Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How old would you assume the child who wrote this was?

188 replies

AloyNoraWarrior · 27/05/2022 11:11

My DS is 9 in Y4. He’s very upset as he said some children in his class have been laughing at his writing. I know he is behind because his school report last term said working towards expectations for every subject. But I’m thinking it must be bad if other children are noticing.

He does have ASD and we are waiting for an ADHD assessment. Last year I asked his teacher if could be assessed for dyslexia because he writes his name incorrectly, but they said they don’t assess children for dyslexia anymore.

I was just wondering how his writing compares to other children his age as I’m not sure what level it should be at. The photo represents his best effort. The second line of the poem is ‘when I am a pest’

How old would you assume the child who wrote this was?
OP posts:
WhatsOnYourToast · 27/05/2022 12:28

orwellwasright · 27/05/2022 12:15

Lower ability Y1? Okaaay. You don't work with KS1 children do you.

In year 1 they are expected to write short stories, poems.... with phonetically plausible spelling as well as the harder works they've been learning. There aren't any particularily diifficult words to spell in that poem, except nothing which he mis-spelt. A fair few reception children could manage that one just trying phonetically. Handwriting isn't that great of course it is a sweet poem for a child of any age to write. But there isn't any content or techniques that would indicate it is written by an older child.

TrifleFunny · 27/05/2022 12:25

40andlols · 27/05/2022 11:19

I know this is a question about reading age but focussing on emotional intelligence, this kid is off the scale. Be very very proud.

This!

SunThroughTheCloudsAt6am · 27/05/2022 12:25

The problem here isn't your son's writing, it's the school's culture allowing other children to think that's something they can comment on/bully over.

My son is dyspraxic. His writing is truly awful (worse than that and he is 11) - and that's after OT and a lot of hard work. The moment he's tired or rushing I honestly don't know how his teachers read it - and yet they do.

He's never been bullied for it, his teachers work around (and as I said are amazing at interpreting it), and when the other kids were learning cursive, they just said that it wasn't going to work for him, and for him to continue as he was - he has a laptop now for some work, but things like spelling tests he still writes which is a great accommodation balance.

TBH, I think that he could do with feeling a little more worried about it himself so he slows down and makes it more readable, but the school's done such a good job on his confidence that he's just not worried about it at all (and TBH, it will be fine, I rarely write anything these days myself, everything's on the computer/phone)

liliainterfrutices · 27/05/2022 12:22

That looks exactly like my younger son's writing. He is 18. He'll never be able to write well because he is dyspraxic and has Ehlers Danlos Syndrome so he uses a laptop. It's no longer an issue and was nothing but a relief when we gave up working on it and simply decided to make use of teachnology.

user1471538283 · 27/05/2022 12:20

It is a lovely poem. I would have thought the school would have clocked that by now he should be trying joined up writing? If schools still expect that? I would push for a dyslexia diagnosis especially as his writing may be holding him back in his other work (in terms of concentrating so hard on his writing he hasn't got the headspace for other stuff).

My DS has a friend who has dyslexia. The most intelligent man on the planet but my word to this day his handwriting is bad. He came on leaps when he had support for his dyslexia.

Penguintears · 27/05/2022 12:18

Lots of positive reviews on Amazon from parents of kids with dyspraxia.

haggisaggis · 27/05/2022 12:18

My dd (also Scotland) was diagnosed as dyslexic at 7. School had recognised issues at 5 and that was confirmed by a private screening when she was 7. But her school (state primary) supported her by scribing where necessary as they recognised that the content she was able to produce was much better if she wasn't concentrating on the act of writing. She had mostly good support all through her schooling (better at secondary than primary) and is now at university. I believe the private report helped to back up our concerns and was useful both at her 2nd primary and at secondary. It was also used by the university as the evidence they needed to provide support there so good value for money really!

hangrylady · 27/05/2022 12:17

Also to add, my DB couldn't read properly by the time he went to secondary school and his handwriting is absolutely awful. Hasn't stopped him having a very successful career and earning a 6 figure salary. I, on the other hand could read perfectly at 5 and have very neat writing but am nowhere near as successful as my little brother!

2bazookas · 27/05/2022 12:17

What he's written is fine for his age in both the meaning, intent and spelling. Probably some classmates are writing cursive script and he doesn't so they tease him. I'd encourage more slow and focussed eye-to-hand control such as colouring in, sewing, knitting , painting, woodwork, meccano models.

(Have you had his eyesight tested to eliminate any vision issues?)

His writing is streets ahead of DH's. DH is 75 and all his life his handwriting would still disgrace a 6 yr old , and always has (school trauma; he's a left hander trained and forced to write with his right hand). Oddly enough, like your DS , he still pitifully hesitates and struggles to sign his own name. When working abroad (before computers), every day he used to write me passionate but barely legible love letters on paper. It's the thought that counts :-)

It hasn't held him back at all. Amazingly the illegible drunk spider trail made no difference to his exam results at school or university and a career as a very talented and successful engineer who can design and make absolutely anything, from the tiniest scale up.

Motheranddaughtertotwo · 27/05/2022 12:15

I’m a year 4 teacher and in all honesty, it is well below expected level. As a mum, I would definitely have it framed, it’s very sweet and it might be a great achievement for him. Keep pushing for the support and keep him practicing. I agree with above that at that level he would struggle to keep up with the content across other subjects. The bullying is a separate issue and I would speak to the school about it.

Mally100 · 27/05/2022 12:15

This is just so beautiful op. Bless him.

To answer your question, my ds is 6yo with very neat handwriting so I would say younger. I'm saying this based on seeing his class mates writing. However it's concerning that there is no support for him.

Penguintears · 27/05/2022 12:15

Your DS sounds lovely. I would frame that poem! It would do wonders for his self-confidence.

Sounds like a dyslexia assessment is a good idea. In the meantime, I would recommend these handwriting books. They were recommended to my DS, who has a physical disability that affects his handwriting, by an occupational therapist and they had a massive positive effect on him. You can just do a page or two a day and for my DS the progress was amazing.

www.glsed.co.uk/product/sen/motor-skills/fine-motor-skills/write-from-the-start/g248709?pk_cid=1&pk_keyword=G248709gls&pk_medium=multifeeds&pk_campaign=Google&pk_source=Google&pk_content=BusinessIndustrial&utm_source=Google&gclid=EAIaIQobChMInJmHmMb_9wIVDuztCh1WgQr4EAQYAiABEgK9mvD_BwE

orwellwasright · 27/05/2022 12:15

WhatsOnYourToast · 27/05/2022 12:09

At this point in the year I'd say lower ability year 1.
Can you try a different school? Private assessment? I know some schools definitely refer. School sounds a bit naff

Lower ability Y1? Okaaay. You don't work with KS1 children do you.

WhatsOnYourToast · 27/05/2022 12:15

I actually think handwriting is an art form, cursive handwriting should absolutely be taught. But I don't think there's enough emphasis on practicing it, but demand it, so many have terrible handwriting. There are a lot of pros to writing vs typing, for example information is absorbed better.
Can he maybe try some cursive handwriting books just focusing on the formation of each letter?

grey12 · 27/05/2022 12:13

Not super neat but not terrible handwriting 🤷🏻‍♀️ there are all kinds of paper with special lines and workbooks if your child is self conscious about it. Nothing wrong with trying to improve themselves!

flowerypillowcase · 27/05/2022 12:11

My husband is 44 and I promise your son'd handwriting is better and neater than his. He passed all his exams and has a good job. It wont hold him back. What a lovely poem. Frame it.

hangrylady · 27/05/2022 12:11

Really difficult to say but anywhere between 6 and 10. I don't know if this is a real thing but I find that girls in general have much neater writing than boys. My 11 year old DD has proper adult handwriting but my 9 year old DS has very sloppy writing and forgets can't be arsed to join up letters and use punctuation properly, even though he knows how to do these things.

Inthesameboatatmo · 27/05/2022 12:11

None of my children have readable joined up writing. 2 are teens one 9 they all just write without joined up and it's neat . I don't care as long as things are spelled correctly and it's neat. Too much focus is put on cursive as far as I'm concerned and the child then gets preoccupied with that rather than learning anything else. That's is a beautiful poem, cherish it and don't over think the handwriting.

Leodot · 27/05/2022 12:10

@whinetime89 I would query it too. I’m a teacher in the UK and we did some dyslexia screenings on children last week!. That doesn’t sound right.

WhatsOnYourToast · 27/05/2022 12:09

At this point in the year I'd say lower ability year 1.
Can you try a different school? Private assessment? I know some schools definitely refer. School sounds a bit naff

viques · 27/05/2022 12:05

It is very sweet, but it is worryingly very far below the expectations of what a NT child would be able to write both in content and in presentation. You do need to get back to the school and push very hard for a proper assessment to be made. How is he in other areas, eg reading? If his reading is as behind he will be struggling with reading maths problems even if he understands concepts, and being able to access information and use it for humanities, science etc will also be putting him behind his peers.

Dobbyismyabsolutefav · 27/05/2022 12:04

Another one who thinks that it might be a good idea for your DS to be assessed by an Educational Psychologist. With a full report you will have so much information and tips on how to help your DS achieve his potential and give your DS lots of coping strategies.

Also children flourish at their own rate and for lots of children handwriting is difficult. Perhaps a laptop for secondary school might help and especially for exams when he is older.

pixie5121 · 27/05/2022 12:04

NoHeavenNoMore · 27/05/2022 11:17

Beautiful. Doesn't matter how old the child is or what the writing. The sentiment is there and that's all that counts

No, no, no!

It isn't all that counts! Attitudes like this are what lead to kids not being diagnosed and struggling through life and never reaching their potential.

OP wasn't asking about the content of the poem, she was asking about his handwriting and yes, as a former teacher, I think it's below what would normally be expected from a child that age. He's mixing lower and upper case letters a little bit and writing is obviously an effort for him. I would be trying to seek support.

Honestly, it's quite offensive how people go 'oh never mind, dyslexia/ADHD/neurodiversity is a gift'. It's a disability and it needs to be treated like one so children get the support they need to achieve what they're capable of. I had parents with the airy fairy 'it's just the way she is' mentality and it had devastating effects on my schooling and mental health.

Swipe left for the next trending thread