Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you're infertile how would you want friend to tell you they're pregnant?

132 replies

whatnextsteps · 27/05/2022 06:35

As the title asks, would you prefer to be told privately or in group setting?

A year and a half ago my best friend was told she can't have children and going through early menopause due to medical reasons/procedures. I know she still has down days about this but tries to hide it from our friend group as she found a support group of women who have gone through or going through similar as her.

I know she'll be happy for me and be an involved honorary auntie but don't know whether to tell her privately before group announcement so she could deal with any emotions as I'm the first of our group to be having a baby.

TIA for your advise

OP posts:
whatnextsteps · 27/05/2022 14:22

To make it clear the meet up was not arranged for me to tell my friends, it was already arranged before I found out I'm pregnant.

Different groups do things different ways, my friends would prefer to be told in person over text.

Thank you for all who gave their experiences from both sides, I will have a good think on what way would work best for my friend and may use some suggestions on how to phrase it.

OP posts:
SleeplessInEngland · 27/05/2022 14:20

You don't need to do a group text at all. Just text/call whoever you care about knowing inidivudually. It can't be that many people.

maddy68 · 27/05/2022 14:14

I don't think it matters as such. If they tip toe around it it's embarrassing and makes it seem like more of a problem. It's going to bring up feelings whichever way

PurpleDaisies · 27/05/2022 14:13

Totally agree with your post @breatheintheamazing

It gets harder and harder as more friends have kids and you’re the only one left. I’ve found it’s now getting a bit easier as my friends’ children are older and able to be left so meet ups don’t always have to have kids there. It’s bloody hard.

breatheintheamazing · 27/05/2022 13:42

whatnextsteps · 27/05/2022 07:20

Thank you for all your advise.

To those saying not to assume she'll want to be an honorary auntie, I know she will, I can't explain how I do I just do.

No you really dont

You know her now - currently on a level playing field if none of you have kids yet - dynamics will change massively once her friends start getting pregnant. No matter how "together" she is at the moment when babies are just a theoretical possibility in the future is totally different to actually being faced with one and her feelings may change

birdglasspen · 27/05/2022 12:58

You must realise a group announcement is not great. Just tell her privately and let her process it.

Abouttimemum · 27/05/2022 12:12

No I’d text them all individually, or phone them. I don’t see why you need to meet up with your mates to tell them you’re preggers tbh. Especially given it’ll be a knife in the heart of one of your friends. In those circs I’d rather that next time we all meet up, everyone just already knew, so that it takes the stress out of it for her.

Johnnypiratesfriend · 27/05/2022 12:08

I found out I couldn't have children and cried on my friends shoulder. My poor friend had just found out she was pregnant but not telling anyone. A few weeks later when she was about to tell people she had a discrete word with my husband who broke it too me kindly.

Merryclaire · 27/05/2022 11:59

Yeah - but I do wonder whether the big group announcement could be problematic if there could be others with issues that have chosen not to share, and it might also put your friend in an awkward position feeling like she’s been tiptoed around. I know you shouldn’t have to pre-empt these things but big group announcements don’t always go as well as imagined. I’d consider telling everyone first and then just celebrate together in person. But you know your friends, so it’s your choice.

We told everyone we were expecting on an individual basis. However, there was a tragedy in our SIL’s family when we were in the early stages, so we took the decision to delay telling that side of the family (except DH’s parents) until 20 weeks, and handled it as sensitively as we could when the time came as we didn’t want to add to their pain and make them feel they had to put on a happy face.

It’s hard to know what to do in these situations but erring on the side of caution is likely to do the least harm. It doesn’t stop you from celebrating and being happy - it’s just how you share the news really.

Whatsonmymindgrapes · 27/05/2022 11:42

Text her so she can react in her own way. Congratulations

PurpleDaisies · 27/05/2022 11:40

As for the group announcement, does no-one else give big news when all their friends are together?

No, it goes on our WhatsApp group. We’d celebrate in person together.

whatnextsteps · 27/05/2022 11:24

I think a lot of you have jumped on my honorary auntie comment, of course I do not expect it and don't expect her to take on her role because she can't have her own children. She is one of my oldest and closest friends, I'm not sure how to explain myself correctly. Of course I'd give her any space she needs.

As for the group announcement, does no-one else give big news when all their friends are together? It'd take weeks for me to meet up individually with everyone to tell them, and there's only about 6 of us in the group I want to tell in person! We've always tried to tell everyone at same time and it just happens we'll all be meeting up a few times between now and October

OP posts:
NC1010 · 27/05/2022 10:55

I've been infertile and had to go through vigorous IVF to get my DD.

I always hated people messaging me first, walking on eggshells around me, not telling me things and not involving me. That was the worst as it then in turn made me feel like I wasn't good enough for the group because nobody thought I could handle the news.

It's the opposite to me, I loved being involved, finding out the news at the same time as everybody else. People who struggle to conceive are going to have people in their life having babies. People going through divorce are going to be surrounded by married couples. Someone who has lost their job is going to be around people who have just got a new job or promotion. As awful as it is, life goes on.

Just tread carefully with your friend, you know her best and only you can know the best way to do this. But all I'm trying to say is eggshells and private messages isn't always the best way.

WimbyAce · 27/05/2022 10:41

I would also say privately text as then she doesn't have to fake a smiley face and can gather her thoughts before she sees you.

watcherintherye · 27/05/2022 10:35

Would this be any good?

‘Hi X. Hope all is well with you. Recently found out I’m pregnant, due in xxxx. Haven’t told the others, yet, so will probably do it in the group. Look forward to seeing you when we next meet up. Lots of love’

notafanofsweetandsour · 27/05/2022 10:16

Mum2One23 · 27/05/2022 09:56

I would keep the group chat free of any baby talk so it doesn’t become a place where she feels excluded and uncomfortable and ends up leaving

I disagree with that. And I say that as the childless one in my friendship group. Children is a big part of peoples lives. Yes be sensitive, don't make every conversation about the baby, but I'd be horrified if my friends felt that they couldn't talk about their exciting time in front of me.

I have very good friends who I can get upset in front of about my infertility, and they can vent their frustrations to me about the difficulties they have being a parent, we support each other. How can friendship work if one half is on eggshells? Being sensitive to each other doesn't mean avoiding the conversation.

AfterGlow87 · 27/05/2022 10:12

As others have said, a text I feel is the best choice, before any ‘group announcements’ (which I personally cannot stand - what’s wrong with telling people individually)

Also please don’t assume to think your friend will want to be involved - unless you have experienced infertility you have really no idea of how she will be feeling. I went through years of announcements and while I was happy for my friends and family, I was absolutely crushed and heartbroken for myself.

There was a time when I could bear to be around friends with babies. Luckily IVF was successful in the end for me but I’ll never forget those feelings and it has made me very aware of others

TenoringBehind · 27/05/2022 10:02

Going against the grain here but I’d say not text or email. I still remember the pain I felt when my SIL did that that years ago (I’ve since been lucky enough to have children, against all odds). The kindest thing is in person but one to one.

HopingForMyRainbowBaby · 27/05/2022 09:58

Definitely text. I've had 2 incidents where I've found out in person and it was awful trying to congratulate someone whilst forcing myself not to cry. The first time was my ex SIL and I found out during a family meal. ExH had conveniently forgotten to tell me. Couldn't eat anything afterwards. Second time was after 15 years of infertility now on medication, had lost 4 stone in weight and with a new BF I fell Pregnant but miscarried xmas day. Someone I work with was Pregnant found out when she was sick. she told me not to worry cos I couldn't catch morning sickness. Another trying to congratulate someone whilst fighting back the tears. I did fall Pregnant again a few weeks later but again went onto miscarry.

Mum2One23 · 27/05/2022 09:56

I would keep the group chat free of any baby talk so it doesn’t become a place where she feels excluded and uncomfortable and ends up leaving

CurbsideProphet · 27/05/2022 09:48

By text. Always by text. There are so many threads about this and the majority is always for a text to allow for a private reaction. I'm now pregnant through IVF and unfortunately may never lose the feeling that everyone else can just have their baby whenever they wanted, while we have to go through such heartbreak and trauma.

As an aside, I've never known any friend to make a public face to face announcement of pregnancy. It's always been by WhatsApp / text. Perhaps with us being a group of mixed ages we've always been sensitive to the fact that some may be happy for their friend, but sad for their own circumstances.

Chubarubrub · 27/05/2022 09:36

Hunkydory99 · 27/05/2022 09:25

I’d also think twice about a big announcement. You don’t know how many others in the group may be struggling or had losses. My husband and I never shared our struggles, we discussed it at length and agreed it was between us. Group announcements were like a knife to my heart, there was a phase where it felt like every ‘event’ someone was making an announcement, I ended up with really bad anxiety. We now have two beautiful children but there was never any guarantee we would.

@Hunkydory99 yes every announcement was, and still is, a knife to the heart.

notafanofsweetandsour · 27/05/2022 09:34

Text is fine. Try and do it when you know she'll be at home. I can't have children and I've had lovely sensitive announcements from friends and a really insensitive one. The sensitive ones are generally along the lines of

"hi, I have some news and I wanted to let you know before I tell everyone so that you're not caught off guard, I'm pregnant, due in December. Obviously we're excited but I know this news may make you emotional and so I wanted you to know first xx" then obviously I sat and cried (because I wanted it to be me, however still happy for them) then replied thank you for being so considerate and told them how happy I was for them.

Worst message I received after my 6th miscarriage (which friend.. now ex friend) knew about - "got a surprise! Had a little accident am pregnant again!" Announcing their third. Completely insensitive.

Lanawashington · 27/05/2022 09:32

Definitely a text message. Not what my friends did, I knew nothing until I just received a Facebook event invite to her baby shower

Hunkydory99 · 27/05/2022 09:25

I’d also think twice about a big announcement. You don’t know how many others in the group may be struggling or had losses. My husband and I never shared our struggles, we discussed it at length and agreed it was between us. Group announcements were like a knife to my heart, there was a phase where it felt like every ‘event’ someone was making an announcement, I ended up with really bad anxiety. We now have two beautiful children but there was never any guarantee we would.