Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Every household?????

638 replies

Trainfromredhill · 26/05/2022 22:33

So, the chancellor is going to give every household £400 for heating. Surely there should be a cut off of household income? The Beckhams, Elton John, james Dyson, Harry styles…….they all get the money too? . I say this as someone in the fortunate position of not needing the £400- I’d much rather it went to someone who does need it.Just seems a huge waste of public money to give it to everyone

OP posts:
Eeiliethya · 27/05/2022 11:32

People can argue this until the cows come home but it is what it is.

Those on lower incomes and means tested benefits are getting an additional £650 on top of the £400.

If we means-tested every household, those on the lower incomes would end up with less than they're already getting because people generally don't work for free (I.e those who would have to spend months means-testing).

Can't please everyone.

If you don't want/need the money, withdraw £400 and walk into your nearest food bank with it.

francesfrankenfurter · 27/05/2022 11:31

The second homes annoys me. Surely they have a register of second homes?

Alexandra2001 · 27/05/2022 11:30

wallpoppy · 27/05/2022 11:27

The administrative cost of means testing benefits often outweighs the cost of just giving everyone the same thing, or comes very close. The effort and cost of setting up means testing for a one-off £400 benefit would not eventually pay for itself the way doing the same for an ongoing benefit would, and would add massively to the timeline of actually getting the money to the recipients.

Rubbish, the benefits system has always been used to help the poorest, DWP and HMRC can easily do this.

Cornettoninja · 27/05/2022 11:29

Topgub · 27/05/2022 11:14

@Cornettoninja

The able bodied person can go up the stairs. Thats the point.

They might not be able to get to the top but they're still a flight up.

But the point is lost because they both still have the same problem - neither can get to the top. They have different needs to enable equality but neither has a more pressing need than the other to get to the top (unless it’s a tyre shop at the top).

Its also arguable the able-bodied person is only advantaged by their ability to take risks to get to the top. The person in a wheelchair isn’t going to fall down the stairs and break their leg. To raise the wheelchair user to the same level as the able bodied person still doesn’t solve the problem of either of them reaching the top.

Both have valid problems, neither particularly require sympathy over solutions.

Alexandra2001 · 27/05/2022 11:28

@MarshaBradyo Turkey has v high inflation because it refuses point blank to raise interest rates.
Totally different economy.

But if you really care about inflation, don't go stimulating the economy by giving millions of people who don't need it £550!

We should be using the benefits system to help the poorest, as we have always done.

These billions could be used to raise wages in the NHS, fund more training places and build at least one of these 40 hospitals BJ promised but which we all seem to have forgotten about.

fwiw i didn't support the Labour proposals either because it also gave money to the well off, its the politics of madness (though it wasn't as much) Topsy Turvey world.

wallpoppy · 27/05/2022 11:27

The administrative cost of means testing benefits often outweighs the cost of just giving everyone the same thing, or comes very close. The effort and cost of setting up means testing for a one-off £400 benefit would not eventually pay for itself the way doing the same for an ongoing benefit would, and would add massively to the timeline of actually getting the money to the recipients.

Genevieva · 27/05/2022 11:25

Better than this windfall tax and give-away would have been if the government had not allowed Ofgem to double the price cap on energy when the energy companies are making record profits. This fuel poverty is the result of government policy.

rainingsnoring · 27/05/2022 11:22

@MarshaBradyo - I can see why it seems a tempting idea to tax the huge energy companies whoever suggests it (Tories have just made Labour's idea much bigger after saying they wouldn't consider it). If anyone is to be targeted it should be those in real trouble not the whole population including very wealthy households.
There are significant down sides to their plan as above. The key is that we really need investment in energy. However, we should not be throwing more and money after projects which continue to need tax payer subsidies (there has been a lot of this already). They need competent people to look at a long term plan not knee jerk responses which buy them another 6 months. The UK is in a really bad situation as we import so much that is essential and the economy is built on service provision (non essential) and foreign money which is very worrying as this is likely to start being withdrawn. Frankly, we should not be encouraging fights with Russia at this precipitous time but I doubt others will agree with me on that.

Topgub · 27/05/2022 11:20

@MarshaBradyo

Linked wages

Reduce tax evasion/avoidance

Reintroduce previous energy cap

Introduce rent caps

Do something about house prices but not sure what

MarshaBradyo · 27/05/2022 11:17

That was to Topgub too

How do you stop people going under with targeted help at the same time as not causing hyper inflation?

do you think they should get any extra help

MarshaBradyo · 27/05/2022 11:14

fromdownwest · 27/05/2022 11:09

To be fair if you laid out the policies and actions of both red and blue, you would be hard pressed to tell the difference. Both as incompetenet as each other at the minute

What would you do?

I may have missed it

Imo we face huge shocks to economy and I worry about runaway inflation (Turkey a good example) but also see that people struggling need help

Do you think they need help? How would you do it

Topgub · 27/05/2022 11:14

@Cornettoninja

The able bodied person can go up the stairs. Thats the point.

They might not be able to get to the top but they're still a flight up.

Topgub · 27/05/2022 11:12

@fromdownwest

Exactly.

UK politics are fucking god awful

Cornettoninja · 27/05/2022 11:11

Topgub · 27/05/2022 11:04

@Cornettoninja

Slight exaggeration for effect, obviously

Its like asking someone in a wheelchair to care that an able bodied person has to walk up some stairs

Not ‘care’ just recognise that it’s a symptom of the same problem. If an able bodied person can’t go up some stairs then there’s little to no chance a wheelchair user will ever get up there either.

@MarshaBradyo why? For the record I am fairly ambivalent about a windfall tax, I fail to see the sustainability of any impact it may have and have already said what I measures I believe have longevity.

MarshaBradyo · 27/05/2022 11:11

Topgub · 27/05/2022 11:07

@MarshaBradyo

Why would anyone who thinks this is an awful idea think it was a good one if Labour suggested it?!

I wouldnt think it was a good idea if anyone suggested it

Cause its a fucking terrible idea

I’ve seen loads of posts from the left applauding it but now not.

Personally I was reticent due to inflationary pressure but I don’t draw conclusions re one doing it bad, other party suggesting same good

MarshaBradyo · 27/05/2022 11:09

a) reducing investment in energy projects by the big energy companies

Btw there’s a big incentive for oil and gas to invest as they get 90% off if so. So if investment is important to you this version will be welcomed over the previous iteration.

I agree inflationary pressures are a concern and other events such as strikes for pay increases or public sector increase will be an issue.

The key is to target the lowest so it’s not ‘eat or heat’ a phrase that was used a lot until now it’s other criticism

I don’t love the higher spending but it is the most targeted way to help the lowest incomes - the extra into bank account that is

fromdownwest · 27/05/2022 11:09

Topgub · 27/05/2022 11:07

@MarshaBradyo

Why would anyone who thinks this is an awful idea think it was a good one if Labour suggested it?!

I wouldnt think it was a good idea if anyone suggested it

Cause its a fucking terrible idea

To be fair if you laid out the policies and actions of both red and blue, you would be hard pressed to tell the difference. Both as incompetenet as each other at the minute

Topgub · 27/05/2022 11:07

@MarshaBradyo

Why would anyone who thinks this is an awful idea think it was a good one if Labour suggested it?!

I wouldnt think it was a good idea if anyone suggested it

Cause its a fucking terrible idea

Songoftheseas · 27/05/2022 11:06

OP, I thought this but was too nervous to comment in case people jumped on me for daring to admit that we are doing ok financially. We definitely do not need the £400 and I would much rather that it go to someone who is struggling.

MarshaBradyo · 27/05/2022 11:05

rainingsnoring · 27/05/2022 10:57

@Cornettoninja 'This cabinet have basically handed £15 billion to the energy companies and pretended it’s going to help out household budgets. This is the exact opposite of good fiscal management. From tories who like to crow about how good they are with the economy yet make baffling economic decisions.

Rishi has basically just spunked £15bn of our money up the wall and achieved precisely fuck all but a sound bite.'

It also potentially does harm in terms of:
a) reducing investment in energy projects by the big energy companies
b) sends a negative signal to business generally
c) possible negative affect on pension funds
d) is inflationary itself and may lead to higher inflation and higher interest rates (obviously these need to go up anyway).

Plus. it's the usual short term, u turn/ knee jerk response rather than the long term policy we actually need. They all seem to be assuming that energy prices will go down but there is absolutely no evidence to support this. The war in Ukraine continues to rage and Europe is apparently trying to manage without Russian gas. That will go well....

Were you, and the pp, for this windfall tax when Labour suggested it?

Topgub · 27/05/2022 11:04

@Cornettoninja

Slight exaggeration for effect, obviously

Its like asking someone in a wheelchair to care that an able bodied person has to walk up some stairs

fromdownwest · 27/05/2022 11:04

rainingsnoring · 27/05/2022 10:57

@Cornettoninja 'This cabinet have basically handed £15 billion to the energy companies and pretended it’s going to help out household budgets. This is the exact opposite of good fiscal management. From tories who like to crow about how good they are with the economy yet make baffling economic decisions.

Rishi has basically just spunked £15bn of our money up the wall and achieved precisely fuck all but a sound bite.'

It also potentially does harm in terms of:
a) reducing investment in energy projects by the big energy companies
b) sends a negative signal to business generally
c) possible negative affect on pension funds
d) is inflationary itself and may lead to higher inflation and higher interest rates (obviously these need to go up anyway).

Plus. it's the usual short term, u turn/ knee jerk response rather than the long term policy we actually need. They all seem to be assuming that energy prices will go down but there is absolutely no evidence to support this. The war in Ukraine continues to rage and Europe is apparently trying to manage without Russian gas. That will go well....

Completely agree, his grasp of macro economics is shocking, or he jsut not give a hoot.

Instead of looking to actually tackle the issue - OFGEM, Rate caps, alternative energy sources etc. He is just funding the issue.

Already talk on the radio of - should netflix etc get a windfall tax. If businesses are under the illusion that at any stage, the governement will drop an arbitrary tax on them, they may think twice on ivnesting in the UK.

The worst COE we have had for a long long time. Makes Gordon Brown look like Gordon Gekko

rainingsnoring · 27/05/2022 11:04

@user1471538283 totally agree that we are heading for a fall.

It's been coming on for years but they keep kicking the can down the road. It is clear that this 'tactic' is no longer working and the government have no idea what to do. Nor do the central banks. It's very worrying.

Cornettoninja · 27/05/2022 11:02

Yes their experience is valid

But there's ways and means

I don’t disagree

Waaaarrgghhh I'm so poor I'm having to trade in the nanny for an aux pair and the RR for a tesla isn't going to produce a helpful discussion

I haven’t actually seen anyone post anything like this.

If that’s how you are approaching these posts then their credence is lost from the start isn’t it? But then so is yours if you can’t shake it.

Topgub · 27/05/2022 10:58

@Pyri

I was replying to the person who said they paid lots of tax and got nothing in return. When in fact, they do get something in return.

I didnt make any comment on poorer people paying more tax. Although I do know they pay more as a proportion of income.

Well off people pay more in total. As they should.