Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How old would you assume the child who wrote this was?

188 replies

AloyNoraWarrior · 27/05/2022 11:11

My DS is 9 in Y4. He’s very upset as he said some children in his class have been laughing at his writing. I know he is behind because his school report last term said working towards expectations for every subject. But I’m thinking it must be bad if other children are noticing.

He does have ASD and we are waiting for an ADHD assessment. Last year I asked his teacher if could be assessed for dyslexia because he writes his name incorrectly, but they said they don’t assess children for dyslexia anymore.

I was just wondering how his writing compares to other children his age as I’m not sure what level it should be at. The photo represents his best effort. The second line of the poem is ‘when I am a pest’

How old would you assume the child who wrote this was?
OP posts:
Riverrushing21 · 27/05/2022 19:26

Teacher here. Firstly, what a lovely poem!

Re possible dyslexia, schools absolutely do still test for it, so I’m not sure why the teacher said that. Looking at his spelling (all correct!) however, I wouldn’t be concerned about dyslexia, unless of course he has copied all of these correct spellings from a ‘word bank’ or something.

To be honest, apart from the handwriting, I can’t see anything majorly alarming. Granted, he isn’t using as much detail in his writing as his ‘Expected’ or ‘Greater Depth’ peers will be, but then you already said he has been graded as working towards.

I would be speaking to his teacher about other children picking on him though as that is not on.

DelphiniumBlue · 27/05/2022 18:03

It is a very sweet poem, he sounds a lovely boy.
The handwriting is not properly joined, and the sizing is not consistent. He could do with handwriting lessons/practice, maybe there's something you could do with him at home, in unpressurised surroundings, just focusing on the shape and size of the letters rather than the content.
You can get books/downloadables with patterns to copy which might help.
It looks like it could be a fine motor skills issue, but not necessarily - I have seen ( rarely) the odd child with handwriting like that but who has great pencil control when it comes to drawing. What are his drawing skills like?
I agree, if you can pay to get him assesses for dyslexia and ADHD it might be worth doing - it might help the school to know how to target and design support.
They should be coming up with ways to help him anyway, and certainly the nasty comments he is getting should be a matter of concern for the school.
You said that he is "working towards" in every subject - that to me suggests he should already be getting a lot of extra support. I think you should contact the SENDCO and ask for a meeting to discuss your concerns and his progress. I'm a little surprised that you are having to ask about this here rather than having school in regular contact with you explaining what they are doing to help.
At most of the schools I have worked at, this would have been flagged up by the staff working with your son, and actioned some time ago, and monitored for progress.

Pillowaddict · 27/05/2022 17:55

Beautiful words! My 9 y/o dd is ASD, ADHD and has just been assessed as being dyslexic, this is very like her writing and spelling. Like your boy she is loving and bright, but struggles with writing and reading. I'd push for more specific support.

SquidGinn · 27/05/2022 17:42

♥️

Thatswhyimacat · 27/05/2022 17:34

That's a lovely poem and actually has a very pleasing rhythm beyond its sentiment!

Whatafustercluck · 27/05/2022 17:28

A lovely poem, you should be very proud of the love he clearly has for you. Treasure it, keep it in a memory box, and don't give it a second thought.

Fameinaframe · 27/05/2022 16:57

Teacher here 🙋
Been teaching year 4 for the last 3 years.
I have seen a huge range of handwriting.
Some better than mine! To some you simply cannot read, backward letters, mixture of large and small letters etc.
Your son is sat around the middle of my HUGE range.

What a lovely poem! 😍

Benjispruce4 · 27/05/2022 16:51

Most often parents seek a private diagnosis but not everyone can.

Benjispruce4 · 27/05/2022 16:50

Perhaps secondary have better budgets but at my primary, we are barely keeping in the black. If parents knew, they’d never vote for that shambles at Westminster. It’s dire.

starlingdarling · 27/05/2022 15:48

Benjispruce4 · 27/05/2022 15:36

Our school doesn’t test for dyslexia as you have to pay. It doesn’t change how we deal with suspected dyslexia though.

That's really sad. Obviously I know you're doing what you can but why does the government wait until university to fund extra provision for dyslexic students?

Can students without a diagnosis still get extra time for GCSEs and A Level exams? At the university they need a diagnosis or we can't make adjustments. I think we do pay for the test (after an online screening test that confirms if there are many indicators) and then we get a grant for support.

Benjispruce4 · 27/05/2022 15:36

Our school doesn’t test for dyslexia as you have to pay. It doesn’t change how we deal with suspected dyslexia though.

starlingdarling · 27/05/2022 15:21

I'd question why they don't test for dyslexia. I don't believe it's true. I work at a university and we arrange dyslexia tests for students who have slipped through the net during school (usually older ones who went when screening wasn't common). We get funding for British students to help purchase things like speech to text software and pens that read text out loud. We also make all sorts of adjustments to put them on a level playing field with their peers. Things like extra time in exams and receiving lecture slides in advance so they have time process them if they need to.

IvorCutler · 27/05/2022 15:18

My son is 8.5 and also autistic. He writes in cursive at school, but this is his normal scrawl.

I think your son’s poem is wonderful and his writing is lovely. It’s not the neatest I’ve seen but not the messiest either, it’s clear. I’m so sorry kids have been mean to him about it, that’s awful.

How old would you assume the child who wrote this was?
Daftasabroom · 27/05/2022 15:18

@AloyNoraWarrior it choked me up.

SuzyQ12 · 27/05/2022 15:16

The poem is lovely! His handwriting is legible, which is more important than being cursive in my opinion, and better than the handwriting of some senior pupils I've read...

Thighdentitycrisis · 27/05/2022 15:16

Also, he may go into medicine!😀

SuzyQ12 · 27/05/2022 15:16

The poem is lovely! His handwriting is legible, which is more important than being cursive in my opinion, and better than the handwriting of some senior pupils I've read...

OchonAgusOchonOh · 27/05/2022 15:15

AloyNoraWarrior · 27/05/2022 12:56

The reason I was thinking dyslexia is because he frequently spells his name wrong and it’s only 4 letters. He does a lot of b/d p/q mixing up.

I’m not sure about his fine motor skills but his gross motor skills are really good. He’s very strong and physically able, rode a bike from a young age, he’s an excellent climber.

Another possibility is dysgraphia. My eldest ds has dysgraphia and his writing can be very difficult to decipher unless he writes very slowly. He also has good gross motor skills. He played hurling at a high level and that involves catching a small, fast moving ball in the air and whacking it with a stick. It's a very fast game that involves excellent motor skills. Same with riding a bike, climbing etc. An educational psychologist or an occupational therapist can diagnose but we found the OT better, mainly because it was something she knew about as she has a son who also has it so she had done a lot of research.

Ds used to get a hard time from his teachers in primary until one of them said to me she started off at the beginning of the year giving out to him but quickly realised he was trying but was not able to do he. She arranged extra classes with a student teacher who was on placement and they stopped trying to get him to write in cursive. His hand writing didn't improve but at least no one was giving him a hard time over it.

His writing is still atrocious but once we got the diagnosis he was allowed to type for all state exams and in uni. He also got extra time in uni exams.

I would definitely recommend getting a diagnosis and see is he allowed type on the strength of that. Dysgraphia is not just about handwriting. It also affects their ability to structure work from a conceptual perspective as they are focusing on the physical activity of writing rather than the content.

Thighdentitycrisis · 27/05/2022 15:15

It doesn’t matter, that poem is beautiful

bigdecisionstomake · 27/05/2022 15:13

Sorry, haven't read the full thread, only the OPs comments, but just wanted to say my son is 23 and his handwriting is only marginally better than that.

He was diagnosed with dyspraxia in his reception year and then dyslexia in year 2 if I remember correctly. I think the neatness of handwriting can be more due to the dyspraxia and lack of fine motor skills rather than the dyslexia itself, although obviously it doesn't help. The two conditions often come hand in hand I think.

If it reassures you, he got a first class honours degree a couple of years ago and has just completed his masters so it hasn't held him back at all. A formal diagnosis did mean he got awarded additional time in his exams though which really helped him as it took him longer to read the questions properly and then write out the answers. He also got help with a laptop at University.

Notsureaboutusername · 27/05/2022 15:01

My brother has writing like that. Nothing wrong with him. He is 57.

Newestname002 · 27/05/2022 14:59

I can't comment on dyslexia or dyspraxia but - What a beautiful, loving poem, @AloyNoraWarrior. What a kind heart your son has. 🌹

pixie5121 · 27/05/2022 14:59

AloyNoraWarrior · 27/05/2022 12:56

The reason I was thinking dyslexia is because he frequently spells his name wrong and it’s only 4 letters. He does a lot of b/d p/q mixing up.

I’m not sure about his fine motor skills but his gross motor skills are really good. He’s very strong and physically able, rode a bike from a young age, he’s an excellent climber.

Well that's a major flag for dyslexia. Spelling your own name wrong at age 9 is a definite cause for concern.

I also think 'upest' in his poem is supposed to be 'upset' rather than 'a pest'.

Definitely push for a dyslexia diagnosis...the school sound rubbish fobbing you off like that. If he's behind at school, he needs help NOW, before it starts seriously impacting on his confidence and future. So many kids are just written off as not being very academic when in fact they just need the appropriate support.

My ex was diagnosed with dyslexia around 8 or 9 and his grades in every subject really picked up after that. He went on to study Computer Science and is now a very successful app developer. It's certainly possibly to thrive with dyslexia or any kind of neurodiversity, but the support needs to be there.

JayAlfredPrufrock · 27/05/2022 14:58

@Marvellousmadness

I’m so glad irony is still alive.

LittleOwl153 · 27/05/2022 14:58

I have an 8yr old Yr3 Leftie and a 12yr old dyslexic...

My 8yr old leftie has probably progressed from this type of writing this school year only. And it was around Yr3 / Yr4 that my 12yr old dyslexic started to have problems and it took 4 further years for them to be taken seriously in school.

The answer on the dyslexia assessment is likely about funding and the 'standing' of an assessment on a 9yr old. The dont usually formally assess until year 6 because there is an issue with assessments 'running out' and being outdated. That said the SENDCO in school should be able to informally administer some of the testing tools to identify what his needs are. Dyslexia covers a broadbase of stuff so no 2 dyslexics are the same. Spelling and other issues - sentence structure etc can all come from being a slow writer and simply not keeping up in class so therefore not learning the topics as the class does (This is exactly where my DD is now with her English).

I would also query hypermobility and/or hand strength and look at some hand exercises which will help. Things like squishy balls or playdough or bread can exercise the hands. You can also look at different pens - for example stablio do a pen that looks like a wand - there are pencils too. School should also look at pencil grips.

You are going to have to fight school for your boy to get him the support he needs sadly as there is not enough funding for support to go around. If his handwriting is that slow then he should be offered the use of a computer or a scribe when there is alot of writing for example. Yes he needs to learn to write - that is a key primary school goal - but writing a birthday card, shopping list or a postcard is enough - he does not need to be able to physically write a 10 page essay if he can communicate it in other ways.

Things you can try from our experience:

  • Going to the GP and asking for an Occupational Therapy assessment
  • Using a slope to write on - try using a closed ring binder and see if that makes a difference - it might take the pressure off his hands
  • Use lined paper to guide his writing - even if this is a strongly inked lined paper underneath the paper he wants to write on
  • try finger exercises - playdough paperclips etc to strengthen his hands
  • try the different pencil grips
  • get him typing - if it turns out he is assessed for struggles in physically writing the earlier he can master a keyboard the better
I'd also report the bullies to the teacher - they may think its nothing but that kind of behaviour should absolutely be stamped out before it really affects your boys self esteme - it already has to a degree and thats not on. (Tell you boy that most GP's I know have appauling handwriting and it is seen as a sign of intelligence!)

I can write for hours on support for this kind of stuff - so I'll shut up - but do ask me questions if I can be of help OP!

Swipe left for the next trending thread