Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Every household?????

638 replies

Trainfromredhill · 26/05/2022 22:33

So, the chancellor is going to give every household £400 for heating. Surely there should be a cut off of household income? The Beckhams, Elton John, james Dyson, Harry styles…….they all get the money too? . I say this as someone in the fortunate position of not needing the £400- I’d much rather it went to someone who does need it.Just seems a huge waste of public money to give it to everyone

OP posts:
Babyroobs · 28/05/2022 11:42

I also think it's hugely unfair for example that a 19 year old just out of school looking for work, claiming UC living with parents will get £650 handed to them wheras others on low pay apprenticeships who don't qualify for UC and probably have travel costs etc won't get anything. My ds gets low pay for his apprenticeship, puts in a 40 hour week and has to travel 60 odd miles to another city a couple of times a week wheras another 20 year old on UC will get this £650 !!

Pippainthegarden · 28/05/2022 11:38

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 28/05/2022 11:18

"We will give everyone £200 that they will repay over four years"

Response "but what about the poor? Sad for them"

"OK, we will double it and not ask for it back"

Response "but what about the super rich? They don't deserve it"

Can't do fucking nowt right.

Exactly, the response of some people to this is ridiculous. A very small minority do people are that rich that it wouldn’t make a difference to them. What I can’t understand is that it’s apparently so wrong we now have enough for our dc to do swimming lessons because of this £400 but shouldn’t get it as not starving, however it was fine all our taxes went on funding all that furlough at 80% so people could maintain their lifestyles?

Mrsmch123 · 28/05/2022 11:30

@Cornettoninja i don't need the £400 at all but I have more than enough. I will take the £400 out of my savings and put it into my babies saving pot as it was money we didn't have so will put it away for him for the future. Nice to have it tho😁

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 28/05/2022 11:18

"We will give everyone £200 that they will repay over four years"

Response "but what about the poor? Sad for them"

"OK, we will double it and not ask for it back"

Response "but what about the super rich? They don't deserve it"

Can't do fucking nowt right.

Mamai90 · 28/05/2022 10:52

You also made choices - a choice to do a lower paid job / not train / have children earlier, and presumably you also have a choice whether to accept the benefits that higher tax payers top up.

Alright Molly-Mae 🙄

Pippainthegarden · 28/05/2022 10:46

Cornettoninja · 28/05/2022 09:40

That’s not what not qualifying for various benefits is though, you’re actually being told ‘you’ve got enough’. Subtle difference.

Whether the threshold for ‘enough’ is right is debatable but in a country where some people have very little and no way to increase that, if you’re just managing you objectively have enough.

The criteria are a very crude threshold though, you can own a 600k house and have a fantastic pension but still be eligible for universal credit or could be a young family with 4 children on 32k and a high mortgage or even renting and trying to save up for a deposit on a house and not entitled to anything. I’ve been in the benefits and just getting by boats and the animosity I see on here towards people on UC saddens me but assuming that anyone not on UC is well off or isn’t true either and I can understand their view that for all the extra effort they often really aren't that much better off then people on benefits and nice they are considered once in a while. Personally I feel the balance of help is about right and taking the £400 off the just getting by families to give £1600 rather than ‘just’ £1200 to those on benefits would cause a lot of understandable resentment

Cornettoninja · 28/05/2022 09:40

Mrsmch123 · 28/05/2022 09:03

its about time people who earn more get a little something back for sure!im sick of being told I "earn to much".

That’s not what not qualifying for various benefits is though, you’re actually being told ‘you’ve got enough’. Subtle difference.

Whether the threshold for ‘enough’ is right is debatable but in a country where some people have very little and no way to increase that, if you’re just managing you objectively have enough.

Pippainthegarden · 28/05/2022 09:37

Spidey66 · 28/05/2022 09:24

Alan Sugar got a Winter Fuel payment on account of him being a pensioner. Initially he did a "Do you know who I am? '' statement and asked for it to go to someone who, you know, couldn't afford their heating bills, but the powers that be insisted he take it. He ended up taking it but gave it to charity.

Why on earth do these people need to make a song and dance about being given this help, one reason only .. to tell everyone they are above charity and to tell everyone they are insulted even of the mere taint of them receiving it. Even though they know this is administratively the most efficient and cheapest way of ensuring everyone gets the help needed. They know full well they could just quietly donate it to charity. They’ll happily minimise their tax bill though and ensure they’re paying a minuscule proportion compared to those middle earners for whom this £400 will make a difference

Spidey66 · 28/05/2022 09:24

Alan Sugar got a Winter Fuel payment on account of him being a pensioner. Initially he did a "Do you know who I am? '' statement and asked for it to go to someone who, you know, couldn't afford their heating bills, but the powers that be insisted he take it. He ended up taking it but gave it to charity.

VanGoghsDog · 28/05/2022 09:17

cptartapp · 28/05/2022 07:37

What about those with oil fired heating? That's a far far bigger expense than our electric.

Use the £400 to reduce your electricity bill, which is where it will land, and ask the company for a two month payment holiday, use the retained money for the oil.

More of a worry for people off grid, because they won't get it at all.

Mrsmch123 · 28/05/2022 09:03

its about time people who earn more get a little something back for sure!im sick of being told I "earn to much".

ReginaGeorgeismyname · 28/05/2022 08:55

*if they are NOT spending then jobs will go I meant!

ReginaGeorgeismyname · 28/05/2022 08:54

110APiccadilly · 28/05/2022 07:04

There's of course a huge difference between a household with two earners on £50K each and one with one earner on £100K. (Or two earners with a much less even split.) One of those households gets much more take-home pay, and is still eligible for child benefit. That's probably why it's easier to talk about individual salaries.

But I'm afraid I do find it hard to agree that a household on £100K, even in the situation that's worst for them in terms of tax, etc, is all that hard up. Admittedly we live in a lower cost of living area, but we have a household income less than half of that (gross, and one of us out-earns the other fairly significantly, so the tax system is not our friend). We don't feel badly off. We do cut our coat according to our cloth, but DD has swimming classes, we have the odd takeaway, we donate monthly to the foodbank, we can deal with unexpected needs to fix things, we can cope with me (I'm the higher earner) going on maternity for a year (admittedly on good Ts and C's) etc.

In contrast, I know people who really struggle if, for instance, a washing machine breaks. Because they just don't have the money to replace it, even with a cheap one.

Yes I agree. I never said household income of 100k is hard up. I said the opposite...they are not poverty stricken.

But £400 will make some difference to these households..even if its just boosting disposable income..which is good as that will stimulate spending elsewhere in the economy. As I said before upthread the middle need to not be too tightly squeezed - the middle need to be able to spend to keep those in industries like beauty and hospitality in work. If they are spending then jobs will go

Pippainthegarden · 28/05/2022 08:51

Alexandra2001 · 28/05/2022 07:02

@110APiccadilly Yes the admin is put onto the claimant but thats because its a taper payment.
This £400 is in two payments & is likely to have to be paid for many years to come as energy is only going to go one way, no one will be dealing with Russia however the war goes.

I was down at our local yesterday, many wealthier people were incredulous about this payment (i'm talking about people on say 40 or 50k p.a) they don't need it and for those that do but aren't on UC, £400 is no where near enough to help.

the Govt is also means testing much of the other help they are giving on energy....we aren't all getting £1250 are we? so the "its too expensive...." argument seems a bit off.

Are these people whose kids have grown up and they’ve paid off their mortgages?? They are just showing off and know full well there is nothing to stop them donating the money if it doesn’t make a difference to them. Most young families without a 40-50k household income with 3-4 children who have bought their house recently (without a huge deposit) would say this £400 very much makes a difference to them and feel grateful they’ve actually been considered

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 28/05/2022 08:04

SlowHorses · 28/05/2022 07:52

Sense of humour fail @SlightlyGeordieJohn? It’s called being ironic. I earn quite enough thanks but well done for being another aggressive oblivious MN poster who thinks if everyone just worked a bit harder they’d get everything they desire in life.

Ah, straight to the insults when someone disagrees with you. How novel.

SlowHorses · 28/05/2022 07:52

Sense of humour fail @SlightlyGeordieJohn? It’s called being ironic. I earn quite enough thanks but well done for being another aggressive oblivious MN poster who thinks if everyone just worked a bit harder they’d get everything they desire in life.

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 28/05/2022 07:48

SlowHorses · 27/05/2022 21:45

If Mr Sunak’s family liquidated their wealth they could afford to give nearly half the UK population £25 each.

I think he should do that. That Rees Mogg Cat fella can chip in too and round it up to £50.

Why would he possibly do that? If you want more money why not do something about it yourself?

cptartapp · 28/05/2022 07:37

What about those with oil fired heating? That's a far far bigger expense than our electric.

cptartapp · 28/05/2022 07:36

Crazy idea.
Just like handing out millions to wealthy pensioners year after year with the winter fuel allowance.
How come child benefit isn't given out similarly? They seem able to 'means test' that easily enough?

110APiccadilly · 28/05/2022 07:16

Alexandra2001 · 28/05/2022 07:02

@110APiccadilly Yes the admin is put onto the claimant but thats because its a taper payment.
This £400 is in two payments & is likely to have to be paid for many years to come as energy is only going to go one way, no one will be dealing with Russia however the war goes.

I was down at our local yesterday, many wealthier people were incredulous about this payment (i'm talking about people on say 40 or 50k p.a) they don't need it and for those that do but aren't on UC, £400 is no where near enough to help.

the Govt is also means testing much of the other help they are giving on energy....we aren't all getting £1250 are we? so the "its too expensive...." argument seems a bit off.

I have to say, I was assuming it was a one-off. It really would be crazy to keep giving it to people who don't need it. I hope you're wrong on that.

I think the means testing for the other parts is very much a blunt instrument - you get it if you get certain qualifying benefits. That's probably not too expensive to administer, but it does mean it risks the cliff edge effect for those who earn just too much.

letsnotdothat · 28/05/2022 07:06

Probably costs more to figure out who needs it and who doesn’t do they’ve just decided to give it to everyone. It’s money from the gas companies anyway so basically giving them it back.

110APiccadilly · 28/05/2022 07:04

ReginaGeorgeismyname · 27/05/2022 18:29

I've been working all day so ended up dipping out of this thread. It's taken an interesting turn...Lots of muddling up between household incomes and individual salaries. I can see why an individual on £100k might be considered 'rich'. But a household income of £100k is NOT rich! Particularly if you have preschool aged children. Clearly this household is not poverty stricken, but let's not pretend £400 makes no difference to such families.

There's of course a huge difference between a household with two earners on £50K each and one with one earner on £100K. (Or two earners with a much less even split.) One of those households gets much more take-home pay, and is still eligible for child benefit. That's probably why it's easier to talk about individual salaries.

But I'm afraid I do find it hard to agree that a household on £100K, even in the situation that's worst for them in terms of tax, etc, is all that hard up. Admittedly we live in a lower cost of living area, but we have a household income less than half of that (gross, and one of us out-earns the other fairly significantly, so the tax system is not our friend). We don't feel badly off. We do cut our coat according to our cloth, but DD has swimming classes, we have the odd takeaway, we donate monthly to the foodbank, we can deal with unexpected needs to fix things, we can cope with me (I'm the higher earner) going on maternity for a year (admittedly on good Ts and C's) etc.

In contrast, I know people who really struggle if, for instance, a washing machine breaks. Because they just don't have the money to replace it, even with a cheap one.

Alexandra2001 · 28/05/2022 07:02

@110APiccadilly Yes the admin is put onto the claimant but thats because its a taper payment.
This £400 is in two payments & is likely to have to be paid for many years to come as energy is only going to go one way, no one will be dealing with Russia however the war goes.

I was down at our local yesterday, many wealthier people were incredulous about this payment (i'm talking about people on say 40 or 50k p.a) they don't need it and for those that do but aren't on UC, £400 is no where near enough to help.

the Govt is also means testing much of the other help they are giving on energy....we aren't all getting £1250 are we? so the "its too expensive...." argument seems a bit off.

HappyHappyHermit · 28/05/2022 06:51

@Alexandra2001 Child benefit is notoriously unfair though as a one person working household starts to lose it at 50k, a two person working household can earn up to 99ishk before that happens. I am grateful that this is for every one, we are ok on paper but have obligations and yes we will and have made cut backs but this will really help at the moment. Perhaps it should just be possible to opt out if you know you don't need it.

gamerchick · 28/05/2022 06:48

PronounMadness · 27/05/2022 21:51

Ours is all going to the local food bank.

Why do I keep seeing this stuff? Nobody is getting the 400 quid in cash. It's going straight to your energy supplier to knock it off your bill.