/05/2022 21:31

BattenburgDonkey · 27/05/2022 16:40

I don’t understand what’s disappointing? Happy and doing so well… poor you.

I completely agree with you @BattenburgDonkey. A happy, healthy child who has a secure job they love.

childofthecorn · 27/05/2022 21:29

It sounds like he will be extremely successful. Speaking as someone who entirely prioritised academic over interpersonal and has no career to speak of despite glowing results!

LuckySantangelo35 · 27/05/2022 21:29

Waxonwaxoff0 · 27/05/2022 20:45

It's embarrassing how many people on MN think their children are only worth something if they're "academic" or "bright." No one seems to give a damn about their DC being happy, or good people, or kind. It's ALL about how well they do at school. Awful.

@Waxonwaxoff0

of course those things are important too. But it’s silly to pretend that doing well at school isn’t important as well.

samyeagar · 27/05/2022 21:21

Again, what does "not living up to their potential" even mean?

A child starts playing violin at 2. Doesn't really excel in academics, but isn't bad either. just pretty average, but by 16 is seated first chair in a local symphony. Then goes away to Uni. Seated first chair in the Uni symphony, plays with regional symphony as third chair over breaks. Gets a degree in teaching, and ends up teaching 6 year olds and never touches the violin again.

Is that "not living up to their potential"?

Kanaloa · 27/05/2022 21:19

Hallyup89 · 27/05/2022 21:00

Not disappointed, just sad and worried. My eldest daughter was so academically gifted as a young child. She's now 18 and diagnosed autistic, has no qualifications and can't look after herself well enough to be independent. She won't talk, can't cook, can't manage a bank account and spends 99% of her day in a darkened room, in front of a computer. I love her, but I'd give anything for her to be 'normal'. If one more person tells me that children with special needs are a gift, I'll punch them.

Obviously this is a different situation though. I have these worries for my son who’s autistic. I want him to have a happy life and of course it will make me sad if he can’t function for himself and experience ‘normal’ life activities.

But to say you’re sad because your child isn’t living up to some super academic expectations? That’s just daft. If your child is doing well in school and is happy and you’re disappointed they haven’t achieved highly enough, that’s not the same as feeling worried and sad about a disabled child that can’t function as an adult.

Littlepond · 27/05/2022 21:17

This is depressing. I was super bright as a kid, went to a super clever secondary school and floundered. Got mediocre GCSEs, kicked out of the clever school, went to college and got shitty a level results, pretty much a total failure. And I assume my mother is disappointed in me too. Fucking useless.

User48751490 · 27/05/2022 21:15

pbdr · 27/05/2022 17:31

There is a strong association between genius level IQ and mental illness in adulthood. I'd much rather have a happy average achiever than a depressed genius.

I just want all of my DC to be happy and average. Good mental health you just cannot put a price on.

If one of my DC wants to be a roofer or a joiner, or plumber, I would be fine as long as it's what they want. Nothing wrong with apprenticeship schemes. Many of my relatives work in the trades.

As others have said, being a genius comes with its own set of problems.

easyday · 27/05/2022 21:10

My son was happy, charming, go with the flow, gregarious as a child. At 18 he is full of self doubt, super critical, feels in a rut and is so very angry. I'm hoping he will find his way and become the kind loving outgoing young man he is meant to be.
Your child will be what he is meant to be.

Lovemusic33 · 27/05/2022 21:04

No, I could never be disappointed in any of my dc.
Dd1 was on the gifted and talented register (what ever that is), she started reeding at nursery, was always top of the class, got level 9’s in her GCSE’s, she’s now about to sit her A levels but isn’t predicted A*’s (but close). She’s secured a place at uni but not a top uni. I’m proud of how well she has done but at the end of the day if she ends up working in a supermarket I will still be proud, if she drops out of uni I will still be proud.

Imnotgonnacrie · 27/05/2022 21:04

I was gifted at primary, won a scholarship to secondary, where I won all the prizes (and was also sporty). Got into a 'top' uni. But my parents genuinely never pushed me and just wanted me to be happy so I think I was better equipped for the real world than a lot of my peers. I spent a lot of time in the bar, played some sport, had great friends. These days I have a nice job but nothing stellar or well paid, mostly because the sacrifices required for the big jobs didn't appeal to me. I sometimes feel like I didn't fulfil early potential, but I also think I'm a lot happier than some of the 'successes' I went to school and uni with (and given my background there's quite a few of those). Contentment is the only goal in life worth pursuing on a personal level.

Lickerz · 27/05/2022 21:03

I had a "pushy" mum. I won't bore you with the details but suffice to say I had an awful stressful childhood, suffered mental health issues, struggle now as an adult to feel happy or enjoy myself (as those activities/feelings were discouraged and seen as pointless when everything was about working hard all the time at things you didn't enjoy). I don't have a good relationship with my mum now and hardly speak to her.

YABU

momtoboys · 27/05/2022 21:02

I have always been a tremendous cheerleader for my sons. Each one of them was special, brilliant, handsome, kind and they could do anything they wanted if they put their mind to it. It took me a while to realize life doesn't always work like that. Each one of them are those things and more but they are absolutely on their own paths. Once in early high school when my oldest was struggling a little academically I was cheering him on on how he can do so much better that that, etc. He turned to me and said "Mom, will you still love me if I turn out to be average?" He was completely serious. It stopped me in my tracks. It really changed how I parented. I had been giving them the message that I loved them more if they were the best at everything.

PurpleButterflyWings · 27/05/2022 21:02

Waxonwaxoff0 · 27/05/2022 20:45

It's embarrassing how many people on MN think their children are only worth something if they're "academic" or "bright." No one seems to give a damn about their DC being happy, or good people, or kind. It's ALL about how well they do at school. Awful.

Exactly this. I know several young people who have suffered severe depression and mental health problems, and two who took their own lives because of the high expectations from their parents, and the finger wagging and head shaking of disappointment when they didn't measure up.

The 'top' few universities in this country, have a high percentage of anxiety, and higher-than-normal suicide rates, because of how they are expected to be top-tier, high achievers.

This thread is repugnant and vile. Shame on you for starting it @meanmama and shame on anyone who agrees with you! Hmm

DaisyQuakeJohnson · 27/05/2022 21:00

I think you've had a bit of a hard time.
This is much more about you questioning your role than your DS' abilities tbh. You're wondering if you didn't push him enough or micro-manage him enough and if that has affected his prospects. I think most parents have those questions and doubts. It's hard to tell when you're pushing too much or not enough or just right. It's like Goldilocks.
I struggle with this for with my own DC. They are bright but lack organisation. It's a constant tightrope of how much to jolly them along or let them find their own path.

Swipe left for the next trending thread