Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Every household?????

638 replies

Trainfromredhill · 26/05/2022 22:33

So, the chancellor is going to give every household £400 for heating. Surely there should be a cut off of household income? The Beckhams, Elton John, james Dyson, Harry styles…….they all get the money too? . I say this as someone in the fortunate position of not needing the £400- I’d much rather it went to someone who does need it.Just seems a huge waste of public money to give it to everyone

OP posts:
user1471538283 · 27/05/2022 10:58

It is all just smoke and mirrors and the reason everyone is getting it is to comfort their comfortably off voters and not to be seen as helping the less well off.

This is clearly them panicking.

I am furious because everyone, even those not earning very much will have to pay this back eventually. The tories will not be taking it out of their own pockets. And it just means that they do not have to do anything about these big energy companies making a ridiculous amount of money.

We are heading for a fall and it is gaining speed.

rainingsnoring · 27/05/2022 10:57

@Cornettoninja 'This cabinet have basically handed £15 billion to the energy companies and pretended it’s going to help out household budgets. This is the exact opposite of good fiscal management. From tories who like to crow about how good they are with the economy yet make baffling economic decisions.

Rishi has basically just spunked £15bn of our money up the wall and achieved precisely fuck all but a sound bite.'

It also potentially does harm in terms of:
a) reducing investment in energy projects by the big energy companies
b) sends a negative signal to business generally
c) possible negative affect on pension funds
d) is inflationary itself and may lead to higher inflation and higher interest rates (obviously these need to go up anyway).

Plus. it's the usual short term, u turn/ knee jerk response rather than the long term policy we actually need. They all seem to be assuming that energy prices will go down but there is absolutely no evidence to support this. The war in Ukraine continues to rage and Europe is apparently trying to manage without Russian gas. That will go well....

luckylavender · 27/05/2022 10:54

RoomOfRequirement · 26/05/2022 22:35

I think it's usually because the admin costs of working out who is entitled and figuring out a cut off that is fair to everyone is more than the money they save.

This

Pyri · 27/05/2022 10:54

Topgub · 27/05/2022 10:47

@Pyri

I never said that were?

Are you mixing me up with someone else?

I know lower incomes pay more tax as a proportion of their income

No, another poster said:

”The people who pay most, actually, are the poorest, you're making the mistake of thinking income tax is the only tax.”

Then you listed out a bunch of other services which higher tax payers receive. My question is that how do they lower income earners pay more in tax? Or do you just mean proportionally on things like VAT and high earners still pay more overall?

Topgub · 27/05/2022 10:53

@Cornettoninja

Yes their experience is valid

But there's ways and means

Waaaarrgghhh I'm so poor I'm having to trade in the nanny for an aux pair and the RR for a tesla isn't going to produce a helpful discussion.

Rosegingerpeaches · 27/05/2022 10:52

I don't think anyone on here is is moaning that they can't afford to live on 100k. I think the point being made is that it 100K doesn't go as far as people think and actually £400 is going to make a difference to them as well. My household income is just over 90K but after childcare, housing, bills and rising food costs it doesn't leave alot. Yes I am grateful that I can afford to eat and have a roof over my head and I dread to think what others are experiencing if we are just about covering our costs, however it will be nice to have something after missing out on the council tax rebate and child benefit. We don't have holidays or buy new clothes for ourselves. I cut my own hair and shop at Aldi. We did make the decision to buy a slightly bigger house, but that is because we didn't have the space to fit twins and two adults working from home in our smaller old house ( working from. home was not our choice). A few years ago we earned a 3rd less but were able to save a decent chunk of our salaries. Instead of arguing about who has it harder we should focus our anger on the fact we are in this mess in the first place. Its terrible that this is even needed in the first place.

Cornettoninja · 27/05/2022 10:51

The answer is not to feel sorry for those in the middle classes though

I’ve never said they need sympathy I don’t think? Just that their experiences are valid and part of a much bigger picture that has ripple effect on us all.

I certainly don’t see the value, as a lot of posters seem to see, of berating someone for not being ‘poor enough’ to share their experience.

ShirleyPhallus · 27/05/2022 10:49

Cornettoninja · 27/05/2022 10:43

Topgub how do lower earners pay more tax on this stuff than higher earners?

isn’t the point that lower earners pay a higher proportion rather than total value?

its the example that if I have a pound and you have ten, 10p is a greater proportion of my wealth than it is of yours.

Yes, but the poster beneath me @SoggyPaper puts it much better. In terms of tax on a bottle of wine for example, a lower earner will pay proportionally more than a higher earner but in actual terms of things like income tax the majority of tax comes from higher earners in a very significant way

Topgub · 27/05/2022 10:47

@Pyri

I never said that were?

Are you mixing me up with someone else?

I know lower incomes pay more tax as a proportion of their income

Topgub · 27/05/2022 10:45

@Cornettoninja

Yes, as I said wealth inequality is only going to keep getting worse.

The answer to that is not to feel sorry for those in the middle class though.

venus7 · 27/05/2022 10:44

SoggyPaper · 27/05/2022 10:14

@venus7

what do you mean by ‘pay most’?

yes, the poorest pay the largest proportion of their incomes as tax - VAT and other taxes on products or services affect them disproportionately.

But, in terms of quantities, higher earners objectively pay more. Far, far more. And it is their taxes that are paying for everything really. Some people genuinely are net contributors to the the public purse. Most people are not.

Arguably, the poorest would be much poorer if it weren’t for the people earning £100k.

Someone on £100k pays £35k in tax and NI. They also pay VAT and other similar taxes - and they pay more of this in absolute terms because they spend more. They may also pay various other taxes.

Proportionally it’s less of their income. But in absolute terms they pay a lot more.

Complexity. It’s a shame it ruins simplistic, highly moralised arguments.

It's also a shame that you can't make a case without being patronising.

Cornettoninja · 27/05/2022 10:43

Topgub how do lower earners pay more tax on this stuff than higher earners?

isn’t the point that lower earners pay a higher proportion rather than total value?

its the example that if I have a pound and you have ten, 10p is a greater proportion of my wealth than it is of yours.

Concernedmom90 · 27/05/2022 10:43

Please stop bashing higher earners. They pay a lot of tax already. The middle earners are not eligible for most benefits. Nurseries around me are at least £1300 per month and I am not even in what's considered a nice area. I can't move as the industry I am in are focused in London/greater London area, I can't retrain as that would mean no income for a few years.

Lincslady53 · 27/05/2022 10:42

If you don't need the money you can donate it to www.nea.org.uk/ or your local foodbank.

ladygindiva · 27/05/2022 10:40

Hhoney · 26/05/2022 22:49

I’m probably in the bracket that misses out on everything but still has to penny pinch. My husband and I earn about £100k per year between us. We don’t get child benefit and are not eligible for the council tax refund.

We are struggling at the moment. After all bills paid we used to have about £400 left each month for non necessities (clothes, eating out, adding to savings, entertainment etc.) Our council tax has gone up by £60 a month, energy by £120 a month (will be more in winter) and food by about £150 a month. Other bills have risen too (childcare, insurance, fuel). We have nothing left at the end of each month anymore.

I’m grateful that I’ve not been left out of this benefit.

Struggling because you only have £400 a month left for entertainment, clothing and eating out? I'm fucking speechless. Jesus. Do you realise how insulting that is?

Pyri · 27/05/2022 10:40

ShirleyPhallus · 27/05/2022 10:17

Of course I choose not to use it and pay double. I’d rather pay for private schooling for example, and let someone who is unable to afford to do so have the place at the local oversubscribed and outstanding state primary near us for example.

You do get something back; the services that taxes pay for. this is the point I was responding to though - I am very happy to pay the higher rate of taxes but don’t necessarily get it back through these services if I don’t use them (which is my choice)

The actual point of debate here though:
that’s a useful list of additional services, but can you explain how lower earners pay more tax towards those than higher earners as commented in the previous post?

@Topgub how do lower earners pay more tax on this stuff than higher earners?

Cornettoninja · 27/05/2022 10:39

I dont envy or blame them. Its the govts fault absolutely

maybe you don’t personally but this thread is a case in point on how people react to seeing those they would class as ‘comfortable’ telling us that they’re not. And it is envy or blame but thoroughly misplaced.

whilst people deride those on higher salaries complaining about how their households have been affected they’re completely distracted from the point of what that means to them.

There’s no need for bleeding hearts but if a face-value middle class is saying they’ve been knocked down a level that has consequences for everyone below them who’ve also been knocked down further.

basically the lower classes need to budge up on the bench because a whole new bunch of people just joined them and it’s redefining ‘poor’. having access to literally hundreds of thousands of pounds isn’t enough to get you recategorised.

Topgub · 27/05/2022 10:35

@JanetPluchinsky

Pointing out other people also work very hard /long hours and don't have the financial security you do is not a race to the bottom

MrOllivander · 27/05/2022 10:33

SoggyPaper · 27/05/2022 10:29

I know you said you aren’t saying they shouldn’t. But the structure of the question implies it must be unreasonable that they get it (and you don’t).

I'm just a bit - ok I try not to look into other people pots because it doesn't make you happier
But it does seem if you're single with no DC and on a low wage then you tend to get missed (I also am chronically unwell and struggle working 42hrs but not unwell enough to get any help)
Paying a mortgage, energy bills, food etc on £1200-1400pm on one wage isn't the easiest

JanetPluchinsky · 27/05/2022 10:31

Topgub · 27/05/2022 10:29

@JanetPluchinsky

We work all the hours under the sun, barely see each other or the kids, and for what?

that big mortgage ? The financial security of not choosing between heating and eating? Not living in a slum?

Plenty of people working all the hours and barely seeing each other or there kids and making much less.

No mortgage so insecure housing . Living in not nice areas

It’s not a race to the bottom.

I know we’re not poor. But we’re not rich either.

Topgub · 27/05/2022 10:29

@JanetPluchinsky

We work all the hours under the sun, barely see each other or the kids, and for what?

that big mortgage ? The financial security of not choosing between heating and eating? Not living in a slum?

Plenty of people working all the hours and barely seeing each other or there kids and making much less.

No mortgage so insecure housing . Living in not nice areas

SoggyPaper · 27/05/2022 10:29

I know you said you aren’t saying they shouldn’t. But the structure of the question implies it must be unreasonable that they get it (and you don’t).

SoggyPaper · 27/05/2022 10:28

MrOllivander · 27/05/2022 10:26

It just doesn't make sense
So these people get this (I'm NOT saying they shouldn't)
I get £400 - single, low wage, no DC. The same as any high earning celeb

Which scenario seems undeserving to you?

MrOllivander · 27/05/2022 10:26

It just doesn't make sense
So these people get this (I'm NOT saying they shouldn't)
I get £400 - single, low wage, no DC. The same as any high earning celeb

Every household?????
Topgub · 27/05/2022 10:26

@SoggyPaper

Some higher earners (not 100k) are most definitely the enemy

Looking directly at bo jo and rishi

Wealth inequality is a huge issue. Its gotten much worse in the last decade and will only keep getting worse

I really don't have much sympathy for higher earners