Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How old would you assume the child who wrote this was?

188 replies

AloyNoraWarrior · 27/05/2022 11:11

My DS is 9 in Y4. He’s very upset as he said some children in his class have been laughing at his writing. I know he is behind because his school report last term said working towards expectations for every subject. But I’m thinking it must be bad if other children are noticing.

He does have ASD and we are waiting for an ADHD assessment. Last year I asked his teacher if could be assessed for dyslexia because he writes his name incorrectly, but they said they don’t assess children for dyslexia anymore.

I was just wondering how his writing compares to other children his age as I’m not sure what level it should be at. The photo represents his best effort. The second line of the poem is ‘when I am a pest’

How old would you assume the child who wrote this was?
OP posts:
BobLep0nge · 27/05/2022 11:46

To me it looks as though it's taken a lot of effort for him physically write the letters. Is he able to tie shoe laces/do up buttons, bead a thread etc?

AloyNoraWarrior · 27/05/2022 11:45

I can afford a private assessment. Maybe I should do that? I think it would help his self-esteem to know there is a reason he struggles. I wonder why they told me they don’t assess anymore?

School do have a strong emphasis on cursive handwriting. When he does cursive it’s completely illegible. The printing takes a long time and then he gets in trouble for being too slow. He said he can’t win because if he writes quickly the teacher can’t mark it because no one can read it but if he prints he’s too slow.

OP posts:
Boymumsoymum · 27/05/2022 11:45

Its a lovely poem OP and to be treasured for its sentiments. I think some previous posters are overlooking a couple of issues such as the 'ing' end of a word misspelled, and a back to front 'p' in upset, which suggest there might be some underlying issues. But this is just Mumsnet not an education forum and the best person to talk to is his teacher for an honest assessment of his situation. I'm not sure it's helpful to guess an age a child might be when writing this as so much depends on how much support they had - a very able much younger child could manage this with lots of support but if it was written completely independently then that's very different.
I think the key thing is what do his school think, and how do you feel about it OP, do you feel he needs more intervention than school are giving? I would definitely raise the comments other kids have made with the teacher as that should not be happening.

RedPlumbob · 27/05/2022 11:44

My local private Ed Psych charges £400 for a comprehensive assessment, I’m in the Midlands and thought it was really cheap - I was expecting around 1K. It’s worth having a look.

RedPlumbob · 27/05/2022 11:43

Mine looked like that up until I was 12, and it honestly isn’t much better now. However I was diagnosed with multiple SpLDs, ADHD and ASD whilst at Uni in my 30s - it’s worth having him checked for the full range.

www.enablespldassessment.co.uk/specific-learning-difficulties

MassiveSalad22 · 27/05/2022 11:41

Oh what a beautiful poem, I live for the day my kids will do that! He sounds like an utter treasure.

My DS is finishing yr 2 and writing much worse than your DS’s so I’d imagine your DS’s writing is within the realms of typical.

Notagain76 · 27/05/2022 11:41

Can you not look up privately for dyslexia testing, not sure if you get dla but sometimes they offer a discount. My lad is unique and has dyspraxia as one of his uniqueness tested and diagnosed on nhs, so I don't think its fair dyslexia isn't

Princetopple · 27/05/2022 11:38

Oh, and no other children ever commented on my son's handwriting as far as I'm aware. It should be dealt with separately and considered some form of bullying. It's completely unacceptable.

Princetopple · 27/05/2022 11:38

Awww, it's adorable. I'm not sure whether you were asking about the content or the spelling or the handwriting, but I'll say that it is roughly around the level of handwriting that my eldest son had at that age (or perhaps slightly better). And to be honest, it isn't much better now that he's 14. He can't write quickly AND neatly (and just neatly at all is a struggle tbh) and the OT said he has weakened hand muscles. Apparently another symptom of ADD, which CAMHS said he had many symptoms of, but then refused to give him a diagnosis. Because of that lack of diagnosis, the school are reluctant to give him a laptop or allow him extra time in exams. It's a situation I'm currently dealing with, so learn from my experience and push and push to get him all the help he needs.

PatchworkElmer · 27/05/2022 11:37

Oh what a lovely poem!

You have my sympathy. I had my (usually very stoic) 5 year old in floods of tears yesterday after school because 2 boys laughed at their writing. Kids can be absolute pricks.

SainteCroissante · 27/05/2022 11:37

You should frame this poem and treasure it forever! (Who's cutting the onions here?!)

I think if you have a hunch he might be struggling with dyslexia trust yourself, and do what you can to get him assessed, or even if you can't get a formal assessment, try some of the methods commonly recommended for people with dyslexia - a previous poster outlined some, and I am sure you can find more on the internet - and see if they help him!

(And I hope the bullying stops, and that you can get the school involved if it does not.)

Notodaynotever · 27/05/2022 11:35

I also think his writing might dramatically improve if he was able to try cursive. Letter join is a great online programme or you can just practice with a white board.

JustFrustrated · 27/05/2022 11:34

It's a lovely poem.

They DO asses for dyslexia. And discalculiA. My 9 year old has just had the tests!

So push back. But! At that age, it's largely inconclusive, so they redo the tests again anyway.

Notodaynotever · 27/05/2022 11:33

What a lovely child.

Get your own private dyslexia assessment and if he's positive and you can possibly afford it, some coaching from a dyslexia specialist. Contact the charity. Work at home with sounds and books, just enjoying stories and rhyme. You'll get an idea of what you need to do.

You'll need to be his advocate now.

PinkWisteria · 27/05/2022 11:32

I would treasure the poem but would share your concerns about his handwriting. One of my children really struggled with hand writing - related to poor muscle tone from a difficult birth rather than dyslexia and no formal diagnosis of anything. Primary school was very supportive and tried lots of different strategies to encourage writing practice and also a few different pens until they found one that suited him better. Then they encoraged him to record ideas on a dictaphone before writing and considered both when marking/assessing as they had noticed he was over simplifying everything to what he could easily write in the time available. All this improved his confidence and his handwriting did get better. At senior school, speed of writing became the main issue so he had lessons in word processing and went on to use a laptop for exams.
Maybe time for a fuller discussion with the teacher.

Winterhail · 27/05/2022 11:30

The poem is lovely and you clearly have a wonderful son. As for the handwriting, I would get him to practise at home, using one of the many handwriting practice books you can buy.

orwellwasright · 27/05/2022 11:30

At around that age the focus shifts to joined up writing and my child's perfectly adequate print morphed to an incoherent mess. He decided to join everything and his writing became one continuous, illegible stream with no word breaks.

The way we teach writing has a lot to answer for imo. Who cares how you write provided it's legible and you can do it reasonably quickly.

brawhen · 27/05/2022 11:30

To add to that above, would we paid for was a private Ed Psych assessment which came back assessing him with dyslexia (and with specific detail on what his difficulties were). It is shorthand to say that it was a 'dyslexia assessment' as their finding could have been that is was something else.

hiredandsqueak · 27/05/2022 11:28

What a lovely poem, I would treasure that. You know what I am in my fifties and have never been able to do continuous cursive writing, I still print as I did when I was five. It never stopped me from doing anything I wanted to do and nobody outside of Primary ever mentioned it and if your son only ever prints that is fine too. In this day and age nobody outside of primary does a great deal of handwriting anyway.

Ejk1990 · 27/05/2022 11:27

I can read it, so its better than my husbands!

I don't think its bad at all. Bless him.

brawhen · 27/05/2022 11:27

The sentiment is beautiful, but it is not all that counts.

The writing looks a little laboured to me, but then again 9 is still quite young.

However, I would definitely push for dyslexia assessment - or even just support. To illustrate what your advice might mean, here is our story:

DS was raising flags for dyslexia in early/mid primary. DS school said it would be a massively long wait for assessment. So we paid for private assessment. Private assessment said moderate dyslexia and gave lots of specific detail on why they thought that, plus suggested support things to try. School then said they would not formally acknowledge the dyslexia assessment BUT they would note that he had difficulties and support requirements that were 'dyslexia like' or had the same description without using the word dyslexia. No real idea why they wanted to do it this way, but the practical outcome for DS was overall helpful.

As an example, one suggestion was to photocopy dense text from text books to double size, to make it less dense to read. They would note that 'It can help DC to have pages copied to double size' but not that 'Due to dyslexia it can help DC to have pages copied to double size'.

Anyway, he went on to get a decent amount of support and has been granted additional time in some subjects for his Nat 5 exams (Scotland, GCSE equivalent) - this is on the basis that teachers have observed that he needs it and not because he has a report to say he has dyslexia.

SingingSands · 27/05/2022 11:24

I like his handwriting, I can read it much easier than my son's handwriting (he was taught cursive halfway through primary and I think it's dreadful).

And the poem... is so simple and beautiful it made me well up, I'd absolutely treasure it. ❤️

Handwriting in young children is something schools seem overly obsessed by, I don't understand it.

Crazykatie · 27/05/2022 11:24

He is probably dyslexic and needs accessing, my OH has a dyslexic GS he had specialist tuition and handwriting is still poor but is very clever and runs his own business. Make sure you get the special tuition it makes an enormous difference, these days you are probably going to have to fight for it, or pay privately.

Myshitisreal · 27/05/2022 11:23

I've no idea but my heart hurts for your boy ♥

nearlyspringyay · 27/05/2022 11:22

That is so cute.

They absolutely do assess children for dyslexia. The school might not do a full assessment but they should be able to do a screen. Mine were screened a few weeks ago and we are now going for private assessment. Worth doing if you can afford it. DTs got extra time in the SATS based on their screening results. I would be taking that up with the SENCO asap.

Swipe left for the next trending thread