Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Every household?????

638 replies

Trainfromredhill · 26/05/2022 22:33

So, the chancellor is going to give every household £400 for heating. Surely there should be a cut off of household income? The Beckhams, Elton John, james Dyson, Harry styles…….they all get the money too? . I say this as someone in the fortunate position of not needing the £400- I’d much rather it went to someone who does need it.Just seems a huge waste of public money to give it to everyone

OP posts:
rainingsnoring · 29/05/2022 11:21

Villagewaspbyke · 29/05/2022 04:13

the £400 is supposed to be targeted at reducing energy bills. So makes most sense to do it directly.and pay it off the bills.

we don’t know if this person’s rent has gone up but I think (given the £400 is due for the October rise) it’s not necessarily “likely”.

The support never had to be targeted in this way. There was no necessity to give every bill payer £400. This was simply the option that the Tories chose.

Of course it is more than likely that the bills have gone up. Are you unaware that rents have shot up, in some areas at much higher rates than inflation? What sort of landlord (business person), when faced with energy bills rising hugely would not increase the rates? Your suggestion makes no sense.
The overall objective is (or at least should be) to target the money at those who need it, not owners of multiple properties. It is bizarre that you should argue that this is reasonable.

rainingsnoring · 29/05/2022 11:20

Villagewaspbyke · 29/05/2022 04:13

the £400 is supposed to be targeted at reducing energy bills. So makes most sense to do it directly.and pay it off the bills.

we don’t know if this person’s rent has gone up but I think (given the £400 is due for the October rise) it’s not necessarily “likely”.

The support never had to be targeted in this way. There was no necessity to give every bill payer £400. This was simply the option that the Tories chose.

Of course it is more than likely that the bills have gone up. Are you unaware that rents have shot up, in some areas at much higher rates than inflation? What sort of landlord (business person), when faced with energy bills rising hugely would not increase the rates? Your suggestion makes no sense.
The overall objective is (or at least should be) to target the money at those who need it, not owners of multiple properties. It is bizarre that you should argue that this is reasonable.

rainingsnoring · 29/05/2022 11:20

Villagewaspbyke · 29/05/2022 04:13

the £400 is supposed to be targeted at reducing energy bills. So makes most sense to do it directly.and pay it off the bills.

we don’t know if this person’s rent has gone up but I think (given the £400 is due for the October rise) it’s not necessarily “likely”.

The support never had to be targeted in this way. There was no necessity to give every bill payer £400.
Of course it is more than likely that the bills have gone up. Are you unaware that rents have shot up, in some areas at much higher rates than inflation? What sort of landlord (business person), when faced with energy bills rising hugely would not increase the rates? Your suggestion makes no sense.
The overall objective is (or at least should be) to target the money at those who need it, not owners of multiple properties. It is bizarre that you should argue that this is reasonable.

LoisLane66 · 29/05/2022 11:07

@Morph22010
The ground floor property is rented to someone who has no connection to me and we share no common areas, different front doors on different streets, mine registered as domestic premises for CT and Electoral register.

LoisLane66 · 29/05/2022 11:03

@Morph22010
I am with EDF for gas which is in my name (as is water) and EDF for electricity BUT here's the rub. This is a privately rented property, been here 12 years. Landlord used to live here, owns the building, out commercial property on ground floor is let and double height flat is let to me on 1st and 2nd floors. Because he used to run business and live here, it's on a business rate and there's a main meter and sub meter in the ground floor premises which shows my use.
Downstairs premises is billed monthly as I am and we both pay the landlord. I pay by bank transfer every month ..for 12 years but it's not in my name although I am sent a comprehensive bill by the landlord ergo I cannot claim as my name's not on the electricity bill from EDF. I've emailed my MP about this as it's discriminatory. I have 12 years worth of electricity bills yet cannot claim this payment.

Morph22010 · 29/05/2022 10:40

Nothappyatwork · 29/05/2022 10:33

The system absolutely is there, I can’t even begin to tell you how easy it would be I’m sure there are plenty software developers around here that could come in and explain robotic automation to you in depth but it is literally a five minute job.

You obviously have a lot more faith in hmrcs systems than I do then, having spent the last 27 years dealing with hmrc everyday I have no faith that they could make it work anytime soon. The only system that worked quickly was the furlough and that was because they took most of the security out so it’s been subject to massive amounts of fraud. Also you’ve still not answered who gets the money under your system if it is one payment per household rather than being credited to the bill. Hmrc won’t be able to credit it to an electricity bill as they don’t prepare electricity bills.

Alexandra2001 · 29/05/2022 10:35

Morph22010 · 29/05/2022 10:11

@Nothappyatwork i’m not saying I need or even want the money, I will also be getting another £150 on top as I have a disabled child to make it worse. I’m just saying I can’t see how it can be implemented in practise to do what you are saying, the system just isn’t there and to build a system to do would cost more than the £400 per high earning household they will be saving

I think the point you are missing is that a: this payment is in two installments and b: is likely to be being paid for many more years to come, so coming up with a different system is a must or do you think we should keep handing out billions to folk who do not need it for the next few years......

Energy prices are highly unlikely to be coming down to anything like pre 2021 levels, far more likely to keep increasing.

Your household income makes perfectly the argument that that handing out taxpayers money to the wealthier in society is nuts.

One solution would be to increase the criteria for UC and make payments based on the benefits system, therefore increasing the numbers getting real help.

Nothappyatwork · 29/05/2022 10:33

Morph22010 · 29/05/2022 10:11

@Nothappyatwork i’m not saying I need or even want the money, I will also be getting another £150 on top as I have a disabled child to make it worse. I’m just saying I can’t see how it can be implemented in practise to do what you are saying, the system just isn’t there and to build a system to do would cost more than the £400 per high earning household they will be saving

The system absolutely is there, I can’t even begin to tell you how easy it would be I’m sure there are plenty software developers around here that could come in and explain robotic automation to you in depth but it is literally a five minute job.

Morph22010 · 29/05/2022 10:11

@Nothappyatwork i’m not saying I need or even want the money, I will also be getting another £150 on top as I have a disabled child to make it worse. I’m just saying I can’t see how it can be implemented in practise to do what you are saying, the system just isn’t there and to build a system to do would cost more than the £400 per high earning household they will be saving

Nothappyatwork · 29/05/2022 10:05

HappyHappyHermit · 29/05/2022 09:54

It definitely wouldn't be fair to do it on income. There are plenty of people who have enough in savings that they no longer have to earn, many living in very expensive houses. Those who are most in need will get extra which is absolutely as it should be, but I think most hard working families will appreciate the extra help at the moment. We definitely will.

If they have enough in savings that they don’t need to work they should be declare in the interest on those savings again through HMRC and again that would allow them to ascertain who can afford it and who cant.

@Morph22010 - my partner contributes…. Well end of conversation then you have a household income of £85,000 you do not need tax payers money to pay your bills with, its irrelevant who’s account it comes out of. 🙄
some people really could start an argument in an empty room.

HappyHappyHermit · 29/05/2022 09:54

It definitely wouldn't be fair to do it on income. There are plenty of people who have enough in savings that they no longer have to earn, many living in very expensive houses. Those who are most in need will get extra which is absolutely as it should be, but I think most hard working families will appreciate the extra help at the moment. We definitely will.

Morph22010 · 29/05/2022 09:41

Nothappyatwork · 29/05/2022 09:18

Do you and your £60,000 partner live in the same household and are registered to the same address yes or no ?
anybody who lives in my house who earns £60,000 a year would be contributing towards the bills if they’re not you need to kick them out because you’re gonna lose out on the £400 top up under my rules.

absolutely ludicrous to suggest that we work upon the lowest common denominator for handing out tax payers cash. If you can’t get your male or female partner to contribute fairly towards your bills that’s your problem not ours as a society which is why we changed the rules on child benefit which incidentally is the same system that HMRC use.

My partner contributes thank you very much. However for practical purposes I pay the bills and he pays the mortgage so it’s nothing to do with not contributing. If you knew anything about hmrc system you would know that the high income child benefit charge doesn’t work properly, hmrc relies very much on people declaring that they are due to pay it rather than actually knowing who is due to pay, if it isn’t the recipient of the child benefit themselves that earns over the limit. There has been some matching up over time to find people who are due to pay and haven’t but it’s taken them years and this isn’t even on the same scale as the £400 as that applies to everyone not just those with children so hmrc haven’t to implement a completely new system for the sake of one lot of £400 would cost more than what they are paying out. I don’t work for hmrc but I see enough of how their system works (or doesn’t work) from the other side in my job to know it’s totally unworkable. For one how to do they decide who is the main person in the house that they pay the £400 to? It should go to the electricity bill payer. How do hmrc know who that is? Electricity company’s know that info are you sugggesting hmrc give them access to everyone’s income records?

Nothappyatwork · 29/05/2022 09:18

Morph22010 · 29/05/2022 08:44

So how are you suggesting pays it out, hmrc or the electricity company?

my situation is I pay the bill. I earn £60k partner earns £25k.

how do electricity company know what I earn to not pay me?

so are you suggesting hmrc pay out? How do they know my partner has me that earns £60k, we are not connected at all on hmrc records as taxation is independent since the 1980s

Do you and your £60,000 partner live in the same household and are registered to the same address yes or no ?
anybody who lives in my house who earns £60,000 a year would be contributing towards the bills if they’re not you need to kick them out because you’re gonna lose out on the £400 top up under my rules.

absolutely ludicrous to suggest that we work upon the lowest common denominator for handing out tax payers cash. If you can’t get your male or female partner to contribute fairly towards your bills that’s your problem not ours as a society which is why we changed the rules on child benefit which incidentally is the same system that HMRC use.

Morph22010 · 29/05/2022 08:44

Nothappyatwork · 29/05/2022 08:36

They don’t need to know how much I household earns if they’ve got one person with a date who’s there in 60 grand for example, thats it, theres your cut off.

They’ve purposely given it to everyone so people dont whinge. And still they do.

So how are you suggesting pays it out, hmrc or the electricity company?

my situation is I pay the bill. I earn £60k partner earns £25k.

how do electricity company know what I earn to not pay me?

so are you suggesting hmrc pay out? How do they know my partner has me that earns £60k, we are not connected at all on hmrc records as taxation is independent since the 1980s

Nothappyatwork · 29/05/2022 08:36

Morph22010 · 29/05/2022 06:54

They know how much individuals earn they have no clue how much individual households earn since independent taxation came in. The £400 is credited to electricity bills not given to individuals.

They don’t need to know how much I household earns if they’ve got one person with a date who’s there in 60 grand for example, thats it, theres your cut off.

They’ve purposely given it to everyone so people dont whinge. And still they do.

TimBoothseyes · 29/05/2022 08:21

Anyone know how the very poorest, on key meters, will get the £400? or do they have to apply, like those who are not on DD

Either vouchers or it will be automatically put on to the key/card when we top up for the 1st time after whatever date the rebate is set for. So if the rebate takes effect on Oct 1st then the first top-up after that will have £400 added.

TimBoothseyes · 29/05/2022 08:14

LoisLane66 · 29/05/2022 01:42

@Hugasauras
Can you explain how the £400 will be divvied up if the recipient is with two different companies for electricity and gas.

I'm on different companies for gas and electric. It is only coming off the electric according to my gas supplier.

MarshaBradyo · 29/05/2022 07:54

I would prefer the very wealthy not to get it, of course it’s not needed, but on balance I would also prefer those who are just outside UC and struggling to get help with the £400

And as other posters have explained well the system to assess this is time intensive and expensive.

TigerRag · 29/05/2022 07:33

Burgoo · 28/05/2022 12:03

As someone on a fair salary I'd say it needs to be proportionate. We don't want to cut off the middle earners, that isn't going to be fair or effective for another election. Also just because someone earns say £40k, doesn't mean that they can absorb the bills when they spent much of that on the mortgage. My house, for example, is going to cost considerably more to heat etc than many council properties.

I would say cap it at £80,000 a year (individually not combined). Any more than that they can absorb the bill.

The expensive house / mortgage is your choice.

My council flat may not be that expensive to heat; but it's an old boiler, etc. My income is significantly less.

Morph22010 · 29/05/2022 07:04

Alexandra2001 · 29/05/2022 07:01

but I really do want to know if you, and others who feel the same, would prefer if those who would just miss out but really need it shouldn’t get it?

But these people are missing because of this stupid policy, there are people in work (full time) who are on £20k to £25k, have very little disposable income but are just above the UC and will only get £400, same as someone on 100k with 1 or 2 rental homes etc etc.

The Govt has the ability to have means tested this, it should not be the Govt's job to hand out billions of pounds to people who do not need it, though its hardly surprising that folk who are usually right wing, suddenly become hardened socialists when they smell some free money.

Anyone know how the very poorest, on key meters, will get the £400? or do they have to apply, like those who are not on DD.

from what I’ve read the £400 will be credited onto the meter, any other payments will be paid out to same account as benefit

Alexandra2001 · 29/05/2022 07:01

but I really do want to know if you, and others who feel the same, would prefer if those who would just miss out but really need it shouldn’t get it?

But these people are missing because of this stupid policy, there are people in work (full time) who are on £20k to £25k, have very little disposable income but are just above the UC and will only get £400, same as someone on 100k with 1 or 2 rental homes etc etc.

The Govt has the ability to have means tested this, it should not be the Govt's job to hand out billions of pounds to people who do not need it, though its hardly surprising that folk who are usually right wing, suddenly become hardened socialists when they smell some free money.

Anyone know how the very poorest, on key meters, will get the £400? or do they have to apply, like those who are not on DD.

Morph22010 · 29/05/2022 06:58

LoisLane66 · 29/05/2022 01:42

@Hugasauras
Can you explain how the £400 will be divvied up if the recipient is with two different companies for electricity and gas.

I was thinking about this and I’m not sure but I’m thinking the only logical way is for it to come off the electricity only. Not everyone is the country is on gas mains, my dad isn’t and they get oil delivered, my neighbour had his gas disconnected as they don’t use any gas (storage heaters) so we’re paying standing charge for nothing. I’m thinking that every house in the country must be on mains electric (I could of course be completely wrong)

Morph22010 · 29/05/2022 06:54

Nothappyatwork · 28/05/2022 21:30

HMRC use something called RPA, robotic process automation they know how much every single one of us earns in a heartbeat, it’s literally at their fingertips so this is a deliberate decision to give everybody the money absolutely nothing to do with the cost of administration.

They know how much individuals earn they have no clue how much individual households earn since independent taxation came in. The £400 is credited to electricity bills not given to individuals.

Villagewaspbyke · 29/05/2022 04:13

rainingsnoring · 28/05/2022 21:48

The likelihood is that their rent will have gone up to cover the increased energy bills. The idea should be a handout to the poorest in society not a windfall for people with multiple properties or millions in assets.

the £400 is supposed to be targeted at reducing energy bills. So makes most sense to do it directly.and pay it off the bills.

we don’t know if this person’s rent has gone up but I think (given the £400 is due for the October rise) it’s not necessarily “likely”.

LoisLane66 · 29/05/2022 02:02

@Babyroobs
Really? 😮
There's a chap living on his own a few roads away who sometimes asks me to do shopping for him in bad winter weather. He's about mid 70s and still does gardening and a bit of DIY for locals, cash in hand.
I know he gets pension credit as he's a bit of a talker.
Are you saying that he'll get 400 energy payment plus 300 extra pension one off plus 680 as he gets pension credit? 😲
Is pension credit a means tested payment?
That seems to be a huge amount of entitlement.