Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Every household?????

638 replies

Trainfromredhill · 26/05/2022 22:33

So, the chancellor is going to give every household £400 for heating. Surely there should be a cut off of household income? The Beckhams, Elton John, james Dyson, Harry styles…….they all get the money too? . I say this as someone in the fortunate position of not needing the £400- I’d much rather it went to someone who does need it.Just seems a huge waste of public money to give it to everyone

OP posts:
FlyingPandas · 27/05/2022 08:07

Agree that the logistics, cost and political debate around linking to income would be so complex and costly that it’s most likely not worth it.

Also agree that those who don’t need it should consider passing it on. We are in the hugely fortunate position of not needing it so will make an equivalent donation to charities most likely to help those struggling in the current situation (ie food bank, Mind etc).

coffeecupsandfairylights · 27/05/2022 08:07

ReginaGeorgeismyname · 27/05/2022 08:02

Median UK household income in 2021 was 31k

I'm certain that is an average salary across the UK. Not an average household income

I stand by my point. If it is enough to live on why do people get universal credit top up on 30k? It isn't enough.

Not everyone does.

RockAndOrRoll · 27/05/2022 08:07

This is bribery money and I strongly oppose why this government is doing what it is doing. I genuinely believe that we have never seen such a badly behaved government and that, as a result of their attitude to all forms of decency, they remain the biggest threat to the country and democracy. That giving money to distract from their utter corrupt and reprehensible behaviour is just playing the only tune they know: that it is ok to give (or take) money in return for a blind eye.

That said, there are a millions different ways people can, do and are struggling with the cost of living. I don't know them or their circumstances and I cannot find it in me to begrudge them £400 (or £300). If it is genuinely surplus to their need, it'll find it's way back into 'the system' anyway because they will spend it.

What's the figure? Something like, for every £1 the government gives, it gets back 75p eventually through various taxes - as that money passes through various hands.

Plus, it's funded by a windfall tax: the windfall having been created by everyone paying more for their energy. So, in this specific case, it does not seem unfair that everyone gets some of that profit back.

Albgo · 27/05/2022 08:06

@Hhoney no, you're really not. There are so may people in a totally different bracket than you are. For example, between my husband and myself our income is less than £25k a year. We literally get no help and are massively struggling. I know lots of families in similar positions. £100k per year does not class as struggling. You honestly don't know how lucky you are.

perenniallymessy · 27/05/2022 08:04

I think they should be using the money to reduce the standing charge (which disproportionately affects those who try to limit their energy use) and provide support to insulate homes.

The standing charge increase is awful and we are all paying for the failed energy companies because ofgem and the government didn't put rules or checks in place that the energy companies could meet their commitments.

They could also reduce the green levies (environmental and social levy that helps pay for the warm home scheme as well as paying for green initiatives such as insulation) on bills and shift those costs back to the oil and gas companies rather than the consumer.

The oil and gas companies should permanently have extra tax on oil and gas profits that they could mitigate with super tax reliefs for investments in green energy.

shivawn · 27/05/2022 08:02

Isn’t it nice that sometimes those paying the most tax get something back very occasionally?

This. 100%.

ReginaGeorgeismyname · 27/05/2022 08:02

Median UK household income in 2021 was 31k

I'm certain that is an average salary across the UK. Not an average household income

I stand by my point. If it is enough to live on why do people get universal credit top up on 30k? It isn't enough.

SnackSizeRaisin · 27/05/2022 07:59

ReginaGeorgeismyname · 27/05/2022 07:46

Anyway 30k is not a low household income. It's around average. Most people manage perfectly well on that sort of amount.

No. 30k is an average salary, not an average household. Many households will have two people earning that.

If its so easy to manage on 30k why are people with kids with a household income of 30k getting universal credit? The answer is because its not enough money these days as housing costs a fortune!

No one is saying 100k household is poor. But they aren't rolling in it once you factor in childcare and housing. Comfortable I'm sure, but 100k for say a family of 4 is not rich these days

I guess it depends where you live. Where we are, nice suburban area in the north west, housing costs are not too bad and certainly affordable for households with 2 working adults even if they are on min wage.

Median UK household income in 2021 was 31k

SnackSizeRaisin · 27/05/2022 07:54

ATadConfused · 27/05/2022 06:35

@SnackSizeRaisin I'm glad you're currently comfortable & hope you remain so with the Oct price rise on energy, food costs going up & fuel.

But how the hell do you do it?

what's your housing situation & how much is your childcare? Trying not to ask deeply personal questions, so I hope those questions are ok?

Private rented at 700 a month (nice area in north west 3 bed with garden and garage). Have savings of few months salary. Have workplace pensions. 1 old car. Nursery cost 36 pounds a day for 1 child (preschool) and private nursery 50 pounds a day for the younger one. They go 2 days each. No family childcare help. I work quite a bit in the evenings which I guess is a downside. We haven't had many holidays recently due to kids and COVID. Don't spend much on clothes haircuts make up consumer goods, furniture is all second hand cheap or free. Kids stuff mostly second hand. Second hand phones on five pounds a month contract. No TV subscriptions. Never go into debt for anything so no interest to pay off. We like nice food so spend 100 per week plus the odd meal out. Lots of cafes. Drink normal amounts of alcohol. Luckily we signed up for a fixed rate energy tarriff until 2024 so hoping not too badly affected by increases there, but that would be a concern otherwise.

Morph22010 · 27/05/2022 07:52

Alexandra2001 · 27/05/2022 07:32

hmrc know what individuals earn not households. The money is not being given to individuals it is being given to households. You could have one partner earning hundreds of thousands and the other not working at all, plus adult children not working

Sorry but households don't have a bank account, this is 400 per uk address but it will have a name to the payee, probably male and spent before the main childcare provider gets it.

This is not about helping the poor but as a bribe to the middle classes to keep the faith.... Cash out to Splash out :(

it is being given as a credit on fuel bills not paid into bank accounts so will benefit whoever it is who usually pays the fuel bills in the household. The increases linked to benefits will be paid to whoever usually gets the benefits. Who it goes to will depend on your household set up. In my household I pay the bills (dh pays mortgage) and I take receipt of ds’s dla so I’ll get his £150 too, i am female. I understand financial abuse will mainly be against females but I think that’s a whole bigger issue they can’t tackle with this mass roll out, they’d have to interview every household in the country and then prob end up still making the wrong decision

ReginaGeorgeismyname · 27/05/2022 07:46

Anyway 30k is not a low household income. It's around average. Most people manage perfectly well on that sort of amount.

No. 30k is an average salary, not an average household. Many households will have two people earning that.

If its so easy to manage on 30k why are people with kids with a household income of 30k getting universal credit? The answer is because its not enough money these days as housing costs a fortune!

No one is saying 100k household is poor. But they aren't rolling in it once you factor in childcare and housing. Comfortable I'm sure, but 100k for say a family of 4 is not rich these days

Littlegoth · 27/05/2022 07:44

I don’t begrudge it going to everyone. It’s fair. There are additional payments to those most in need.

if you don’t need it and you wish it could go to someone more needy, then pass it on.

ifonly4 · 27/05/2022 07:43

Understand where you're coming from OP, but we all have difference circumstances and the logistical problem of the government trying to work out the exact amount that people really can't be struggling is hard.

Just hope anything who genuinely doesn't need it or would rather it goes to a household really struggling, feel they can donate it to a charity or by food for the a food bank. My friend is well off and gave her children the challenge of considering what people using the foodbank really needed and chosing a bagful of food each to donate, which she paid for. She reckons she'll be doing it again with the latest rebate.

Despinetta · 27/05/2022 07:42

Presumably it's cheaper to give it to everybody than to means test it. DH and I discussed this yesterday and agreed we'd donate ours to a local food bank.

Pippainthegarden · 27/05/2022 07:40

Tomanyhandbags · 26/05/2022 22:40

If you genuinely don't need the payment you can always give it to a charity such as a local food bank or somewhere else that will benefit households in need.

Exactly, I have people who complain about universal benefits just because they don’t need them rather than do exactly this! Each household’s circumstances are different, I actually had far more disposable income as a single mother on benefits than as current blended family with child maintenance going out, a large family to house etc, however we are not considered low income because children not resident full time aren’t counted. There will be other families that have high mortgages, undiagnosed disability, students, all manner of reasons why they don’t receive means tested benefits but are not actually any better off than those on benefits. Far more people will genuinely benefit from a universal system. Not only this, people who are struggling and paying taxes do tend to get a bit miffed when they are always just outside the threshold for receiving help and can’t blame them for thinking they may as well just make sure they keep under it. Just be thankful your lucky enough to not need it and donate it to charity

user1471542288 · 27/05/2022 07:39

Why don’t they exclude people paying higher rate tax? An easy way to means test as HMRC have this information.

Mrsmch123 · 27/05/2022 07:39

Im glad that I finally get something back from the government. Sick of being told I "earn to much". Why shouldn't I receive what everyone else does🤷🏻‍♀️I pay enough in to the system!

SnackSizeRaisin · 27/05/2022 07:36

sst1234 · 27/05/2022 06:16

This thread is bringing out those who are competitively claiming to live on the least amount of money. This attitude towards earnings is so bizarre. It’s nothing to be proud of that this country has such a tolerance for low pay. The fact the £100k is considered rich shows how far people have been duped into accepting low wages.

100k is considered rich compared to the average. If everyone earns more then everything costs more. There are only rich people because there are poorer people doing vital work for low pay. If checkout workers and factory workers get paid more then goods cost more. If nurses get more tax will need to go up to pay for it.

Anyway 30k is not a low household income. It's around average. Most people manage perfectly well on that sort of amount. If you are lucky enough to earn more then good for you, however please don't claim to be poor.

JudgeRindersMinder · 27/05/2022 07:35

RoomOfRequirement · 26/05/2022 22:35

I think it's usually because the admin costs of working out who is entitled and figuring out a cut off that is fair to everyone is more than the money they save.

I think it’s this too.

carefullycourageous · 27/05/2022 07:34

oviraptor21 · 27/05/2022 07:28

You can. Just donate the same amount to the cause of your choice.

A good cause currently, I would suggest, is to the Lib Dems Tiverton campaign, or the Labour party Wakefield campaign Grin

Alexandra2001 · 27/05/2022 07:32

hmrc know what individuals earn not households. The money is not being given to individuals it is being given to households. You could have one partner earning hundreds of thousands and the other not working at all, plus adult children not working

Sorry but households don't have a bank account, this is 400 per uk address but it will have a name to the payee, probably male and spent before the main childcare provider gets it.

This is not about helping the poor but as a bribe to the middle classes to keep the faith.... Cash out to Splash out :(

oviraptor21 · 27/05/2022 07:28

bbqhulahoop · 26/05/2022 22:37

YANBU, but the people you've referenced either vote Tory or don't vote 🤦🏼‍♀️ I def won't be voting for them either way. Wish yuu could defer your payment to nhs/ education etc

You can. Just donate the same amount to the cause of your choice.

carefullycourageous · 27/05/2022 07:28

Anonnnnnnm · 27/05/2022 07:16

@Alexandra2001 you ignored the fact that people on higher incomes contribute more to society. Like it or not, it's fact. Therefore, I'll be keeping my £400.

Declaring something to be 'fact' does not make it so. Trickle down has been completely disproven. Higher earners do not contribute more, some pay more tax but many also hoard more rather than spending, pollute more and often behave in antisocial ways such as avoiding (some to the point of evading and some beyond the point of evading) tax.

A society with fewer extremely high earners, more progressive taxation and greater equality along the model of scandinavian economies would be better for all of us.

Keep your £400 if keeping money matters to you. I personally already intended to donate my £150 council tax rebate even though I am a not close to being a high earner, I have yet to decide what I will do with any other funds.

StridTheKiller · 27/05/2022 07:27

I wish more people thought like you OP, unfortunately we are a greedy grabby society.
£400 will go nowhere towards helping the poorest.

AngelinaFibres · 27/05/2022 07:27

Trainfromredhill · 26/05/2022 22:47

@ShirleyPhallus . I don’t share your view. DH and I are both very high earners. £400 makes absolutely zero difference to our day to day living…….so no, I don’t view it as ‘getting something back’ I just see it as misspent money. And I don’t agree that it isn’t taking anything away from anyone else……this will all have to be recouped to pay the growing national debt……so someone somewhere will be paying it back(and you can bet if the tories are still in power it won’t be the high earners paying it back).

If you don't need it then donate it. I expect a lot of people who are comfortably off will do just that.