Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to breastfeed in front of everyone?!

134 replies

HWka · 27/05/2022 08:24

I’m due to give birth any day now and it’s our first, first grandchild on my DH side (not on mine). My DHs parents are also divorced so there’s two sets of grandparents there and then my parents also.
I understand everyone is so excited about the baby and the support is wonderful but my DH keep making plans for things like Father’s Day, birthday meals out, Christmas, summer stay overs and discussing it as “and the baby will be here!” But I don’t want to take my baby to lots of restaurants out, holidays I don’t want to be on, Christmas stayovers with his family and then another stay over with his other parent!
I’m planning on breastfeeding and I just want the time and space to do this- I’m not comfortable doing it in a restaurant (I don’t care if others do at all I just don’t want to get my boobs out in front of my in laws or my own family for that matter!)
My family are really chilled and excited about the baby but just want me to do whatever I’m happy with.
I don’t want to be the daughter in law from hell but am I a bit mean by not wanting to take my baby to every event and be expected to pass it round like a doll whilst trying to feed?! Not to mention the fact I’ll be on maternity pay so I don’t want all my money going on these events!
I had a quiet word with my husband and he said that we can just do whatever I’m happy with, which I really hope he sticks to.
I know I’ll just need to stand up for myself nearer the time and say no but I just wondered if I’m been a bit hormonal and unreasonable?!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
custardbear · 28/05/2022 01:00

GrendelsGrandma · 27/05/2022 16:00

Yabu because you need to be in the here and now, not planning arguments for a year's time. You don't know how you'll feel. It's a waste of time worrying about it.

Breastfeeding doesn't always work out, so there's that. Intending to is great but be kind to yourself if things don't go according to plan.

First time I did it in public felt a bit strange but soon my tits felt no more private than my elbow and tbh I couldn't give a shit what anyone thought. Or maybe I did but it was about item 74 on my list of things to worry about so I never got round to stressing about it. Once feeding is established you can latch them on with about half a cm of skin showing.

If just enjoy being able to get around without a baby right now, stress about this as and when you need to.

That's YOU though, not everyone feels that comfortable with showing breast in public

custardbear · 28/05/2022 00:56

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 27/05/2022 14:49

I don't blame you OP. I was never into exhibition breastfeeding either

Wow. The absolute ridiculousness of this comment.

I once got on a bus with DS3 in a sling. An older man commented that I could be breastfeeding and no one would ever know!

Reader, I was breastfeeding him.

If that’s ‘exhibition breastfeeding’ just because I happened to be out of my own house then so be it.

PS in 14 months of breastfeeding I never had any negative comments at all btw.

Often it's not so much about negative feelings from others, it's more about how one feels about oneself and others watching or showing your body in public

Riceball · 27/05/2022 22:25

By 6 months it can have a roast potato instead of a breastfeed. See how it goes. Good luck.

ChickinMarango · 27/05/2022 22:04

@HWka I thought I’d hate feeding in front of people. We had our baby just before Christmas and I refused to miss our yearly trip to the zoo which had been cancelled the year before.

4 days pp I was sat in the soft play facing a queue of people through floor to ceiling glass doors all alone while hubby and DD played. A few hours later I was sat on a bench in the cold, in a thoroughfare feeding, again on my own.

Now it’s not for everyone but you may find ways to bf discreetly, you may not care or you may be very self conscious but please don’t make any plans based on your feelings just yet. (Also, there are some fab bf tops which are really discreet and mean not a lot is on show).

Calphurnia88 · 27/05/2022 21:20

minuette1 · 27/05/2022 21:02

That's fair enough but the OP is talking about Christmas when the baby will be starting to eat solids anyway!

See above.

minuette1 · 27/05/2022 21:02

Calphurnia88 · 27/05/2022 12:17

To clarify though, I am not suggesting PP become a hermit. Just that DH winds himself in a bit before making lots of plans that involve the baby in the days and weeks after birth. I think he might be in for a bit of a shock when they arrive...

That's fair enough but the OP is talking about Christmas when the baby will be starting to eat solids anyway!

Calphurnia88 · 27/05/2022 17:07

TheKeatingFive · 27/05/2022 16:38

You misunderstand.

I don't think I do, no.

Of course it's normal to be concerned in the early days when getting established.

However I have never in my life come across someone making plans for 7/8 months down the line based around not wanting to breastfeed in front of family members. Or deciding they won't be visiting restaurants for the whole time they're feeding their baby.

I deleted my last post due to a mistype - sorry, but I think you've missed my point entirely.

As a new mum myself, I suspect this isn't about whether or not OP wants to feed in a restaurant, or whether she wants to spend Christmas with in laws. I suspect this is about DH signing her up for all these things (and more) before she's even had the baby. My point was that feeding in public, and seeing your baby being passed around, are all very normal anxieties, and DH (whilst with the best intentions) isn't helping by filling up her calender with things that will involve both of these before she's had chance to figure it all out.

NumberCurtains · 27/05/2022 16:46

This sounds extreme. It sounds like you are planning on putting you and your husband's lives completely on hold once you have the baby. This just isn't necessary or healthy.

Even if you don't want to feed the baby in public, you can still visit people (ask if there is a spare room you can use), have people visit you at home, attend events (make sure there is somewhere private to feed baby/express/take a sling or shawl or time around feeds - doable after around 3 months or so).

Your current plan makes it sound like you plan on sucking all joy out of your life over the next few months (which will be difficult and different enough with a newborn anyway), isolate yourselves (bad idea during such a tricky time) and alienate a vital part of your support network. Yes, babies are important and benefit from a lot of time and attention from their parents. However, making them the ONLY important thing in your life is a big mistake. Your sense of self, relationship, self esteem, mental health and close relationships will suffer.

I've breastfed 2 children until they were 2.5 years old. I get the importance of a mother's touch and close contact - I've never been the sort to pass my baby around. But I still acknowledge that me and my partner have needs that exist aside from the baby!

TheKeatingFive · 27/05/2022 16:38

You misunderstand.

I don't think I do, no.

Of course it's normal to be concerned in the early days when getting established.

However I have never in my life come across someone making plans for 7/8 months down the line based around not wanting to breastfeed in front of family members. Or deciding they won't be visiting restaurants for the whole time they're feeding their baby.

Calphurnia88 · 27/05/2022 16:34

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

ChocolateHippo · 27/05/2022 16:29

Mixed feelings on this. I like that we've become a society where breastfeeding in public is completely acceptable and largely accepted but I do think this has led to pressure on mums to 'just get on with it' even if they'd prefer not to get their breasts out in public. I remember taking my then 3 week old for a check-up in hospital and asking the receptionist if the hospital had a breastfeeding room. I was told breezily, 'Oh, you can just do it anywhere" and had to be very clear that I didn't want to "do it anywhere", I wanted to do it in a private, unobserved space with no one else around. She looked at me doubtfully and suggested the cafe! And this was apparently a 'Baby-Friendly' hospital which heavily promoted breastfeeding.

My baby had difficulty latching on and would come on and off, screaming piercingly the whole time, so he wasn't one of those babies that 'no one would know you were feeding'. Instead, I'd have everyone in the vicinity staring at me, uncovered, wondering what I was doing to this poor baby! Things did improve as the baby got older but in the meantime I invested in a breastfeeding cover and that was a lifesaver.

Curiosity101 · 27/05/2022 16:08

Yanbu to want to wait and see how you feel nearer the time. Committing to lots of trips, visitors and holidays now does seem silly. I'm glad it sounds like your DH is supportive. It'll potentially be good for you and DH to have lots of things you could do, just try not to commit until nearer the time.

Speaking from my own experience of BFing and talking to others, I do agree with a PP who said it gets much easier once you get to 5-6 weeks. It can be a bit of a slog until then for various reasons and so if you combine that with not feeling comfortable about the idea of breastfeeding in public I can completely see why you'd want to keep the diary clear. As it happens I have been quite comfortable with it pretty much from day 1 (I left all hopes of dignity somewhere in labour suite 😅😄), but I can fully appreciate that won't be everyone's experience.

I also don't understand why people think it's ok to assume they can hold and cuddle a new baby. They're not a toy. If new parents are happy to show off their baby then fab... But if they want privacy and to be left alone then that's fine too. It's a huge adjustment, particularly when it's your first.

GrendelsGrandma · 27/05/2022 16:00

Yabu because you need to be in the here and now, not planning arguments for a year's time. You don't know how you'll feel. It's a waste of time worrying about it.

Breastfeeding doesn't always work out, so there's that. Intending to is great but be kind to yourself if things don't go according to plan.

First time I did it in public felt a bit strange but soon my tits felt no more private than my elbow and tbh I couldn't give a shit what anyone thought. Or maybe I did but it was about item 74 on my list of things to worry about so I never got round to stressing about it. Once feeding is established you can latch them on with about half a cm of skin showing.

If just enjoy being able to get around without a baby right now, stress about this as and when you need to.

TheKeatingFive · 27/05/2022 15:50

I get your point but essentially I think OP is getting a hard time here for having very natural and normal anxieties as she nears her due date

I'm not sure I agree that vetoing Christmas plans at this point and not wanting to go to restaurants for the duration of breastfeeding fall under the heading of 'natural and normal' anxieties. Unless they're fundamentally about wanting to avoid the in-laws, which they might well be.

Calphurnia88 · 27/05/2022 15:34

TheKeatingFive · 27/05/2022 15:02

OP isn't saying she wants to sit at home and breastfeed for 2 years (as some PP have suggested), she's saying she's overwhelmed that DH is already committing to various things including the baby, such as summer holidays.

Well the OP states quite clearly that she doesn't want to feed either in a restaurant or in front of the in-laws.

So it's logical enough to assume she doesn't want to feed publicly. I can't imagine strangers would be preferable. Or a cafe radically different to a restaurant.

Actually I feel much more comfortable BFing in front of strangers, who I know I'll never see again, than I do in front of family. I do it, but still find it slightly awkward. That's just me though.

I get your point but essentially I think OP is getting a hard time here for having very natural and normal anxieties as she nears her due date - anxieties (such as BF in public) which are probably being exacerbated by DH committing her to lots of plans, that her to consider how baby will be fed, before baby is even born.

Giraffesandbottoms · 27/05/2022 15:18

The phrase “exhibition breastfeeding” being used on here is as insulting as it is stupid. Feeding with a muslin slung over your shoulder in public/breasts covered is hardly “exhibition feeding”. And that’s what everyone I’ve ever seen has done. I think that or the vest and jumper combo or breastfeeding clothes are extremely discreet (and a lot more discreet than those massive breastfeeding aprons!)

I was extremely concerned about this, pre baby. It’s a PFB worry, to be frank. I was angry before even having the baby, at the thought that I might have to go elsewhere in my home to feed, to make FIL or otherwise comfortable. Once you have the baby things change pretty dramatically/ the first few weeks of feeding can be tricky but generally if things go well you will master it and it becomes a piece of cake (and if they don’t go well, statistically you will switch to formula and it won’t even be an issue).

do not create problems and stress for yourself when they don’t really exist (said by someone who did just that!)

FictionalCharacter · 27/05/2022 15:03

Your baby (not theirs), your choice. Don’t let them bully you into doing anything you don’t want, including letting them pass the baby round if you don’t want them to.

TheKeatingFive · 27/05/2022 15:02

OP isn't saying she wants to sit at home and breastfeed for 2 years (as some PP have suggested), she's saying she's overwhelmed that DH is already committing to various things including the baby, such as summer holidays.

Well the OP states quite clearly that she doesn't want to feed either in a restaurant or in front of the in-laws.

So it's logical enough to assume she doesn't want to feed publicly. I can't imagine strangers would be preferable. Or a cafe radically different to a restaurant.

WonderingWanda · 27/05/2022 15:01

You can do whatever you want of course but I think you will go round the bend bit if you aren't planning on attending any social events while you are breastfeeding. Especially if you are home alone all day with a newborn, that will get a bit lonely. Won't you want to go to baby groups or meet up for coffees with other new Mum's or go for walks? Surely you will have to get used to some breastfeeding away from home? How long do you plan to breastfeed?

You can buy covers, you can sneak off to the car or a quiet corner if you rrally do fel uncomfortable but once you've got the hang of it a well placed muslin is usually enough to protect your modesty. Or you could express and take bottles for the outings.

You cannot possibly know how you will feel about breastfeeding until you've done it. It's nothing like going topless on a beach or being naked in front of people.

I think it's a bit unreasonable to cancel yours and your partners lives for the forseable. However, you could say to him that it might be better to not make fixed plans for now and decide as and when for each event. I think maybe it's not about the breastfeeding but the idea that you feel his family are taking over a bit and that your dh js just agreeing without checking with you.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 27/05/2022 14:49

I don't blame you OP. I was never into exhibition breastfeeding either

Wow. The absolute ridiculousness of this comment.

I once got on a bus with DS3 in a sling. An older man commented that I could be breastfeeding and no one would ever know!

Reader, I was breastfeeding him.

If that’s ‘exhibition breastfeeding’ just because I happened to be out of my own house then so be it.

PS in 14 months of breastfeeding I never had any negative comments at all btw.

Calphurnia88 · 27/05/2022 14:49

Youseethethingis1 · 27/05/2022 14:28

Not wanting to have lots of nights away and restaurant visits and events scheduled when you will have a very new baby as a first time Mum is not the same as saying you never want to leave the house, see the family, take baby to any groups.
OP might well be up for all those things when the time comes, the point is she doesn't need the pressure and especially without prior consultation.
People are getting a little carried away in the rush to tell her how wrong she is.

I agree, it's become a bit of a hyperbolic pile-on. Which never happens on MN 🤔

OP isn't saying she wants to sit at home and breastfeed for 2 years (as some PP have suggested), she's saying she's overwhelmed that DH is already committing to various things including the baby, such as summer holidays. Which is not only understandable, but realistic given the baby hasn't even been born yet. They don't know how the birth will be, how quickly they will adjust to new life as parents, etc.

All being well they'll have a happy and contented baby that will fit in just fine at all these things... However in my case I have a colicky, nap refuser who refuses to settle ever on an evening. Short visits are a great way to introduce baby to family but a summer holiday? Would be hell.

Youseethethingis1 · 27/05/2022 14:28

Not wanting to have lots of nights away and restaurant visits and events scheduled when you will have a very new baby as a first time Mum is not the same as saying you never want to leave the house, see the family, take baby to any groups.
OP might well be up for all those things when the time comes, the point is she doesn't need the pressure and especially without prior consultation.
People are getting a little carried away in the rush to tell her how wrong she is.

TheKeatingFive · 27/05/2022 14:24

I don't blame you OP. I was never into exhibition breastfeeding either

ffs what an appalling misogynistic comment, wanting to leave your own house isn't 'exhibition breastfeeding' 🙄

Imagine how much hostility you must feel to new mothers to come out with such bollocks.

SickAndTiredAgain · 27/05/2022 14:10

I don't blame you OP. I was never into exhibition breastfeeding either

What is exhibition breastfeeding? No one is expecting anyone to breastfeed while tap dancing on a stage with nipple tassels on the other breast.

luckylavender · 27/05/2022 13:10

Shoxfordian · 27/05/2022 08:32

It does sound like you’re being unreasonable to me; you can feed the baby before or after a restaurant meal out for example or you can go to a different room in a house to breastfeed. Sounds like you just don’t want to do any of these things

Not all babies can be fed to your schedule. That's not how it works.