Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Preschooler and Extended Learning (Reception - KS1)

44 replies

NC12345678901 · 26/05/2022 18:30

DD is 3 yrs 4 months.

Preschool teacher informed me today that they would like to start something called Extended Learning with DD as she is apparently ready for KS1 learning materials.

I’ve always known that my DD is bright but with this confirmation from a professional, for some odd reason, I’m starting to feel anxious about this, going forwards.

AIBU? TIA.

OP posts:
NC12345678901 · 26/05/2022 22:44

@InChocolateWeTrust

Tbh it's pointless as all they will do in a state school reception is effectively hold your child back to the academic level of her peers.

I see. This is what I’m afraid of. Ok, thank you for sharing your experience. This has helped massively.

OP posts:
InChocolateWeTrust · 26/05/2022 22:41

Tbh it's pointless as all they will do in a state school reception is effectively hold your child back to the academic level of her peers.

DS was similar, not pushed but picked up phonics regardless before school and was very good at number based play.

His reception teacher just fudged baseline assessments to ensure the paperwork suggests he has made adequate progress, while actually expecting little from him all year and teaching him nothing he hadnt already mastered.

NC12345678901 · 26/05/2022 22:38

NC12345678901 · 26/05/2022 21:05

Just to confirm, in terms of the votes, do 88% of you feel that I am being unreasonable to feel anxious about this going forwards? This isn’t clear. Please clarify. TIA

?

OP posts:
NC12345678901 · 26/05/2022 22:37

@FloweryCurtainTwitcher

BTW if it is a funded setting with 15 or 30 hour funding they have to deliver the EYFS- sounds like they wouldn't be complying.

No, it is not a funded setting. Is that what you mean? If so, then no, I am paying for DD’s preschool.

OP posts:
NC12345678901 · 26/05/2022 22:34

Bunnycat101 · 26/05/2022 21:37

I think you’d be bonkers to have a 3yo trying to tackle ks1 material. I have a bright year 1 and a bright 3yo. The cognitive difference between them is massive. The gap between the reception and year 1 curriculum is also massive. 3yos just need to be happy and learn and develop their social skills. If they pre-school are just talking about doing a bit more counting/phonics that is very different to the ks1 curriculum.

Id also say be very careful in terms of pushing on too much. We’ve had a lot of issues this year with my 5yo bringing home school books with content well beyond her age. One day we had a book back with lots of reference to suicide which just isn’t appropriate for a 5yo.

I see. Thank you very much for this information. I will most certainly be taking this on board.

OP posts:
FloweryCurtainTwitcher · 26/05/2022 21:51

Rubbish.
We get children into reception assessed by their nurseries as having met all of the end of reception early learning goals. They cant do any of them and have no understanding.

BTW if it is a funded setting with 15 or 30 hour funding they have to deliver the EYFS- sounds like they wouldn't be complying.

BendingSpoons · 26/05/2022 21:50

It seems quite a jump to move on to the KS1 curriculum when she won't be starting KS1 for over 2 years. Like the PP I have a year 1 child and a 3y3m child. Both are bright, but my youngest is nowhere near ready for KS1 work. For example he can count to 60 and is beginning to add very small numbers e.g. 1+2, but he has nowhere near enough understanding to do the manipulation of numbers DD does in year 1.

When my eldest was in nursery, they started to give her a reading book from Reception, but this was from when she was nearly 4, so basically 6m early. In class it was the same as normal. Of course your DD may be more advanced than this. (Did you say she was reading?) I would find out exactly what they are doing. Is it really KS1 work or just extending what she is already doing, so probably more advanced EYFS work. Also it being done age appropriately, as even if my 3yo could manage the academics of year 1 work, O wouldn't want him doing the formal sit down learning.

Bunnycat101 · 26/05/2022 21:37

I think you’d be bonkers to have a 3yo trying to tackle ks1 material. I have a bright year 1 and a bright 3yo. The cognitive difference between them is massive. The gap between the reception and year 1 curriculum is also massive. 3yos just need to be happy and learn and develop their social skills. If they pre-school are just talking about doing a bit more counting/phonics that is very different to the ks1 curriculum.

Id also say be very careful in terms of pushing on too much. We’ve had a lot of issues this year with my 5yo bringing home school books with content well beyond her age. One day we had a book back with lots of reference to suicide which just isn’t appropriate for a 5yo.

NC12345678901 · 26/05/2022 21:05

Just to confirm, in terms of the votes, do 88% of you feel that I am being unreasonable to feel anxious about this going forwards? This isn’t clear. Please clarify. TIA

OP posts:
NC12345678901 · 26/05/2022 19:50

@careerchange456

It doesn't need to be formally taught in the scenario you have described which as a PP mentioned sounds very much like hot housing.

I completely agree.

A skilled EYFS teacher would be able to incorporate this into the learning environment and provide opportunities to develop this further, possibly with a little one on one time or small group session on phonics, numbers etc throughout the normal week.

Exactly this and I am hoping this will be the case. I will never push DC to do more than what is within her capability both mentally and academically. I just hope that I am making the right choice in agreeing to this change in her curriculum/schedule, so to speak.

Thank you for your reply.

OP posts:
LittleScottieDog · 26/05/2022 19:47

"Extended Learning" sounds made up (by them, not you). It's not an official thing in EYFS, as far as I know. Are the nursery saying they've assessed your daughter and she's already met all the Early Learning Goals across all topics? Even the brightest Reception children I've taught needed support in some areas to either meet or exceed by the end of the year.

You say your daughter can read. Who taught her phonics?

careerchange456 · 26/05/2022 19:46

The thing is, if she's bright, she's very likely to be interested in and pick up reading, numbers etc naturally. It is the preschool's job to spot this and provide the correct resources and opportunities for her to develop this. It doesn't need to be formally taught in the scenario you have described which as a PP mentioned sounds very much like hot housing.

A skilled EYFS teacher would be able to incorporate this into the learning environment and provide opportunities to develop this further, possibly with a little one on one time or small group session on phonics, numbers etc throughout the normal week.

NC12345678901 · 26/05/2022 19:38

Endofdaysarehere · 26/05/2022 19:27

I have a bright one (not in the gifted and talented area by any means) who is having a tortuous time in reception. She’s moving faster than the class and is bored. Her behaviour is suffering and deteriorating daily. Although not disruptive she finds it too hard to sit though lessons that just don’t match to where she is.

I would be very very wary of pushing academics prior to reception and intentionally helping create this type of situation.

I see. I am sorry to hear your DC is having such a difficult time. I will bear this in mind going forwards with my DC. Thank you for your input and advice.

OP posts:
Endofdaysarehere · 26/05/2022 19:27

I have a bright one (not in the gifted and talented area by any means) who is having a tortuous time in reception. She’s moving faster than the class and is bored. Her behaviour is suffering and deteriorating daily. Although not disruptive she finds it too hard to sit though lessons that just don’t match to where she is.

I would be very very wary of pushing academics prior to reception and intentionally helping create this type of situation.

NC12345678901 · 26/05/2022 19:08

Thank you so much for your replies. I will proceed with caution going forwards. I really appreciate gaining feedback from actual teachers. Your advice is priceless. Thank you 💐

OP posts:
NC12345678901 · 26/05/2022 19:07

@careerchange456

This sounds like an absolute disaster. There's absolutely no way a 3 year old needs to be pushed on academic stuff in preschool. Yes she may be bright but that needs to be incorporated into the normal day at preschool - lots of stories/books being read, learning rhymes, solving problems etc

Thanks so much for your reply. I agree with you to a certain extent. In terms of what you’ve suggested in terms of incorporating lots of stories/books being read, learning rhymes etc, I also agree with this, although she is pretty much fluent in all of the above.

Is she extremely able in all areas? Social skills, listening to others, sharing and cooperating, physical development, gross motor skills, fine motor skills, understanding of the world etc? If not, these should be worked on rather than pushing academics.

Yes to all of the above. I’ve always thought she was beyond her years in this respect but with a professional confirming this, in essence it gave me validation of what I already knew. I absolutely believe DD is capable of all of the above and then some.

Thank you very much for your detailed reply.

OP posts:
CaptainMyCaptain · 26/05/2022 18:59

I'm a retired eyfs teacher and agree with the two previous posters. The teacher has probably been set a target 'to improve learning for more able children' so it's a box to tick. I was once told to do this and the parent rightly objected. I hate this target culture and believe young children should be allowed to be young children and develop all aspects of their lives rather than being hot housed in one area.

Maymaymay · 26/05/2022 18:54

I'm an eyfs teacher and this is lazy bad practice. She needs to continue mastering what she knows and having practical experiences. What the teacher is trying to do is hot-housing and will potentially backfire, they should be extending her through their usual provision not starting KS1. Education is a marathon and these years should be spent preparing solid foundations, not rushing off the starting line.

careerchange456 · 26/05/2022 18:41

KS1 lead teacher here

This sounds like an absolute disaster. There's absolutely no way a 3 year old needs to be pushed on academic stuff in preschool. Yes she may be bright but that needs to be incorporated into the normal day at preschool - lots of stories/books being read, learning rhymes, solving problems etc

Is she extremely able in all areas? Social skills, listening to others, sharing and cooperating, physical development, gross motor skills, fine motor skills, understanding of the world etc? If not, these should be worked on rather than pushing academics.

If she really is ready for all of that, then the preschool need to be extremely careful that they follow the same kind of teaching that she will have when she starts school (same phonics scheme, maths scheme, handwriting formation, etc etc) because it's extremely detrimental if a bright children is 'taught' a load of things only for them to have to be unlearnt at school because the child has many gaps in the building blocks of their learning (e.g parents/nurseries teaching column addition/subtraction far too early, using letter names not sounds, allowing children to write in capitals all the time, etc!)

Be extremely cautious with this. Bright preschool children can be challenges and stimulated in a wide variety of ways without resorting to teaching 'academic' stuff. The other skills that a 3 year old needs to develop are of far greater importance.

Swipe left for the next trending thread