Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Preschooler and Extended Learning (Reception - KS1)

44 replies

NC12345678901 · 26/05/2022 18:30

DD is 3 yrs 4 months.

Preschool teacher informed me today that they would like to start something called Extended Learning with DD as she is apparently ready for KS1 learning materials.

I’ve always known that my DD is bright but with this confirmation from a professional, for some odd reason, I’m starting to feel anxious about this, going forwards.

AIBU? TIA.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
FlamingoDust · 27/05/2022 21:01

I personally don't see the problem. My daughter was very similar in nursery and she just wanted to learn. She could read alredy read to a year 2/3 level, count to well over a hundres, talked in complex sentences, had amazing comprehension etc. In nursery they put her in the year above to join in with the phonics classes and she loved it. This continued for the next couple of years until the class no longer did phonics. She got to meet children in other year groups and work with different teachers. It ws a very positive experence from start to finish

Doggyfish · 27/05/2022 19:40

My sons school explained to us at the start of reception that it would feel that they are taking things very slowly but, like building a house, it's important to make sure that the foundations are really solid - otherwise a few years down the line, the house could collapse.

Your job, and nursery's job, is to ensure readiness for school but I think beginning to teach material that forms part of the curriculum could cause some problems down the line, so tread carefully.

Louise0701 · 27/05/2022 19:30

Does she know her number bonds to 20?

Louise0701 · 27/05/2022 19:30

i hope this doesn’t come across as blunt, but you’ve taught her the alphabet as opposed to phonetic sounds and this will be at complete odds with what she will learn in reception.

she won’t know the red & green words etc and she will be “wrong” for reading a letter as Ay Bee Cee Dee etc
the Y1 phonics check will test phonetical knowledge and not whether they can read & say the alphabet.

WhatsOnYourToast · 27/05/2022 19:22

Dont get me wring, she sounds bright for preschool, but she is nowhere near ready for Year 1 work, so I would be quite concerned about them pushing that in her. She has not completed the things expected in Reception, it would be bonkers to start her on year 1 work. It doesn't sound like a very good nursery. Why an earth they'd suggest this for a child who is clearly not ready for this is beyond me. Sometimes they dabble into reception topics but teachers and the children usually find it frustrating because they have to teach writing all over again to very young child because they've been taught to write in print.

She is not able to skip count, can she count backwards and forwards from any given number within 20? There doesn't sound like that much she is off at for reception maths. But for literacy, it doesn't sound like she's completed phonics stages 1 to 4. It sounds like she has memorised and enjoys writing a few specific sentences, but not free writing. (I.e. something brand new and spontaneous that is phonetically plausible with some exception words spelt correctly). Reception children would be able to write the capitals by end of the year and understand to use them for words like I and the beginning of sentences, for names etc.

I would decline the offer and just leave it be, or perhaps just gently support her at home when she wants too. I know CGP does phonics and maths books for 3-4 which she may enjoy before working through 4-5. But ultimately I would definitely reconsider if this is the right environment for her? I could maybe understand doing play based activities within the Eyfs which is where her skills certainly place her, but year 1 for where she is would ring alarm bells for me. What is their goal here? Why expect things of a 3 year old that she clearly can't do?

NC12345678901 · 27/05/2022 18:31

Beees · 27/05/2022 15:33

This, this and this again.

Honestly she's 3 years old please just let her enjoy being 3. 3 year olds should be playing and making new friends not writing sentences and doing timetables.

If this is honestly what her nursery think she should be learning I'd be moving her, they clearly know absolutely nothing about young children.

You’re right. I feel like I want to keep doing 3 year old activities with her because at the end of the day, she’s a very young child. I don’t want her to be force fed materials and activities “just because she is ahead of her years”. Thank you for this clarification and advice.

OP posts:
Beees · 27/05/2022 15:33

Coffeepls · 27/05/2022 08:11

Your child only has limited time to play all day, explore and be free - just because they are bright doesn’t mean they don’t need this crucial development time. Don’t rush them - formal learning will come all too soon and there will be much less time for valuable play.

This, this and this again.

Honestly she's 3 years old please just let her enjoy being 3. 3 year olds should be playing and making new friends not writing sentences and doing timetables.

If this is honestly what her nursery think she should be learning I'd be moving her, they clearly know absolutely nothing about young children.

NC12345678901 · 27/05/2022 15:29

Sorry for the typos with the bold writing in the wrong places. Hope you got the gist 🙂

OP posts:
NC12345678901 · 27/05/2022 15:28

@WhatsOnYourToast

Starting year 1/KS1 materials, are you sure they don't mean reception?

They said Reception and Year 1 materials.

Can she skip count by 2s, 3s and 5s to 10, can she count to 20 and backwards? Addition and subtraction within 10?

She can’t skip count but she can count from 100 backwards. She can add and subtract within 10.

Can she write simple sentences?

She can write “my name is ”, “daddy’s name is ”, “mummy’s name is *”. Although not in cursive.

She can write her ABC’s (not in cursive) in lower case letters but not upper case letters just yet.

Thank you for posting that photo showing cursive writing. I have saved it to my photos.

OP posts:
WhatsOnYourToast · 27/05/2022 10:22

This is the handwriting most schools teach. Has she mastered all of these and can she write simple sentences with them?

Preschooler and Extended Learning (Reception - KS1)
WhatsOnYourToast · 27/05/2022 10:17

Starting year 1/KS1 materials, are you sure they don't mean reception?
Can she skip count by 2s, 3s and 5s to 10, can she count to 20 and backwards? Addition and subtraction within 10?
Can she write simple sentences? Go on Google images and search 'reception writing' as an idea as to whether or not she is there. Have you taught her to write in print or cursive? Most, if not all schools, do cursive from reception. How is her spacing between words?
What sort of books is she reading?

They actually aren't allowed to stretch children too far ahead of the National Curriculum these days, so unless it is an independent school or home education once she's school aged, I would have concerns about her being bored and cresting behavioural issues.

ClaraTanging · 27/05/2022 09:28

Are you saying that your nursery aged child will be starting year 1 learning? This is very impressive and you must be super proud of her. Can she read and write?

My oldest son is in Year 1 and slightly ahead of his peers in reading, maths and English. He’s reading book band brown at the moment which is year 3 I think. Maths is also very good and writing with correct spelling is good too. Once he finishes his work, he either gets golden time - he can read a book, choose to do an activity or he gets extended work. Which is basically a challenge with a little bit of difficulty.

CaptainMyCaptain · 27/05/2022 08:36

FloweryCurtainTwitcher · 26/05/2022 21:51

Rubbish.
We get children into reception assessed by their nurseries as having met all of the end of reception early learning goals. They cant do any of them and have no understanding.

BTW if it is a funded setting with 15 or 30 hour funding they have to deliver the EYFS- sounds like they wouldn't be complying.

Yes I used to get this too.

Coffeepls · 27/05/2022 08:11

Your child only has limited time to play all day, explore and be free - just because they are bright doesn’t mean they don’t need this crucial development time. Don’t rush them - formal learning will come all too soon and there will be much less time for valuable play.

NC12345678901 · 27/05/2022 07:21

@RoseGoldEagle

I wondered this OP. I voted YANBU meaning ‘YANBU to be anxious about this, I don’t think it’s a good idea’. The high number of votes of YABU don’t match the subsequent posts though and without exception they’re advising against it. So I don’t think they mean ‘YABU to be anxious’, I think they mean ‘YABU to go ahead with this’

I see. Thank you for clarifying this for me @RoseGoldEagle and yes, I am apprehensive of going ahead with this based on all the advice.

OP posts:
Whinge · 27/05/2022 07:20

How long has your daughter been at the preschool, and how often does she go?

I agree with the posters saying you should be wary about this. The sudden jump from EYFS to KS1 material is ringing alarm bells. She may be bright but there are plenty of ways to extend her learning without introducing work / materials from the KS1 curriculum.

RoseGoldEagle · 27/05/2022 07:01

Just to confirm, in terms of the votes, do 88% of you feel that I am being unreasonable to feel anxious about this going forwards? This isn’t clear. Please clarify. TIA

I wondered this OP. I voted YANBU meaning ‘YANBU to be anxious about this, I don’t think it’s a good idea’. The high number of votes of YABU don’t match the subsequent posts though and without exception they’re advising against it. So I don’t think they mean ‘YABU to be anxious’, I think they mean ‘YABU to go ahead with this’

There are so many play based ways to make sure children are delighted and enthusiastic about learning. There’s a world of ways they can still stretch and stimulate your DD in age appropriate ways that don’t involve the KS1 syllabus. I think you are right to be wary.

NuttyinNotts · 27/05/2022 06:47

I would want confirmation that this would be taught through play based learning. EYFS is play based, KS1 isn't. I absolutely wouldn't want a 3 year old sat at a desk being taught formally. Extend her learning in a play based style and based on her interests sure, but it doesn't sound great if she would be taught with the expectations of a 6 year old.

Fritilleries · 27/05/2022 06:24

Bunnycat101 · 26/05/2022 21:37

I think you’d be bonkers to have a 3yo trying to tackle ks1 material. I have a bright year 1 and a bright 3yo. The cognitive difference between them is massive. The gap between the reception and year 1 curriculum is also massive. 3yos just need to be happy and learn and develop their social skills. If they pre-school are just talking about doing a bit more counting/phonics that is very different to the ks1 curriculum.

Id also say be very careful in terms of pushing on too much. We’ve had a lot of issues this year with my 5yo bringing home school books with content well beyond her age. One day we had a book back with lots of reference to suicide which just isn’t appropriate for a 5yo.

What makes your children "bright," please? Asking out of curiosity as people say my 3yo is also bright.

NC12345678901 · 27/05/2022 06:15

watcherintherye · 26/05/2022 23:29

You say your daughter can read. Who taught her phonics?

You do know that children can learn to read without the holy grail of phonics, don’t you?

I taught her to read and I taught her phonics. She understands the alphabet as Ay Bee Cee Dee rather than Ah Buh Cuh Duh and so on. I’ve been reading with her every single night since she was about 6 months old.

So when I ask her what a word begins with, she responds with Ay Bee Cee or Dee.

She can also almost count to 100. She’s currently struggling on 80 to 100.

OP posts:
Tigofigo · 26/05/2022 23:36

I'd instead focus on child-led learning. What is your DD interested in? What would she like to learn more about and try doing?

School learning can become so narrow, even in end yR/y1 it's mostly phonics, writing and maths and there's not much v space for child-led learning. I'd rather they used this time to foster a great understanding of the world and skills other than those she'll learn at school.

watcherintherye · 26/05/2022 23:29

You say your daughter can read. Who taught her phonics?

You do know that children can learn to read without the holy grail of phonics, don’t you?

CrabbyCat · 26/05/2022 23:16

DD decided aged 3 years 2 months she was going to learn to read just like her reception age brother, and was bright enough to be capable of doing it. I entirely went with her interests - we did reading but no writing for another year, and no maths at all.

She's now in reception, and on a higher book band than at least a quarter of DC1s year 2 class. However, because we only did this one aspect, she's not bored and there are other children better than her at other aspects - which is motivating her to work hard on those, which I think is an important skill to learn.

DC1 took a few months to get going with reading but than made very rapid progress. When I compare the two, some of the bits she has made much slower progress on are around having the world knowledge to understand some of what she is reading, not having as broad a vocabulary being younger, and picking up some of the higher order skills like inference more slowly. Unless your DD is very driven herself to learn them now, I'm less convinced of the rationale for introducing something now she'd pick her much more rapidly if it was left until she was at school?

NC12345678901 · 26/05/2022 23:04

JessicaBrassica · 26/05/2022 22:47

It can be done well - but probably best if child initiated

D's started reception phonics in preschool. He came home one day and said he didn't like preschool because they wouldn't teach him to read. Flippantly I told him to tell his preschool teacher. Next day she went to the reception teacher and started borrowing materials!

They did it gently and D'S was not significantly ahead of his peers going into yrR but he was very confident. He still loves reading and in yr 5 is the best reader in his class.

Sounds like a bit of a rocky start, but pleased to hear DC is doing well and thriving now in Year 5. That’s lovely. Thank you for sharing your story.

OP posts:
JessicaBrassica · 26/05/2022 22:47

It can be done well - but probably best if child initiated

D's started reception phonics in preschool. He came home one day and said he didn't like preschool because they wouldn't teach him to read. Flippantly I told him to tell his preschool teacher. Next day she went to the reception teacher and started borrowing materials!

They did it gently and D'S was not significantly ahead of his peers going into yrR but he was very confident. He still loves reading and in yr 5 is the best reader in his class.