Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how we stop women ending up with bullshitter/shirker/less than mediocre men?

257 replies

BigOldBlobber · 26/05/2022 13:58

Okay, so I'm not wanting to start a fight, or a finger pointing exercise. And I am most certainly not talking about women who find themselves in abusive or violent homes. I am well aware of the vulnerability some women have, and cycles of abuse.

But, how do we stop future women putting up with mediocrity or really, less than mediocrity from men?! Is it changing expectations of men? Culture change? Gender/sex based role shift?

I have a toddler DD and it really worries me to think that in the future she may end up trapped with a shitty partner.

(This is based off the many threads where women have had children with men, to find out that they have actually become tethered to a man-child, shirker etc)

OP posts:
janeseymour78 · 26/05/2022 19:13

ThinWomansBrain · 26/05/2022 17:08

By normalising - and teaching girls - that it is perfectly acceptable not to be in a relationship.

I have finally made this peace with myself lately. I was in relationships from 14-28 and now at 30 have been single for a couple of years (with some lovers as I love being single but not celibate ☺️)

I've only ever really loved two men. The first we were too young and stupid to make a proper go of it - and really he was too passive and his family were a nightmare. The second I loved a lot and did live with for a time, but be cheated on me and I was broken for a while. Lost every ounce of confidence.

Over the years nearly all the men I've dated have expected me to fit into their lifestyles or had a vision of what our lives should be like. Right now I have a great job, amazing friends, my own home...and I'm honestly very content. I'm sure I'll meet someone and do feel the pressure of marriage etc from family at times. But given I feel so content it does have me questioning why we're fed this line about how awful it is being single.

Topgub · 26/05/2022 19:02

@User135644

It can also teach mysoginy and homophobia

No thanks

orwellwasright · 26/05/2022 19:00

User135644 · 26/05/2022 17:17

I quoted the wrong post here but you're right. Women are often desperate to have children/a family and then will pick Mr Average during their main fertile years.

What's wrong with average??

User135644 · 26/05/2022 18:59

Topgub · 26/05/2022 18:21

@User135644

Wtf has the church got to do with it?

Men are taught not to care, thats the problem

It can teach responsibility.

orwellwasright · 26/05/2022 18:58

hobosexual

Are they the ones who fancy hobbits?

AchatAVendre · 26/05/2022 18:55

BeatricePortinari This actually applies to all personal choices you make for yourself: your health, your appearance, your home, your friends, your career. If a man sees that you take care of yourself in all these ways because you value yourself, he will respond to the value you place on yourself.

Unlikely. Not enough men earn enough money any more for women to base their lives and happiness around attracting a man. Its also really bad for your self confidence if you do these things for some imaginary fairytale man, rather than your own health/career/wellbeing.

What needs to be resolved is the large number of low quality men who have issues regarding control which manifest themselves in abuse, along with men who cannot form healthy relationships because they practice what basically amounts to unformalised polygyamy.

Many men just seem to have very unrealistic ideas of relationships. There was a video going around social media this morning of a young man who had put his requirements for a girlfriend in a series of demands, which included his knowing the password to her phone, dictating how she dressed and knowing her whereabouts at all times by using a tracking app on her phone.

The fact that we are getting such young men thinking this is acceptable is worrying and I think it does need some education for both girls and boys that this is not a way to form a healthy relationship.

Sceptre86 · 26/05/2022 18:53

I was raised to belive I was equal to any man to believe I was worthy, valuable and loved. I know my worth. I am an introvert but have an inner confidence that my parents instilled in me. They raised me up. They also led by example so when my dad was home, he'd be working alongside my mum doing chores. My brother wasn't let off because he was a boy and my parents raised us all to pitch in. It was very much it was everyone's home so we all had to take our share of responsibility and as for cleaning after dinner muydad would emphasise that if we all did a bit then we could all sit and relax together rather than one person being stuck in the kitchen. My parents emphasised that a big part of love is actually respect and that if you can see someone is knackered but don't do anything to lighten their load , you don't care about them very much. That lesson has stayed with me.

My dh will never add to my load, instead he always tries to lessen it or share. That means more to me than superficial stuff like, big declarations of love on social media or expensive presents. He is an equal parent and is just as capable as me. He cooks and cleans and is respectful of me. We discussed this before getting married though and if he wasn't on the same page I wouldn't have married him.

The whole 'men don't get it' is a shitty excuse for poor behaviour and I won't stand for it but many women do and I think a lot of them make a rod for their own back by getting with worthless men. I'm on a Facebook group for women who've had babies at the same time as me and many are having issues with their mh, I haven't pointed it out but they are all the women who have complained about uninterested partners, ones whose life hasn't changed since baby arrived, who sleep in different rooms because they can't possibly have disturbed sleep, who can't cook a meal as they've been at work all day and won't take care of the baby so their partner can because they need time to unwind.Many of these women describe men who were useless before they had kids (couldn't possibly do the grocery shop, meal plan or cook) so I have limited sympathy on the rants because they won't address the behaviour. It's different before you have kids, they can maybe take it on without feeling aggrieved but the resentment builds when you have a baby that isn't sleeping, is teething, has colic etc and the oh waits for his tea because he couldn't possibly cook it. One women has recently posted that she is engaged but if you go off of her posts the oh is completely uninterested in the baby, leaves all household chores to her and is one of those who doesn't get it. So many people offered her congratulations but when one sensible person said that she should think carefully before accepting the proposal she was called a Debbie downer. This group is full of many educated women so it's common in all walks of life. I don't understand why they won't raise their standards.

Topgub · 26/05/2022 18:44

I agree @Reallyreallyborednow

We should be moving away from the idea that appearance is linked to self respect not enforcing it

Same with linking self respect and sexual partners

Reallyreallyborednow · 26/05/2022 18:41

This actually applies to all personal choices you make for yourself: your health, your appearance, your home, your friends, your career. If a man sees that you take care of yourself in all these ways because you value yourself, he will respond to the value you place on yourself

my appearance? Really? I don’t give a fuck about my appearance, does that mean I don’t value myself and a man can treat me like shit?

if anything I think we place too high a value on appearance over everything else.

Ponoka7 · 26/05/2022 18:30

"I’ll be encouraging my DDs to stay single and have fun!"

And if they do and aren't celibate, they'll get accused of having low self esteem because they aren't withholding sex before they get a commitment. You've only got to look at threads about fuck buddies. According to a lot of posters we all should have good self esteem which will make us aspire to a relationship.

Topgub · 26/05/2022 18:21

@User135644

Wtf has the church got to do with it?

Men are taught not to care, thats the problem

UpToMyElbowsInDiapers · 26/05/2022 18:18

I think about this a lot. I have a 5yo DD and 3yo and 1yo DSs. Because DD is the oldest it’s sooooo easy to fall into the habit of making her the “responsible one”, even though she’s still really young. I’m trying to make a very conscious effort to place the same caring & cleaning demands on my 3yo DS as on her, even though it takes more work sometimes given his age.

So: if the baby’s nose is running, I try to ask DS first for a tissue. He needs to clean up his toys like his sister, clear his dinner plate like his sister, and sweep and vacuum the floor every now and then (it helps that he loves those tasks!). I’m trying to teach him from as young as possible to be competent around the home, so that I’m hoping he’ll be a natural at it when he has a partner.

I’m also trying to teach him to NOTICE what needs to be done, so that the mental load doesn’t all fall on his eventual partner. E.g., if he’s come down the stairs and left open the baby gate, instead of saying “close the gate”, I’ll say “look around - what have you forgotten to do”.

This may sound crazy with a 3yo but I think it’s really important!

ScarlettSunset · 26/05/2022 18:17

In my own case it was due to poor role models. I honestly thought it was normal and was just how it was. Pretty much everyone I knew was in similarly rubbish relationships.

I decided though, that I'd rather be alone than stick with it so I got out. I did eventually meet someone else who is a world away from all that and it's been a huge revelation that decent men even existed.

I'm sure, if I hadn't seen women just 'putting up with it', I'd have known there were better options out there

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 26/05/2022 18:13

@CounsellorTroi I don't agree with what you've said... my dad was an amazing man and fantastic father. I've floundered in relationships with awful men as I'd assumed they'd all be like my dad. They were not.

butimjayigetaway · 26/05/2022 18:12

CounsellorTroi · 26/05/2022 14:04

This may not be a popular view on here but I think women who have had good, loving and respectful fathers are much less likely to end up with shitty/mediocre men.

I think your right, it's modelling.

Growing up with a good relationship to model is important.

It's not just that though.

I was this woman. There was nothing wrong with me. I supported myself and was a nice person living on my own and working.

So why did I think an absolute waste of oxygen was a good partner for almost a decade?

I think it's because I, and others, have no inclination to actually seek out a decent life partner. It's all 'I don't need a man and I'm just going to have fun' type of narrative.

For the most part women want families and a good partner, so why is this not a priority?

Did your mother ever say anything to you akin to 'find a decent man and settle down'?

Did your parents ever speak to you about what to look for in a good partner? How to be a good partner? How to work with a man on each other's strengths to form the basis of a family?

If not, I do believe this a big part of the problem. Pairing up is not seen as a priority when in reality it is maybe the thing that has the biggest impact on our lives - in fact I will go out on a limb and say it is the thing that has the biggest impact on our lives; it affects our financial stability, mental health, parenting, ability to become a parent, career, and happiness.

Bedknobbroomsticks · 26/05/2022 18:10

I was raised in a culture where women are second rate to men and this idea was enforced by my parents. They were not enlightened enough to go against the grain as some of my friends' parents were. So I didn't have much self esteem and wasn't respected by my male siblings or parents. So ended up in relationships where I wasn't treated with respect because I didn't recognise what that behaviour looked like. It becomes a vicious cycle because I worry we're not modelling a healthy relationship a home for DD.

The biggest difference is that I do talk to DD a lot about self respect and work hard on her confidence and making sure she understands what qualities to look for in a partner. The other big difference (as other posters have pointed out) is that if DD does make a mistake, I'll always be there to have her back no matter what. I've not been able to walk away from mine as in my culture it would bring too much shame on my family and my family aren't supportive of us separating. I can't face dealing with a separation and the issues of co-parenting as well as the fallout from my own family.

With age, I look back and see why I've made the decisions I did in terms of relationships. I'm using this to hopefully teach DD to make wiser choices. If she doesn't, she fully knows she can walk away and I'll be there for her.

User135644 · 26/05/2022 18:07

Topgub · 26/05/2022 17:56

@Confuseddotcombo

Men and women are different but there's no biological reason for women to care about cushions

Society tells women they should

Fuck knows why though.

I think that's the difference though. A lot of men don't give a fuck about what society expects, they do what they want. The decline of the church/nuclear family in our culture has only accelerated that.

Perhaps men are more individual/women are more collective (hunter/gatherer etc).

Bedknobbroomsticks · 26/05/2022 18:04

I was raised in a culture where women are second rate to men and this idea was enforced by my parents. They were not enlightened enough to go against the grain as some of my friends' parents were. So I didn't have much self esteem and wasn't respected by my male siblings or parents. So ended up in relationships where

CaptSkippy · 26/05/2022 18:03

BeatricePortinari · 26/05/2022 16:52

I am a woman.

I value women highly.

I see a lot of unhappiness for women as expressed right here on this thread.

I'm expressing my not currently fashionable view in good faith as I think it would have better outcomes for women. And I'd like to see that.

Feel free to disagree but your snide and insults are not warranted.

Women are unhappy because of shitty men and your solution is to scare these women into relationship with these shitty men by saying they will be unhappy unless they don't.

Under the circumstances, I've been shokingly nice.

minipie · 26/05/2022 18:03

Hmm well I know lots of couples where the husband likes a nice house, holidays, social life and well brought up DC just as much as the wife does

but the DH expects it to all just happen somehow on minimal effort from him

it’s not that the DH has lower standards for these things, just doesn’t see them as his problem to make them happen

CounsellorTroi · 26/05/2022 18:01

rainbowmilk · 26/05/2022 17:28

Yep. Not much you can do about those who'll pick up whatever is on offer because having the kids is more important than who the father of them is. The friends I mentioned are smart, strong women with great starts in life, who got all the right messages, and in theory there was no reason why they should be where they are - except that they prioritised having kids over everything else. That's their right, and probably quite difficult to argue with.

But I do think there are women who are socialised into having kids rather than making an active choice, and I'd like to see more that represents childlessness in a positive way, and helps to reassure people that that's a perfectly happy way of life for many.

Absolutely this.

Topgub · 26/05/2022 17:56

@Confuseddotcombo

Men and women are different but there's no biological reason for women to care about cushions

Society tells women they should

Fuck knows why though.

Confuseddotcombo · 26/05/2022 17:45

Different perspective here, what if the woman earns way more than the DH who works PT? Woman pays majority of the bills/ child costs, but DH cooks/cleans/ childcare. She does life admin because he doesn’t have the attention to detail and she is controlling.

On paper he might look like a cocklodger, but maybe that’s their deal.

He is lucky, but she gets to do what she wants. There is no magic formula for splitting the ‘work’ of running a household/bringing up a family. But might not last when kids no longer need him and balance goes out of kilter.

The truth is women tend to care more about more shit than men….

  • Home decor (he doesn’t care about nice kitchens and cushions)
  • posh meals out (he’s happy with a burger)
  • planning 5* holidays (he just wants a beer in the sun)
  • cleaning spotlessly (he does an ok job, woman re-does it)
  • varied activities for the kids
  • interest in parenting theory (he feels his way through it)
Men and women are different. Roles have been reversed and it can be confusing. I think a lot of men don’t really care as much about the things women do, so they don’t put as much effort in.

Also I don’t know many couples which fit the ideal of earning similar incomes and splitting family ‘work’ out equally. It’s unrealistic.

I think the key is balance and each bringing a similar effort to the table.

rainbowmilk · 26/05/2022 17:28

User135644 · 26/05/2022 17:17

I quoted the wrong post here but you're right. Women are often desperate to have children/a family and then will pick Mr Average during their main fertile years.

Yep. Not much you can do about those who'll pick up whatever is on offer because having the kids is more important than who the father of them is. The friends I mentioned are smart, strong women with great starts in life, who got all the right messages, and in theory there was no reason why they should be where they are - except that they prioritised having kids over everything else. That's their right, and probably quite difficult to argue with.

But I do think there are women who are socialised into having kids rather than making an active choice, and I'd like to see more that represents childlessness in a positive way, and helps to reassure people that that's a perfectly happy way of life for many.

PrimarilyParented · 26/05/2022 17:24

Teach daughters and sons how to leave poor relationships and that this is something to be proud of not ashamed of. Teach them self worth and that no matter what mistakes they make in relationships they can start over and you will be there to support them. People of both genders end up in crap relationships and stay, this is what needs to change.

also, teach your daughters and sons to never be financially beholden to anyone or to lose their identity to them, this will mean that they can leave a bad situation when they want to.