Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Every household?????

638 replies

Trainfromredhill · 26/05/2022 22:33

So, the chancellor is going to give every household £400 for heating. Surely there should be a cut off of household income? The Beckhams, Elton John, james Dyson, Harry styles…….they all get the money too? . I say this as someone in the fortunate position of not needing the £400- I’d much rather it went to someone who does need it.Just seems a huge waste of public money to give it to everyone

OP posts:
Villagewaspbyke · 27/05/2022 02:49

FrozZen · 27/05/2022 02:45

Don't means test. Utter waste of money. Cap what the sodding companies are charging, and their profits. Not the families struggling. Why start at the lower end of the pyramid??? Start at the top....

The energy companies already are capped in what they can charge. That’s why many suppliers have gone bust when wholesale prices rocketed.

FrozZen · 27/05/2022 02:49

And why isn't there a single investigative journalist looking in to which politicians have shares in these power companies.......???? From every angle inc the Panama Papers etc. Then, folk might get a lot more cross than getting hairy about a few parties. It goes far deeper than getting pished in Downing Street. It is time Great Britain got a handle on governmental corruption. It affects ALL OF US and is rife. Disgustingly so.

Villagewaspbyke · 27/05/2022 02:47

SlowHorses · 26/05/2022 23:03

There’s another thread on this exact topic.

I’ll post what I did there. Means testing as a way of fairly distributing to the needy doesn’t work. Morally sounds right but read the link below.

If you don’t need it give it to charity. I also posted the amount of charity the British public raise every year. It’s billions for both home and abroad. Trust people to do the right thing as most people will and don’t fight about who is most worthy. The only wrath should be directed as the government.

amp.theguardian.com/social-care-network/2013/jan/14/means-testing-benefits-not-efficient-fair

Means testing of benefits does generally work that’s why we do it with most benefits. To pay benefits at a reasonable level for everyone is enormously expensive and pointless if they don’t need it. The state pension is one example of a universal benefits which is so hugely expensive that it needs to have the age moved up and up. It’s likely that in the next few years it will become means tested.

The article is just an opinion piece in the guardian- hardly convincing.

tbf though, in this case (a one off payment direct to energy companies to reduce a spike in prices) it probably is easiest to pay it to everyone. But usually means testing is fairest and most efficient

FrozZen · 27/05/2022 02:45

Don't means test. Utter waste of money. Cap what the sodding companies are charging, and their profits. Not the families struggling. Why start at the lower end of the pyramid??? Start at the top....

FrozZen · 27/05/2022 02:40

The profits being posted are OBSCENE. Not just millions but billions. Enough. Surely? If all the profits were being re-invested, it would be different, but the shareholder dividends are simply unreal. And many are watching their share portfolios increase whilst the poor try to choose between heating, food, or just curl up and give up. Why are transnational corporates being allowed to do this?????? Cui bono?

WiddlinDiddlin · 27/05/2022 02:38

Because its less cost effective to means test - means testing COSTS, a lot - than it is to just hand it out to everyone.

This is the same reason why OAP winter fuel payments are not means tested.

And this attitude of 'why should someone get something they don't deserve' is why we have so many issues and why we can't have a much better system like universal basic income.

This is why our government have spent over 2 BILLION quid MORE on the move from DLA to PIP, which still isn't complete - than they would have spent keeping DLA and potentially letting fraudulent claims slip through the net.

The move from DLA to PIP was absolutely designed to cut payments and save costs.

2 BILLION more than not doing it at all.

Because, purely because, a noisey section of the population can't stand to see someone getting something they maybe shouldn't. And not caring who misses out as a result.

FrozZen · 27/05/2022 02:25

Why not instruct the power companies to reduce their bills, NOW? Zero windfall tax, zero payments to households, zero bloody admin. Like many other nations have done...price per unit = x until the govt says otherwise. End of.

Sortilege · 27/05/2022 02:23

Baggyeye · 26/05/2022 22:56

Yes what will happen to people with a property portfolio, surely they are not going to be given a massive cheque?! Especially as it's likely to be tenants rather than property owners facing steep energy rises?

The £400 universal payment is essentially a rebate applied to each domestic fuel account. So for tenanted properties, where the tenant is the bill payer, the tenant gets the rebate.

Untenanted properties and second homes are the issue.

FrozZen · 27/05/2022 02:21

So, as we all now have multiple bank accounts tied to our lives, out of necessity (especially if you are self-employed), this is just going to be another "Oops, we overpaid many thousands of folk, twice (or more)" fup again? Adiós billions of quid, never to be reclaimed by the tax payer as there are insufficient folk left in the office for the civil Service to work through the double payments etc on top of the already mad corruption from covid payments. Genius. 👏

mummy203 · 27/05/2022 02:16

It’s an admin thing. Please consider donating it. CAB or you local food bank will have a list of desperate people that need it.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 27/05/2022 02:10

Ignoring the extra costs of means-testing for a bit, it doesn't really matter that much that rich people are included in a handout, because it's disproportionately the higher earners that pay for it.

Simplifying a lot, if I have a hundred widgets and my nine brothers have only ten widgets each, you could

  1. Take ten widgets off me, and then give everybody a widget, including me, so I have 91 widgets and my brothers each have 11 widgets, or
  1. Take nine widgets off me and give one to each of my brothers, so I have 91 widgets and my brothers each have 11 widgets

— they both come out the same.

As long as rich people are required to pay more into the system than poor people, it more or less shakes out either way.

Except for the fact that means-testing you have to spend some of the money on assessing eligibility. Which all goes into GDP, I guess, but won't look as good in the papers as a larger disbursement.

GetThatHelmetOn · 27/05/2022 02:00

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Not really, I am wonderful at budgeting and proud of everything I have achieved in my life (low salary down to wanting to simplify my life) but, here’s the big point: I was not asked for opinion about dismantling most of our gas storage facilities which put us in this predicament, the energy price increases issue was all there long before Rusia invaded Ukraine. Obviously, the war made it worse but this has been shoved under the carpet by the Tories at least since the start of last summer. 😉

Bpdqueen · 27/05/2022 01:39

Everyone saying they don't need it feel free to donate it to me im poor 🤣

ReeseWitherfork · 27/05/2022 00:34

However, something is going very wrong if you're struggling on £100k/year. Life should be comfortable at the very least!

What bollocks. This will very much depend on where you live, when you bought a property, how many kids you have in childcare... and so on.

Anyone suggesting £100k a year is "comfortable" probably didn't have to buy a starter house for £300k+ and have huge monthly mortgage payments.

Many couples have to make the horrendous decision to pay out the equivalent of one salary on childcare so that one parent (usually the mother!) doesn't completely lose her place on the job ladder for the sake of a few years.

Not to mention that it would be ludicrous not to pay into a pension, so a good few hundred quid is being taking up there. A luxury some can't afford for sure, but that doesn't negate its impact. Plus there will be student loan repayments deducted as we'd be expecting those earning above average to have that level of education.

An average salary in London is £40k. Earning £50k isn't substantially more when you consider the lack of things like child benefit.

AlbertaAnnie · 27/05/2022 00:24

Let me just find the world smallest violin 🤣🤣🤣

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 27/05/2022 00:19

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

GetThatHelmetOn · 27/05/2022 00:18

I agree that the money could have been better used to solve the issue at the root of the problem but… that wouldn’t have covered up the party gate issue isn’t it.

This throwing a bit of bread at us to keep us thinking they are the good guys even if we are were we are thanks to their lousy decisions.

Baggyeye · 27/05/2022 00:17

NewYorkLassie · 27/05/2022 00:03

this will all have to be recouped to pay the growing national debt

Will it? I thought it was being paid for by an additional windfall tax on the energy companies. It’s not coming straight out of the existing kitty.

Nope it will be 'partially' paid for by the windfall debt rest will come from taxpayers

15 billion in measures announced
5 billion windfall tax on energy companies
6 billion cost of £400 universal household grants

www.msn.com/en-gb/money/other/sunak-announces-c2-a3400-energy-bill-discount-for-all-households-and-a-windfall-tax/ar-AAXLHYc

GetThatHelmetOn · 27/05/2022 00:15

Disclaimer: I still fervientky believe that furlough payments should have been calculated on the basis of need though, especially in a system where people working long hours and earning peanuts have their benefits reduced pound by pound after they have savings over…£6000?

Babyroobs · 27/05/2022 00:15

Ridiculous isn't it, but then means testing is so complex. In my job I regularly come across elderly people claiming disability benefits and they have 100k + in the bank, yet they will still get the extra £150. It would be too complex to means test it.

Summerstink · 27/05/2022 00:13

saleorbouy · 26/05/2022 23:17

It's absolute BS why are they giving away money. Surely it should be invested into generating cheaper electricity therefore reducing energy prices over the long term.
A one of payment is not going to fix high energy prices or help inflation.
This is just a brief appeasement of public opinion and a huge waste of tax payers money.
I understand people are struggling under the current financial burden but there are better solutions than this.

I agree with this. So puzzled why money isn't being spent to deal with the source of the problem. 15 billion might -

  1. Insulate to a high standard homes in Council and Housing Association ownership NOW. The difference in the warmth, energy use and comfort in homes that have good insulation is huge.
  1. Provide grants for homes to put in solar panels, wind turbines and ground source heat pumps. People can generate their own energy and sell surplus back to the grid. 100% grants for pensioners and people on low incomes?
  1. Provide tax savings for landlords to insulate rental properties.

That's before you look at bigger energy generation schemes, like wind and tidal power, which take longer to get operational. The UK is surrounded by seas which could produce massive amounts of energy for us on each tide.

GetThatHelmetOn · 27/05/2022 00:13

Trainfromredhill · 26/05/2022 22:40

figuring out a cut off that is fair to everyone

I don’t think anyone with a household income of over £200k could say they ‘needed’ £400. Some might even say £100k.
nothing in life is fair, but I’m not sure anyone with a household income of £100k is choosing between eating or heating….unless they are living way outside their means.

Oh well, it can always be argued that it is the people paying higher taxes the ones who are paying the most to subsidise us all. I really don’t think what I pay in taxes would be much help to help anyone 🤷🏻‍♀️

worriedatthistime · 27/05/2022 00:08

@InChocolateWeTrust then how would people who are unable to work get it , or below the threshold
And again its a lot more admin

worriedatthistime · 27/05/2022 00:07

@Cuckoo48 so what just becAuse you know a few pensioners who don't need it many many more do and is it so hard to understand sometimes mean testing is expensive
Plus if they are so well off they are still paying taxes so whats the issue

godmum56 · 27/05/2022 00:06

InChocolateWeTrust · 26/05/2022 23:37

They could have given it via a temporary increase to personal allowance. That way anyone earning over £100k would have had it clawed back.

again that takes admin and costs money