Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Every household?????

638 replies

Trainfromredhill · 26/05/2022 22:33

So, the chancellor is going to give every household £400 for heating. Surely there should be a cut off of household income? The Beckhams, Elton John, james Dyson, Harry styles…….they all get the money too? . I say this as someone in the fortunate position of not needing the £400- I’d much rather it went to someone who does need it.Just seems a huge waste of public money to give it to everyone

OP posts:
110APiccadilly · 28/05/2022 06:47

Alexandra2001 · 28/05/2022 06:40

As said, that doesn't seem to apply to Child Benefit.... or a host of other benefits.

Would be better to give £400 extra to the poor than £400 to everyone.

Just been listening to another maternity scandal (Nottingham) interim report puts the number one reason as lack of staff, training and 10 years of cuts... if there is spare money hanging around, lets use it to recruit midwives... not give it to folk who don't need it.

The cost-benefit (no pun intended) calculation would be different for something like child benefit though as it's a regular payment, not a one-off. Though as I understand it, they've put most of the admin burden of the child benefit stuff on those claiming it as you have to do tax returns now if you're over the threshold. (That's my understanding, I am not in a position to have personal experience!)

I'm not sure why I'm defending this, as I think it's a stupid policy overall, but this one aspect of it is probably not as much of a waste of money as you'd think.

gamerchick · 28/05/2022 06:46

This reply has been deleted

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

I know right Grin

the bracket that just misses out is those who earn just over the threshold for UC. Not those on 100k. I'll bet if those struggling on 100k posted a breakdown, there would be savings to be made that most of us would spot.

Alexandra2001 · 28/05/2022 06:40

Hearwego · 27/05/2022 21:52

From the government’s perspective it’s probably too complicated to means test the payments. So easier to give it to everyone.
Higher earners pay lots in income tax anyway, effectively going back into the coffers.

As said, that doesn't seem to apply to Child Benefit.... or a host of other benefits.

Would be better to give £400 extra to the poor than £400 to everyone.

Just been listening to another maternity scandal (Nottingham) interim report puts the number one reason as lack of staff, training and 10 years of cuts... if there is spare money hanging around, lets use it to recruit midwives... not give it to folk who don't need it.

Murdoch1949 · 28/05/2022 00:59

It is cheaper to give it to everyone than means test it.

Hearwego · 27/05/2022 21:52

From the government’s perspective it’s probably too complicated to means test the payments. So easier to give it to everyone.
Higher earners pay lots in income tax anyway, effectively going back into the coffers.

PronounMadness · 27/05/2022 21:51

bbqhulahoop · 26/05/2022 22:37

YANBU, but the people you've referenced either vote Tory or don't vote 🤦🏼‍♀️ I def won't be voting for them either way. Wish yuu could defer your payment to nhs/ education etc

Ours is all going to the local food bank.

strawberriesarenot · 27/05/2022 21:50

My MP has seven houses...

lonelyapple · 27/05/2022 21:46

High income households already pay shit loads of tax and NI, why shouldn't they get something back from this.

SlowHorses · 27/05/2022 21:45

If Mr Sunak’s family liquidated their wealth they could afford to give nearly half the UK population £25 each.

I think he should do that. That Rees Mogg Cat fella can chip in too and round it up to £50.

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 27/05/2022 21:44

Hearwego · 27/05/2022 21:40

Wasn’t it Thatcher who said something like the problem with socialism is eventually you run out of money ?
I do worry about the country’s borrowing debt. It will have to be repaid.

But I understand we’re in unprecedented times. And it’s better to help people now rather than let people run into massive debt where they would cost the tax payer even more money.

Typical Boris government. They say they won’t do something ( in this case tax the fuel companies) and then weeks later they go ahead with it.

I also feel this is a diversion tactic, from party gate. I’m sure Boris was on the phone to Rishi telling him to go ahead with the increased payments just as Boris was about to land in even more hot water.

The quote was, I think, that you always run out of other people’s money.

Hearwego · 27/05/2022 21:40

Wasn’t it Thatcher who said something like the problem with socialism is eventually you run out of money ?
I do worry about the country’s borrowing debt. It will have to be repaid.

But I understand we’re in unprecedented times. And it’s better to help people now rather than let people run into massive debt where they would cost the tax payer even more money.

Typical Boris government. They say they won’t do something ( in this case tax the fuel companies) and then weeks later they go ahead with it.

I also feel this is a diversion tactic, from party gate. I’m sure Boris was on the phone to Rishi telling him to go ahead with the increased payments just as Boris was about to land in even more hot water.

ParsleyRosemarySage · 27/05/2022 19:14

Sortilege · 27/05/2022 02:23

The £400 universal payment is essentially a rebate applied to each domestic fuel account. So for tenanted properties, where the tenant is the bill payer, the tenant gets the rebate.

Untenanted properties and second homes are the issue.

I have a question about the admin for this, how it’s being done. Is the above poster correct about how the rebate is going to be distributed?

If so, what about tenanted properties where the tenant does NOT pay the bill directly, either because bills are included - I could see landlords putting up the cost and pocketing the rebate - or because the property is on a meter with the landlord acting as a middleman? Where the landlord pays the bills, but has a meter installed so they can up the price? Are these situations not legal any more, and are they still happening anyway?

I am guessing that people in government don’t know and don’t care to know about all eventualities, and there will be circumstances where rich unscrupulous landlords gain and poor tenants lose out. (I can’t think where I get the cynical idea that government policies haven’t been fully planned out, but there we are.)

ReginaGeorgeismyname · 27/05/2022 18:29

I've been working all day so ended up dipping out of this thread. It's taken an interesting turn...Lots of muddling up between household incomes and individual salaries. I can see why an individual on £100k might be considered 'rich'. But a household income of £100k is NOT rich! Particularly if you have preschool aged children. Clearly this household is not poverty stricken, but let's not pretend £400 makes no difference to such families.

MarshaBradyo · 27/05/2022 18:09

BobbyeinArkansas · 27/05/2022 17:55

this seems like a very socialist measure, rather than a Conservative. Don’t think this is why people vote Tory. Just cut tax or reverse the ridiculous NI increase.

Windfall taxing the corporation doesn’t help investment in the long run either.

What if there’s a big discount for investment?

BobbyeinArkansas · 27/05/2022 17:55

this seems like a very socialist measure, rather than a Conservative. Don’t think this is why people vote Tory. Just cut tax or reverse the ridiculous NI increase.

Windfall taxing the corporation doesn’t help investment in the long run either.

rainingsnoring · 27/05/2022 17:48

Pippainthegarden · 27/05/2022 17:00

You don’t seem to understand that there are so many people who fall between the gaps, we are financially worse off than if we were in difference circumstances but on universal credit due to being a blended family. Other people are in that situation because they are students, all manner of reasons. So sorry if we’re actually glad we’re actually eligible for some help for once! They’ll be plenty of people like us and plenty of people who earn just above the threshold etc and sorry to you to if it perhaps makes them not feel like why do they bother. Those below the threshold are getting significantly more so it’s not the case the help isn’t being targeted

Of course it's obvious that some people are just above the threshold for benefits although you have said above that you are on UC anyway. That's always the case and those people will always feel hard done by.
I didn't say you shouldn't be pleased anywhere, it's human nature to be pleased by a giveaway. The government is aware of that and they are playing on that. The public is constantly played and most people seem unaware of it.
I'm not sure you have read or understood any of the other points made elsewhere on the thread about the disadvantages of the scheme and the problems it may cause now and in the future.

Pippainthegarden · 27/05/2022 17:00

rainingsnoring · 27/05/2022 16:50

There are other ways to help people though that would have been preferable. A windfall tax and a universal payout isn't essential and has many negatives other than the one you have mentioned. It would have been better, for example, to uplift UC again by £20/ week as during the pandemic but they don't want to do that. They want to throw money at everyone, notably the older and better off people who vote for them. Some people can see this (I think you mentioned it earlier) but others don't. Why is it that the government can't come up with better, fairer ideas rather than expecting individuals to be generous and donate what they don't need. Most people won't do this; only a tiny number of pensioners opted out of the Winter fuel allowance, for example. Society in general is far more selfish and focused on the individual and their immediate family nowadays so it's not surprising.

You don’t seem to understand that there are so many people who fall between the gaps, we are financially worse off than if we were in difference circumstances but on universal credit due to being a blended family. Other people are in that situation because they are students, all manner of reasons. So sorry if we’re actually glad we’re actually eligible for some help for once! They’ll be plenty of people like us and plenty of people who earn just above the threshold etc and sorry to you to if it perhaps makes them not feel like why do they bother. Those below the threshold are getting significantly more so it’s not the case the help isn’t being targeted

Nellodee · 27/05/2022 16:57

We shouldn't be putting a windfall tax on energy companies - we should be suing the bloody arse off of them for knowingly destroying the climate. Then we should be investing that money into renewables. People say, but there is a storage issue, we would still need nuclear, etc etc.

But we all saw how globally we were able to produce a vaccine in record time because it was needed, and we know far more can be done than is being done now.

With the right will, we could wean ourselves off dirty energy completely in five years. It would create huge amounts of jobs and kickstart the economy. Why are we just in reaction mode? Why don't we aim for a New Deal, rather than Hooverville?

Pippainthegarden · 27/05/2022 16:51

Rosscameasdoody · 27/05/2022 16:26

Many people seem to be having a problem with the £400 energy rebate being universal. Those people on means tested benefits, and also some disability benefits are being targeted for extra help via the benefits system, and I think those who object to the £400 might get their heads round it a bit better if they accept that the benefit system is not the best way to target the most in need. Means testing thresholds and tapers are set very low and some households who struggle miss them by only a couple of pounds and lose out on a lot of help as a result. The universal £400 rebate will catch these people who would otherwise have missed out, and they will get at least some help. OK, so it will also be paid to some who don’t need it, but those people are perfectly free to donate £400 to charity or a food bank when their rebate is applied - thereby redistributing the help to those who most need it.

Exactly, it so annoys me that people gloat on about how they wouldn’t need it, what exactly is it that’s annoys people about the fact that my family isn’t going to starve if we don’t get it but it would enable us to pay for swimming lessons for little one etc. Is it the fact they don’t realise that’s the case for a lot of families receiving it or do they not realise wealth exists on a wide spectrum and can only see themselves who £400 is small change and those on benefits? Alternatively is it that they think this money shouldn’t be to help compensate for the cost of living rises that have meant swimming lessons had to be given up and those kind of things?

rainingsnoring · 27/05/2022 16:50

Rosscameasdoody · 27/05/2022 16:26

Many people seem to be having a problem with the £400 energy rebate being universal. Those people on means tested benefits, and also some disability benefits are being targeted for extra help via the benefits system, and I think those who object to the £400 might get their heads round it a bit better if they accept that the benefit system is not the best way to target the most in need. Means testing thresholds and tapers are set very low and some households who struggle miss them by only a couple of pounds and lose out on a lot of help as a result. The universal £400 rebate will catch these people who would otherwise have missed out, and they will get at least some help. OK, so it will also be paid to some who don’t need it, but those people are perfectly free to donate £400 to charity or a food bank when their rebate is applied - thereby redistributing the help to those who most need it.

There are other ways to help people though that would have been preferable. A windfall tax and a universal payout isn't essential and has many negatives other than the one you have mentioned. It would have been better, for example, to uplift UC again by £20/ week as during the pandemic but they don't want to do that. They want to throw money at everyone, notably the older and better off people who vote for them. Some people can see this (I think you mentioned it earlier) but others don't. Why is it that the government can't come up with better, fairer ideas rather than expecting individuals to be generous and donate what they don't need. Most people won't do this; only a tiny number of pensioners opted out of the Winter fuel allowance, for example. Society in general is far more selfish and focused on the individual and their immediate family nowadays so it's not surprising.

Rosscameasdoody · 27/05/2022 16:26

Many people seem to be having a problem with the £400 energy rebate being universal. Those people on means tested benefits, and also some disability benefits are being targeted for extra help via the benefits system, and I think those who object to the £400 might get their heads round it a bit better if they accept that the benefit system is not the best way to target the most in need. Means testing thresholds and tapers are set very low and some households who struggle miss them by only a couple of pounds and lose out on a lot of help as a result. The universal £400 rebate will catch these people who would otherwise have missed out, and they will get at least some help. OK, so it will also be paid to some who don’t need it, but those people are perfectly free to donate £400 to charity or a food bank when their rebate is applied - thereby redistributing the help to those who most need it.

Mrsmch123 · 27/05/2022 16:11

Do I "need" the £400...:well no. But it's certainly nice to have it🤷🏻‍♀️

Summerstink · 27/05/2022 15:58

balalake · 27/05/2022 15:33

@Summerstink if we had remained in the EU, Boris Johnson would not be Prime Minister, Rishi Sunak probably not chancellor.

True. I was thinking more along the lines of comparison with the energy price situation in other comparable EU countries, having accepted the fact we have a Johnson/ Sunak in charge.

Although the alternative reality of a different leader all this time is intriguing to think on.

DogInATent · 27/05/2022 15:57

balalake · 27/05/2022 15:33

@Summerstink if we had remained in the EU, Boris Johnson would not be Prime Minister, Rishi Sunak probably not chancellor.

Three wins for the price of one...

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 27/05/2022 15:35

Topgub · 27/05/2022 11:20

@MarshaBradyo

Linked wages

Reduce tax evasion/avoidance

Reintroduce previous energy cap

Introduce rent caps

Do something about house prices but not sure what

Rent caps reduce the availability of rented homes.

We stopped renting one of our homes out last year because of the changes in how mortgage interest could offset income. A rent cap on top would see us empty another one, as it just wouldn’t make sense to rent out.