Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Every household?????

638 replies

Trainfromredhill · 26/05/2022 22:33

So, the chancellor is going to give every household £400 for heating. Surely there should be a cut off of household income? The Beckhams, Elton John, james Dyson, Harry styles…….they all get the money too? . I say this as someone in the fortunate position of not needing the £400- I’d much rather it went to someone who does need it.Just seems a huge waste of public money to give it to everyone

OP posts:
user1472151176 · 28/05/2022 18:44

Something that I have become aware of is:
A married couple as a household earns £65,000 per year. One of them earns £51,000 and the other earns £14,000 - no benefits at all and have just had child benefit removed as one earns over the threshold.
Another married couple earns as a household £98,000 per year. They each earn £49,000 and under the threshold. No benefits but still have the child benefit.
That's a difference of £33,000!!! The system is unfair and seriously needs to be addressed

PeachyPeachTrees · 28/05/2022 18:43

We don't need it either but we will just spend a bit more and spending is good for the economy.

Lincslady53 · 28/05/2022 18:23

bbqhulahoop · 26/05/2022 22:37

YANBU, but the people you've referenced either vote Tory or don't vote 🤦🏼‍♀️ I def won't be voting for them either way. Wish yuu could defer your payment to nhs/ education etc

You can donate it to whoever you like. Please let us know who you be donating yours to.

BouleBaker · 28/05/2022 17:53

DH works for a utility company and sets up the systems for these kinds of payments, The utility companies have no idea how much you earn, but they can very easily set up a system that credits every household with £400. Administering any kind of means test would cost a bloody fortune, and does for those benefits that are means tested.

rainingsnoring · 28/05/2022 16:52

Rosscameasdoody · 28/05/2022 15:39

This point was discussed on a similar thread. I believe these plans were drawn up as soon as it became clear that the first plan wouldn’t fly, and delayed until they knew what was in the Gray report. The announcement came the same day as the publication of the Gray report to divert attention. It’s a cynical attempt to bribe us all in the hope that we’ll forget all the crap that’s gone down come the general election.

The way in which the disabled and other benefit recipients have been treated by successive Tory governments pretty much tells you that they have no time for those they perceive as being bottom of the pile, and yet now they’re throwing money at us - it’s almost like they’ve suddenly developed a social conscience !! That is until you come to consider how all of this generosity is going to be repaid. When the time comes to settle up, you can bet your bippy that disability benefits and essential public services will be well in their sights for the cuts that will inevitably follow.

There are quite a few points in my post so I'm not sure which one you are referring to.
I think we are both highly cynical about the government's timing and motivation.

I disagree with the whole approach and disagree that giving a blanket £400 to everyone is a good idea. There would have been many other ways to help. Several have already been mentioned on this thread. The general £400 plus extra for pensioners is just a bung.

Pippainthegarden · 28/05/2022 16:44

breadwidow · 28/05/2022 16:02

Not read the whole thread admittedly so someone may have said this, but to everyone saying it's too hard/expensive to means test it in anyway, my answer is child benefit. This was universal til 2010 when it was partially taken away for this earning over £50k and fully taken away for everybody earning over £60k. This forced millions into self assessment and I think probably has been massive admin pain abs cost but proves where there is a political will to means test there is a way. I think the tories are much more willing to find ways to cut benefits for working people, who are far less likely to vote for them, than pensioners. It's also easier to means test based on income rather than wealth. I expect this is the reason that the fuel payment is going to everyone

I know more than a few families who now think unless they are going to earn over 70k then why bother earning anything over 50k now as already paying 40% tax plus NI. Not only that, it makes you wonder what else your going to be considered too rich for. That’s even without taking into the equation parents paying maintenance, uni fees etc. was silly to bring it in the first place

breadwidow · 28/05/2022 16:02

Not read the whole thread admittedly so someone may have said this, but to everyone saying it's too hard/expensive to means test it in anyway, my answer is child benefit. This was universal til 2010 when it was partially taken away for this earning over £50k and fully taken away for everybody earning over £60k. This forced millions into self assessment and I think probably has been massive admin pain abs cost but proves where there is a political will to means test there is a way. I think the tories are much more willing to find ways to cut benefits for working people, who are far less likely to vote for them, than pensioners. It's also easier to means test based on income rather than wealth. I expect this is the reason that the fuel payment is going to everyone

MrPlopper · 28/05/2022 15:51

Baggyeye · 26/05/2022 22:56

Yes what will happen to people with a property portfolio, surely they are not going to be given a massive cheque?! Especially as it's likely to be tenants rather than property owners facing steep energy rises?

We're not actually physically receiving £400 are we? It will be deducted from our yearly energy bill by our providers therefore it will be the tenant who pays the bill who receives the grant?

GoodThinkingMax · 28/05/2022 15:50

It probably costs more to means test it than just make it universal

Rosscameasdoody · 28/05/2022 15:49

110APiccadilly · 28/05/2022 07:16

I have to say, I was assuming it was a one-off. It really would be crazy to keep giving it to people who don't need it. I hope you're wrong on that.

I think the means testing for the other parts is very much a blunt instrument - you get it if you get certain qualifying benefits. That's probably not too expensive to administer, but it does mean it risks the cliff edge effect for those who earn just too much.

It’s a blunt instrument within the benefits system too. There are families who are struggling and because they earn a pound or two above the means tested benefit tapers and thresholds, they miss out on a lot of support. That means they’ll also lose out here too - which is why the £400 universal payment is a good idea. It will catch those people and at least they’ll get something. Those who feel they don’t need it can maybe donate it to charity or their local food bank - thereby ‘redistributing’ it to those in more need.

Rosscameasdoody · 28/05/2022 15:45

lonelyapple · 27/05/2022 21:46

High income households already pay shit loads of tax and NI, why shouldn't they get something back from this.

Because it’s not about how much tax you pay, it’s about how much you will struggle to pay the bills. High income households will still get the £400, but the top ups are, rightly, for those lower down the income scale.

Rosscameasdoody · 28/05/2022 15:39

rainingsnoring · 28/05/2022 15:17

We can argue forever about what is a 'fair' cut off. The answer is that there never is one and that people will always disagree. It is pretty obvious that an income of say £50K will go a very long way for one person with a fully paid off mortgage and no dependents and not far at all for two working parents, paying for full time childcare and supporting two children, renting and unable to afford to purchase a house. Incomes in isolation mean nothing.

Surely the main point is whether or not throwing more and money around at the whole populace is a bright idea and why this self proclaimed low tax, fiscally responsible chancellor keeps saying one thing and doing the exact opposite.

It's yet another knee jerk, after months of dithering, coincidentally timed (obviously) just as Sue Gray's report was released.
How is this to be paid for apart from the 5 billion which he expects to get from the windfall tax? Do higher earners (or even lower rate tax payers) see their taxes going down in order to pay for this (they have already increased considerably)? Will there be yet more borrowing after Rishi announced how he wanted to be responsible about debt? More QE? Why is he stoking inflation further at a time when it is so high? How will that help those struggling with the cost of living? What happens if energy prices don't recede (there is no evidence that they will as the war in Ukraine continues and Europe announces that it wants to wean itself off Russian gas)? Is he planning handouts every year? What do people think will happen to interest rates on their mortgage, loan or credit card?

Why is he not suspending VAT or green levies on fuel bills? Why is he not targeting help carefully? Why did he raise NI and freeze tax bands just to now throw yet more money around?

It's all very well thinking I need/deserve an extra £400 or whatever but a bit more critical thinking about where it will come from and what the potential consequences might be would be preferable.

This point was discussed on a similar thread. I believe these plans were drawn up as soon as it became clear that the first plan wouldn’t fly, and delayed until they knew what was in the Gray report. The announcement came the same day as the publication of the Gray report to divert attention. It’s a cynical attempt to bribe us all in the hope that we’ll forget all the crap that’s gone down come the general election.

The way in which the disabled and other benefit recipients have been treated by successive Tory governments pretty much tells you that they have no time for those they perceive as being bottom of the pile, and yet now they’re throwing money at us - it’s almost like they’ve suddenly developed a social conscience !! That is until you come to consider how all of this generosity is going to be repaid. When the time comes to settle up, you can bet your bippy that disability benefits and essential public services will be well in their sights for the cuts that will inevitably follow.

Rosscameasdoody · 28/05/2022 15:20

You also made choices - a choice to do a lower paid job / not train / have children earlier, and presumably you also have a choice whether to accept the benefits that higher tax payers top up.

Nice to see that poverty is still the fault of the poor isn’t it ?

rainingsnoring · 28/05/2022 15:17

We can argue forever about what is a 'fair' cut off. The answer is that there never is one and that people will always disagree. It is pretty obvious that an income of say £50K will go a very long way for one person with a fully paid off mortgage and no dependents and not far at all for two working parents, paying for full time childcare and supporting two children, renting and unable to afford to purchase a house. Incomes in isolation mean nothing.

Surely the main point is whether or not throwing more and money around at the whole populace is a bright idea and why this self proclaimed low tax, fiscally responsible chancellor keeps saying one thing and doing the exact opposite.

It's yet another knee jerk, after months of dithering, coincidentally timed (obviously) just as Sue Gray's report was released.
How is this to be paid for apart from the 5 billion which he expects to get from the windfall tax? Do higher earners (or even lower rate tax payers) see their taxes going down in order to pay for this (they have already increased considerably)? Will there be yet more borrowing after Rishi announced how he wanted to be responsible about debt? More QE? Why is he stoking inflation further at a time when it is so high? How will that help those struggling with the cost of living? What happens if energy prices don't recede (there is no evidence that they will as the war in Ukraine continues and Europe announces that it wants to wean itself off Russian gas)? Is he planning handouts every year? What do people think will happen to interest rates on their mortgage, loan or credit card?

Why is he not suspending VAT or green levies on fuel bills? Why is he not targeting help carefully? Why did he raise NI and freeze tax bands just to now throw yet more money around?

It's all very well thinking I need/deserve an extra £400 or whatever but a bit more critical thinking about where it will come from and what the potential consequences might be would be preferable.

VanGoghsDog · 28/05/2022 13:55

Burgoo · 28/05/2022 12:03

As someone on a fair salary I'd say it needs to be proportionate. We don't want to cut off the middle earners, that isn't going to be fair or effective for another election. Also just because someone earns say £40k, doesn't mean that they can absorb the bills when they spent much of that on the mortgage. My house, for example, is going to cost considerably more to heat etc than many council properties.

I would say cap it at £80,000 a year (individually not combined). Any more than that they can absorb the bill.

Once you start making these sorts of proclamations, you get into difficulties.

I earn £75k. But I put loads into my pension, taking my actual salary down to around £48k, below the higher rate threshold.

I have no mortgage, no kids, no debts. I take home over £3k and I have a second income of c£10k of which I usually put £6k into the pension and take £2-4k as dividends. £2k of that is untaxed.

I don't meet your threshold but I also don't "need" the £400. My combined utility bill is currently £168, fixed to next April. My other bills are pretty low too.

Burgoo · 28/05/2022 12:03

As someone on a fair salary I'd say it needs to be proportionate. We don't want to cut off the middle earners, that isn't going to be fair or effective for another election. Also just because someone earns say £40k, doesn't mean that they can absorb the bills when they spent much of that on the mortgage. My house, for example, is going to cost considerably more to heat etc than many council properties.

I would say cap it at £80,000 a year (individually not combined). Any more than that they can absorb the bill.

Babyroobs · 28/05/2022 11:59

Sortilege · 28/05/2022 11:58

But for example, a rent paying adult with LCWRA will get a lower work allowance than the young adult with LCWRA living with their parents rent free. Always seemed one of the design glitches to me @Babyroobs

Yes exactly.

Sortilege · 28/05/2022 11:58

But for example, a rent paying adult with LCWRA will get a lower work allowance than the young adult with LCWRA living with their parents rent free. Always seemed one of the design glitches to me @Babyroobs

Sortilege · 28/05/2022 11:56

Babyroobs · 28/05/2022 11:55

An out of work 19 year old would not get a work allowance unless they had a child on their claim or had the Limited capability for work element on their claim because they are limited in their ability to work by illness or disability.

Yes I know.

TigerRag · 28/05/2022 11:56

Louise0701 · 28/05/2022 11:53

@Babyroobs unless your hypothetical 19 year old living at home pays the energy bill; no he will not get “handed” the money.
the money doesn’t go in your bank account, it’s credited to your energy account.

That's the £400. The £650 goes to your bank account

Babyroobs · 28/05/2022 11:55

Sortilege · 28/05/2022 11:48

Yes that crossed my mind. In the same way the same group get a generous “work allowance” as a reward of sorts for not having rent to pay(something aimed at home owners). It’s almost lik the people who wrote the policy don’t understand the different client groups.

An out of work 19 year old would not get a work allowance unless they had a child on their claim or had the Limited capability for work element on their claim because they are limited in their ability to work by illness or disability.

Louise0701 · 28/05/2022 11:55

@Babyroobs anyone claiming UC needs £650 support!
the energy payments are going onto energy accounts. It’s not a cash payment.
if you feel so strongly then give your son £650.

Babyroobs · 28/05/2022 11:53

Louise0701 · 28/05/2022 11:53

@Babyroobs unless your hypothetical 19 year old living at home pays the energy bill; no he will not get “handed” the money.
the money doesn’t go in your bank account, it’s credited to your energy account.

He will get £650 handed to him if he has a UC claim due to being out of work.

Louise0701 · 28/05/2022 11:53

@Babyroobs unless your hypothetical 19 year old living at home pays the energy bill; no he will not get “handed” the money.
the money doesn’t go in your bank account, it’s credited to your energy account.

Sortilege · 28/05/2022 11:48

Babyroobs · 28/05/2022 11:42

I also think it's hugely unfair for example that a 19 year old just out of school looking for work, claiming UC living with parents will get £650 handed to them wheras others on low pay apprenticeships who don't qualify for UC and probably have travel costs etc won't get anything. My ds gets low pay for his apprenticeship, puts in a 40 hour week and has to travel 60 odd miles to another city a couple of times a week wheras another 20 year old on UC will get this £650 !!

Yes that crossed my mind. In the same way the same group get a generous “work allowance” as a reward of sorts for not having rent to pay(something aimed at home owners). It’s almost lik the people who wrote the policy don’t understand the different client groups.