Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Every household?????

638 replies

Trainfromredhill · 26/05/2022 22:33

So, the chancellor is going to give every household £400 for heating. Surely there should be a cut off of household income? The Beckhams, Elton John, james Dyson, Harry styles…….they all get the money too? . I say this as someone in the fortunate position of not needing the £400- I’d much rather it went to someone who does need it.Just seems a huge waste of public money to give it to everyone

OP posts:
Topgub · 27/05/2022 12:11

@SoggyPaper

I've never said people on 100k dont have problems.

However your ideal has to apply to all.

Its not a race to the bottom to acknowledge your advantage and privilege.

It is much easier to have more money than to have less. Thats just a fact.

Its not the lack of understanding that those on higher wages still have problems thats the issue.

Its the belief that those problems are just as bad as those on less.

Only having 400 left after youve paid all your expensive bills is not the same problem as not being able to pay your bills.

Its a problem if you think you deserve to have lots left after paying all your expensive bills, sure

MarshaBradyo · 27/05/2022 12:10

rainingsnoring · 27/05/2022 11:52

@MarshaBradyo - I already suggested a couple of time raising benefit levels to target those most in need.

However, I don't pretend to be any kind of an expert (this is nothing to do with my professional field, I just find politics and economics interesting). There are far more knowledgable people than me out there. What I really disagree with is the short term, self serving politics that is clearly being practised nowadays with absolutely no cogent, long term plan nor, frankly, any interest in making one as far as I can see. It's incredibly frustrating when this country is obviously in real trouble.
They are worried about inflation but keeping throwing money around to everyone, they want investment but impose an extra energy tax, they are worried about general business investment but increase corporation tax and contribute to uncertainty, they increase taxes and then throw a bit of a giveaway at everyone, the NHS has a backlog but they don't make a sensible plan about what is needed, they through money in its general direction, there is huge concern about energy (and food) yet they persist in antagonising Russia.
There is no plan.

I cross posted with your pp on that, thanks for answering again

I get the exasperation at seeing huge sums flying around and have felt that in the past, the only thing I’d say is there have been a fair few posts from people just outside benefits level who likely will very much need the £400 help. I know the very top do not but I can’t see a way to get it to the lower middle / middle but not benefits in an easy way.

I’m interested in economics and politics too (studied former, no expert but probably have a latent interest which attracts me to the topic) re direction I think a few things stand out

massive global shocks to economy
investment incentive for oil and gas with this levy (which I don’t believe Labour had)
Trying to increase skills with training incentives long term

re benefits iirc they are almost increasing to inflation and it will be a big bill. The other issue is public sector pay and how to not cause inflationary spikes

re Russia, yes again it’s hard to see huge spending but I think it is right in war against Putin which Ukraine needs support with - from everyone not just us

LampLighter414 · 27/05/2022 12:09

Should cover the cost of my empty holiday home's standing charges and occasional heating over the winter to stop the pipes freezing nicely ☺ leaves me with more money to spend elsewhere so the rest of the economy benefits too

rainingsnoring · 27/05/2022 12:06

'Interest rates are set by the BoE independently, they may well do but there’s going to be a lot of squeezed people when it happens'
@MarshaBradyo -just to add. There doesn't seem to be much independence of the BoE.

Rosscameasdoody · 27/05/2022 12:06

Alexandra2001 · 27/05/2022 11:30

Rubbish, the benefits system has always been used to help the poorest, DWP and HMRC can easily do this.

The problem with this approach is that means tested benefits do not always reflect the poorest, as the thresholds for a lot of benefits are set very low and people can sometimes miss them by just a pound or two. As evidenced by several threads on this very subject, a lot of people are struggling and can’t access help because they’re slightly better off than someone who is on the bones of their arse. The system is broken.

SoggyPaper · 27/05/2022 12:04

Topgub · 27/05/2022 11:14

@Cornettoninja

The able bodied person can go up the stairs. Thats the point.

They might not be able to get to the top but they're still a flight up.

But the person in the wheelchair can still see it from the other’s perspective and recognise that it’s hard for them too.

An attitude of ‘oh it’s much easier for you’ is really unhelpful. And just invites a race to the bottom where people decide that the wheelchair user isn’t deserving enough because they can breathe without assistance and move around at all.

It is both possible and desirable to look at someone earning £100k and recognise that there are complexities and challenges in their lives too, which mean that their life is not quite what you imagine it should be. Even if you only earn £16k and cannot possibly imagine ever earning anything like £100k.

That’s not ‘feeling sorry for them’. I’m not sure that feeling sorry for people is a good mechanism for deciding who deserves help or understanding. It’s just saying that the whole of society would be better off if people actually tried to see the challenges in other people’s lives and didn’t see anyone better off than them, or not scraping along at the bottom of the heap, as having nothing to worry about.

Rosscameasdoody · 27/05/2022 12:00

Cornettoninja · 27/05/2022 11:32

I agree. I’d rather fuel rationing over rocketing costs, at least it’s a quantifiable amount to budget with that doesn’t land people in debt.

Theresa May’s government tasked Ofgem with setting the price cap in 2019 and it does so independently of government. The energy industry was privatised and deregulated back when we lived in a world where there was cheap gas and no appreciation of climate change. For things to change, that has to be dismantled - it’s no longer relevant.

stayathomer · 27/05/2022 11:55

Living in Ireland so not a thing for us but while we are seen as middle earners (I’m minimum wage but dh is a decent wage) I agree if someone offered me this I’d be looking for it to go towards helping someone hear their home. Out of everything in life the thing we’re luckiest with is that our home is really really warm and a sun trap in the summer and weirdly not bad in the winter, they should definitely find a way of helping those who absolutely cannot pay heating bills x

Cornettoninja · 27/05/2022 11:52

Topgub · 27/05/2022 11:43

@Cornettoninja

The wheelchair user cant take the risk. They're not choosing not to as your post implies.

Raising the wheel chair user to the first floor helps reduce the overall inequality

True, it wasn’t an implication I intended to make but it is there nonetheless.

I’m not in agreement with arguing a metaphor that’s aim seems to be that raising people to an equally bad position is a good goal to have. In your scenario now both people are in a position with the same significant risks without protection. and still no way of getting to the top of the stairs with very little quantifiable gain for being half way up the stairs.

rainingsnoring · 27/05/2022 11:52

@MarshaBradyo - I already suggested a couple of time raising benefit levels to target those most in need.

However, I don't pretend to be any kind of an expert (this is nothing to do with my professional field, I just find politics and economics interesting). There are far more knowledgable people than me out there. What I really disagree with is the short term, self serving politics that is clearly being practised nowadays with absolutely no cogent, long term plan nor, frankly, any interest in making one as far as I can see. It's incredibly frustrating when this country is obviously in real trouble.
They are worried about inflation but keeping throwing money around to everyone, they want investment but impose an extra energy tax, they are worried about general business investment but increase corporation tax and contribute to uncertainty, they increase taxes and then throw a bit of a giveaway at everyone, the NHS has a backlog but they don't make a sensible plan about what is needed, they through money in its general direction, there is huge concern about energy (and food) yet they persist in antagonising Russia.
There is no plan.

Rosscameasdoody · 27/05/2022 11:49

This has been discussed on other threads. The government know how to target the most vulnerable through the benefits system but to introduce further means testing for everyone else would be prohibitively expensive - so funds that could be used to help people would instead go on admin costs. Rishi Sunak and others in government have been quoted as saying they will give their £400 to charity and there are numerous suggestions for anyone well off enough not to need it, to donate themselves and redistribute the funds that way. I also think that we ought not to forget that the government is hoping that by giving something to all, all will be forgiven come the general election. I suggest we all express our opinions at the ballot box !!

Topgub · 27/05/2022 11:43

@Cornettoninja

The wheelchair user cant take the risk. They're not choosing not to as your post implies.

Raising the wheel chair user to the first floor helps reduce the overall inequality

MarshaBradyo · 27/05/2022 11:43

Raining what would you do?

apols if I missed it. I am interested in other policies people think would work though

rainingsnoring · 27/05/2022 11:42

'There is targeted help with the extra £650 etc so you would have just done that and not anything to other people?

Interest rates are set by the BoE independently, they may well do but there’s going to be a lot of squeezed people when it happens'

Yes, I think raising benefits would definitely be preferable. Why do you think everyone needs extra help despite the negative impacts? It's clearly a political choice to save their own skin (yet again).

wallpoppy · 27/05/2022 11:41

Alexandra2001 · 27/05/2022 11:30

Rubbish, the benefits system has always been used to help the poorest, DWP and HMRC can easily do this.

Rubbish yourself. I actually work on some key software tangentially related to this area (or rather I did before I fucking gave up and went to work on something less broken) and you can't just search up "everyone on benefits already" and then send them some cash for their electric bill. Or go on the HMRC database and search "everyone who made less than £20k last year" and send them some money. Or whatever. It absolutely doesn't work that way, you can't just repurpose an already byzantine and barely-functioning digital system to do something new and provide a new benefit.

You SHOULD be able to, it SHOULD work better, it SHOULD be sensibly put together and maintained, but it absolutely IS NOT for reasons of greed, stupidity, laziness, technological incompetency, and grift. You know, the values of the Tory party.

I don't want Ed Sheeran to be sent £400 to heat his swimming pool either but don't be rude to me just because I'm explaining how this works to people (like you) who don't know.

rainingsnoring · 27/05/2022 11:39

MarshaBradyo · 27/05/2022 11:34

Yes to this

Obviously you can never please everyone but that does not mean that this was the only policy choice. There were many others.
Throwing money around like confetti to people who don't need it and hoping they might donate to a food bank is utterly ridiculous.

The trouble with price caps is what @MarshaBradyo said about small companies going out of businesses because they cannot charge what they need to and become massively loss making. This is exactly what has happened. Ofgem should have been aware of this and not allowed this to happen.

MarshaBradyo · 27/05/2022 11:39

rainingsnoring · 27/05/2022 11:33

The interest rates need to be raised more, at least on par with what the Fed is doing. The pound has lost significant value because of the inaction by the central bank here. And then Rishi comes in throwing money around undoing the feeble action anyway.

It would be better to target those in need via the systems which are already in place, UC and pension credits. These are the people that need the most help in general. Giveaways to everyone make no sense at all. It will only be reclaimed with unwanted tax rises anyway. Very poor timing to raise taxes at such a time too.

There is targeted help with the extra £650 etc so you would have just done that and not anything to other people?

Interest rates are set by the BoE independently, they may well do but there’s going to be a lot of squeezed people when it happens

BlessedByTheShitFairy · 27/05/2022 11:37

is this one of those threads where people discuss how wealthy they are?

pulls up gilded chair.

Whooshaagh · 27/05/2022 11:36

Alexandra2001 · 27/05/2022 11:30

Rubbish, the benefits system has always been used to help the poorest, DWP and HMRC can easily do this.

It’s not rubbish for one off payments.
Consider the admin necessary to target this payment in 6 months and people would still slip through the net.
Also many working parents are struggling too atm.

MarshaBradyo · 27/05/2022 11:34

Eeiliethya · 27/05/2022 11:32

People can argue this until the cows come home but it is what it is.

Those on lower incomes and means tested benefits are getting an additional £650 on top of the £400.

If we means-tested every household, those on the lower incomes would end up with less than they're already getting because people generally don't work for free (I.e those who would have to spend months means-testing).

Can't please everyone.

If you don't want/need the money, withdraw £400 and walk into your nearest food bank with it.

Yes to this

Meraas · 27/05/2022 11:34

I didn't realise we are all getting £400, but I will happily take it and keep it.

I didn't mind when lots of people got £150 council tax rebate or those getting the extra payments, so I don't think anyone should mind me getting me £400.

rainingsnoring · 27/05/2022 11:33

MarshaBradyo · 27/05/2022 11:17

That was to Topgub too

How do you stop people going under with targeted help at the same time as not causing hyper inflation?

do you think they should get any extra help

The interest rates need to be raised more, at least on par with what the Fed is doing. The pound has lost significant value because of the inaction by the central bank here. And then Rishi comes in throwing money around undoing the feeble action anyway.

It would be better to target those in need via the systems which are already in place, UC and pension credits. These are the people that need the most help in general. Giveaways to everyone make no sense at all. It will only be reclaimed with unwanted tax rises anyway. Very poor timing to raise taxes at such a time too.

MarshaBradyo · 27/05/2022 11:33

Genevieva · 27/05/2022 11:25

Better than this windfall tax and give-away would have been if the government had not allowed Ofgem to double the price cap on energy when the energy companies are making record profits. This fuel poverty is the result of government policy.

I put this on another thread but will paste and see if any correction

this is why imo re energy cap

Earlier some questions re why not just keep cap as it is made me think about the process

I’m sure someone will correct me if I’m wrong but this is the way I see it

global prices on oil and gas have gone up hugely - BP and Shell etc as oil and gas have bumper profits

Consumer energy companies have to pay more as the intermediary and as a result pass higher cost into consumer

the cap means it’s the intermediary that makes up the difference - hence loads of smaller energy companies collapsing when hikes first hit.

But because oil and gas have bumper profits they are redirecting some to energy companies which then helps us

a but like owning a shop and price of tomatoes hikes and you pass it on, but growers are benefitting not shops

So the cap has to rise, but taking bumper profit from oil and gas makes sense, although adding investment criteria is good imo.

Cornettoninja · 27/05/2022 11:32

Genevieva · 27/05/2022 11:25

Better than this windfall tax and give-away would have been if the government had not allowed Ofgem to double the price cap on energy when the energy companies are making record profits. This fuel poverty is the result of government policy.

I agree. I’d rather fuel rationing over rocketing costs, at least it’s a quantifiable amount to budget with that doesn’t land people in debt.

francesfrankenfurter · 27/05/2022 11:32

Tomanyhandbags · 26/05/2022 22:40

If you genuinely don't need the payment you can always give it to a charity such as a local food bank or somewhere else that will benefit households in need.

My experience is poorer people give to food banks, not rich people.