Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Every household?????

638 replies

Trainfromredhill · 26/05/2022 22:33

So, the chancellor is going to give every household £400 for heating. Surely there should be a cut off of household income? The Beckhams, Elton John, james Dyson, Harry styles…….they all get the money too? . I say this as someone in the fortunate position of not needing the £400- I’d much rather it went to someone who does need it.Just seems a huge waste of public money to give it to everyone

OP posts:
worriedatthistime · 27/05/2022 00:04

@londonmummy1966 i don't need to think thanks
Your dad will pay a fair amount if tax on that though so hes also helping pay his own pension as well as paying into it himself
You obviously don't get CB so are a little bitter but why begrudge others
CB is easier as you have to actually claim it physically so if over you don't claim or pay on tax returns , so its done in a totally different way to the flat payments and these payments, so maybe you should be the one thinking and not pensioner bashing which is so popular on here
Obviously you have an issue with your df too but he is just one pensioner , don't group them all together
When you work with them day by day and see the Struggles many have it annoys me

godmum56 · 27/05/2022 00:04

Feelingoktoday · 26/05/2022 22:42

I hope the central govt distributes the money and not the local councils. We really don’t have the staffing resources.

as I understand it the fuel 400 is going straight to the energy companies to apply against people's energy bills and the actual cash that people will receive will be paid via the pensions and benefits route. Its the fastest and most economical way to do it.

Cuckoo48 · 27/05/2022 00:03

worriedatthistime · 26/05/2022 23:47

@Cuckoo48 pensioner bashing yet again , so what they have paid taxes and still will be of so well off
That same money helps many many pensioners who aren't well off which there are more off
Means testing isn't always cost effective and many richer pensioners will give to charity etc
Why the jealousy and ageist post because thats what it is

I'm talking about my own flipping relatives, not bashing random pensioners! They agree with me; they don't remotely need the money.
Mine give it to their granddaughter, a uni student on a fixed low income who does struggle with bills. My inlaws probably spend theirs on wine and crisps!

NewYorkLassie · 27/05/2022 00:03

this will all have to be recouped to pay the growing national debt

Will it? I thought it was being paid for by an additional windfall tax on the energy companies. It’s not coming straight out of the existing kitty.

londonmummy1966 · 26/05/2022 23:57

@worriedatthistime - my issue is that it is fine to make sure that flat rate benefits are paid to pensioners regardless of income - and I know loads who are on 6 figures as they bought their annuities when interest rates were really high (I was paying mortgage interest at the time and it was painful). There are also those like my DF who gets nearly £130k pa index linked ex civil service pension (so you and I are already funding that). However when it comes to paying a flat rate benefit - ie child benefit - to a two parent hard working family with not excessive salaries and a joint income that is less that my fathers - oh no they have to cut that. So my problem is the arrant hypocrisy of saying that it can't be done/ its too expensive/ what's the problem, when those raising children can be penalised but pensioners - bless 'em - cannot. If you can't see why that is annoying - before we even get to the unfairness to the disabled and carers - perhaps you should do a bit of thinking?

worriedatthistime · 26/05/2022 23:50

@Basilbrushgotfat but that would take admin , if you don't need it then you use the money you would of paid towards your bill and donate to a food bank or a charity of choice , or whatever you see fit
Everyone has been asking for help sAying something should be done and when they do , thats not good enough either
Its impossible to always be fair , life isn't fair thats just a simple fact

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 26/05/2022 23:48

It's going to cost 11 billion. At its most basic format. Employing steps to means test it would cost more than the cost of just issuing it to every household.

Personally I'd rather they just took the 11billion hit on vat from energy suppliers so they could pass the saving down the line per unit used.

But I ain't in charge.

worriedatthistime · 26/05/2022 23:47

@Cuckoo48 pensioner bashing yet again , so what they have paid taxes and still will be of so well off
That same money helps many many pensioners who aren't well off which there are more off
Means testing isn't always cost effective and many richer pensioners will give to charity etc
Why the jealousy and ageist post because thats what it is

worriedatthistime · 26/05/2022 23:44

@londonmummy1966 alwAys one who comes along and mentions the pensioners
And yes they did work for it many of them , and if high earner now will still pay tax etc so whats your problem

Basilbrushgotfat · 26/05/2022 23:42

More work for them in separating out by wealth I imagine.

They ought to have a way for people to reject the money though, so it can be used elsewhere

worriedatthistime · 26/05/2022 23:38

Because its cheaper to do this than the adjoin costs to mean test, I can't believe people don't get this
The chancellor himself has said he will give his away and anyone who doesn't need it can do this

InChocolateWeTrust · 26/05/2022 23:37

They could have given it via a temporary increase to personal allowance. That way anyone earning over £100k would have had it clawed back.

Lunar27 · 26/05/2022 23:36

Hhoney · 26/05/2022 22:49

I’m probably in the bracket that misses out on everything but still has to penny pinch. My husband and I earn about £100k per year between us. We don’t get child benefit and are not eligible for the council tax refund.

We are struggling at the moment. After all bills paid we used to have about £400 left each month for non necessities (clothes, eating out, adding to savings, entertainment etc.) Our council tax has gone up by £60 a month, energy by £120 a month (will be more in winter) and food by about £150 a month. Other bills have risen too (childcare, insurance, fuel). We have nothing left at the end of each month anymore.

I’m grateful that I’ve not been left out of this benefit.

🤦

Don't get me wrong, I'll gratefully receive anything off the government as I have no shame.

However, something is going very wrong if you're struggling on £100k/year. Life should be comfortable at the very least!

BrilloSolar · 26/05/2022 23:34

Everyone: gas and electricity prices are absolutely going crazy, the government should do something.

Government: OK, we'll subsidise it.

Everyone: but don't subsidise it for THOSE people. Please spend more of our money on making sure THOSE people don't benefit too.

Disclaimer- hate the Tory government and think A LOT could have been done- invest in renewable energy years ago; not rely on a county with a known sociopath as a leader; not be only interested in the investments of your mates, etc, etc, etc, But come on, many people above have given clear arguments as to why means testing was not the best way to go here, but no - you know best and you'd be able to run this country (although actually you probably would be better than bojo)

Cuckoo48 · 26/05/2022 23:31

They've been helping my wealthy pensioner parents and in-laws to heat their comfortable detached homes every winter for years with a winter fuel payment.

OytheBumbler · 26/05/2022 23:22

This reply has been deleted

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Me too

ilovesooty · 26/05/2022 23:22

StrandedStarfish · 26/05/2022 23:16

He is buying votes by bribing every bill payer

I expect it will work. Many of the electorate are thick enough to vote Tory at the next election.

qpmz · 26/05/2022 23:19

ShirleyPhallus · 26/05/2022 22:38

Isn’t it nice that sometimes those paying the most tax get something back very occasionally?

I personally am very happy to pay tax, I think the country runs better when there is more in the general purse but it’s also frustrating to be constantly hit with the biggest rises in taxes, bills, hits to NI etc. It’s nice to have a little something back and doesn’t take anything away from anyone else.

Note - this almost never ever happens so I really don’t begrudge it happening as a one off

I pay higher tax too but definitely don't agree it's nice to get something back! This isn't meant to be a nice gift so you can reward yourself for being a high earner, it's meant to help feed people and keep them warm! Confused

saleorbouy · 26/05/2022 23:17

It's absolute BS why are they giving away money. Surely it should be invested into generating cheaper electricity therefore reducing energy prices over the long term.
A one of payment is not going to fix high energy prices or help inflation.
This is just a brief appeasement of public opinion and a huge waste of tax payers money.
I understand people are struggling under the current financial burden but there are better solutions than this.

StrandedStarfish · 26/05/2022 23:16

He is buying votes by bribing every bill payer

SlowHorses · 26/05/2022 23:14

Bingo.

thread goes the same way as the other one. No one bothers to read why means testing doesn’t work in helping the needy and fixates on the very rich and famous. Let the pensioner bashing commence.

londonmummy1966 · 26/05/2022 23:13

Please would the pensioners on MN stop peddling the fiction about the £300 only going to those benefitting from the warm homes discount - the government has said it is going to everyone who benefits from the winter fuel allowance - which is paid to everyone in receipt of the state pension regardless of their income and capital resources.

londonmummy1966 · 26/05/2022 23:11

Just pointing out gently that wealthy pensioners are getting £700. Elton John, Cliff Richard, Brian May, Paul McCartney, Mick Jagger......

Plus loads like my DF on index linked pensions of £100K plus who think that is fine cos they worked hard and paid their taxes.

I just don't get why disabled people get £150 and pensioners £300. I also don't get why child benefit is not availale to higher rate tax payers but pensioners on many multiples of the higher rate band get every benefit going "cos they're old".

Confusedmeanderings · 26/05/2022 23:09

As PP have said, it would cost more to figure out and implement a more targeted system of giving out the money and there are always people who fall through the cracks. We have savings of £40 000, however our monthly income is £550. We retired a few years early and we are topping up our income from the savings. This was always planned and we're doing OK, but we don't tend to qualify for means tested benefits because of the high amount of savings. If they made this money means tested, we probably wouldn't get it yet we could definitely do with it.

palmplantcirca1980s · 26/05/2022 23:05

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn