Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Every household?????

638 replies

Trainfromredhill · 26/05/2022 22:33

So, the chancellor is going to give every household £400 for heating. Surely there should be a cut off of household income? The Beckhams, Elton John, james Dyson, Harry styles…….they all get the money too? . I say this as someone in the fortunate position of not needing the £400- I’d much rather it went to someone who does need it.Just seems a huge waste of public money to give it to everyone

OP posts:
JanetPluchinsky · 27/05/2022 09:42

autienotnaughty · 27/05/2022 09:38

Yep surely there should be a limit say those over 100k not eligible seems ridiculous that the government is lining the pockets of the rich.

£100k to house and feed a family in the south east is not rich.

We have a £400k mortgage on a very normal sized house. Our bills alone come to £4K a month and that’s without the support we send DS at Uni. We both work all the hours under the sun to earn our money, we have no savings and no spare cash. No foreign holidays, our car is 10yrs old. The occasional takeaway as a treat is about as luxury as our lives get.

bubblesbubbles11 · 27/05/2022 09:42

"I think it's usually because the admin costs of working out who is entitled and figuring out a cut off that is fair to everyone is more than the money they save"

Maybe I am being thick here. But what have I missed from the following albeit blunt instrument alternative?

Everyone whose house is valued on zoopla above X / everyone who pays council tax Y or above in their local area is still entitled to the £400 but they have to actively apply for it via some government administered form online or by postoffice hard copy return form.
Immediately filters out those who (i) are so wealthy they do not need it (ii) are wealthy enough that they cannot be bothered with the hassle (iii) could be bothered but not for £400 which is not a significant enough amount to make it worth the admin.

Everyone else in the country who falls below/outside the above gets the payment automatically.
I really cannot see how the admin costs of something like the above is going to be more than the amount which would be saved by the number of well off people who would by default fall into (i), (ii) or (iii) above.

What is wrong with that?

ShirleyPhallus · 27/05/2022 09:39

orwellwasright · 27/05/2022 09:30

Earning £100k comes with a different set of expenses basically

Don't be ridiculous. Of course it doesn't. What you spend your money on is a choice. Higher mortgage? You chose to buy a bigger house. Ditto bills. Higher childcare costs? You chose to have children/more children. Higher food costs? You chose to shop somewhere expensive and buy expensive food etc. etc.

A very common attitude on Mumsnet - which thankfully I don't come across outside of this website - is how much wealthy people just constantly whine about their circumstances. There's this perpetual hard-done-by whinge that people don't understand how difficult their lives are and they need special safe spaces to discuss what a burden having lots of money is.

What a burden having lots of money is

It isn’t a burden if you’re constantly taxed to the hilt on absolutely everything, because you don’t have it to keep it, it’s used for taxes. You know, to make payments to those lower earners who receive benefits. You also made choices - a choice to do a lower paid job / not train / have children earlier, and presumably you also have a choice whether to accept the benefits that higher tax payers top up.

Not really nice criticism either way is it?

autienotnaughty · 27/05/2022 09:38

Yep surely there should be a limit say those over 100k not eligible seems ridiculous that the government is lining the pockets of the rich.

SpeckledlyHen · 27/05/2022 09:38

AuntieStella · 27/05/2022 09:35

It's expensive to means test properly, and proxies are invariably flawed

I'd rather see a fund set up for people to return the money if they do not need it.

A bit like Age Concern has had for years for winter fuel payments, but with more oomph

That's a good idea. Although I think there will still be loads of people who don't need the money that will take it anyway.

Cornettoninja · 27/05/2022 09:38

Topgub · 27/05/2022 08:52

So basically the tories are using billions of tax payers money and giving it to the energy companies who are ripping us off and telling us we should be grateful?

Are they having an actual laugh?

This the most ridiculous and pointless idea I have ever heard.

What about next year? And the year after?

When they double prices again to recoup the 5 billion they are 'paying'

If the tories actually wanted to fo something they could keep the cap as it was, introduce rent control and link wages/ increase mw

Anyone who continues to vote tory after this year really needs to ask themselves exactly what it is they're voting for

I completely agree. This isn’t anything that’s remotely helpful in a sustainable way.

Imho we need reductions in VAT (the treasury is profiting from higher prices so they wouldn’t see any massive change to their bottom line - 20% of 200 is more than 20% of 100) which would equally benefit businesses and food prices, caps on energy companies standing charges so peoples usage actually makes a real difference to their outgoings and a review of temporary changes to the green tax to be reviewed on an ongoing basis till fuel and energy prices stabilise.

Giving my energy company £400 to ‘credit my account’ is bs. I want help to budget this over the next couple of years, preferably with measures that have a positive ripple effect on other prices.

This cabinet have basically handed £15 billion to the energy companies and pretended it’s going to help out household budgets. This is the exact opposite of good fiscal management. From tories who like to crow about how good they are with the economy yet make baffling economic decisions.

Rishi has basically just spunked £15bn of our money up the wall and achieved precisely fuck all but a sound bite.

SpeckledlyHen · 27/05/2022 09:37

I couldn't agree more but if the cost of means testing means that people who need the money get less then I would rather it this way. I am in the fortunate position of not needing the £400 - it is difficult to know what to do, the only thing I can think of is spending that money in a supermarket for the food back - or donating directly to the food bank (I do both of these anyhow, but would up the amounts).

MargaretThursday · 27/05/2022 09:35

My parents feel the same about the winter fuel bill. They donate it back to a charity that helps people who are struggling with fuel bills.

AuntieStella · 27/05/2022 09:35

It's expensive to means test properly, and proxies are invariably flawed

I'd rather see a fund set up for people to return the money if they do not need it.

A bit like Age Concern has had for years for winter fuel payments, but with more oomph

Lex345 · 27/05/2022 09:33

I don't think I am pathetic for being grateful. Would you rather I stomp and complain I am poor, say it isn't enough and its not fair?

I have never and will never vote Tory. But that doesn't mean I shouldn't be grateful for whatever help I might get. It feels bad enough to really need help without being labelled pathetic for being grateful

40andlols · 27/05/2022 09:33

You don't really have a choice but to spend min £1500 on rent and min £2000 on childcare, min £400 bills, min £400 food and so on. It's not big luxury houses or nannies or M&S delivery etc.

People will say "move to a cheaper part of the country" and all of that but if your support network, job, non resident parent etc. is in london you can't simply move.

Justkidding55 · 27/05/2022 09:31

Desperate to buy themselves some of our favour now that they are undoubtedly the most corrupt government there is.

BunsyGirl · 27/05/2022 09:31

@Badgirlgonegood you haven’t answered the question and clearly don’t understand economics…if everyone lived in the same cheap area of the country it wouldn’t be cheap anymore…and not everyone can pack up and move 100 miles away due to their personal circumstances (children from previous relationships, elderly and vulnerable relatives to care for, job may not exist in other parts of the country…) I am sick to my back teeth of people assuming that people can live a life of luxury on a certain income when it is just not possible in some parts of the country.

PineappleWilson · 27/05/2022 09:31

People who have arrears because they've been struggling to pay the bills thus far will have it eaten up by arrears, so not only do people who really don't need it get £400, people on desperate need are likely to not see the benefit at all as it will just go towards filling that black hole.

orwellwasright · 27/05/2022 09:30

Earning £100k comes with a different set of expenses basically

Don't be ridiculous. Of course it doesn't. What you spend your money on is a choice. Higher mortgage? You chose to buy a bigger house. Ditto bills. Higher childcare costs? You chose to have children/more children. Higher food costs? You chose to shop somewhere expensive and buy expensive food etc. etc.

A very common attitude on Mumsnet - which thankfully I don't come across outside of this website - is how much wealthy people just constantly whine about their circumstances. There's this perpetual hard-done-by whinge that people don't understand how difficult their lives are and they need special safe spaces to discuss what a burden having lots of money is.

the80sweregreat · 27/05/2022 09:30

I cannot give my 400 to charity as it will be sitting in my energy companies bank account ( earning them interest)
The 150 from the council tax rebate went towards normal bills and food.
I do give to charity, but it won't be 400 as I will need that for the fuel bills this winter.
It would have been even more controversial to have given every household 400 pounds straight up so they are doing it this way instead.

Topgub · 27/05/2022 09:27

@Anonnnnnnm

Youre not getting £400. Your energy provider is

And if you dont have any disposable income on 100k then thats down to your own choices, innit

Anonnnnnnm · 27/05/2022 09:22

NewbieDivergent · 27/05/2022 09:16

I cant believe there's a poster complaining they are struggling on 100k a year,my family have to live on 22k

And your circumstances are identical are they? Of course they aren't. We have to stop assuming people who earn more have more disposable income, I'm sorry but it's not that simple. Yes of course some do, but not all. It depends where you live, how many kids, all sorts of different factors involved here. It's not a competition, we're all getting £400 and we will do with it what we wish.

rainingsnoring · 27/05/2022 09:20

I agree @Trainfromredhill . It makes no sense to throw money at everyone and clearly it will just mean that taxes subsequently go up even more than they already have. The idea is a little sweetener to keep all their usual voters onside (second home owners, wealthy pensioners, etc). They are playing people as always. Increase taxes and then throw a morsel to the grateful populace.

Increasing the UC to £20 extra per week again and increasing pension credits for the poorest pensioners would have made more sense. Also not raising in the middle of a cost of living crisis.
The government have no idea what they are doing or what they stand for. They have no idea what to do at all.

ChiswickFlo · 27/05/2022 09:20

It's all rather amusing in a dark way...

This govt have - and will continue to - lie to us, break their own laws and line the pockets of their mates.

They will tell us "we are all in it together" (this thread should disabuse us of that idea!)

And some will be pathetically grateful for cash that will go straight to the tory donors energy companies.

Our sc and gdcs will be paying for this "largesse" for decades to come.

Add to this the jubilee celebrations next week and all a bit "Bread and circuses" innit?

There is no political will to do anything that would actually help - like end decrease fuel duty, stop the NI increase and increase disability and and make it easier to apply for.

Because the UK public will tolerate anything from an Eton poshboy

NewbieDivergent · 27/05/2022 09:16

I cant believe there's a poster complaining they are struggling on 100k a year,my family have to live on 22k

Badgirlgonegood · 27/05/2022 09:14

BunsyGirl · 27/05/2022 09:00

@Badgirlgonegood But how much are you paying for housing and childcare?

I made a choice to pay less. I could have stayed in the town I grew up where the same type of house would cost £150000 more than my house and childcare is also alot more.

But I wanted more disposable income so I moved to a cheaper part of the greater city and slashed the cost of living.

We also choose to have a modest second had car and shop at Aldi mainly.

We have plenty left to save and go on carefully chosen holidays (not cheap just affordable for us).

My point is - those on £100,000 have lots of choices before they get to a point they have to PENNY PINCH.

yellowsuninthesky · 27/05/2022 09:12

RoomOfRequirement · 26/05/2022 22:35

I think it's usually because the admin costs of working out who is entitled and figuring out a cut off that is fair to everyone is more than the money they save.

Exactly this. If you don't need the £400 you can give it to charity or someone else who does need it.

the80sweregreat · 27/05/2022 09:12

Before I'm flamed, 5 bil is from the energy companies windfall taxes and 10 bil is the governments contribution.

the80sweregreat · 27/05/2022 09:10

I'm sure that Elton John and other celebs and the rich may well give theirs away. They are still affected by higher prices elsewhere , everyone has to eat , but it does become the politics of envy when they bring in universal things like this too. ( child benefit was the same too and that took years to change to being means tested)
Seems they can't win. 10 bil is an eye watering amount on top of the extra they had to print off for the pandemic ( much was wasted there by them of course )
This isn't like any conservative government I've ever known. Plus the energy companies will still have all that interest from this 400 sitting in the various accounts , not everyone will probably use it all up straight away and the very rich tend to live abroad in the winter in their other homes as well.