Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how we stop women ending up with bullshitter/shirker/less than mediocre men?

257 replies

BigOldBlobber · 26/05/2022 13:58

Okay, so I'm not wanting to start a fight, or a finger pointing exercise. And I am most certainly not talking about women who find themselves in abusive or violent homes. I am well aware of the vulnerability some women have, and cycles of abuse.

But, how do we stop future women putting up with mediocrity or really, less than mediocrity from men?! Is it changing expectations of men? Culture change? Gender/sex based role shift?

I have a toddler DD and it really worries me to think that in the future she may end up trapped with a shitty partner.

(This is based off the many threads where women have had children with men, to find out that they have actually become tethered to a man-child, shirker etc)

OP posts:
BlackandBlueBird · 26/05/2022 15:35

In my experience, the women I know who have chosen to be SAHM in a genuine, "I don't want to work and this works more for me" kind of way, are actually pretty happy, as are their partners.

I’m glad you said that. I’m a SAHM by choice. DH never stops telling me how much more important my job is than his. He’s also made sure that I have a lot of independent savings solely in my name.
SAHM doesn’t mean financial control by the husband.

Bananalanacake · 26/05/2022 15:31

Some of it is to do with people moving in together in less than a year of knowing each other. Once the twat is in your home they are more difficult to get rid of. whereas if you realise he's a twat and you don't live together it's much easier to ghost/dump them politely.
There's thread at the moment where the OP wants the guy to leave, it's her home but he has his stuff there. If she had not let him move in she wouldn't have this problem.

IncompleteSenten · 26/05/2022 15:29

As pp say, lead by example

MsMarch · 26/05/2022 15:27

As a society, we have to stop excusing poor behaviour. Stop saying things like, "I'm sure he just didn't think" or "he probably didn't mean it that way" when a man does something wrong. Stop laughing or looking away when men make inappropriate statements or jokes.

I remember the old, "if he pulls your hair at school it's because he likes you" bullshit. That mindset continues and needs to stop.

But in light of the fact that even on a women-dominated forum like MN, there are always loads of posters who tell an OP to stop overreacting or to be more understanding, I'm not hugely confident.

My biggest fear for DD is not that she'll be in a shitty relationship - it's that she won't have an opportunity for a relationship because we're encouraging her to have high standards while the rest of the world is keeping the bar low for men.

Reallyreallyborednow · 26/05/2022 15:25

I think gender stereotypes and that whole gender roles crap still has a lot to answer for.

especially as we seem to be moving away from equality and towards a very binary society, back to pink brain/blue brain, women are good carers and like glitter, men earn money and like sports stuff.

it’s a society wide issue. Why is it always women that go part time/sahm? If it’s because men are paid more why is that? Are women socialised into being less ambitious? So women are at home more and then pick up the wifework. The men are working full time and haves wives at home picking up the slack.

for many working men too there isn’t the flexibility or acceptance of childcare that women are allowed- the amount of times dh got asked “can’t your wife do it” when he left early for nursery run or took a day off for sick kids. I never got asked that.

so we’re still in this model where housework and childcare is womens work, earning money is mens.

then you have all the shit people come out with like “men don’t see dirt”. Of course they fucking do. They just don’t think it’s their job to clean it.

plus the social judgement- if a house is less than clean or the kids less than immaculate whose fault is it? Always the woman. So a man can leave his house a shit tip and it’ll be his wife that is blamed.

so while I fully support the choice to sah or not, i don’t think we’ll get real change until women and men share that burden equally.

Ponderingwindow · 26/05/2022 15:21

@Theblacksheepandme
well yes, learning to look for the red flags is the key. But you also have to allow enough time to do that and enough stresses on the relationship. Having a baby too soon doesn’t give you that chance. It doesn’t have to be engagement and marriage. You could just as easily spend several years living together, deal with the stress of an illness, and get a puppy. The point is to test-drive the relationship and make sure that it can survive some actual living before having a baby. As a middle-aged person, we tend to automatically understand that the dating-engagement-marriage paradigm is symbolic of that.

catscatscatseverywhere · 26/05/2022 15:20

In my opinion, it's low self-esteem and/or ignoring red flags.

Triffid1 · 26/05/2022 15:18

Topgub · 26/05/2022 15:12

@Villagewaspbyke

Lots of women are of the view they need a man because they need someone to pay the bills

Theyre happy enough to rely on them so they dont have to work

Then when they're not happy they're stich with kids and no money

In my experience, the women I know who have chosen to be SAHM in a genuine, "I don't want to work and this works more for me" kind of way, are actually pretty happy, as are their partners. It seems that when the've made this decision, jointly, with their partners, a fairly clear "contract" was agreed up front. And it's a contract in which both roles are appreciated. So, the man might be working long hours, earning lots of money etc, and lots of things are done by his wife to facilitate this and to insulate him from any home "stress" but usually it goes both ways - he's happy for her to spend "his" money on home help, luxuries etc. And the men then do plenty with their children on weekends etc. I have friends in this category and having worked in the City, have met many many couples like this.

It's the SAHM who are forced into it due to circumstances and finances and who are then massively financially abused on top of everything else who land up stuck with kids and no money.

Natty13 · 26/05/2022 15:15

CounsellorTroi · 26/05/2022 14:04

This may not be a popular view on here but I think women who have had good, loving and respectful fathers are much less likely to end up with shitty/mediocre men.

I agree with this but think its more to do with having your mother role model healthy behaviours.

I know a lot of women who pick a lazy man child/stay in crap relationships/people please to the point of burn out and depression who have loving and wonderful fathers. I dont know a single one who had a badass for a mother.

My mum is lovely, soft, warm and friendly but she is a strong woman and won't let anyone walk all over her especially any man so my siblings and u have all grown up to have thst expectation. My brothers are good partners and my sister and I are strong women ourselves. All of us have good balance in our relationships, I think because of the example our mother (and father) set us.

CharSiu · 26/05/2022 15:15

Yep lead by example. It was the 1970’s and my Mother told me to never rely on a man for money. I also saw her stand up to a group of skinheads who were taunting a woman with special needs when I was about 10, she was not afraid of anything. Both her parents had been in the military and my Grandmother would stand up to anyone.

The only issue we have is people and very often other women are the worst find us difficult because we actually consider our own needs.

prettyteapotsplease · 26/05/2022 15:13

We need to bring up girls to have confidence and self-esteem and to learn to say no firmly to awful men. But how? My own dad was a bully and while I got into a few bad relationships early on I somehow had the confidence to walk away - where that came from I do not know. I eventually ended up with 'a good'un' but that was sheer luck.

Ponderingwindow · 26/05/2022 15:13

EcoEcoIA makes a very good point. There simply are not going to be enough quality men for all women to find a co-parent and partner. It’s also true that the odds of finding a quality partner aren’t equally distributed.

Women need to become ok with the idea that it’s ok to end up single. If she still wants to have a child, then formal sperm donation arrangements may be a better option than a lackluster co-parent.

Theblacksheepandme · 26/05/2022 15:12

@Ponderingwindow
some find this old-fashioned, but emphasize the value of the dating-engagement-marriage process before having children. It provides an opportunity to evaluate your potential co-parent and gives you many steps to walk away before you are tied to a person forever by a shared child.

I really don't agree with this. It is something like my 90 yr old MIL would say. There are plenty relationships I know like what you describe and the men treat their wives like crap. They may seem great before the wedding but change afterwards or when a baby arrives. It is all about looking for the red flags and teaching our daughters how to look for them.

BlackandBlueBird · 26/05/2022 15:12

This may not be a popular view on here but I think women who have had good, loving and respectful fathers are much less likely to end up with shitty/mediocre men.

Obviously there are many exceptions (as some PP on this thread) but largely I agree with this.

Also: when I was a child, almost all the Dads I knew were brilliant and involved. I can think of one very strong exception and I always found it so strange going to that friend’s house, that her Dad just sat and watched TV while her Mum did everything. That was really outside the norm (this was in the 90s). There’s no way that I
would’ve put up with a useless DH!

Now I’m a Mum and all of my kids’ friends have really kind, involved Dads. All of my Mum friends have brilliant husbands. I read the threads on here and am pretty shocked tbh. So far outside my sphere of experience.

So I wonder if there are also pockets in society where the deadbeat Dad thing is just way less of an issue and expectations are just higher all round.

Topgub · 26/05/2022 15:12

@Villagewaspbyke

Lots of women are of the view they need a man because they need someone to pay the bills

Theyre happy enough to rely on them so they dont have to work

Then when they're not happy they're stich with kids and no money

rainbowmilk · 26/05/2022 15:11

Make it easier/more acceptable/more represented for women not to have children. Again, won't be a popular view, but in my experience it's motivated by the fact that women want to have kids more than men do, and have a much smaller window in which to do so. I have a number of unhappily married friends and they all say they were running out of time and wanted someone to have kids with, even if he "wasn't perfect".

In some respects, yes, you're fighting biology, but I also believe that there's such a huge social stigma around women being single and childlessness, and it contributes to the fact that women continue to accept men who quite frankly don't deserve to be in a relationship.

TiredButDancing · 26/05/2022 15:11

But these men don't announce themselves into your life as useless, lazy fuckers. There's a gradual decline over time. And then you think 'but he'll step up when the baby is here because it's his child'. And he doesn't.

I disagree. I think the signs are OFTEN there. But they are ignored or dismissed as "boys will be boys" or because women have been socialised to accept things. It certainly wasn't a surprise to any of us that BIL didn't step up when they had children. I've been to a number of weddings over the years where DH and I have privately wondered.... sure enough, they might still be together but the woman has done all the sacrificing and parenting etc to her greater or lesser detriment...
The families you meet on the playground and who you then aren't surprised when you hear they've split up a few years later.

It's often NOT a surprise. Yes, the truly evil abusive ones who are clever camelons hide it, but the day to day lazy, entitled shits... you can spot them a mile away if you know what to look for.

orwellwasright · 26/05/2022 15:06

There are intrinsic and extrinsic factors. Women need to be brought up to be confident and value themselves.

But equally we need to examine a culture where women are still expected to subjugate their needs to a man because men are important and women are there to prop them up.

Triffid1 · 26/05/2022 15:06

Interesting how many of these posts are about changing girls...

I think expecting our daughters to have good role models, male and female, is right (don't have to be an actual parent).

The socialisation of girls being kind/helpful etc and boys being noisy/cheeky starts ridiculously early - we need to nip this in the bud for both girls and boys. It's completely pointless changing girls' attitudes if we don't change the boys' too - dangerous in fact as then there are more boys (men) who won't get girls (women) and as we saw in Plymouth, this has all kinds of other consequences.

Also, stop telling women to overrule their instincts or to compromise when there's no need. I see it on here time and time again. A woman in the early stages of dating a man just isn't quite feeling it. The things she's not loving might well be red flags, but sometimes they're just things that don't work for her - he calls too often/too seldom/too early/too late, she doesn't like the way he talks about his job, she finds his toes a total turnoff... And yet, time and time again she's told that she should accept it. Why? I never understand this. I'm not saying that relationships have to be perfect but if you're compromising massively right from the start, it doesn't bode well for your long term prospects. My dad once told me that if a relationship is hard from the beginning when things are easy, how on earth will it survive when things genuinely get hard. Advice to live by I say.

BigOldBlobber · 26/05/2022 15:03

@EcoEcoIA I suppose I'm wondering more about heterosexual relationships as those are the ones often complained about on MN, or raised. A lot of women probably would be better off alone rather than paired with men.
Also my pondering doesn't take into account lesbian relationships. I wonder if they face the same amounts of disrespect.

OP posts:
Lightning020 · 26/05/2022 15:02

I think it does not help matters either that perhaps the majority of women cannot last without a man. It should be a wish not a need. Luckily I prefer single but many women are still hoping for the one and then take somebody on as they cannot hack being on their own. Even if he is mediocre.

overponder · 26/05/2022 15:01

StepAwayFromGoogling · 26/05/2022 14:29

Oh god, I wish I knew the answer to this. Yes to the positive father figure. But these men don't announce themselves into your life as useless, lazy fuckers. There's a gradual decline over time. And then you think 'but he'll step up when the baby is here because it's his child'. And he doesn't. But your children love him and you don't want to blow apart their home. So you end up just getting on with it. And thus you model it for the next generation...

Basically this. In a cocklodging nutshell.

BigOldBlobber · 26/05/2022 14:59

@Ponderingwindow It would be seen as old fashioned but I honestly agree. Me and DH got together at 15, and he wanted kids around 20. I told him no frigging way until we'd both got a degree/trade, a house and a marriage. His family very much thought I was being dramatic.

OP posts:
Theblacksheepandme · 26/05/2022 14:58

AchatAVendre
Educate both sexes about it in schools? What makes a healthy relationship is taught in Dutch schools, as is respect for women.

Completely agree with you.

EcoEcoIA · 26/05/2022 14:57

Why do women have to end up with men?
But if we would like to imagine an "ideal" world in which each woman would end up with a man who is above say the bottom 20% in honesty, conscientious, etc... then there would be no more than 80% of the male heterosexual population meeting those criteria (probably less because the combination of attributes is rarer than the possession of just one attribute), which we would want to pair with 100% of the female heterosexual population. Assuming the numbers of heterosexual men and heterosexual women are approximately equal then we are trying to match (less than) 80% of a number with 100% of the same number. That would imply polygyny.
If we would prefer monogamous (or serially monogamous) pairing and we consider that levels of honesty, conscientiousness etc.. might be equally distributed among the sexes then the problem seems to be a more tractable one of each person finding a person at their own level, though given the dishonesty with which people misrepresent themselves it may take some time for each person to discover another's true value.

Swipe left for the next trending thread