Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Every household?????

638 replies

Trainfromredhill · 26/05/2022 22:33

So, the chancellor is going to give every household £400 for heating. Surely there should be a cut off of household income? The Beckhams, Elton John, james Dyson, Harry styles…….they all get the money too? . I say this as someone in the fortunate position of not needing the £400- I’d much rather it went to someone who does need it.Just seems a huge waste of public money to give it to everyone

OP posts:
Morph22010 · 29/05/2022 15:44

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 29/05/2022 15:16

@Threadkill
But they could have stuck with council tax bands. Had a sliding scale so A gets 600 b gets 500 c gets 450 d400 and the rest nothing.

Then those with the least get the most and those with expensive houses who can live without government help don't get any.

And if you're in a band e-g and struggling you can downgrade housing.

I live in a band b house and have combined household income of £85k, that elderly lady who was on gmtv who was having to travel on buses all day as she couldn’t heat her home lives in a band e so it doesn’t always follow

Babyroobs · 29/05/2022 15:28

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 29/05/2022 15:16

@Threadkill
But they could have stuck with council tax bands. Had a sliding scale so A gets 600 b gets 500 c gets 450 d400 and the rest nothing.

Then those with the least get the most and those with expensive houses who can live without government help don't get any.

And if you're in a band e-g and struggling you can downgrade housing.

Many older people are stuck in large properties but actually are poor in terms of pension provision. It's easy to say sell up and move but may not be practical unless they have family to help.

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 29/05/2022 15:19

And @Threadkill there are 4.5m houses in bands e-g so plenty of wastage.

It's doubly bad because giving a nice bit of extra cash they don't need to these wealthy households will fuel inflation, which is the problem we're trying to solve.

But it wins Tory votes.

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 29/05/2022 15:16

@Threadkill
But they could have stuck with council tax bands. Had a sliding scale so A gets 600 b gets 500 c gets 450 d400 and the rest nothing.

Then those with the least get the most and those with expensive houses who can live without government help don't get any.

And if you're in a band e-g and struggling you can downgrade housing.

Threadkill · 29/05/2022 14:29

RoomOfRequirement · 26/05/2022 22:35

I think it's usually because the admin costs of working out who is entitled and figuring out a cut off that is fair to everyone is more than the money they save.

That’s right. Means testing too expensive - cheaper to let everyone have it. People on universal credit get more money than the rest, but you can’t just give it to people on UC cos then the Squeezed Middle gets nothing and they need help too. But don’t worry - only about 1-2% population earn > 1
£100K so there’s not much going to waste. I think everyone else faced with an energy bill of > £3Kper yearneeds some help, and if they don’t they can alwaysgive it to charity.

Morph22010 · 29/05/2022 14:27

GuildfordAngel · 29/05/2022 13:53

As far as I am aware, 2nd homes will not receive the payment.

how does the electricity company know it’s a second home?

Nothappyatwork · 29/05/2022 14:14

Nothappyatwork · 29/05/2022 14:11

Anybody who has an electricity supply will receive the £400.

@GuildfordAngel i do wish Mumsnet had an edit button at times, meant to say every single electricity supply account that any one person has will receive £400 paid into it so as others have said, some people may receive multiple payments

Nothappyatwork · 29/05/2022 14:11

GuildfordAngel · 29/05/2022 13:53

As far as I am aware, 2nd homes will not receive the payment.

Anybody who has an electricity supply will receive the £400.

orwellwasright · 29/05/2022 14:06

Morph22010 · 29/05/2022 13:04

They changed the rules a few years ago and you don’t have to declare self employed income under £1000 anymore. It was a simplification as it cost hmrc more to process the tax return than the tax. I’m not sure if the same applies for tax credits though

All income must be declared for tax credit purposes.

The anomaly with tax credits is that, unlike other benefits, it's administered by HMRC not DWP.

But it's administered separately. It's nothing to do with your personal tax account.

AFAIK all income needs declaring for all means tested benefits. But to DWP not HMRC (apart from tax credits as previously explained).

Rosscameasdoody · 29/05/2022 14:00

Morph22010 · 29/05/2022 13:04

They changed the rules a few years ago and you don’t have to declare self employed income under £1000 anymore. It was a simplification as it cost hmrc more to process the tax return than the tax. I’m not sure if the same applies for tax credits though

But if he’s on pension credit he should be declaring the extra income to DWP, not HMRC. It’s essentially benefit fraud.

GuildfordAngel · 29/05/2022 13:53

As far as I am aware, 2nd homes will not receive the payment.

Morph22010 · 29/05/2022 13:04

Nothappyatwork · 29/05/2022 12:42

The trouble is the systems working against him I mean seriously can you imagine him filling out an online self-assessment for what the odd 50 quid here or there ?

They changed the rules a few years ago and you don’t have to declare self employed income under £1000 anymore. It was a simplification as it cost hmrc more to process the tax return than the tax. I’m not sure if the same applies for tax credits though

Nothappyatwork · 29/05/2022 12:42

Babyroobs · 29/05/2022 12:41

Yes he will get all 3 including the extra £650 if on pension credit as that is one of the means tested qualifying benefits. he should be declaring the cash in hand income though.

The trouble is the systems working against him I mean seriously can you imagine him filling out an online self-assessment for what the odd 50 quid here or there ?

Babyroobs · 29/05/2022 12:41

LoisLane66 · 29/05/2022 02:02

@Babyroobs
Really? 😮
There's a chap living on his own a few roads away who sometimes asks me to do shopping for him in bad winter weather. He's about mid 70s and still does gardening and a bit of DIY for locals, cash in hand.
I know he gets pension credit as he's a bit of a talker.
Are you saying that he'll get 400 energy payment plus 300 extra pension one off plus 680 as he gets pension credit? 😲
Is pension credit a means tested payment?
That seems to be a huge amount of entitlement.

Yes he will get all 3 including the extra £650 if on pension credit as that is one of the means tested qualifying benefits. he should be declaring the cash in hand income though.

Nothappyatwork · 29/05/2022 12:39

Morph22010 · 29/05/2022 11:55

Yes that is what they are planning to do and what you have said shouldn’t happen and that it should be capped based on income and that it would be a five minute job to implement based on robotic automation. What I am asking you and the bit I do not understand is how is it a 5 minute job to cap based on income if the electricity company do not have details of people’s income.

It wouldn’t be anything to do with the electricity companies they don’t need to know your income, it would literally be a case of the electricity company knows that they supply you, they apply for the £400 HMRC know how much you earn, computer says yes or no.

Babyroobs · 29/05/2022 12:37

MarshaBradyo · 29/05/2022 07:54

I would prefer the very wealthy not to get it, of course it’s not needed, but on balance I would also prefer those who are just outside UC and struggling to get help with the £400

And as other posters have explained well the system to assess this is time intensive and expensive.

People not on UC will get the £400 towards gas and electricity.

VladmirsPoutine · 29/05/2022 12:03

This might have already been mentioned but it's nothing to do with administrative costs. It's basically a reputation white wash for the Tories. If you think about it the votes they tend to court: 2nd homeowners who will receive it twice and rich people who'll see it as a bit of bonus cash. That's all there is to it - keep their base sweet whilst seemingly appearing to help out everyone else so they don't get totally obliterated.

Morph22010 · 29/05/2022 11:55

Nothappyatwork · 29/05/2022 11:42

I’ve completely misunderstood it then because I thought that that was exactly what they were planning to do is give it to the electricity company and deduct it from the bill have I got that wrong ?

Yes that is what they are planning to do and what you have said shouldn’t happen and that it should be capped based on income and that it would be a five minute job to implement based on robotic automation. What I am asking you and the bit I do not understand is how is it a 5 minute job to cap based on income if the electricity company do not have details of people’s income.

Morph22010 · 29/05/2022 11:50

Alexandra2001 · 29/05/2022 10:35

I think the point you are missing is that a: this payment is in two installments and b: is likely to be being paid for many more years to come, so coming up with a different system is a must or do you think we should keep handing out billions to folk who do not need it for the next few years......

Energy prices are highly unlikely to be coming down to anything like pre 2021 levels, far more likely to keep increasing.

Your household income makes perfectly the argument that that handing out taxpayers money to the wealthier in society is nuts.

One solution would be to increase the criteria for UC and make payments based on the benefits system, therefore increasing the numbers getting real help.

If it’s going to be paid for many years to come then I think a completely different system needs to be developed, but that will take time and this payout is just a crude sticking plaster so it can be done quickly. I completely agree with you about our situation and that it needs to be better targeted. Back when Ds was born in 2010 we were entitled to a low amount of tax credits, I wasn’t on the income I am now but still a decent salary. This was under the labour government and I recall your household income could be relatively high and you still got the basic level of tax credit. Maybe something like this could be brought back as it would collect data on household income and allow targeted extra payments to be made as and when. But then this wouldn’t be fair to single people with no children and it’s just as expensive for them to heat a house. The arguement against tax credits being operated like this was that what was the point In taxing people to then give them money back you might as well just increase the tax allowances so they could earn more before paying.

i don’t know the answer. There were complaints up thread about disabled people only being entitled to £150 when pensioners were entItled to £300 but then my particular situation demonstrates why all disabled people don’t need a higher a higher amount.

it’s just so complicated once you start thinking it all through, whatever system there is always people that gain and people that lose out.

Nothappyatwork · 29/05/2022 11:44

Sorry I see what you mean yes they would still credited to the bill depending on the household income, correlate the two as they are perfectly capable of doing so.

Nothappyatwork · 29/05/2022 11:42

Morph22010 · 29/05/2022 10:40

You obviously have a lot more faith in hmrcs systems than I do then, having spent the last 27 years dealing with hmrc everyday I have no faith that they could make it work anytime soon. The only system that worked quickly was the furlough and that was because they took most of the security out so it’s been subject to massive amounts of fraud. Also you’ve still not answered who gets the money under your system if it is one payment per household rather than being credited to the bill. Hmrc won’t be able to credit it to an electricity bill as they don’t prepare electricity bills.

I’ve completely misunderstood it then because I thought that that was exactly what they were planning to do is give it to the electricity company and deduct it from the bill have I got that wrong ?

rainingsnoring · 29/05/2022 11:36

Alexandra2001 · 29/05/2022 10:35

I think the point you are missing is that a: this payment is in two installments and b: is likely to be being paid for many more years to come, so coming up with a different system is a must or do you think we should keep handing out billions to folk who do not need it for the next few years......

Energy prices are highly unlikely to be coming down to anything like pre 2021 levels, far more likely to keep increasing.

Your household income makes perfectly the argument that that handing out taxpayers money to the wealthier in society is nuts.

One solution would be to increase the criteria for UC and make payments based on the benefits system, therefore increasing the numbers getting real help.

I agree that energy prices are likely to remain high. However, do you think it is likely that the government will continue with subsidies in this form because of that? I agree that any additional support needs to be targeted.

Xiaoxiong · 29/05/2022 11:35

I was at a dinner the other night with a few people in your position OP, and the consensus was that if we didn't need it, we should donate it and claim the gift aid to make it £500 for the charity. National Energy Action looks like a good one, or a local mutual aid group - we have one that does hardship grants, administered locally with referrals from GPs and health visitors.

As far as I can see that's a win win - the government doesn't waste money on means testing, individuals decide if they need it or not (and sometimes it's unpredictable who needs it or not), and then charities can benefit from the gift aid uplift.

LoisLane66 · 29/05/2022 11:25

The £650 is to be paid in two instalments, in October and February (so the news outlets said) not just 'handed to' the recipient.
The 400 is to be paid in several tranches from October.

rainingsnoring · 29/05/2022 11:21

Sorry, my internet is playing up!