Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Every household?????

638 replies

Trainfromredhill · 26/05/2022 22:33

So, the chancellor is going to give every household £400 for heating. Surely there should be a cut off of household income? The Beckhams, Elton John, james Dyson, Harry styles…….they all get the money too? . I say this as someone in the fortunate position of not needing the £400- I’d much rather it went to someone who does need it.Just seems a huge waste of public money to give it to everyone

OP posts:
SlowHorses · 26/05/2022 23:03

There’s another thread on this exact topic.

I’ll post what I did there. Means testing as a way of fairly distributing to the needy doesn’t work. Morally sounds right but read the link below.

If you don’t need it give it to charity. I also posted the amount of charity the British public raise every year. It’s billions for both home and abroad. Trust people to do the right thing as most people will and don’t fight about who is most worthy. The only wrath should be directed as the government.

amp.theguardian.com/social-care-network/2013/jan/14/means-testing-benefits-not-efficient-fair

NannyGythaOgg · 26/05/2022 23:02

It's going to be paid direct to your energy company. I think energy companies should give everyone the option of donating back and using it to increase the 'warm homes' discount to those who need it.

Currently the warm home discount is based purely on income and very welcome it is to someone on a basic pension. However, my home is newish and well insulated. There are many people who are otherwise in a similar situation to me who have to pay a much bigger proportion of their income on heating.

Another alternative would be for those who don't need it to donate it back and it be used to insulate older and/or more draughty and hard to heat homes.

Whichever option I think it should be geared towards those who pay a bigger proportion of their (low) income on heating - not based on income alone.

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 26/05/2022 23:01

mumda · 26/05/2022 22:58

They could have asked the energy companies to apply a discount to every household account.
Job done.

But just giving people money boosts the economy more.

They are, aren’t they?

Louise0701 · 26/05/2022 23:00

@Baggyeye our tenants all pay their own energy Bills. I’m assuming it’ll go to the bill payers? If not and we get it, we will give it to our tenants.

Hugasauras · 26/05/2022 23:00

mumda · 26/05/2022 22:58

They could have asked the energy companies to apply a discount to every household account.
Job done.

But just giving people money boosts the economy more.

But that's what is happening.

'Direct debit and credit customers will have the money credited to their account, while customers with pre-payment meters will have the money applied to their meter or paid via a voucher'

The only people getting cash in their accounts are those who are already means tested via benefits, etc.

Louise0701 · 26/05/2022 22:59

I’m with you @Trainfromredhill we don’t need ours and I think it’s ridiculous it’s been given to everyone. We will be donating ours.

mumda · 26/05/2022 22:58

They could have asked the energy companies to apply a discount to every household account.
Job done.

But just giving people money boosts the economy more.

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 26/05/2022 22:56

Hugasauras · 26/05/2022 22:54

The admin and resource cost of means testing and administering would be huge.

The money is almost certainly not coming to individual bank accounts as £400 cash; it will go directly to the energy companies who will then apply it to each account. If they means test, the additional admin of linking up eligible recipients to the correct energy accounts would be huge, on top of the admin of means testing in the first place, and it would require a lot of cross-organisational working and resources. It would most likely take a long time and a lot of money to implement a system that worked properly.

Exactly. It’s just the same as when Babbage introduced the penny post, having realised that it cost more to calculate the difference in postage costs than was brought in by variable costs.

Baggyeye · 26/05/2022 22:56

Yes what will happen to people with a property portfolio, surely they are not going to be given a massive cheque?! Especially as it's likely to be tenants rather than property owners facing steep energy rises?

BrilloSolar · 26/05/2022 22:55

Not going to repeat what everyone has said about it costing more to means test (oops- did just repeat it) but to put it another way: everyone could get £400, or the government could fund the cost for it to be means tested and those in need will get £200 once the costs have been taken out. Which is best?

Plus, with means testing there will always be those just at the cut off who struggle but don't seem to on paper.

Hugasauras · 26/05/2022 22:54

The admin and resource cost of means testing and administering would be huge.

The money is almost certainly not coming to individual bank accounts as £400 cash; it will go directly to the energy companies who will then apply it to each account. If they means test, the additional admin of linking up eligible recipients to the correct energy accounts would be huge, on top of the admin of means testing in the first place, and it would require a lot of cross-organisational working and resources. It would most likely take a long time and a lot of money to implement a system that worked properly.

ilovesooty · 26/05/2022 22:53

PurpleDaisies · 26/05/2022 22:35

People with second homes get it twice.

People like Sunak will get it 12 times.

Disgraceful.

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 26/05/2022 22:52

Trainfromredhill · 26/05/2022 22:47

@ShirleyPhallus . I don’t share your view. DH and I are both very high earners. £400 makes absolutely zero difference to our day to day living…….so no, I don’t view it as ‘getting something back’ I just see it as misspent money. And I don’t agree that it isn’t taking anything away from anyone else……this will all have to be recouped to pay the growing national debt……so someone somewhere will be paying it back(and you can bet if the tories are still in power it won’t be the high earners paying it back).

I’m not sure if you’re serious here. Of course it’ll be the high earners paying it back. This government has a higher rate of tax on higher earners than we had under Labour, a higher personal allowance (but no lessons allowance for high earners), and it has removed the tax advantages of being able to fund pensions from higher earners.

How can you possibly suggest that higher earners have been looked after compared to how they were treated under Labour, or relative to lower earners?

If, as you say, you are very high earners, then you are each paying 47% on most of your earnings, have zero personal allowance, and can only put £4,000 into your pensions each year.

carefullycourageous · 26/05/2022 22:51

They are desperate to buy us off.

ShirleyPhallus · 26/05/2022 22:49

There’s also a huge difference in “high earners” which MN often defines as £60k+ and “very high” earners which could be £1m+ salaries. Of course those in lower brackets would appreciate the funds

Hhoney · 26/05/2022 22:49

I’m probably in the bracket that misses out on everything but still has to penny pinch. My husband and I earn about £100k per year between us. We don’t get child benefit and are not eligible for the council tax refund.

We are struggling at the moment. After all bills paid we used to have about £400 left each month for non necessities (clothes, eating out, adding to savings, entertainment etc.) Our council tax has gone up by £60 a month, energy by £120 a month (will be more in winter) and food by about £150 a month. Other bills have risen too (childcare, insurance, fuel). We have nothing left at the end of each month anymore.

I’m grateful that I’ve not been left out of this benefit.

Baggyeye · 26/05/2022 22:48

Johnson is trying to buy the country off (to distract from the report that shows he runs No 10 as a house of debauchery) by using the public's own money!

Just like eat out to help out it's an ill-conceived squandering of public money. Absolutely take money from the energy companies and help those in need but it's a nonsense paying it to high-earning households.

ShirleyPhallus · 26/05/2022 22:48

Trainfromredhill · 26/05/2022 22:47

@ShirleyPhallus . I don’t share your view. DH and I are both very high earners. £400 makes absolutely zero difference to our day to day living…….so no, I don’t view it as ‘getting something back’ I just see it as misspent money. And I don’t agree that it isn’t taking anything away from anyone else……this will all have to be recouped to pay the growing national debt……so someone somewhere will be paying it back(and you can bet if the tories are still in power it won’t be the high earners paying it back).

Donate it back then. You can choose to pay more tax than you’re charged as standard. If you don’t need it then that’s fine.

But some people may appreciate it

Trainfromredhill · 26/05/2022 22:47

@ShirleyPhallus . I don’t share your view. DH and I are both very high earners. £400 makes absolutely zero difference to our day to day living…….so no, I don’t view it as ‘getting something back’ I just see it as misspent money. And I don’t agree that it isn’t taking anything away from anyone else……this will all have to be recouped to pay the growing national debt……so someone somewhere will be paying it back(and you can bet if the tories are still in power it won’t be the high earners paying it back).

OP posts:
TheDogsMother · 26/05/2022 22:46

It's the same of winter fuel allowance which is a blanket payment to pensioners regardless of means. If you don't need it then contributing to a food bank would be a really great thing to do.

Alicesweewonders · 26/05/2022 22:43

Rather than do something about the energy companies, they'd rather throw money at the problem.

For a party that is against socialism, they've spend they past few years doing nothing but spend other people's money.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 26/05/2022 22:43

Trainfromredhill · 26/05/2022 22:40

figuring out a cut off that is fair to everyone

I don’t think anyone with a household income of over £200k could say they ‘needed’ £400. Some might even say £100k.
nothing in life is fair, but I’m not sure anyone with a household income of £100k is choosing between eating or heating….unless they are living way outside their means.

It's cheaper to give everyone £400 than it is to figure out a sensible cut-off, figure out who earns above it (especially when it comes to people who are self employed or have fluctuating incomes) and then pay them.

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 26/05/2022 22:42

PurpleDaisies · 26/05/2022 22:35

People with second homes get it twice.

Really? Excellent. It’s costing a fortune running two homes at the moment.

VanGoghsDog · 26/05/2022 22:42

It's not really about need, it's about sharing out a windfall. I don't need it. I'll donate it to charity.

Feelingoktoday · 26/05/2022 22:42

I hope the central govt distributes the money and not the local councils. We really don’t have the staffing resources.