Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is anyone else slightly disappointed their DC didn’t turn out to be quite as amazing as I thought they were when they were little?

282 replies

meanmama · 27/05/2022 16:29

DS was naturally very academically advanced at an early age. He basically taught himself to read, was years ahead of the rest of the class in maths, drew pictures like a 7 year old at age 3, wrote chapter books with punctuation in reception, learnt musical instruments with ease. You name it, he could do it. This was completely without any pushing from myself or DH - we have another DC who is much more academically ‘normal’ and have treated them both the same.
I couldn’t help but have extremely high hopes and dreams for DS who is now 16. But although he’s still very bright he’s also quite lazy so achieves above average but nothing like when he was little. I sometimes wonder if I should have been more pushy about made sure he pushed himself but I’m just not that type of parent.
I feel bad for feeling like this, I know IABU and obviously I do massively appreciate the fact that DS is doing pretty well academically, has lots of friends a good social life and is happy. But part of me can’t help but feel just a bit disappointed that he didn’t grow up to be the genius I thought he would.

OP posts:
lollipoprainbow · 28/05/2022 12:04

These days do we just have to be happy and grateful our kids are not suicidal?

Frankly yes.

lollipoprainbow · 28/05/2022 12:03

A happy adult life involves freedom to choose their work (doing well at school sets that up), ability to make money and not have to stress about finances all the time (doing well at school sets that up), having a healthy body (doing the sports even when not in the mood sets that up) and feeling safe, loved and supported (that’s on me as their parent for the rest of my life).

So if you don't do well at school and have crap parents your doomed then I guess.

CoalCraft · 28/05/2022 11:46

Some kids develop more quickly intellectually than average but that doesn't mean they'll end up more than average intellectually as adults. I was an "early bloomer"; exceptional at primary level, very good during GCSEs, good at A levels, above average at undergrad and then decidedly average at PhD. I'm decidedly average now too, if not a bit thick.

Kanaloa · 28/05/2022 11:42

And obviously nobody is suggesting kids should ‘not bother with school.’ They’re suggesting that not all kids will be geniuses. And doing well in school is great but being super academic isn’t everybody’s path.

Kanaloa · 28/05/2022 11:41

so no, my kids aren’t allowed to play PlayStation all day just because it makes them happy. They aren’t allowed to eat crap just because it makes them happy and they’re not allowed to not bother with school just because they’d rather do other things.

A few posters on the thread have done this. Employed this silly hyperbole of ‘oh so kids should just be allowed to sit around playing PlayStation and eating junk food?’

Literally nobody is saying that. They’re saying that expecting a child to be exceptional because they did well at school in infants is ridiculous. And feeling ‘disappointed’ with a child who is doing well in school, is happy, and has friends and is a pleasant young man to be around is just daft. This isn’t about expecting nothing from your children.

NerrSnerr · 28/05/2022 11:30

NeverDropYourMooncup · 28/05/2022 11:04

The Thread has spoken.

Got to keep those tall poppies down. Can't have them or you getting above your station and risking them not fitting in with everybody else.

It's not about encouraging your children not to do their best. It's about making sure they're living the life they want- not the life you want for them.

Both my older siblings were like the children described on here. Reading chapter books before school, talented at sport and everything they did. Everyone expected them to excel. They both rebelled massively in different ways because they couldn't cope with the pressure. One is dead (alcohol/ suicide) the other didn't finish university, was unemployed for years and now works in a basic admin role.

Mediocre old me, couldn't read at 5, scraped through GCSEs plodded on through life and has a half decent job, family, house etc. nothing exceptional but leading a happy life.

Give your children the best start in life you can, give them opportunities to explore talents and things they love but don't push them to be the people you want. Let them become themselves.

Hawkins001 · 28/05/2022 11:27

FirewomanSam · 28/05/2022 09:37

I should of expanded on what I ment, for day to day interactions like the poem describes, that I would say could be argued that it does not merit the history books as it's normal human interactions etc, but e.g. Being academic, a high achiever, an engineer, ect has the potential to make history and Mark their name in the history books for e.g. X invention, or x study of the human psychological perspectives for e.g. Business etc

@Hawkins001 many, many people who ‘make the history books’ did not do well at school or were told they’d never amount to anything in life. People who do radical, groundbreaking things or have the big, innovative ideas don’t always (dare I even say, don’t usually) get there by keeping their heads down and doing what they’re told.

I mentor 16-17 year olds and it breaks my heart how stressed they always are, thinking that they MUST have their whole lives figured out at that age and that if they don’t get top grades they’ve ruined their future prospects forever. I know so many adults who did badly at school but then went on to have brilliant careers, maybe even returning to GCSEs and A levels later in life to pick up the qualifications they missed out on at school, if they decide they need them later. I remember telling one of my mentees that my friend in his 30s was doing his Maths GCSE now because he needed it for work, and her face was one of total shock. She had absolutely no idea that was even an option and was so so worried that if she failed maths, doors would be closed to her forever.

Of course doing the best you can at school gives you certain opportunities earlier in life and makes some things easier but there’s more than one way to be successful, and some people take a more meandering path, and that’s ok.

I must admit, you have a good analysis, and I agree that some of my research has confirmed the autodidact method that some historical people have used.

Therealpink · 28/05/2022 11:24

I just want my kids to be happy but part of that is not assuming that them sitting playing PlayStation and not achieving but happy will set them up for a happy adult life.

A happy adult life involves freedom to choose their work (doing well at school sets that up), ability to make money and not have to stress about finances all the time (doing well at school sets that up), having a healthy body (doing the sports even when not in the mood sets that up) and feeling safe, loved and supported (that’s on me as their parent for the rest of my life).

so no, my kids aren’t allowed to play PlayStation all day just because it makes them happy. They aren’t allowed to eat crap just because it makes them happy and they’re not allowed to not bother with school just because they’d rather do other things.

Hawkins001 · 28/05/2022 11:23

LuckySantangelo35 · 28/05/2022 11:06

@NeverDropYourMooncup

what do you mean?

Basically that it's seen as wrong via some, that if you want your dc to achieve more and be better than they are, ect.

Starlia · 28/05/2022 11:13

This makes me feel terribly sad OP. trigger warning ahead
I was your child. I was reading early, well ahead of my peers academically and wrote my first novel when I was 12.
I found the pressure to constantly over-achieve relentless and was actively suicidal for most of my teen years.
My parents were and are constantly disappointed in me.
I am a published author (no Grisham by any means though), have a job that pays well and a wonderful little family. Yet I constantly feel like I will never meet their expectations. I just want my parents to acknowledge and accept me.
If your child is happy and healthy, then that is enough. More than enough. Tell him how proud you are of him and mean it. It will feed his soul.

LuckySantangelo35 · 28/05/2022 11:06

NeverDropYourMooncup · 28/05/2022 11:04

The Thread has spoken.

Got to keep those tall poppies down. Can't have them or you getting above your station and risking them not fitting in with everybody else.

@NeverDropYourMooncup

what do you mean?

pixie5121 · 28/05/2022 11:05

Hallyup89 · 27/05/2022 21:00

Not disappointed, just sad and worried. My eldest daughter was so academically gifted as a young child. She's now 18 and diagnosed autistic, has no qualifications and can't look after herself well enough to be independent. She won't talk, can't cook, can't manage a bank account and spends 99% of her day in a darkened room, in front of a computer. I love her, but I'd give anything for her to be 'normal'. If one more person tells me that children with special needs are a gift, I'll punch them.

Totally agree. It's so incredibly offensive to describe disabilities as a gift. It really belittles the enormous amounts of effort many of us have to put in to achieve very average results when it comes to daily life and getting by. I would give anything to be neurotypical. Yes, I have above average intelligence and academic capability, but what good is that, really, if everyday life is such a slog? The hairdresser I go to is always super cheerful and happy, nothing gets her down, she gets on with everybody and just really enjoys life. She did badly at school but she's found a job she loves and is good at. I'd much rather be her.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 28/05/2022 11:04

The Thread has spoken.

Got to keep those tall poppies down. Can't have them or you getting above your station and risking them not fitting in with everybody else.

SpringBadger · 28/05/2022 11:02

His life's not over yet, OP!

I've known plenty of very academic children crumble in their teens, and not have the high-achieving teens and twenties that their hopeful parents envisaged. The raw mental ability was there, but not the resilience or social skills or all the other equally important factors for success.

Your son is actually better off than that - he's happy and popular, and it's only the academic side that he's taken his eye off for now. That's much easier to pick back up again.

LuckySantangelo35 · 28/05/2022 10:59

Kanaloa · 28/05/2022 10:58

But the boy is doing all that. As said above, obviously nobody is going to say it’s absolutely fine for a teen to sit around doing absolutely nothing and failing all their classes. But this boy is doing well in school and is happy and sociable. He is a ‘good person’ and is achieving decent grades.

@Kanaloa

Agreed, don’t think it applies to this particular young person.
was speaking more in general.

Kanaloa · 28/05/2022 10:58

LuckySantangelo35 · 28/05/2022 10:51

@MysteriousMonkey

These days do we just have to be happy and grateful our kids are not suicidal? That seems to be setting the bar pretty low for most young people. And I say most because I do recognise that some people do have mental health disorders which has been the case for many years.

That wasn’t even a thought process when I was teen, it was expected I would be a good person, kind, work hard and apply myself etc, the basic function of keeping myself alive wasn’t something to be happy, grateful for, if you see what I mean. Surely most young people are today are not so fragile that more can’t be expected of them?

But the boy is doing all that. As said above, obviously nobody is going to say it’s absolutely fine for a teen to sit around doing absolutely nothing and failing all their classes. But this boy is doing well in school and is happy and sociable. He is a ‘good person’ and is achieving decent grades.

LuckySantangelo35 · 28/05/2022 10:51

MysteriousMonkey · 27/05/2022 22:59

I totally understand. One of mine wanted to be doctor, I was told they were an exceptional science student in year 7. Now we're at A Level stage and they can barely be bothered to turn up to school and are likely to do very poorly in their a levels... That said I read all sorts of things about teen suicides and depression and I think they may be causing me stress but at least they are happy 😅

@MysteriousMonkey

These days do we just have to be happy and grateful our kids are not suicidal? That seems to be setting the bar pretty low for most young people. And I say most because I do recognise that some people do have mental health disorders which has been the case for many years.

That wasn’t even a thought process when I was teen, it was expected I would be a good person, kind, work hard and apply myself etc, the basic function of keeping myself alive wasn’t something to be happy, grateful for, if you see what I mean. Surely most young people are today are not so fragile that more can’t be expected of them?

FirewomanSam · 28/05/2022 09:37

I should of expanded on what I ment, for day to day interactions like the poem describes, that I would say could be argued that it does not merit the history books as it's normal human interactions etc, but e.g. Being academic, a high achiever, an engineer, ect has the potential to make history and Mark their name in the history books for e.g. X invention, or x study of the human psychological perspectives for e.g. Business etc

@Hawkins001 many, many people who ‘make the history books’ did not do well at school or were told they’d never amount to anything in life. People who do radical, groundbreaking things or have the big, innovative ideas don’t always (dare I even say, don’t usually) get there by keeping their heads down and doing what they’re told.

I mentor 16-17 year olds and it breaks my heart how stressed they always are, thinking that they MUST have their whole lives figured out at that age and that if they don’t get top grades they’ve ruined their future prospects forever. I know so many adults who did badly at school but then went on to have brilliant careers, maybe even returning to GCSEs and A levels later in life to pick up the qualifications they missed out on at school, if they decide they need them later. I remember telling one of my mentees that my friend in his 30s was doing his Maths GCSE now because he needed it for work, and her face was one of total shock. She had absolutely no idea that was even an option and was so so worried that if she failed maths, doors would be closed to her forever.

Of course doing the best you can at school gives you certain opportunities earlier in life and makes some things easier but there’s more than one way to be successful, and some people take a more meandering path, and that’s ok.

notanothertakeaway · 28/05/2022 09:33

museumum · 27/05/2022 16:41

I was academically ahead by miles in primary, a straight A student in secondary but distinctly average at uni. It’s just how I am. Due to my experience I think it’s very dangerous to expect “gifted” primary age children to always be ahead.

@museumum I was the same, but I wonder if it's a case of progressing until you reach your peak

massistar · 28/05/2022 09:30

Glad this thread has given you a little perspective OP. I'm guilty of feeling a bit like you as I also have a bright but lazy DS.

One look at the thread of the mum at her son's bedside made me realise that happy, healthy and sociable is what we should aspire for our kids to achieve.

There are so many kids out there with mental health issues who are struggling that I thank my lucky stars that mine is blessed with a sunny, carefree nature above all else.

lollipoprainbow · 28/05/2022 08:45

I do massively appreciate the fact that DS is doing pretty well academically, has lots of friends a good social life and is happy

Good because you should, I'd give anything for my dd to have this.

MsTSwift · 28/05/2022 07:30

Interesting read especially as Dh and his family are the inverse of this!. Dh always been very driven did as well as it is possible to do academically got to Cambridge and now has a prestigious professional job. His parents who left school at 16 and are manual workers seem utterly baffled by him and to this day don’t seem to fully realise how well he’s done!

when my mother gushed how proud they must me fil response was “well he never gave us any trouble”. That’s as far as he will go with his praise! Guess they cannot be accused of pushiness !

blueshoes · 28/05/2022 01:59

GorgeousGoldies · 27/05/2022 19:00

I think it’s very different being disappointed in them not trying, rather than being disappointed in them not succeeding.

Agree.

Children tend to be lazy. I am. Left to my own devices I'd be on my phone or surfing the net all day. Why would my dcs be any different?

I see my job as a parent to push my children if I think they can work harder. There is a cultural aspect to this.

There seems to be this mindset on this thread (UK-centric) that children are happiest if parents have no expectations of them. What about showing children what they can be capable of if they try harder and for them to get satisfaction and confidence from achievement. How great can a child feel when they can see their peers excelling and they don't. There is a strong correlation between hard work and achievement. It is the Matthew effect. Success begets success. Success brings choices. Children are too young to realise that and sometimes it is too late by the time they wake up. I believe in my dcs which is why I seek to understand their strengths and steer them in directions that optimise their individual potential.

shinynewapple22 · 28/05/2022 01:12

How awful to feel like this about your normal, happy, healthy child .

This isn't the first thread I've seen like this though .

I'm never sure whether the OP is on a wind up or if it's a stealth boast.

Thedogscollar · 28/05/2022 00:46

Your son is alive and happy.
Be grateful for that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread