Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How old would you assume the child who wrote this was?

188 replies

AloyNoraWarrior · 27/05/2022 11:11

My DS is 9 in Y4. He’s very upset as he said some children in his class have been laughing at his writing. I know he is behind because his school report last term said working towards expectations for every subject. But I’m thinking it must be bad if other children are noticing.

He does have ASD and we are waiting for an ADHD assessment. Last year I asked his teacher if could be assessed for dyslexia because he writes his name incorrectly, but they said they don’t assess children for dyslexia anymore.

I was just wondering how his writing compares to other children his age as I’m not sure what level it should be at. The photo represents his best effort. The second line of the poem is ‘when I am a pest’

How old would you assume the child who wrote this was?
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Ruralbliss · 28/05/2022 07:49

My 19 year old just wrote a card to his grandma and it was very similar. He has ASD and ADHD.

School wasn't good for him as bullied but now he's thriving in the world of work, living in a shared house and has a nice steady girlfriend.

jamimmi · 27/05/2022 23:06

I'd push for a dyslexia and dysppraxia assessment looking at his writing. He may have issues with fine moter control ans oftenthey occur together . My son had writing similar at his age ,it did improve bit not alot.. At 17 he was pick up as having issues and given a key board for exams it was a game changer..

nightcapers · 27/05/2022 23:01

That is a beautiful poem. You have a very sweet boy. All the best to you

WhackingPhoenix · 27/05/2022 21:36

What a lovely pest 🥰

Handwriting means nothing OP, I’ve not met a doctor with legible writing yet!

wolfstrawb · 27/05/2022 21:14

My son is 9, he has moderate dyslexia along with some other diagnosis'. His handwriting is completely different in style but probably at a similar level when he puts in his best effort (it's very variable).
I'd be questioning what the school are doing to help. My son has a lot of help. Tasks are broken down so he focuses on 1 thing at a time -so his TA might scribe for him and then he will copy it out after. On top of writing being a major effort, spelling is his weakest area and we aren't close to getting on top of that yet but he is intelligent so he is also starting to use dictation software so he can produce work which reflects his ideas and understanding.
It's true that schools don't in the main really assess or refer for a dyslexia diagnosis - they can screen but most parents have to pay privately for an assessment. I recommend getting a full assessment by an Ed Psych. Schools are likely to pay more attention to it and it's been invaluable he explaining to my son why he struggles more than his peers (which has really helped his self esteem).
The poem clearly shows your son has a lot to offer :)

CP2701 · 27/05/2022 21:12

Don't confuse handwriting and ability. I am a teacher. There are children with the most beautiful handwriting who can barely sound out words. Other children can have untidy handwriting but more than capable at reading and writing. Focus on the actual content, which is lovely! Presentation is a very small part.

They definitely still assess for dyslexia.

Benjispruce4 · 27/05/2022 21:09

You, when, love, still and nothing are all tricky words.

lunchboxproblems · 27/05/2022 21:02

@Benjispruce4 my middles in Y1 would be fine with this aside from potentially spelling love and when, but I can fully understand the varying impact covid has had across schools!

Benjispruce4 · 27/05/2022 20:55

I work in yr 1&2 at the moment and it’s only that reliable at the most able end. Commas are still erratic. This post Covid cohort anyway!

Justdiscovered · 27/05/2022 20:48

Definitely get a private assessment if you can afford it. Also assess for dyspraxia

Justdiscovered · 27/05/2022 20:41

Definitely start exploring the possibility of home having a laptop to write- but this has to come with touch typing intervention or practice at home (I think there’s some free stuff online )
I would keep reinforcing that is his ideas that are important and he just needs to find a way that works for home to get them on paper. Keep fighting his corner- too many boys get to secondary school who have all the right ideas and understanding but have not been allowed to develop their writing and therefore appear behind.

AloyNoraWarrior · 27/05/2022 20:40

He does have a support plan but I’m not sure what’s on it. I used to have regular meetings with the SENCO but haven’t done so this year. I know he does a few small groups, one is anger management, and another is like a social stories type thing. He also does something called Lexia at lunchtime which he’s not that happy about as he’d rather be out playing.

The past month I’ve let his reading slide because we’ve been working on Tables as he has that multiplication test after half-term which we’ve been told all children must get 100% on, and there’s no way he will get 100%.

The bullying needs addressing, I’ve spoken to the school several times about this sort of thing. The problem is he has the reputation for being the ‘naughty child’ and it seems that other children know which buttons to press and DS ends up the one in trouble.

OP posts:
lunchboxproblems · 27/05/2022 20:36

Benjispruce4 · 27/05/2022 20:25

Year 1&2 rarely use punctuation and spelling like that.

All of the words used are either phonetic or YR/1 'tricky' words so the average Y1 and certainly average Y2 child should be using spelling like that. Same with most of the punctuation.

Benjispruce4 · 27/05/2022 20:25

Year 1&2 rarely use punctuation and spelling like that.

Badgerstmary · 27/05/2022 20:17

Hi op, I’ve taught various years at primary schools. I would say yr 1/2 & try & get a private referral.
A lovely poem.

AreYouACheese · 27/05/2022 20:11

His writing isn't too different my (just) 11 year old.

My son has no diagnosed learning difficulties, but it has been brought up by teachers a fair amount.

But -- everyone has different writing. Some people have beautiful handwriting, others not so much. It's not something I worry about, and it's not something I'm encouraging him to improve. He is good at spelling, and I can understand (for the most part!) what he is writing.

Your sons writing is perfectly legible. And his poem is so, so sweet.

I hope he isn't hurt by the other children laughing. That is so unkind, and if I ever caught one of my children laughing at someone's writing, I would not be impressed. If it something he wants to improve at, if it is important to him, encourage him to write more, to try different types of pens. I always find my writing is much nicer when I use certain types. A fine nib biro, or fountain pen make writing flow easily for me. But a gel pen, or a thick nibbed biro makes my writing look and feel horrible.

Sorry, went off on one, but I really love pens Grin and I also am a bit weird about how my writing looks. So, I can understand if it is something that bothers him!

Localher0 · 27/05/2022 20:04

First- that is a wonderful poem. One to treasure and keep safe forever.
Second - my DS is 20 and his handwriting looks like that. He has dyspraxia and ADD. it was identified early and he was a designated laptop user at school from 11 onwards. He got super GCSEs & A levels and is at a great Uni. So please don't worry - get assessments as needed and provide the support he needs. Nurture him.

greybear · 27/05/2022 19:54

My son who is 27 has handwriting exactly like this too! I was worried about it when he was at school especially when he came to do GCSES, in case the examiner couldn't read his answers.

He did fine though, got the grades he needed to go to college to do a computing course. Then went on to study computer networks at uni, graduated with a first and now earns 65k a year. His handwriting didn't hold him back at all either, everything is typed now anyway!

LondonQueen · 27/05/2022 19:53

The words are very sweet, the handwriting isn't fantastic but it is still legible. You mention he has ASD, does he have any additional support at school?

Pumperthepumper · 27/05/2022 19:50

I’d be pushing for a dyslexia referral. The handwriting is a red herring, loads of kids don’t develop solid fine motor control until later on, but constantly mixing up the letters in his name would indicate a deeper issue to me.

Howmanysleepsnow · 27/05/2022 19:49

Apart from not being cursive very similar to my y4 ds. His teacher says his writing is on target, if a bit messy 😂

Doggyfish · 27/05/2022 19:45

I think it's lovely. Don't worry about his handwriting, or him being a bit behind. Not everyone can be brilliant at everything. He sounds like a great boy.

lunchboxproblems · 27/05/2022 19:39

It's an incredibly sweet poem! I'm a Y1 teacher and this seems like something an average 5/6 year old could produce in terms of spelling, most (but not all) of them have neater handwriting. My school does dyslexia assessments for KS2 so certainly some schools still do them.

Maybebabyno2 · 27/05/2022 19:38

It's clearer than any Dr's notes I've ever written.

What a lovely poem OP.

Kids are horrible to each other and will pick any random thing they can to take the piss. Maybe he is dyslexic, maybe he is just a bit lazy, just be there to support him either way. I am not dyslexic but I do sometimes put letters the wrong way round when writing in a hurry or if I'm really tired. It could go either way try not to worry and maybe ask the school for an assessment.

Riverrushing21 · 27/05/2022 19:28

Just to add, if he is working towards then he should already be having loads of support, so maybe ask the teacher what support he is getting and push for more if you’re not satisfied with her answer. I’m not saying him being this level isn’t alarming… just that the piece of work you have shown is typical of a working towards child in my opinion, so shouldn’t shock you if you have already been told this.