Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think maybe they need to make NHS dentist places means tested?

133 replies

dameofdilemma · 27/05/2022 09:03

Reading about the shortage of NHS places and having seen it in real life….is the Govt going to do anything at all about it?

I’m fortunate enough to be able to afford treatment as a private patient but what about those who can’t? Dp is registered as an NHS patient and is even thinking of giving up his place and registering privately (if he knew if would go to someone who needed it).

I’ve had two dentist appointments recently, both times while waiting, a string of people were coming in to ask about NHS places. The local FB pages are full of desperate posts as no one can find an NHS place. They’re facing long, long waits for treatment at hospitals.
Having had agonising tooth pain recently, its debilitating, it effected my ability to sleep, eat and work properly. This isn’t a ‘nice to have’ treatment, its essential.

So maybe the NHS places should be reserved for those on the lowest (or no) incomes? It can’t make any practical sense to offer places to higher earners, if places are so scarce, if all that happens is people are then having to rely on (already overloaded) hospitals or being unable to work etc.

I know we don’t want as two tier system or a shift to private healthcare etc but reading some of the stories of people unable to eat and passing out from dehydration, the status quo clearly isn’t working either.

OP posts:
MillyMollyMardy · 27/05/2022 23:04

@mumda the BDA doesn't think there is a shortage of Dentists it's mainly no-one wants to carry out NHS Dentistry.
I'm an NHS Dentist for the last 30 years but I'm broken, the demand is unrelenting and I feel like last man standing. I don't think we can afford to keep providing it for much longer; our lab bills, material costs, equipment costs are all rising significantly and the NHS contract doesn't increase at anywhere near the same rate.

mumda · 27/05/2022 22:51

Or just train more dentists?

We seriously need to have more doctors and nurses too.

MillyMollyMardy · 27/05/2022 22:44

The Goverment have said there is no more money for NHS Dentistry. The exodus of Dentists from the NHS is happening. They have only commisioned NHS Dentistry for half the population and right now there are recruitment issues for NHS Dentists and nurses so there are many unfilled vacancies.

In an ideal world the NHS would set up and run NHS clinics but Dentistry is expensive to provide. They took out of hours care away from Dental Practices in 2006 to save money. It didn't.

Dental Practices run efficiently, we are good at it, you can't provide Dentistry cheaper than the way it is already provided in the UK. Don't compare it to other countries they are cheaper due to the local economy, the exchange rate, regulation differences.

As Bickles said NHS Dentistry needs urgent reform, the contract needs to pay Dental Practices reasonably for what is provided. It is completly inappropriate that Private Dentistry props up NHS Dentistry. Priority needs to be given to under 18s (they need preventative care and regular check ups to ensure they start with healthy teeth)and those on low income. There is also a need for affordable family Dentistry for others, not everyone needs high end cosmetic and implant work. The Government needs to be honest about what they want to do about NHS Dentistry, they are busy killing it at the moment.

Buttons0522 · 27/05/2022 16:20

If my NI contributions were reduced then crack on but until then it will be middle earners who lose out again - earn too much to qualify for support but earn too little to be able to pay for it!

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 27/05/2022 16:18

So you want those who pay the most in for the service to be stopped from using it?

Yes, that’s very unreasonable.

MoodyTwo · 27/05/2022 16:15

Surely the more you earn, the more tax you pay ... so your contributions into the system cover more

AppleandRhubarbTart · 27/05/2022 15:34

dameofdilemma · 27/05/2022 14:39

Some really interesting posts here, v informative to hear from dentists too.

Theres no easy solution but as of today, some people are paying NI for an NHS service they can’t in practice use. Exactly the position lots of posters say they don’t accept.
Its happening already by stealth, as another poster said.

Speaking as one of those people, I don't accept blanket denial of NHS dentistry to those in a certain income bracket. I'm not happy about the way others are being deprived of a service they pay NI towards now either, but aside from willingness to vote for tax raising parties to fund a better service there isn't much I can do to assist them. Whereas there are things I could do myself if I were forced out, such as ensuring the tax I paid to the Exchequer was reduced.

ThinWomansBrain · 27/05/2022 14:58

Lavenderlast · 27/05/2022 12:41

What about the NHS stops spending millions of pounds on sex changes and spends that money on dentists instead 😱

or IVF - double benefit, fewer people needing dental treatment.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 27/05/2022 14:57

People will get used to paying for dentistry like they pay for eye tests and glasses and will take out insurance

No, I’m pissed off paying £500 for special glasses every 2 years. I don’t want to add dental charges to that. What’s the point in paying national insurance?

ThinWomansBrain · 27/05/2022 14:55

Shortage of NHS dentists depends on where you're based - I had a series of private dentists after they started changing the contracts in late 1980's. When one retired a few years ago, I contacted a local dentist (central London) with good reviews, they asked whether I'd prefer to be a private or NHS patient.
Only difference seemed to be a three week wait for my first appointment - never had any problems scheduling appointments since then.
Me being denied NHS dental treatment wouldn't make an iota of differnence to my friend living in Devon, where there ar no Dentists with spaces for provate or NHS patients.
The current system isn't working; training, contracts and obligations of Dentists needs to be reviewed and overhauled, but I don't think that means testing would resolve the problems.

LakieLady · 27/05/2022 14:50

Ok, seems you all disagree - what’s the alternative?

Give newly qualified dentists an incentive to work in the NHS for a few years by writing off their student loans if they do 10 years NHS work.

godmum56 · 27/05/2022 14:44

SueSaid · 27/05/2022 09:49

Our private dentist used to be nhs but then we all got a letter to say they were now private, that was it! Too late now but there should have been strict legislation in place so dentists couldn't do this. All private dentists should have had to maintain nhs places.

I don't think nhs dentists should be means tested but this situation we have is ridiculous and needs immediate attention. Why don't they appoint a 'tzar' like they do with other problems.

why? do pharmacies have to offer reduced price medicines to everyone?

dameofdilemma · 27/05/2022 14:39

Some really interesting posts here, v informative to hear from dentists too.

Theres no easy solution but as of today, some people are paying NI for an NHS service they can’t in practice use. Exactly the position lots of posters say they don’t accept.
Its happening already by stealth, as another poster said.

OP posts:
Sleepyquest · 27/05/2022 13:03

No , the national health service needs to be for everyone or scrapped. It's funded by those paying NI.

I could just about afford to go privately but then I'd have to make other cut backs and I've cut back enough lately, so I'm not going to.

DenholmElliot1 · 27/05/2022 12:59

But people on low incomes get their income topped up with universal credit don't they?

Isn't that actually what universal credit is for then?

Lavenderlast · 27/05/2022 12:41

What about the NHS stops spending millions of pounds on sex changes and spends that money on dentists instead 😱

JorisBonson · 27/05/2022 12:28

I'm a low to middle earner without children and just about live comfortably. Yet again I would be getting the shit end of the stick if NHS dentistry was means tested.

Catfordthefifth · 27/05/2022 12:18

Bickles · 27/05/2022 10:38

I guess a compromise to incentivise working in the NHS. I did it for years and it’s not fun. Working privately is much nicer. It’s hard work but it is Dentistry as we were taught to do it, not rushed and with good materials, labs and nurses. No one expects you to work for hours and hours for free. You get out of it what you put in. You sleep well at night knowing that you have looked after your patients well.
Anyway if you have a good NHS dentist then obviously the system is working?
if the system isn’t then what solution do you suggest if my idea (just my thoughts) is so rubbish? How will you do the maths?

Your solution is from a purely selfish pov, which I get, you should be paid properly for what you do however that shouldn't be at the expense of people like me.

I don't have a dentist full stop! We moved and even the private practices are taking on, so no it's clearly not working.

Perhaps we stop wasting money within the NHS using overpriced single suppliers and paying £££ in locums and instead pay staff properly, incentivise them to stay including dentists and maybe make it policy that each practice has to have a big % of NHS patients and bloody well pay them for it. I don't mind paying a little more tax if I actually might benefit for once, but I never sodding do because we are "too well off" except we aren't, really.

Pixiedust1234 · 27/05/2022 12:16

Not sure if anyone else mentioned this but what about the women who are being financially abused or have selfish husbands? How do they afford to go private?

My own circumstances are I am too ill to work but cannot claim benefits as my husband earns over the threshold, however he spends his wages on his hobbies so there is nothing left after house bills and food. According to you I would have to go private. Thanks 🙄

LampLighter414 · 27/05/2022 12:13

Nope sorry I pay more than enough NICs for the privilege of being charged ~£25 for a NHS checkup vs £60 privately

The only practice I could find taking on NHS patients is a 12 mile drive away. I'm glad I found it.

Ponoka7 · 27/05/2022 12:11

"I've never understood why there's never been an attempt to have the NHS provide dentistry"

Originally they were. Then they began to separate. It worked well. Then in the 90's the budget was well overspent, dentists got less and moved into private care. I suppose we also started to want better looking teeth. All of the dentists in my area have gone private and all are occupying old GP surgeries. As said this government hasn't got the will to change anything.

francesfrankenfurter · 27/05/2022 11:57

I would support dentists being employed directly by the NHS as long as there were going to be enough of them for everyone who wants a dentists on the NHS. Remember they don't do anything at all cosmetic. It's all pretty basic healthcare stuff.
But this government does not have the ambition or basic competence to achieve this.

Dinoteeth · 27/05/2022 11:43

I've never understood why there's never been an attempt to have the NHS provide dentistry. Its always been privately provided by self employed / employed by a private company then charging back to the NHS for each treatment they do.

It's the same model used for GPs and opticians. GP practices are all private businesses.

MargosKaftan · 27/05/2022 11:38

I've never understood why there's never been an attempt to have the NHS provide dentistry. Its always been privately provided by self employed / employed by a private company then charging back to the NHS for each treatment they do.

Quite rightly, many on the left have fought like mad to stop this model being used in other parts of the NHS, yet we've known it doesn't work for dentistry for decades and there's never been an attempt to fix this.

You could say the last 1/2 years of uni training if they are to be funded by the state, you must work for 5 years in the NHS or pay it back. In the NHS you'd be salaried, preferably working out of NHS owned buildings. The booking of appointments, the wages of reception and nursing staff, the costs of equipment aren't funded by the dentist.

I've just accepted we have to have private treatment for our dcs as their NHS dentist has moved away, the new owners are private only and all the NHS places in our whole town are full. We can afford it, but ffs its ridiculous.

woodhill · 27/05/2022 11:33

Has the end of free funding for NHS courses at university affected this as well?

Swipe left for the next trending thread