Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Every household?????

638 replies

Trainfromredhill · 26/05/2022 22:33

So, the chancellor is going to give every household £400 for heating. Surely there should be a cut off of household income? The Beckhams, Elton John, james Dyson, Harry styles…….they all get the money too? . I say this as someone in the fortunate position of not needing the £400- I’d much rather it went to someone who does need it.Just seems a huge waste of public money to give it to everyone

OP posts:
anotherbrewplease · 27/05/2022 06:25

At 100k your household is in the top few percent of earners and if you have to penny pinch on that it suggests you are terrible with money. You can very easily live on half that, you just need to make less expensive lifestyle choices and live within your meansWe have a combined income of 30,000 and live comfortably with no particular penny pinching. We don't get any benefits. We have 2 children in nursery as well

Very well said - and so true. We are a family of 5 and live on much less than £100k a year! And always have done - never been in debt.

And sorry to those that think I'm on a 'race to the bottom' or whatever. I like my job, but it's not a big earner as I work as a Band 5 in the NHS. We don't NEED a foreign holiday every year etc

sst1234 · 27/05/2022 06:16

This thread is bringing out those who are competitively claiming to live on the least amount of money. This attitude towards earnings is so bizarre. It’s nothing to be proud of that this country has such a tolerance for low pay. The fact the £100k is considered rich shows how far people have been duped into accepting low wages.

speakout · 27/05/2022 06:13

As I understand it will be a £400 reduction in our bill, not a cash payment.
Energy companes are recording record profits, and this is being passed on to the consumer .

daisychain01 · 27/05/2022 06:11

godmum56 · 27/05/2022 00:04

as I understand it the fuel 400 is going straight to the energy companies to apply against people's energy bills and the actual cash that people will receive will be paid via the pensions and benefits route. Its the fastest and most economical way to do it.

That sounds the most sensible way to do it.

SnackSizeRaisin · 27/05/2022 06:08

Hhoney · 26/05/2022 22:49

I’m probably in the bracket that misses out on everything but still has to penny pinch. My husband and I earn about £100k per year between us. We don’t get child benefit and are not eligible for the council tax refund.

We are struggling at the moment. After all bills paid we used to have about £400 left each month for non necessities (clothes, eating out, adding to savings, entertainment etc.) Our council tax has gone up by £60 a month, energy by £120 a month (will be more in winter) and food by about £150 a month. Other bills have risen too (childcare, insurance, fuel). We have nothing left at the end of each month anymore.

I’m grateful that I’ve not been left out of this benefit.

At 100k your household is in the top few percent of earners and if you have to penny pinch on that it suggests you are terrible with money. You can very easily live on half that, you just need to make less expensive lifestyle choices and live within your means

We have a combined income of 30,000 and live comfortably with no particular penny pinching. We don't get any benefits. We have 2 children in nursery as well.

FiddlefigOnTheRoof · 27/05/2022 06:05

I don’t see the problem - clearly it’s a practical decision. We will donate it to charity.

BalloonsAndWhistles · 27/05/2022 06:02

Hhoney · 26/05/2022 22:49

I’m probably in the bracket that misses out on everything but still has to penny pinch. My husband and I earn about £100k per year between us. We don’t get child benefit and are not eligible for the council tax refund.

We are struggling at the moment. After all bills paid we used to have about £400 left each month for non necessities (clothes, eating out, adding to savings, entertainment etc.) Our council tax has gone up by £60 a month, energy by £120 a month (will be more in winter) and food by about £150 a month. Other bills have risen too (childcare, insurance, fuel). We have nothing left at the end of each month anymore.

I’m grateful that I’ve not been left out of this benefit.

Exactly the same for us, almost word for word.

Emotionalsupportviper · 27/05/2022 06:02

It’s not unreasonable that net contributors to the system should get something back.

"Net contributors" like Jacob Rees-Mogg and Alan Sugar who have their business interests registered broad so they pay next to no tax here?

However, I agree that the administration costs would be huge and it's better that some wealthy leeches get it than children and vulnerable people suffer. However people with more than one home should not get more than one payment (if Daisies is right)

Please donate any cash you don't need to a food bank or similar charity, "Train

Morph22010 · 27/05/2022 06:00

Totally agree with the posts that it would be impossible to means test. There is no system in the country that knows all household incomes due to independent taxation which came in decades ago so they’d have to develop a whole new system to means test which would cost more than what they are paying out. Only system that knows household income is for people on certain existing benefit like universal credit but they are wanting the £400 to go to a larger range of people.

£300 to pensioners I believe is because in general pensioners use more heat as they are at home longer and have more chance of dying from cold than average person.

disabled people vary so I can see why it’s £150 and not higher as not all disabled people need in the same way not all pensioners need but it is impractical to look at every case, If disabled people are on certain other means tested benefit they will get more. They may be unable to live alone and with retired parents who get the £300. We get dla for my son but have a household income of £80k plus so don’t really need the £150 but I’m free to donate it elsewhere if I choose, that’s up to me. Dla is a gateway benefit as it opens up other support, so for example people in receipt of higher rate mobility dla automatically qualify for blue badge so that is why people may claim dla even if they don’t strictly need the money.

Emotionalsupportviper · 27/05/2022 05:57

PurpleDaisies · 26/05/2022 22:35

People with second homes get it twice.

I was wondering about that.

daisychain01 · 27/05/2022 05:52

RoomOfRequirement · 26/05/2022 22:35

I think it's usually because the admin costs of working out who is entitled and figuring out a cut off that is fair to everyone is more than the money they save.

I'd be supportive of the government giving the supplement to people on UC or other benefits. Yes it leaves out people who are border line but it's a quick way of stopping the most vulnerable from having to make the "eating or heating" choice.

I heard it was £100 per household. Has that changed?

comealongponds · 27/05/2022 05:45

Instinctively YANBU but practically means testing wouldn’t work (and given past experience of the Tories setting up things like this eg track and test, would be extremely expensive and inefficient)

if you’re rich enough to not need it then donate it to a food bank charity, bet most of the rich won’t do that though.

sst1234 · 27/05/2022 05:38

If you don’t want it, donate it. Somehow I don’t think you will though. In the meantime, quit with the faux outrage about being so well off that you are offended to receive it.

One-offs should be universal. It’s not unreasonable that net contributors to the system should get something back.

BracedlnEndIessJanuary · 27/05/2022 05:29

Admin effects all sorts - e.g. all those on free school meals before April 2018 got to keep them until next phase of school, irrespective of circumstances.
Anyone applying after that - the threshold was 7k. I earn 10k, 2 kids, that's not far off 100 quid a month if I wanted both to have a warm meal at lunchtime.
Child allowance - anyone over 50k high earner charge, two parents each earning 49k, still got it.
Just look at the admin involved for furlough, loans etc and how well that went.

MeanderingGently · 27/05/2022 05:18

Every household won't get it, I won't. I'm on a low income and I could really do with the money, £400 quid would make the world of difference to me. But I rent, I pay bills but they are included in the rent, utilities are a separate payment to the renting company, not to the utilities provider. Therefore I won't get any money back via my bills, and as the council tax is done the same, I won't get any there either.

I am 3 years off retirement; my job is heavily physical but I can't stop as I have would have nothing to pay the rent with if I did. I notice pensioners will get some extra money too, but I'm not there yet so I'll miss out on that as well. There must be plenty of people like me who will miss out because we don't fit into the system.....

GrumpyPanda · 27/05/2022 05:00

RoomOfRequirement · 26/05/2022 22:35

I think it's usually because the admin costs of working out who is entitled and figuring out a cut off that is fair to everyone is more than the money they save.

This. FWIW Germany does €300 per working taxpayer for transport rather than heating purposes. Not means tested since this would make the process too slow and expensive but to make up for it the whole payment will be taxable and tax progression is intended to make up for the missing means testing.

Zebedee55 · 27/05/2022 05:00

How and when these payments will be made:

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10857277/What-does-Rishi-Sunaks-15bn-cost-living-giveaway-mean-you.html

Scottishskifun · 27/05/2022 04:55

I actually voted YABU purely because the cost and logistics involved would take years to sort out who would be entitled for it and who wouldn't via HMRC.

People need this money off energy bills and not for a huge paperwork exercise and given a large chunk also going to he plunged into fuel poverty aren't those in receipt of benefits it would simply take too long.

UniversalAunt · 27/05/2022 04:32

Calling out the ageist claptrap & assumptions about pensioners.
Give it up.

Worried675 · 27/05/2022 03:33

Means testing costs more than any money saved by means testing. That's why it's often not done, i.e. Scottish baby box etc.

Villagewaspbyke · 27/05/2022 03:14

FrozZen · 27/05/2022 03:00

Jeez, I'm not looking for "some conspiracy". But, it is hard to ignore the facts. Please correct me if the share ownership details available on every single publicly traded global energy company are wrong. And explain how/why. Cheers.

What facts? Your post doesn’t make sense.

Share ownership details of public companies are public information and are freely available. They also change frequently as people buy and sell shares.

There are obviously many millions even billions of shares in issue but as I said, large listed companies are primarily owned by insurance companies and pension funds on behalf of their beneficiaries (people with life insurance or annuities in the case of insurance and pensioners and pension savers for pension funds). So likely You own some yourself at least beneficially.

Topseyt123 · 27/05/2022 03:05

I think it is fine. Anyone who doesn't want theirs can donate it to charity. Or give it to me.

FrozZen · 27/05/2022 03:00

Jeez, I'm not looking for "some conspiracy". But, it is hard to ignore the facts. Please correct me if the share ownership details available on every single publicly traded global energy company are wrong. And explain how/why. Cheers.

Villagewaspbyke · 27/05/2022 02:54

FrozZen · 27/05/2022 02:49

And why isn't there a single investigative journalist looking in to which politicians have shares in these power companies.......???? From every angle inc the Panama Papers etc. Then, folk might get a lot more cross than getting hairy about a few parties. It goes far deeper than getting pished in Downing Street. It is time Great Britain got a handle on governmental corruption. It affects ALL OF US and is rife. Disgustingly so.

Don’t be ridiculous. Oil and gas companies are generally large listed companies that are owned by pension funds and insurance companies. At the moment they are profiting because prices are up but they make losses when prices are down such as during Covid. That’s business. It’s not some big conspiracy.

the80sweregreat · 27/05/2022 02:53

Ten billion is coming from the government, not the energy companies ( its all on another thread) I wasn't actually aware of this. 5 bil is the windfall tax part.
For such a big giveaway from a conservative government is incredible.