Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Every household?????

638 replies

Trainfromredhill · 26/05/2022 22:33

So, the chancellor is going to give every household £400 for heating. Surely there should be a cut off of household income? The Beckhams, Elton John, james Dyson, Harry styles…….they all get the money too? . I say this as someone in the fortunate position of not needing the £400- I’d much rather it went to someone who does need it.Just seems a huge waste of public money to give it to everyone

OP posts:
balalake · 27/05/2022 15:33

@Summerstink if we had remained in the EU, Boris Johnson would not be Prime Minister, Rishi Sunak probably not chancellor.

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 27/05/2022 15:30

Pyri · 27/05/2022 10:40

@Topgub how do lower earners pay more tax on this stuff than higher earners?

They don’t. The bottom three quintiles receive more in tax credits and benefits than they pay in.

On average the changeover point at which you start contributing financially is about £40,000.

The ONS has some good reports laying out incomes by decile before and after taxes and benefits.

Summerstink · 27/05/2022 14:56

How different do you think it would be if we were still in the EU? All other things being the same?

fromdownwest · 27/05/2022 14:19

Do we have any idea on the logistics of this all?
Are our gas and electric providers going to pay £400 on our account, then invoice Rushi?
Are we getting a cheque in the post?

Have they actually thought of the logistics of this?

And have they not learned their lesson from the Billions lost to covid grants for businesses that just 'appeared' over night

People will find a way to bleed this dry, and once again, the dis honest will come out on top.

He really is a fcking idiot. And to think I voted for this sht show

autienotnaughty · 27/05/2022 13:59

SafferUpNorth · 27/05/2022 12:37

We're by no means wealthy but don't NEED the £400 urgently. Sure it would be nice but I think it's lazy of the Govt not to even try target this, even just by some crude means testing like tax band. It dilutes the impact for those most in need.

I am thinking of donating ours to a local charity that directly assists struggling households. Hoping to encourage others to do the same! #pledgemywindfallgrant

That's a lovely idea hope others follow suit xx

DogInATent · 27/05/2022 13:04

It would cost too much to identify who as entitled, who wasn't, deal with the appeals, etc. Don't underestimate the admin cost of means tested benefits.

It's cheaper and easier to give it to everyone.

The same argument works in favour of UBI to replace most other benefits, but the politics of "It's not fair" and Levelling-Down-Not-Up get in the way every time. They get in the way of a lot of good ideas.

SafferUpNorth · 27/05/2022 13:04

Rosscameasdoody · 27/05/2022 12:54

See your point, but I think you’re overlooking the fact that the universal £400 is not by any means altruistic on the part of government. It’s done with one eye on the general election and in the hope that if they’re seen to be trying to help, even at this late stage, then all will be forgiven at the ballot box. Which, hopefully, it won’t. It’s also a convenient distraction from the Gray report, released on the same day. Cynical, moi ?

@Rosscameasdoody ... in fact I totally share your cynicism, that's exactly my view too! Which makes it all the more ridiculous that it's so obviously lazily done.
As with Rishi this morning, journos should be making it their business to ask every politician, celeb and businessman what they'll be doing with their £400...

ShirleyPhallus · 27/05/2022 12:57

Rosscameasdoody · 27/05/2022 12:21

It’s your choice to have private healthcare - just because you don’t use the NHS doesn’t mean you shouldn’t contribute. If you have an emergency will you be ringing a private provider - no, you’ll dial 999 and get an ambulance to take you to the nearest NHS hospital for emergency treatment, like the rest of us.

My first post literally says I am very happy to pay the additional tax and think it’s a good thing for high earners to pay more tax. I haven’t said anywhere I think I shouldn’t pay for the NHS?

Rosscameasdoody · 27/05/2022 12:54

SafferUpNorth · 27/05/2022 12:37

We're by no means wealthy but don't NEED the £400 urgently. Sure it would be nice but I think it's lazy of the Govt not to even try target this, even just by some crude means testing like tax band. It dilutes the impact for those most in need.

I am thinking of donating ours to a local charity that directly assists struggling households. Hoping to encourage others to do the same! #pledgemywindfallgrant

See your point, but I think you’re overlooking the fact that the universal £400 is not by any means altruistic on the part of government. It’s done with one eye on the general election and in the hope that if they’re seen to be trying to help, even at this late stage, then all will be forgiven at the ballot box. Which, hopefully, it won’t. It’s also a convenient distraction from the Gray report, released on the same day. Cynical, moi ?

Rosscameasdoody · 27/05/2022 12:46

Alexandra2001 · 27/05/2022 12:39

I don't want Ed Sheeran to be sent £400 to heat his swimming pool either but don't be rude to me just because I'm explaining how this works to people (like you) who don't know

You don't know what i do or have done, so less of the high n mighty! esp as you've explained nothing, only your own prejudice.

But the point is, the benefits system is well versed in handing out additional monies to the less well off... as well you should know, from CB, to winter heating allowance and HB.

There are millions who aren't Ed Sheeran or Richi Sunak, who don't need £400 from the tax payer, this is 10 billion of money that is being added to the balance sheet for no good reason.

Too many well off folk just want to get their hands on free money.

The benefits system is not the best way to work out who gets what with a one off payment like this and it’s not a case of ‘too many well off folk just want to get their hands on free money’ as you so charmingly put it. The people targeted through the benefits system for the extra funding are largely either on disability benefits like PIP, or means tested benefits. Means testing thresholds are set very low and a lot of people who are on low incomes and struggling, are unable to access these benefits because they are only a pound or two over the threshold, so miss out on a lot of help. Jesus, this thread really is bringing out the worst in people !! While those of us largely at the bottom of the pile are sniping at each other about who deserves what, we’re leaving those at the top of the pile alone. It’s called divide and rule and the Tories are masterful at it. Seems they’ve hit the jackpot with this one.

ThatsMyJam · 27/05/2022 12:42

The answer to not being on a minimum wage is always to work harder/train yourself up etc but these jobs need doing by somebody.

If everyone woke up tomorrow with the skills to be a brain surgeon we would be in deep trouble. On the face of it we would have an extremely intelligent skilled workforce but also a nation of people who would be unwilling to work in shops, be carers, be delivery drivers, be cleaners, work in childcare etc. They would all say they are brain surgeons and why should they be the one to do the minimum wage jobs.

Everyone on minimum wage would love to be paid more and put more tax into the system. It is not a choice to earn minimum wage. No one turns down a pay rise.

Rosscameasdoody · 27/05/2022 12:40

Topgub · 27/05/2022 09:27

@Anonnnnnnm

Youre not getting £400. Your energy provider is

And if you dont have any disposable income on 100k then thats down to your own choices, innit

But the £400 will be taken off your energy bill - as was the case with the £200 previously mooted. The only difference is that we’ll benefit from the rebate being more, and not having to pay it back.

Alexandra2001 · 27/05/2022 12:39

I don't want Ed Sheeran to be sent £400 to heat his swimming pool either but don't be rude to me just because I'm explaining how this works to people (like you) who don't know

You don't know what i do or have done, so less of the high n mighty! esp as you've explained nothing, only your own prejudice.

But the point is, the benefits system is well versed in handing out additional monies to the less well off... as well you should know, from CB, to winter heating allowance and HB.

There are millions who aren't Ed Sheeran or Richi Sunak, who don't need £400 from the tax payer, this is 10 billion of money that is being added to the balance sheet for no good reason.

Too many well off folk just want to get their hands on free money.

SafferUpNorth · 27/05/2022 12:37

We're by no means wealthy but don't NEED the £400 urgently. Sure it would be nice but I think it's lazy of the Govt not to even try target this, even just by some crude means testing like tax band. It dilutes the impact for those most in need.

I am thinking of donating ours to a local charity that directly assists struggling households. Hoping to encourage others to do the same! #pledgemywindfallgrant

endlesslystandingonlego · 27/05/2022 12:34

Your local food bank, citizens advice, local aid charity, homeless shelter, womens aid, would be incredibly grateful for the £400 you don't want.

Or the fuel bank foundation feels appropriate here www.fuelbankfoundation.org

Rosscameasdoody · 27/05/2022 12:30

bubblesbubbles11 · 27/05/2022 09:42

"I think it's usually because the admin costs of working out who is entitled and figuring out a cut off that is fair to everyone is more than the money they save"

Maybe I am being thick here. But what have I missed from the following albeit blunt instrument alternative?

Everyone whose house is valued on zoopla above X / everyone who pays council tax Y or above in their local area is still entitled to the £400 but they have to actively apply for it via some government administered form online or by postoffice hard copy return form.
Immediately filters out those who (i) are so wealthy they do not need it (ii) are wealthy enough that they cannot be bothered with the hassle (iii) could be bothered but not for £400 which is not a significant enough amount to make it worth the admin.

Everyone else in the country who falls below/outside the above gets the payment automatically.
I really cannot see how the admin costs of something like the above is going to be more than the amount which would be saved by the number of well off people who would by default fall into (i), (ii) or (iii) above.

What is wrong with that?

Because you’re including people who may be asset rich but cash poor, and that will include vulnerable people who won’t apply - not because they can afford to lose £400, but who will find the application process so daunting that they won’t do it.

Rosscameasdoody · 27/05/2022 12:26

ShirleyPhallus · 27/05/2022 09:39

What a burden having lots of money is

It isn’t a burden if you’re constantly taxed to the hilt on absolutely everything, because you don’t have it to keep it, it’s used for taxes. You know, to make payments to those lower earners who receive benefits. You also made choices - a choice to do a lower paid job / not train / have children earlier, and presumably you also have a choice whether to accept the benefits that higher tax payers top up.

Not really nice criticism either way is it?

No, and it’s not helpful either. Generally high earners have had more opportunity than those on lower wages, so the ‘choice’ to do a lower paid job is actually down to luck isn’t it ? And FYI people on benefits are tax payers too, as are those on lower wages, so we all contribute to the benefits system in one way or another.

FreddyVoorhees · 27/05/2022 12:25

RoomOfRequirement · 26/05/2022 22:35

I think it's usually because the admin costs of working out who is entitled and figuring out a cut off that is fair to everyone is more than the money they save.

Exactly this. Means testing is expensive and time consuming. Doubt HMRC would be massively thrilled about adding this one to the to do pile after the couple of years they've had.

rainingsnoring · 27/05/2022 12:21

MarshaBradyo · 27/05/2022 12:10

I cross posted with your pp on that, thanks for answering again

I get the exasperation at seeing huge sums flying around and have felt that in the past, the only thing I’d say is there have been a fair few posts from people just outside benefits level who likely will very much need the £400 help. I know the very top do not but I can’t see a way to get it to the lower middle / middle but not benefits in an easy way.

I’m interested in economics and politics too (studied former, no expert but probably have a latent interest which attracts me to the topic) re direction I think a few things stand out

massive global shocks to economy
investment incentive for oil and gas with this levy (which I don’t believe Labour had)
Trying to increase skills with training incentives long term

re benefits iirc they are almost increasing to inflation and it will be a big bill. The other issue is public sector pay and how to not cause inflationary spikes

re Russia, yes again it’s hard to see huge spending but I think it is right in war against Putin which Ukraine needs support with - from everyone not just us

Yes, agree that there are some other groups who are struggling too but this seems the most fair way to target struggling people overall.
There may well be more public sector strikes in the near future as you say.
Unfortunately, I think we are not helping Ukraine at all. We are also increasing the massive hit to the global economy (I think we are heading for worldwide recession). I guess these things always go wrong (conflicts, etc) when resources are in short supply.

Rosscameasdoody · 27/05/2022 12:21

ShirleyPhallus · 27/05/2022 10:07

What taxes do you include within this? We have private healthcare and dentistry, so don’t use the NHS, pay for private nursery without any childcare funding and will pay for private schooling from primary. Those are some huge costs we won’t get back in services. Are you also including things like having bins collected?

It’s your choice to have private healthcare - just because you don’t use the NHS doesn’t mean you shouldn’t contribute. If you have an emergency will you be ringing a private provider - no, you’ll dial 999 and get an ambulance to take you to the nearest NHS hospital for emergency treatment, like the rest of us.

SoggyPaper · 27/05/2022 12:15

Rosscameasdoody · 27/05/2022 12:06

The problem with this approach is that means tested benefits do not always reflect the poorest, as the thresholds for a lot of benefits are set very low and people can sometimes miss them by just a pound or two. As evidenced by several threads on this very subject, a lot of people are struggling and can’t access help because they’re slightly better off than someone who is on the bones of their arse. The system is broken.

I’m amazed at the faith people have in the structure of the benefits system that allows them to think that DWP can easily change stuff. Honestly, it’s really, really not as straightforward as you’d hope to make what seem like small changes to anything with the benefits system.

Assume greater levels of systemic incompetency than you could possibly imagine. And really hard to fix issues within it.

It’s a bit like how impressive conspiracy theorists’ faith is in the competence of governments to not only achieve things but to cover them up effectively too. When in reality, there is absolutely no way any government is pulling off the things they think they have anyway. And certainly no way that they’re doing it secretly.

rainingsnoring · 27/05/2022 12:15

LampLighter414 · 27/05/2022 12:09

Should cover the cost of my empty holiday home's standing charges and occasional heating over the winter to stop the pipes freezing nicely ☺ leaves me with more money to spend elsewhere so the rest of the economy benefits too

Sorry to single this post out but it clearly demonstrates why it is a ridiculous policy.

Topgub · 27/05/2022 12:14

Or the difference between not being able to have any heating on in winter in the home you live in or being able to heat your empty holiday home and spend the difference

🙄

Alexandra2001 · 27/05/2022 12:12

Whooshaagh · 27/05/2022 11:36

It’s not rubbish for one off payments.
Consider the admin necessary to target this payment in 6 months and people would still slip through the net.
Also many working parents are struggling too atm.

This isn't a one off payment, the Govt has put in place the legislation until 2025! Fuel prices will not return to pre 2022 prices for many years, if at all, as we move to net zero, so help for the less well off will be required for a v long time.

Working people who are struggling will, in the main, also be in receipt of UC etc.

The Govt moved child benefit to be means tested to save them billions, so its easily done.

On the price cap, if billing companies cannot make a good profit, then their parent companies may well shut them down e.g BG and EDF..

Ofgem really do need to look at the standing charge again, companies may have incurred costs to take on millions of extra customers but they are not also making money out of them.

Rosscameasdoody · 27/05/2022 12:11

wallpoppy · 27/05/2022 11:41

Rubbish yourself. I actually work on some key software tangentially related to this area (or rather I did before I fucking gave up and went to work on something less broken) and you can't just search up "everyone on benefits already" and then send them some cash for their electric bill. Or go on the HMRC database and search "everyone who made less than £20k last year" and send them some money. Or whatever. It absolutely doesn't work that way, you can't just repurpose an already byzantine and barely-functioning digital system to do something new and provide a new benefit.

You SHOULD be able to, it SHOULD work better, it SHOULD be sensibly put together and maintained, but it absolutely IS NOT for reasons of greed, stupidity, laziness, technological incompetency, and grift. You know, the values of the Tory party.

I don't want Ed Sheeran to be sent £400 to heat his swimming pool either but don't be rude to me just because I'm explaining how this works to people (like you) who don't know.

Well said !!

Swipe left for the next trending thread