Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Every household?????

638 replies

Trainfromredhill · 26/05/2022 22:33

So, the chancellor is going to give every household £400 for heating. Surely there should be a cut off of household income? The Beckhams, Elton John, james Dyson, Harry styles…….they all get the money too? . I say this as someone in the fortunate position of not needing the £400- I’d much rather it went to someone who does need it.Just seems a huge waste of public money to give it to everyone

OP posts:
SoggyPaper · 27/05/2022 10:26

CupidStunt22 · 27/05/2022 10:25

The ridiculous bashing of the ‘fabulous’ £100k income lifestyle is quite galling, actually

Oh our hearts BLEED for you! Are the mean poor people managing on a THIRD of your income being horrible to you? Is your position in the TOP 6% of household income a hard place to be?

This is just not nice or helpful.

I say that as someone on 1/3 of that income.

CupidStunt22 · 27/05/2022 10:25

The ridiculous bashing of the ‘fabulous’ £100k income lifestyle is quite galling, actually

Oh our hearts BLEED for you! Are the mean poor people managing on a THIRD of your income being horrible to you? Is your position in the TOP 6% of household income a hard place to be?

JanetPluchinsky · 27/05/2022 10:23

orwellwasright · 27/05/2022 10:16

We SHOULD feel rich and the fact we’re not is out of our hands

Relatively rich person whining they don't feel rich enough and then saying their lifestyle choices are nothing to do with them is a perfect example of this endless entitlement I see on here.

It’s not entitlement. I’m well aware our combined income sounds huge. But the reality is we live in a very normal house with a very ordinary car, no holidays, no champagne.

The cost of living crisis affects almost everybody. I’m not saying we’re affected in the same way as someone having to choose between heating and eating but it is fucking depressing to not have any money at the end of the month on our income. We work all the hours under the sun, barely see each other or the kids, and for what?

Our mortgage is massive and we will benefit from that in about twenty years, we are very fortunate to be able to make that choice but the idea that we’re greedy spendthrifts without a care in the world is completely off base. Yeah we could move to a cheaper part of the country but if we all did that it wouldn’t be cheaper anymore, would it? And our jobs and families are here.

SoggyPaper · 27/05/2022 10:22

Topgub · 27/05/2022 10:17

@SoggyPaper

Arguably if the wealth was more evenly distributed through fairer wages more people could earn more and there would be less poorer people

Yes. But there would still be taxes and net contributors required to balance out the people who are unable to work.

The point is it’s not simple. And high earners are not the enemy.

SoggyPaper · 27/05/2022 10:20

SnackSizeRaisin · 27/05/2022 10:14

We don't get low income benefits as we have savings. You can't claim if you have over I think 16000. We get the child benefit that everyone gets.

I am not making out we are magicians anyway. It's a normal income to have. We are north west England

Objectively you are not living off £30k a year and paying 2x £1250 a month for 2 children under 3 in nursery.

Say your £30k gross income is £22k and £8k. That’s about £2200 a month.

You’re not paying for FT nursery for 2 children out of that. If you are paying £2500 on nursery a month, you are not living in £30k a year. You are living off rapidly depleting savings.

Cornettoninja · 27/05/2022 10:20

@ReginaGeorgeismyname your missing the fact that to be comfortable on £30k (with no benefit top ups which simply wouldn’t be possible in some parts of the country) your likely living in an area of limited opportunity and the chances are a tiny proportion of the local population earn huge salaries. This also leaves you vulnerable to economic shocks and a poorer chance of recovery.

it’s absolutely possible but not without fairly steep down sides, but people aren’t offering a fantasy experience.

ShirleyPhallus · 27/05/2022 10:17

Topgub · 27/05/2022 10:13

@ShirleyPhallus

Emergency healthcare (did you go entirely private for all maternity services?)

Policing, fire service, govt, council, prisons, justice services,

We're also back to choice.

You pay tax. The govt provides healthcare, education

You choose not to use it and pay double.

Thats up to you. But the services are still there for you to use.

Of course I choose not to use it and pay double. I’d rather pay for private schooling for example, and let someone who is unable to afford to do so have the place at the local oversubscribed and outstanding state primary near us for example.

You do get something back; the services that taxes pay for. this is the point I was responding to though - I am very happy to pay the higher rate of taxes but don’t necessarily get it back through these services if I don’t use them (which is my choice)

The actual point of debate here though:
that’s a useful list of additional services, but can you explain how lower earners pay more tax towards those than higher earners as commented in the previous post?

Topgub · 27/05/2022 10:17

@SoggyPaper

Arguably if the wealth was more evenly distributed through fairer wages more people could earn more and there would be less poorer people

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 27/05/2022 10:17

Tabitha005 · 27/05/2022 10:05

It's so fucked up. We'll be donating ours to the Trussell Trust.

If you have an independent food bank nearby could you consider them too, please? We are having to shout more loudly for help at the moment, most people know the Trussell trust name but there are always local, often church based banks. We aren't all religious, there is no evangelising, just housed and supported by a church. So please give us a thought"

ShirleyPhallus · 27/05/2022 10:17

Topgub · 27/05/2022 10:13

@ShirleyPhallus

Emergency healthcare (did you go entirely private for all maternity services?)

Policing, fire service, govt, council, prisons, justice services,

We're also back to choice.

You pay tax. The govt provides healthcare, education

You choose not to use it and pay double.

Thats up to you. But the services are still there for you to use.

Of course I choose not to use it and pay double. I’d rather pay for private schooling for example, and let someone who is unable to afford to do so have the place at the local oversubscribed and outstanding state primary near us for example.

You do get something back; the services that taxes pay for. this is the point I was responding to though - I am very happy to pay the higher rate of taxes but don’t necessarily get it back through these services if I don’t use them (which is my choice)

The actual point of debate here though:
that’s a useful list of additional services, but can you explain how lower earners pay more tax towards those than higher earners as commented in the previous post?

orwellwasright · 27/05/2022 10:16

We SHOULD feel rich and the fact we’re not is out of our hands

Relatively rich person whining they don't feel rich enough and then saying their lifestyle choices are nothing to do with them is a perfect example of this endless entitlement I see on here.

Topgub · 27/05/2022 10:15

@Cornettoninja

I dont envy or blame them. Its the govts fault absolutely.

not really surprising to come across people punching down in order to elevate themselves and avoid the reality that they’re not doing quite as well as they thought.

yes but they are still financially secure.

SoggyPaper · 27/05/2022 10:14

@venus7

what do you mean by ‘pay most’?

yes, the poorest pay the largest proportion of their incomes as tax - VAT and other taxes on products or services affect them disproportionately.

But, in terms of quantities, higher earners objectively pay more. Far, far more. And it is their taxes that are paying for everything really. Some people genuinely are net contributors to the the public purse. Most people are not.

Arguably, the poorest would be much poorer if it weren’t for the people earning £100k.

Someone on £100k pays £35k in tax and NI. They also pay VAT and other similar taxes - and they pay more of this in absolute terms because they spend more. They may also pay various other taxes.

Proportionally it’s less of their income. But in absolute terms they pay a lot more.

Complexity. It’s a shame it ruins simplistic, highly moralised arguments.

SnackSizeRaisin · 27/05/2022 10:14

ReginaGeorgeismyname · 27/05/2022 06:55

We have a combined income of 30,000 and live comfortably with no particular penny pinching. We don't get any benefits. We have 2 children in nursery as well.

Lots of these types of posts recently. At 30k a year with two kids you will be in receipt of universal credit and child benefit. Stop making out you are a magician with money.

I actually agree with everyone getting the £400. Something was needed for the squeezed middle too...too much squeezing of the middle means they cut out the cleaners, hair appointments, meals out etc which then has a knock on effect further down the economy where people start to loose their jobs.

We don't get low income benefits as we have savings. You can't claim if you have over I think 16000. We get the child benefit that everyone gets.

I am not making out we are magicians anyway. It's a normal income to have. We are north west England

jamapop · 27/05/2022 10:13

SoggyPaper · 27/05/2022 10:04

Do people really think that a system based on zoopla house price matching (an inaccurate and gameable system!) is s viable means testing and delivery mechanism?

It’s almost absurd how little appreciation there is about the sheer complexity of actually getting a payment like this to people. Never mind adding on weird ways of means testing it.

😂

and then what, weight it by region? Or even more granular by council ward?

110APiccadilly · 27/05/2022 10:13

Presumably to avoid a cliff edge effect, but I agree it seems a bit mad.

Maybe there should be something where those of us who don't need it pledge to donate it or something?

Topgub · 27/05/2022 10:13

@ShirleyPhallus

Emergency healthcare (did you go entirely private for all maternity services?)

Policing, fire service, govt, council, prisons, justice services,

We're also back to choice.

You pay tax. The govt provides healthcare, education

You choose not to use it and pay double.

Thats up to you. But the services are still there for you to use.

MarshaBradyo · 27/05/2022 10:11

SoggyPaper · 27/05/2022 10:04

Do people really think that a system based on zoopla house price matching (an inaccurate and gameable system!) is s viable means testing and delivery mechanism?

It’s almost absurd how little appreciation there is about the sheer complexity of actually getting a payment like this to people. Never mind adding on weird ways of means testing it.

I agree, zoopla isn’t viable but not are even more robust sources due to complexity

Badgirlgonegood · 27/05/2022 10:11

BunsyGirl · 27/05/2022 09:31

@Badgirlgonegood you haven’t answered the question and clearly don’t understand economics…if everyone lived in the same cheap area of the country it wouldn’t be cheap anymore…and not everyone can pack up and move 100 miles away due to their personal circumstances (children from previous relationships, elderly and vulnerable relatives to care for, job may not exist in other parts of the country…) I am sick to my back teeth of people assuming that people can live a life of luxury on a certain income when it is just not possible in some parts of the country.

I agree with parts of your post so no need to be patronising 😊. I was going to elaborate in my previous post and say that we can’t expect everyone to downsize etc but I ran out of time.

All I am saying and this was not aimed at you, is that those on 100,000 grand are not penny pinching. Another poster said that.

venus7 · 27/05/2022 10:10

This reply has been deleted

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Surely that should be 'grand' pinching, not penny pinching.
If you're struggling on £100000, you're the one who needs lessons in economising from that Tory MP!

Cornettoninja · 27/05/2022 10:10

Topgub · 27/05/2022 09:49

@Cornettoninja

I agree but it is hard not comment when those in more fortunate positions say that poorer people only have themselves to blame

Especially when they dont acknowledge their own choices in why they feel 'penny pinched' or the advantages they do have

I agree and it’s hard not to have a gut response, but it’s really worth stepping back if you can.

Taking it all at face value I think I’d probably be looking to explain why £100k p/a wasn’t cushioning me from having to watch my budgets. It’s not really surprising to come across people punching down in order to elevate themselves and avoid the reality that they’re not doing quite as well as they thought. That’s not to say anyone has to be sympathetic but I use that to not misdirect my own grievances/anger.

A salary of £100k (or two salaries combining) doesn’t come without significant costs either - living in a particular area, transport/commutes, qualifications etc. it’s a bitter pill to swallow that you can invest in those costs and still not be financially secure. From my pov, it’s a reminder of how far off I am from improving my own situation if it’s not possible for people on £100k.

I do think people at all levels need to be aware of blaming/envying others because it really does remove the blame (and therefore responsibility) from those who are actually in a position to address issues.

bubblesbubbles11 · 27/05/2022 10:09

Soggy
"Do people really think that a system based on zoopla house price matching (an inaccurate and gameable system!)"

OK maybe not zoopla but what is wrong with council tax bands? They are adjusted throughout the country so apart from those who are extremely cash poor sitting in houses they cannot really afford (and I dont know how many of those there are, but I would guess they struggled alot with their energy bills before the cost of living crisis and as I say above,they can still have the money they just have to actively apply for it) council tax bands could be utilised to ensure those very wealthy people are not spending their £400 equivalent on champagne or whatever.
Of course there is complexity involved in "getting a payment like this to people" but then this is a gmt which initiated a miriad of incredibly expensive "solutions" during the pandemic because emergency.

MarshaBradyo · 27/05/2022 10:09

bubblesbubbles11 · 27/05/2022 10:00

Marsha thank you this is useful food for thought.
"Isn’t the issue that it’s energy companies that are the system and they don’t have the capacity to match with zoopla or land registry etc"

I am not an expert on how the different levels of government work. But there has to be a way where central gmt pay those in council tax bands x and below via local gmt a one off credit of £400 which that household can then redirect to their chosen energy supplier.
If the payment is being made directly to the energy companies, in light of the number of different energy providers out there, it just feels totally circular and incestuous like the primary goal of the gmt here is to stay in the good books of the energy companies.
I think the "blank cheque" mentality of R.Sunak has run away with itself.

It feels a bit head blurry at this point, but it’s not really going to energy companies in that way. It’s the government paying £400 of each of our bills.

It’s not profit to them, they’d take it off us if they didn’t get it.

I find the amounts stressful although I’ve kind of let go now as it’s just so much it washes over you. I do worry for the next generations. I think we have massively burdened them, and at times unfairly.

The benefit bill is going up too iirc as matching inflation (or nearly), not sure if that will be welcomed, but it will be useful.

Not related to your posts but generally it’s so close to Labour policies I’m not sure if you’d applaud Labour doing a windfall tax why this would make some angry. But I guess people are loyal over looking at the same thing in the same light.

ShirleyPhallus · 27/05/2022 10:07

venus7 · 27/05/2022 10:03

You do get something back; the services that taxes pay for. You're not making a donation to charity when you pay tax. The people who pay most, actually, are the poorest, you're making the mistake of thinking income tax is the only tax.

What taxes do you include within this? We have private healthcare and dentistry, so don’t use the NHS, pay for private nursery without any childcare funding and will pay for private schooling from primary. Those are some huge costs we won’t get back in services. Are you also including things like having bins collected?

Tabitha005 · 27/05/2022 10:05

It's so fucked up. We'll be donating ours to the Trussell Trust.

Swipe left for the next trending thread