Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how we stop women ending up with bullshitter/shirker/less than mediocre men?

257 replies

BigOldBlobber · 26/05/2022 13:58

Okay, so I'm not wanting to start a fight, or a finger pointing exercise. And I am most certainly not talking about women who find themselves in abusive or violent homes. I am well aware of the vulnerability some women have, and cycles of abuse.

But, how do we stop future women putting up with mediocrity or really, less than mediocrity from men?! Is it changing expectations of men? Culture change? Gender/sex based role shift?

I have a toddler DD and it really worries me to think that in the future she may end up trapped with a shitty partner.

(This is based off the many threads where women have had children with men, to find out that they have actually become tethered to a man-child, shirker etc)

OP posts:
AllAloneInThisHouse · 28/05/2022 11:49

I agree with the few comments (shame more women don’t see that) who said about supporting women to remain single, and childfree.
Stop shaming women who are single and who don’t have kids.
Women can be perfectly happy and have good lives without ever being involved with a man in a romantic/sexual way and without having kids.

Daleksatemyshed · 28/05/2022 11:03

Society is always changing but attitudes change more slowly. There may be far fewer overtly racist people but still sadly many racists who've just learnt not to say it aloud.In the same way, a lot of men, and women, say the right things but don't really believe them when it comes to relationships.
Over and over posts on MN show a man who changed after his first DC, he didn't change, he just made all the right noises. Look at a man's actions, not what he says

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 28/05/2022 10:23

spotcheck · 28/05/2022 10:18

@Bedknobbroomsticks

Yes, good friends DO tell friends when they are making a mistake. But also, you can't make someone value themselves. Sometimes life has to teach us, and we have to learn it ourselves.

People KNOW they drink too much/eat too much/ form bad relationships. It isn't going to be brand new, revelatory information when a friend points it out - all it does is make you feel isolated from that friend.

That’s not true at all. I’d let myself get really out of shape a few years back and it was only when a friend politely pointed out how far I’d let it go that I realised it was time to do something about it.

fUNNYfACE36 · 28/05/2022 10:20

Nothappyatwork · 26/05/2022 14:37

My youngest DD is 18 and it’s almost as if it’s like an inbuilt ingrained urge she has to fix people and put them right and of course men absolutely love this and lap it up, she’s from a very nice home nobody around her is into drink or drugs but she just can’t help like bringing the stray dogs home. One of them will get her pregnant. I would genuinely love to know what the answer is.

I could have written this about my 20 year old dd.The man she is with now seems very devoted and thoughtful.The thing that worries me is his dm has been married 4 x ( divorces down to badly behaving men) so he has no template for a long lasting forever marriage

spotcheck · 28/05/2022 10:18

@Bedknobbroomsticks

Yes, good friends DO tell friends when they are making a mistake. But also, you can't make someone value themselves. Sometimes life has to teach us, and we have to learn it ourselves.

People KNOW they drink too much/eat too much/ form bad relationships. It isn't going to be brand new, revelatory information when a friend points it out - all it does is make you feel isolated from that friend.

Mumoblue · 28/05/2022 10:08

While I do believe that everyone is responsible for their own choices- if holding women accountable for men mistreating them changed anything, this world would be a utopia by now. It doesn’t.

Also it’s funny to see people say that shitty men are “bad boys” and “exciting”. The guy who turned out to be a waste of space on me was anything BUT an “exciting bad boy”.

Sometimes this “women bring it on themselves by choosing wrong” attitude sounds like just another way for people to convince themselves My Nigel Would Never.
And I don’t even think it helps women at all. In fact this kind of attitude can cause women to paper over cracks early on so as to not look like they chose poorly and “failed” at relationships.

CounsellorTroi · 28/05/2022 09:34

A lot of women are attracted to shit men because they have charm or are handsome or exciting. Then he turns out to be a bad partner. Or they get tired of the bad boys and settle for some mediocre man who they never really liked to begin with because they wanted kids.

A lot of women think they can change men too. They rarely can.

User135644 · 28/05/2022 09:30

Bednobsbroomsticks · 28/05/2022 07:41

This probably won't go down well but women have to start taking responsibility for their decisions. We are not weak little victims. If he is an arsehole then leave. If you move him in after 5 minutes then wonder where the nice helpful guy went, well what did you expect moving a stranger in? He cheats and you stick around and he cheats again? No surprises.

Men will treat you how you allow them to.

I see my friend go from one disaster to another. Kids suffering. But I'm nit allowed to question her choices because she's a grown woman and has been a victim? She has been with a man for years that made her kids life hell. Is that her fault?

Most women will meet a dodgy guy at some point. It's what they choose to do about it that matters. Look at all these women who idolise johny depop who calls women whores and c*s. Women need to raise the bar.

A lot of women are attracted to shit men because they have charm or are handsome or exciting. Then he turns out to be a bad partner. Or they get tired of the bad boys and settle for some mediocre man who they never really liked to begin with because they wanted kids.

Pippainthegarden · 28/05/2022 09:25

museumum · 28/05/2022 09:00

It’s so much broader than just an individual couple. It’s all of society’s attitudes. If you visit a friend do you judge her husband if the floor needs a hoover? If your brother doesn’t buy presents for his niece and nephew do you wonder why your sil didn’t step up?
women take over and cover up for their partners not doing their fair share because if they don’t other women judge the woman in the relationship.

Have you ever seen an advert for air freshener where it’s a man screwing up his nose in disgust? Of course not!

Absolutely, half the time it’s other women putting this pressure on

Pippainthegarden · 28/05/2022 09:23

I have the most wonderful dh now but having been in this situation and seeing the cycle perpetuated among the young women I see through my work and their poor mother’s who often feel helpless I often wonder this. I do just wish I could give them the knowledge and self respect I now have.
I think we just need to guide our young people the best we can and continue having the support that exists in this country. The benefits and housing system meant I was able to get out, it is just a shame it’s being ever more eroded. I see it therefore as all the more important to try and encourage my girls to pass their test, get some of their own security etc before embarking on having children and women need to better recognise the benefits of marriage/civil partnerships. However some people take this to the extreme and insist on working in jobs stressing them out just in case they end up single and then they end up single as all their effort is on the defensive. Children growing up with positive role models would also help but among friends and even reading MNs can see why peoples relationships don’t work out due to the attitude of both men and women. The value and effort of unpaid care work is completely undervalued and not acknowledged which probably doesn’t help in most relationships. It takes 2 to tango and make a relationship work however

FabFitFifties · 28/05/2022 09:08

It would be the end of humanity due to lack of alternatives. Maybe not such a bad thing.

balalake · 28/05/2022 09:02

Make sure you never vote for a party led by one. Boris Johnson is the perfect role model for the kind of man the OP describes.

museumum · 28/05/2022 09:00

It’s so much broader than just an individual couple. It’s all of society’s attitudes. If you visit a friend do you judge her husband if the floor needs a hoover? If your brother doesn’t buy presents for his niece and nephew do you wonder why your sil didn’t step up?
women take over and cover up for their partners not doing their fair share because if they don’t other women judge the woman in the relationship.

Have you ever seen an advert for air freshener where it’s a man screwing up his nose in disgust? Of course not!

Badbadbunny · 28/05/2022 08:58

Chilver · 27/05/2022 19:09

I've only read to end of page 2 but can't believe that all barr two of the responses are about women and girls changing. I don't disagree but what about all the women raising boys? How about raising boys to be respectful and good role models themselves??

Of course we need to do that too for the longer term. But, today, here and now, we can't change today's mens' behaviour. All we can do today, is be more choosy and careful ourselves.

We have to deal with the practicality of our actions/choices today. We have the power to do that now with who we choose as partners and ensure our own independence/protection so we can walk away if necessary. It's all we can do short term.

As long as today's feckless blokes can still get replacement girlfriends/partners, they'll not change their behaviour. If they start being told to bugger off when they start behaving badly, they may start to get the message but it will take a lot of time.

Changing mens' behaviour is for the longer term. Yes, we can educate and nurture our sons to respect women and our daughters not to put up with bullshit, but that's long term.

So two pronged attack. Protect ourselves short term and educate for the long term.

CounsellorTroi · 28/05/2022 08:58

We need a new narrative that it really is OK to be single, it really is OK to prefer girls rather than boys, etc etc. I sometimes think it's become easier for a teen girl to say she's gay rather than have the pressure of explaining why she's not got a boyfriend.

Also that it is really ok not to want children. Or at least to be really really choosy about the father. That not having children is not necessarily worse than having them with a shit father.

Whitehorsegirl · 28/05/2022 08:53

I think women have for a long time been conditioned to put their needs last and to believe that having a relationship and to maintain it at all cost should be their main goal.

I realise I was putting up with dodgy men because I had low self-esteem, was raised by an abusive father and did not know what a healthy relationship should be like. I did not respect myself and my body.

I think we need to both change society as a whole so that is it less misogynist but also work on ourselves to raise our expectations when it comes to men.

There is also something about the need for parents to raise boys to be respectful of women. There is a recent thread which I found really disturbing where a mum is trying to minimise her adult son verbally and physically assaulting her daughter as ''out of character''...as long as we give men excuses like that and allow them to treat us poorly this cycle will continue.

CounsellorTroi · 28/05/2022 08:50

When it comes to partners, I've always taken things very slow. I cringe when I've seen friends "fall in luuuuuuvv" instantly and virtually move in with a guy within the week - 9 times out of 10 it leads to misery. People need to think with their head and not their heart.

or with other parts of their body. Women can do this as much as men.

Badbadbunny · 28/05/2022 08:46

@spotcheck

And these men are clever- they aren't assholes/ liars all the time. They create an illusion. People like us want the illusion to be real, so so badly.

But the red flag signs are usually there if you look for them. Trouble is too many people generally don't question things, whether it's choosing a partner, buying a car/house, or whatever. Far too many people just accept things at face value. Yes, it's not nice to by cynical and questionning about everything, but it's pretty much essential to avoid being let down, in whatever way.

When it comes to partners, I've always taken things very slow. I cringe when I've seen friends "fall in luuuuuuvv" instantly and virtually move in with a guy within the week - 9 times out of 10 it leads to misery. People need to think with their head and not their heart. I've ditched boyfriends after I've seen how they behave after a few drinks. I ditched one who became really nasty and aggressive when someone else accidentally drank out his glass. The "true colours" are always there just beneath the surface and we should stop falling for their apologies.

We also need a culture change away from the "we need a man" mentality. Young girls are conditioned into obsessing about hair and make up and told how beautiful they are. Then you get pop music, a lot of which is about waiting for a man, a man choosing you, taking a man back, etc. I cringe when you see those old films where the woman are sat at the edge of a dancefloor just waiting to be chosen by a man for a dance and accepting any man who comes to choose them - in a lot of ways, we've really not moved on. School is dominated by girls discussing boyfriends, pressure on those without boyfriends to get one, etc.

We need a new narrative that it really is OK to be single, it really is OK to prefer girls rather than boys, etc etc. I sometimes think it's become easier for a teen girl to say she's gay rather than have the pressure of explaining why she's not got a boyfriend.

Bednobsbroomsticks · 28/05/2022 08:28

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 28/05/2022 08:24

If your friends can’t tell you when you are making a mistake then who can?

I’ve told a friend before that they are drinking too much, and another that they are in a bad relationship that was doing them harm.

It’s what good friends do.

Agree wholeheartedly

Bednobsbroomsticks · 28/05/2022 08:27

spotcheck · 28/05/2022 08:05

I think you nailed it.

I was raised in house where I was resented, neglected and verbally abused. It took me a depressingly long time to figure out what was actually normal ( rather than what 'felt' normal. )

Sorry you went through that (hugs). Exactly this though. What my friend thinks is normal isn't and it seems her recognising this isn't allowed by telling her she's making bad decisions. It doesn't help her

Bednobsbroomsticks · 28/05/2022 08:25

spotcheck · 28/05/2022 08:20

This probably won't go down well but women have to start taking responsibility for their decisions

This makes me seethe. I lost friends because they judged my 'choices' . The same friends who are all #bekind

Everyone ( I repeat Every. One) has a battleground. It may be food, relationships with friends, career, romantic relationships- but it is all the same thing- our sense of self worth.

Some people have excellent tools because they were raised with love and kindness. Others flounder because we don't know what it feels like to be valued and treated with love. And these men are clever- they aren't assholes/ liars all the time. They create an illusion. People like us want the illusion to be real, so so badly.

So, people who judge their friends might want to look at where their own weaknesses are, and ask if they want to be judged BY THEIR FRIENDS for the amount they eat/ drink, for being too scared to enter a career you want or whatever their battlefield is

My point was I can't judge and don't say these things. Instead I am there to listen to all the shit they go through. But at what point xan you say to a woman what if you made different choices? You can't. You have to keep quiet and support . And on and on it goes...

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 28/05/2022 08:24

spotcheck · 28/05/2022 08:20

This probably won't go down well but women have to start taking responsibility for their decisions

This makes me seethe. I lost friends because they judged my 'choices' . The same friends who are all #bekind

Everyone ( I repeat Every. One) has a battleground. It may be food, relationships with friends, career, romantic relationships- but it is all the same thing- our sense of self worth.

Some people have excellent tools because they were raised with love and kindness. Others flounder because we don't know what it feels like to be valued and treated with love. And these men are clever- they aren't assholes/ liars all the time. They create an illusion. People like us want the illusion to be real, so so badly.

So, people who judge their friends might want to look at where their own weaknesses are, and ask if they want to be judged BY THEIR FRIENDS for the amount they eat/ drink, for being too scared to enter a career you want or whatever their battlefield is

If your friends can’t tell you when you are making a mistake then who can?

I’ve told a friend before that they are drinking too much, and another that they are in a bad relationship that was doing them harm.

It’s what good friends do.

spotcheck · 28/05/2022 08:20

This probably won't go down well but women have to start taking responsibility for their decisions

This makes me seethe. I lost friends because they judged my 'choices' . The same friends who are all #bekind

Everyone ( I repeat Every. One) has a battleground. It may be food, relationships with friends, career, romantic relationships- but it is all the same thing- our sense of self worth.

Some people have excellent tools because they were raised with love and kindness. Others flounder because we don't know what it feels like to be valued and treated with love. And these men are clever- they aren't assholes/ liars all the time. They create an illusion. People like us want the illusion to be real, so so badly.

So, people who judge their friends might want to look at where their own weaknesses are, and ask if they want to be judged BY THEIR FRIENDS for the amount they eat/ drink, for being too scared to enter a career you want or whatever their battlefield is

spotcheck · 28/05/2022 08:05

CounsellorTroi · 26/05/2022 14:04

This may not be a popular view on here but I think women who have had good, loving and respectful fathers are much less likely to end up with shitty/mediocre men.

I think you nailed it.

I was raised in house where I was resented, neglected and verbally abused. It took me a depressingly long time to figure out what was actually normal ( rather than what 'felt' normal. )

Anonnnnnnm · 28/05/2022 07:59

CounsellorTroi · 26/05/2022 14:04

This may not be a popular view on here but I think women who have had good, loving and respectful fathers are much less likely to end up with shitty/mediocre men.

I get what you're saying, I do. But it really isn't true. Speaking from experience.

Swipe left for the next trending thread