Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to breastfeed in front of everyone?!

134 replies

HWka · 27/05/2022 08:24

I’m due to give birth any day now and it’s our first, first grandchild on my DH side (not on mine). My DHs parents are also divorced so there’s two sets of grandparents there and then my parents also.
I understand everyone is so excited about the baby and the support is wonderful but my DH keep making plans for things like Father’s Day, birthday meals out, Christmas, summer stay overs and discussing it as “and the baby will be here!” But I don’t want to take my baby to lots of restaurants out, holidays I don’t want to be on, Christmas stayovers with his family and then another stay over with his other parent!
I’m planning on breastfeeding and I just want the time and space to do this- I’m not comfortable doing it in a restaurant (I don’t care if others do at all I just don’t want to get my boobs out in front of my in laws or my own family for that matter!)
My family are really chilled and excited about the baby but just want me to do whatever I’m happy with.
I don’t want to be the daughter in law from hell but am I a bit mean by not wanting to take my baby to every event and be expected to pass it round like a doll whilst trying to feed?! Not to mention the fact I’ll be on maternity pay so I don’t want all my money going on these events!
I had a quiet word with my husband and he said that we can just do whatever I’m happy with, which I really hope he sticks to.
I know I’ll just need to stand up for myself nearer the time and say no but I just wondered if I’m been a bit hormonal and unreasonable?!

OP posts:
mummyh2016 · 27/05/2022 13:05

YABU. I completely get at the start you will want to stay at home to establish breastfeeding but do you honestly expect to never go out? You will make yourself ill.
And tbh how you have read your post makes me think you'll have no issue going to events with your family, just his will be the problem.

Penguinevere · 27/05/2022 13:02

I felt a bit like you are describing for the first few weeks. Events were more of a hassle than they were enjoyable mostly due to feeding. But it gets better and I wouldn’t assume it’s going to be all bad.

Penguinevere · 27/05/2022 12:59

I think you should see how it goes op. It might be ok.

Neverendingwashingpile · 27/05/2022 12:54

Hi op,

I haven't rtft but I've seen some lovely supportive comments and agree you won't know how you'll feel until the time and Christmas etc is very far away, lots of mums excuse themselves to feed baby, it gets easier as they get older etc etc

It can also be helpful to question why you feel uncomfortable... In western culture breasts are highly sexualised. When you start feeding/thinking about feeding your baby yourself, your perspective can shift a bit and you realised that your boobs are there to provide nutrition and comfort for your babies. Anyone who feels uncomfortable with you feeding needs to deal with that issue. You're just doing what's natural and using your body as it was intended to feed your baby.

Hope that helps a bit X

Regularsizedrudy · 27/05/2022 12:54

TeddyTonks · 27/05/2022 08:45

YAB a bit ridiculous to be honest. How long are you planning to shut yourself away for? 🤔

There are loads of ways to breastfeed 'discreetly' if that's what you want to - specially designed clothes, covers, use a muslin, go into another room...I've breastfed two for over a year each and never shut myself away or avoided events because of it. Honestly you're massively over thinking. What do you think happens when you have a second? You'd deprive child one of any social interaction because you need to feed child two??

Of course take your time to get used to it, work out strategies you're comfortable with etc, but mostly, get a bit of a grip!

She’s a first time mum navigating a completing alien situation. It’s a total unknown. I don’t see how comments like this are helpful and tbh could be very off putting for breast feeding.

Choopi · 27/05/2022 12:50

Wait until the baby is born. You might not want to be a recluse that is excluded from family events just because you had a baby. Most people enjoy living life with their baby alongside them and like being more than just mum, you might actually be glad of some normality and some company. It could be very lonely staying at home just you and baby until you finish breastfeeding.

jamapop · 27/05/2022 12:50

Also in the nicest, gentlest way .. you are being a bit U.

I think fair enough to say you want to take things slowly at the start. Establish breastfeeding at home without the stress of people watching. Not rush out to restaurants, cafes, anything else when you have a newborn who might be difficult in the pram etc (mine hated it and it took me some time to get used to how the carrier worked). Take your time and get to know your baby.

Don’t plan on hiding away for months or a year though. Just say the first month or so you’ll take things easy - no expectations of leaving the house etc. After that just see how things go but the assuming you’ll be hiding away for the whole baby stage is a bit bonkers.

As for feeding outside. You can do so modestly if you want like with a cover, but to never feed in public means you won’t take your child to any baby group? The library? Baby rhyme times? Nothing?

mewkins · 27/05/2022 12:49

I'm with you OP. Fathers Day is soon and aside from the feeding you will have a tiny baby and may well not feel like going out. Re the feeding, stand your ground and do what is comfortable.

Calphurnia88 · 27/05/2022 12:48

Youseethethingis1 · 27/05/2022 12:41

@Calphurnia88
Wrong poster! I didn't say that.

I'm confused then! You seem to be responding to me, but I was responding to someone else?!

Sorry! 🌸

Pyewhacket · 27/05/2022 12:47

I don't blame you OP. I was never into exhibition breastfeeding either. In the end I went back to work after 12 weeks so it sorted itself out. The other two were formula-fed from the outset and they all grew up to be happy and healthy kids.

If hubby is so keen to plan "your season " I would take a bottle with you and let him do the honours - and while he's playing happy families he can change junior's nappy at the same time. Win-win.

Hugasauras · 27/05/2022 12:43

Honestly, I think you're overthinking it and you just need to wait till the baby is here. Personally, once baby was here and we had BFing established, I had no problems doing it anywhere. No one actually cares about your boobs, as strange as that may seem when it feels like you're just getting them out in public. No one ever gave me a second look when feeding DD in myriad places such as the supermarket, park bench, cafes and restaurants, library. In fact a couple of times I was just brought a glass of water without asking.

Limiting your social affairs purely because of breastfeeding will make your world very small. I loved being out and about when DD was tiny. I did a lot of going to cafes or other places so we could get out of the house, I could have a hot drink and chat with friends, etc. I think before the baby arrives you can build things up into being these massive issues, but in reality, once baby arrived I was keen for her to meet people, for loved family members to get a chance to see her and hold her because it made them so happy. Seeing my granny holding my DD, her first great-grandchild, was a lovely moment. She is 90 and her only comment when I was feeding DD in front of her was 'Ooh yes I breastfed all of mine, so convenient!'

It sounds like your husband is really excited about the baby arriving and wants to share that with his loved ones. It's fine to say when you don't want to do things and to not want to always be here there and everywhere, but a blanket 'I'm not doing this because breastfeeding' is a bit short-sighted. For me, the intensive part of establishing breastfeeding was a few weeks. After that, it wasn't for hours and hours a day, it didn't involve me waving boobs around, and DD just latched on quickly, fed, and was done without anyone else really noticing or caring.

custardbear · 27/05/2022 12:43

Please don't stress OP. I also hated bf in front of others, with both my children, I never got used to it.
I would cover myself in a Muslin or two and my babies, I'd also face the wall if out or take myself off to a quiet place like nursery or my room if they wanted feeding when people visited. Let your DH know it's not ok for anyone to follow you as well, as you need quiet time.
You may possibly get used to it, but if you don't, don't allow it to shut down your socialisation as maternity leave can be quite depressing at times, just find ways to do things comfortably
Be confident to tell people you're feeding in peace if they come into the room, but get DH to be very proactive too
Good luck and enjoy your baby when they arrive

Talkingmouse · 27/05/2022 12:42

You are massively overthinking this. Just take yourself to a discrete corner when feeding, or another room, if it bothers you.

Ironically I only have one friend who I ever saw expose her breasts, and she was very reserved about it. She had a weird huge shawl contraception thing. Cue massive struggles to get this thing to fit/work, with an agitated baby wriggling in one hand, this cover thing ended up wrapped round her head, breasts on display for all in the cafe 🤪

Just relax, it will be fine.

Youseethethingis1 · 27/05/2022 12:41

@Calphurnia88
Wrong poster! I didn't say that.

megletthesecond · 27/05/2022 12:39

Yanbu. Especially in the early days, lie low and keep guest visits very short.
See how you go once you are in a good routine and your baby is older.

Calphurnia88 · 27/05/2022 12:38

Youseethethingis1 · 27/05/2022 12:30

No, I'm saying a baby being "shown love" by its wider family doesn't have to happen at "events" and, to be honest, it's not even nearly as important to a very young baby as being able to get on with things with its mother without anyone else getting in the way.

You literally responsed 'this is rubbish' to a PP who had said 'a breastfeeding relationship can be disrupted by constantly going out to events and passing baby around' and you also said 'of course a breastfeeding relationship cannot be disrupted by a baby being shown love from its wider family and being at events.'

NamechangeFML · 27/05/2022 12:37

Firstly, theyre just excited OP , let them dream away about Christmas
Secondly, youll go nowhere for weeks when you're exclusively breast feeding lol.
Thirdly, if you do manage to get out the door- there are plenty of privacy rooms in places now, some are lovely, some are just a chair!
Forth: you think you wont, but youll get used to being outside and feeding - at first i was there, with the nursing tops and muslins trying to protect my modesty- now my boobs are out all over the place whilst my DC has a look about before going for a snack.
you can express milk prior, get baby used to taking a bottle from birth! Itll give you a break when uou need it and dont discount combi feeding!!
my MIL is still uncomfortable with me feeding 15 months on LOL but i just ignore it , cos its her , not me.

try and not worry about everyone before youve even started. And yes, youlp find yourself putting your foot down a lot to even the nicest DGPs

SlashBeef · 27/05/2022 12:37

So you're planning to just stay at home as long as you're breastfeeding? You'll make yourself unwell.

lisavanderpumpscloset · 27/05/2022 12:36

Fully agree with you. You're the one that needs to be comfortable. You need to make sure your DH supports you on this

Youseethethingis1 · 27/05/2022 12:30

No, I'm saying a baby being "shown love" by its wider family doesn't have to happen at "events" and, to be honest, it's not even nearly as important to a very young baby as being able to get on with things with its mother without anyone else getting in the way.

Calphurnia88 · 27/05/2022 12:17

To clarify though, I am not suggesting PP become a hermit. Just that DH winds himself in a bit before making lots of plans that involve the baby in the days and weeks after birth. I think he might be in for a bit of a shock when they arrive...

MarvelMrs · 27/05/2022 12:14

He is excited which is understandable. But it is up to you to define how and where your body is on display. Breastfeeding is wonderful and I found I was comfortable in some situations and not in others. It could even depend where the table was in the restaurant or who else was in the house. Some people stare, some don’t. It is impossible to decide until the event itself. So just explain that whatever or wherever you go you need to have control over your body/boobs and it will be up to you where you feed. Have plans like the car nearby so you can pop out and sit in the back and feed if you are not comfortable in the restaurant, etc. but your DH needs to understand it will be led by you.

Calphurnia88 · 27/05/2022 12:10

minuette1 · 27/05/2022 11:08

I'm sorry but this is rubbish - of course a breastfeeding relationship cannot be disrupted by a baby being shown love from its wider family and being at events - unless the mother is choosing to withhold breast milk in those situations which is entirely different thing.

Nothing wrong with baby being 'shown love' but there are practical reasons why some visits/events could be disruptive, especially in the days and weeks after birth.

The amount of times I have gone to feed DC and a relative has said 'let me hold him first' - I've got a lot better at saying no, but in the (critical) first few weeks I was worried it would come across that I was withholding DC, especially during the seemingly never ending cluster feeding stage, so I caved. DC was pretty much attached to my boob from 6pm onwards at the beginning, so I'm not sure how visits/events that coincided with that would not have been disruptive to establishing BF.

I have also suffered painful engorgement as a result of DC having more bottles than I would have wanted to fit around extended family visits where we were constantly out and about and I wasn't comfortable BF. This took a few days to correct itself.

TooManyPJs · 27/05/2022 12:10

Are you just going to stay at home for the next year or two? That sounds really depressing.

As others have said if you are not comfortable breastfeeding in front of others you can go to a private room.

It is completely unreasonable not to expect family to want to bond with your baby too. And very unfair on your child not to facilitate those relationships forming.

grey12 · 27/05/2022 12:09

I used a big whitish (white with some pattern, light is better in the warm weather) cloth with 2 pegs holding to my clothes at the shoulders. It gives total privacy!! (Did it in public in a very conservative country, so sometimes I would tuck one of the bottom ends in my back pocket if needed)

The first few weeks it's nice to stay at home and chill with baby but afterwards you may want to get out of the house 🙂 you shouldn't let breastfeeding discourage you

Swipe left for the next trending thread