Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Every household?????

638 replies

Trainfromredhill · 26/05/2022 22:33

So, the chancellor is going to give every household £400 for heating. Surely there should be a cut off of household income? The Beckhams, Elton John, james Dyson, Harry styles…….they all get the money too? . I say this as someone in the fortunate position of not needing the £400- I’d much rather it went to someone who does need it.Just seems a huge waste of public money to give it to everyone

OP posts:
Seymour5 · 31/05/2022 13:03

Babyroobs · 30/05/2022 19:59

He could definitely look at claiming Attendance Allowance if he has health conditions which mean he needs help with personal care etc. in my experience it's a lot easier to get than DLA/ PIP etc. Speak to AGE uk, they can send you a factsheet and help with form filling if needed.

Thanks, but his personal care, mobility etc is pretty much ok. He is in no pain, just has a dodgy ticker and needs to take things steady. Hence being at home a lot, and needing warmth, like many older people. I’m involved locally with Age UK, and familiar with the help thats available. He wouldn’t qualify.

After being unaware when he was seriously ill in his 50s about benefits like DLA, I’ve educated myself. I learnt (too late) he should have had care and mobility elements for at least a couple of years when he had a serious heart attack, when angina meant he could only walk a few yards, then when he was slowly recovering from open heart surgery. The effect of that illness meant his income went down considerably afterwards, with the knock on effect on any extra pension. DLA would have helped immensely, but as I worked we thought we just had to soldier on.

Alexandra2001 · 31/05/2022 09:01

Morph22010 · 30/05/2022 22:43

Put more in a pension scheme as you can deduct pension contributions in calculating your earnings for high interest child benefit purposes

These posts do illustrate the folly of £400 for everyone.

Whilst many are struggling with heating or eating, plenty of others are talking about higher income effecting CB and paying extra into their pension schemes..... yet will still be getting the £400.

Meanwhile, Cornwall council is selling off for development, all its outdoor leisure centres.... got no money.... some of these places have taught children how to swim, climb, canoe etc for generations but plenty of cash to buy off Con voters.

Morph22010 · 30/05/2022 22:43

breadwidow · 30/05/2022 21:52

@rainingsnoring just seen you replied to my post on child benefit- that's me, just sneaked over £60k and I'm tempted to cut my hrs to keep the benefit as with that loss plus tax I'm no better off being promoted!

It also really pisses me if it's done on income if one parent not the household - my DH earns very little yet we lose it, couple who both earn £49k each get to keep the lot

Put more in a pension scheme as you can deduct pension contributions in calculating your earnings for high interest child benefit purposes

breadwidow · 30/05/2022 21:52

@rainingsnoring just seen you replied to my post on child benefit- that's me, just sneaked over £60k and I'm tempted to cut my hrs to keep the benefit as with that loss plus tax I'm no better off being promoted!

It also really pisses me if it's done on income if one parent not the household - my DH earns very little yet we lose it, couple who both earn £49k each get to keep the lot

Babyroobs · 30/05/2022 19:59

Seymour5 · 30/05/2022 17:42

Pensioner couple here, in a band B house. Neither of us has enough in pensions to pay income tax, so we’re far from well off. However, we’re just too well off to receive Pension Credit. DH has a limiting condition that means he feels the cold, and rarely goes out, so our heating bills are quite high. He never claimed DLA, and once you’re over state pension age, forget it.

We’re grateful for the extra £300.

He could definitely look at claiming Attendance Allowance if he has health conditions which mean he needs help with personal care etc. in my experience it's a lot easier to get than DLA/ PIP etc. Speak to AGE uk, they can send you a factsheet and help with form filling if needed.

Seymour5 · 30/05/2022 17:42

Pensioner couple here, in a band B house. Neither of us has enough in pensions to pay income tax, so we’re far from well off. However, we’re just too well off to receive Pension Credit. DH has a limiting condition that means he feels the cold, and rarely goes out, so our heating bills are quite high. He never claimed DLA, and once you’re over state pension age, forget it.

We’re grateful for the extra £300.

Morph22010 · 30/05/2022 07:18

@TigerRag i do appreciate I am in a lot more of a fortunate position financially than others, I know lots of parents who have had to give up work due to difficulties with schooling etc. We have just fallen lucky in that the school he is in we have found jobs that we can work round him so we can do drop offs and pickup as there is no childcare availability. I do feel like I’m running round like a headless chicken all the time and it is really stressful and I could do with cutting down hours but I am really worried about Ds’s future and especially when he leaves school as we will no longer both then be able to work as he’ll need supervision so im trying to save as much as I can and pay into my pension whilst I have the opportunity to be earning this amount. We get middle rate care and lower rate mobility for Ds so it’s around £380 every 4 weeks and then I also get £250 a month travel allowance from the la for taking him to school. But then things like child care, if you can find, cost alot more than for non disabled kids. Last year I paid an extra £50 a day for a 1-1 at a holiday club on top of the usual fee that other kids pay so that’s the kind of thing the dla goes towards

TigerRag · 30/05/2022 06:49

Morph22010 · 30/05/2022 05:09

@Rosscameasdoody i have a disabled child who we get dla for but as he is in school we both work around school hours and I earn £60k dh earns £25k so our household income is £85k so we are an example of why all disabled people don’t need extra £150as dla is not means tested. If disabled people/ families with a disabled child have a lower income and do need the money then they will probably also be on another means tested benefit like universal credit. Before people start saying we shouldn’t claim Dla is not just a financial benefit it also entitles you to other support that is not financial, lots of places you have to show dla as proof, or for example you can get a blue badge if you have high rate mobility dla.

If only your situation was the same as everyone elses.

It, according to Scope, costs on average £583 per month extra for a disabled person. Whilst that £150 will help, it won't go far.

Morph22010 · 30/05/2022 05:09

@Rosscameasdoody i have a disabled child who we get dla for but as he is in school we both work around school hours and I earn £60k dh earns £25k so our household income is £85k so we are an example of why all disabled people don’t need extra £150as dla is not means tested. If disabled people/ families with a disabled child have a lower income and do need the money then they will probably also be on another means tested benefit like universal credit. Before people start saying we shouldn’t claim Dla is not just a financial benefit it also entitles you to other support that is not financial, lots of places you have to show dla as proof, or for example you can get a blue badge if you have high rate mobility dla.

Rosscameasdoody · 29/05/2022 22:34

Morph22010 · 29/05/2022 11:50

If it’s going to be paid for many years to come then I think a completely different system needs to be developed, but that will take time and this payout is just a crude sticking plaster so it can be done quickly. I completely agree with you about our situation and that it needs to be better targeted. Back when Ds was born in 2010 we were entitled to a low amount of tax credits, I wasn’t on the income I am now but still a decent salary. This was under the labour government and I recall your household income could be relatively high and you still got the basic level of tax credit. Maybe something like this could be brought back as it would collect data on household income and allow targeted extra payments to be made as and when. But then this wouldn’t be fair to single people with no children and it’s just as expensive for them to heat a house. The arguement against tax credits being operated like this was that what was the point In taxing people to then give them money back you might as well just increase the tax allowances so they could earn more before paying.

i don’t know the answer. There were complaints up thread about disabled people only being entitled to £150 when pensioners were entItled to £300 but then my particular situation demonstrates why all disabled people don’t need a higher a higher amount.

it’s just so complicated once you start thinking it all through, whatever system there is always people that gain and people that lose out.

How does your situation demonstrate why disabled people don’t’ t need a higher amount ? Sorry, you’ve lost me.

Threadkill · 29/05/2022 22:16

Also, energy prices are approaching their second peak and I think (personally) will come down afterwards as demand destruction (energy becoming simply too expensive to use) kicks in and Ukraine situation eventually gets resolved (prob around same time as Boris leaves number 10 and Trump gets back into Whitehouse) and China goes into recession dragging world with it. But I wouldn’t bet my house on this prediction! However, remember that a mere year ago oil prices where negative! Oil producers were having to pay refineries to take it off their hands). Things can change v quickly in this ole world.

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 29/05/2022 22:13

GuildfordAngel · 29/05/2022 13:53

As far as I am aware, 2nd homes will not receive the payment.

How so? It’s coming off bills, how’s anyone going to know which bill is for a second home?

mybiggestfan · 29/05/2022 22:07

I agree that in an ideal situation it would be means tested, however this would cost more to administrate than simply giving it to us all. I dont need the money I will put my £400 into the local food bank. Hopefully others will follow suit.

Threadkill · 29/05/2022 22:00

And rich aren’t going to buy more gas/electric cos they’ve got more money, so they won’t be driving up energy prices. Youonly use as mich fuel as u need.

Threadkill · 29/05/2022 21:57

Yup, council tax bands are really old and outsated and base on 1980’s values. I agree that giving money to the rich won’t fuel inflation cos inflation for rich is lower. Poorer peoples inflation fueled by energy costs and food prices this time round. As a proportion of income rich spend far less on energy and basic foods. If you buy a loaf of bread from Gails at £7 you won’t notice the 10p increase as much as someone buying a packet of white sliced for 99p from Iceland. It’s all relative.

rainingsnoring · 29/05/2022 18:47

Alexandra2001 · 29/05/2022 16:30

@rainingsnoring
I agree that energy prices are likely to remain high. However, do you think it is likely that the government will continue with subsidies in this form because of that? I agree that any additional support needs to be targeted

Yes, the numbers who will go into energy debt will be huge and will increase over time, so the Govt will a: be forced to bail out the billing companies and b; provide more targeted and greater support to the poorest, probably in the form of reduced tariffs, which the energy companies will administer.

So, as the real need will be from winter, it means the Govt has a few months to introduce a more targeted system.

However, we shouldn't forget that the monies on offer aren't just to help the poor, its to help the Tories win the next GE, so they'll be no change.

The government seem to think that the high energy prices will magically come down and don't seem to be in the habit of making long term plans at all.

I have already said more than once on this thread that I think the universal nature of this is a bung to the Tory's usual voting core.

Rosscameasdoody · 29/05/2022 18:14

Alexandra2001 · 29/05/2022 10:35

I think the point you are missing is that a: this payment is in two installments and b: is likely to be being paid for many more years to come, so coming up with a different system is a must or do you think we should keep handing out billions to folk who do not need it for the next few years......

Energy prices are highly unlikely to be coming down to anything like pre 2021 levels, far more likely to keep increasing.

Your household income makes perfectly the argument that that handing out taxpayers money to the wealthier in society is nuts.

One solution would be to increase the criteria for UC and make payments based on the benefits system, therefore increasing the numbers getting real help.

And how would increasing the criteria for UC help people on other benefits ? Such as disability benefits for example ? The benefits system - as has been pointed out ad infinitude - is not the best way to determine who is in need and who is not. The thresholds and tapers for means tested benefits are set so low that families who struggle will continue to do so because they earn a pound or two over the threshold to qualify and miss out on substantial help. Until we come up with an alternative to outdated and damaging means testing the solution will continue to be a universal payment to catch those who lose out. Those people lucky enough not to need the universal payment can always donate it to their local food bank or charity so that it’s redistributed to those who need it. Yep

Nothappyatwork · 29/05/2022 18:00

Morph22010 · 29/05/2022 16:48

It is a credit on the energy account but if you have that credit it makes other money available for you to spend that you would have been spending on energy, I don’t mean it in a bad way, so for example kids could be desperate for clothes or there could be household things that have broken and need replacing that people just can’t afford

The £400 is going to be a credit on the energy account, the £650 is going to be paid via benefits to be spent on whatever it is that the parents want it spent on that may or may not be fuel.

Morph22010 · 29/05/2022 16:48

Alexandra2001 · 29/05/2022 16:33

@Morph22010 I thought the 400 was a credit on their account? but you re right, the real risk is the additional 650 will be spent and not on energy.

I'd like to have seen a targeted scheme to insulate properties, this ultimately (for many people) will mean a real reduction in energy use.

It is a credit on the energy account but if you have that credit it makes other money available for you to spend that you would have been spending on energy, I don’t mean it in a bad way, so for example kids could be desperate for clothes or there could be household things that have broken and need replacing that people just can’t afford

Alexandra2001 · 29/05/2022 16:33

@Morph22010 I thought the 400 was a credit on their account? but you re right, the real risk is the additional 650 will be spent and not on energy.

I'd like to have seen a targeted scheme to insulate properties, this ultimately (for many people) will mean a real reduction in energy use.

Alexandra2001 · 29/05/2022 16:30

@rainingsnoring
I agree that energy prices are likely to remain high. However, do you think it is likely that the government will continue with subsidies in this form because of that? I agree that any additional support needs to be targeted

Yes, the numbers who will go into energy debt will be huge and will increase over time, so the Govt will a: be forced to bail out the billing companies and b; provide more targeted and greater support to the poorest, probably in the form of reduced tariffs, which the energy companies will administer.

So, as the real need will be from winter, it means the Govt has a few months to introduce a more targeted system.

However, we shouldn't forget that the monies on offer aren't just to help the poor, its to help the Tories win the next GE, so they'll be no change.

Morph22010 · 29/05/2022 16:29

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 29/05/2022 15:19

And @Threadkill there are 4.5m houses in bands e-g so plenty of wastage.

It's doubly bad because giving a nice bit of extra cash they don't need to these wealthy households will fuel inflation, which is the problem we're trying to solve.

But it wins Tory votes.

Giving to wealthy households won’t fuel inflation as if people are wealthy enough they will buy what they want to buy anyway not just because they have an extra £400, they’ll prob just end up putting in savings. It’s more likely to fuel inflation by being given to poorer or middle income people who are more likely to go out and spend the extra cash that they didn’t have available before. Btw I’m not using this to say who should and shouldn’t have just that it won’t fuel inflation by giving to richer people

Morph22010 · 29/05/2022 16:18

Nothappyatwork · 29/05/2022 09:18

Do you and your £60,000 partner live in the same household and are registered to the same address yes or no ?
anybody who lives in my house who earns £60,000 a year would be contributing towards the bills if they’re not you need to kick them out because you’re gonna lose out on the £400 top up under my rules.

absolutely ludicrous to suggest that we work upon the lowest common denominator for handing out tax payers cash. If you can’t get your male or female partner to contribute fairly towards your bills that’s your problem not ours as a society which is why we changed the rules on child benefit which incidentally is the same system that HMRC use.

Yes we live in same house since 1999. It’s not him that earns £60k it’s me, he earns 25k, he’s pays mortgage and I pay bills, buy food etc so I wouldn’t get £400 on your system based on myself which I don’t actually have an issue with. I just think the system wouldn’t work or would take a hell of a lot of human input to make it work, not sure of your background, maybe you work for hmrc but you do seem to have a lot more faith in the accuracy of hmrc’s data than I do, perhaps I have become jaded having worked I tax for 27 years and seeing some of the cock ups made. I think addresses in particular aren’t accurate as they have been entered in various formats over the years so difficult to search and match up when same address. If hmrc have to employ a team of 10 or 20 extra people to deal with queries when computer is saying no and it shouldn’t then that’s going to eat into the £400 a household saving. At the minute under the proposed system all the admin is pushed onto the electricity company. If it’s an ongoing thing then they really need to think of another way.

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 29/05/2022 16:02

It's not perfect to use council tax bands but it's an existing assessment that relates to the value of where you're living (so no admin cost). Surely better than giving everyone the same despite enormous disparity's in what people have.

Maybe there should be more help for older people to release equity? When my mum was in a home we got a drawdown from the council against her house. Why not extend that scheme so people with high value housing assets can use them to make life more comfortable?

JenniferWooley · 29/05/2022 15:49

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 29/05/2022 15:16

@Threadkill
But they could have stuck with council tax bands. Had a sliding scale so A gets 600 b gets 500 c gets 450 d400 and the rest nothing.

Then those with the least get the most and those with expensive houses who can live without government help don't get any.

And if you're in a band e-g and struggling you can downgrade housing.

My 2 bed with no garden housing association flat is band C & I have a total household income of £28,000, my nieces 4 bed on a corner plot with huge garden ex-council house is band B they have a household income of £75,000 - council tax bands don't always translate to the size/value of the property or the household income.