Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

8 year old reading grim newspaper article at school

132 replies

Pearlclutching · 26/05/2022 12:28

Name changed but have been hanging out around here for almost a decade.

I don't know if I'm overreacting and would like some advice.

DS8 and I were at the shops at the weekend, and he spotted a headline on the local paper. Something along the lines of Sex Offender Convicted of Taplow Lake Murder. He was immediately interested and said he knew all about it, rattling off accurate, detailed information about the case and the previous offences of the man responsible. He told me he'd read a big article about it on a sheet of newspaper being used to cover the table in an art class. He asked me what a sex offender is and why someone would bind and gag a woman before killing them. We haven't had a talk about sex and I really don't want his first knowledge of it to be violent and negative.

When I told my husband, he was horrified and said I should let the school know. Not so much a complaint as a heads-up.

This morning, I told the head of lower school what happened but didn't make any requests or give any opinion - just stated the facts. He chuckled, said my son will do well on the crime round at pub quizzes in future, and praised his curiosity.

Is it reasonable to expect a school to make some effort to shield lower school pupils from the details of sex crimes and sexually-motivated murder or is the head of lower school right to chuckle and say it's fine? My husband thinks I should go to the headmaster, but I'm not sure.

Really interested to know what people think.

OP posts:
Pearlclutching · 27/05/2022 07:42

Thedogshouses · 27/05/2022 04:59

Poor kid.

To clarify: we watch programmes on a screen and projector. He knows how to turn this on and has access to kids Netflix, CBBC, Amazon prime... He has a tablet. He reads children's newspapers and watches Newsround at school. We talk about the news all the time. I realise I didn't go into detail at first (not my first AIBU and should have known better) but there's been a lot of reaching going on here.

We're not anti telly: we just watch things in a slightly unusual way which means that the TV news is never on. This is a consequence rather than an active choice. He doesn't have his own computer (do all other 8 year olds?) and we don't buy daily newspapers (circulation figures suggest we're not alone here) because we have phones.

Making sure he's aware of the world does not mean I have to allow him to know about and read about everything.

OP posts:
bloodyunicorns · 27/05/2022 07:19

This thread is amazing. And not in a good way!

The number of posters who are openly sneery at op for limiting her Dc's access to the internet - it's none of your business, and a lot better for the dc than being on a screen all the bloody time.

Op, I quite agree about safeguarding. The teacher's response was poor, and there is no suggestion that he will change his ways in future and screen newspapers, so I'd probably take this further.

AtomicBlondeRose · 27/05/2022 07:08

So - all the teachers in the thread actually agree with OP and say they can do and scan newspapers for this sort of thing, and everyone else piles on her and says she’s precious and can’t possibly expect teachers to do this…

Pearlclutching · 27/05/2022 07:04

fUNNYfACE36 · 27/05/2022 06:54

I really think this is one of the most absird and precious threads i have read in a while.
Do you never have the news on at home? Have you never taken your child into a newsagent ? Or fo you blindfold him until you have censored u he articles on yhe front page? I think its a little poor that at 8 your child is not being exposed to current affairs .I.mean the news is on before the 9 pm watershed, so obviously most people are not in agreement with you

Please have a look through my posts. There's a button that allows you to see all of the OP's contributions. He's not at all ignorant of current affairs and crime, only (until recently) of sex crimes.

OP posts:
BogRollBOGOF · 27/05/2022 07:03

I've got a stack of old newpapers (2019) aquired from a relative's stash. I needed some pages to send in with my y4 for some of his media work, and due to the themes of a lot of the ongoing news stories there were a lot on unsuitable themes right through the papers and it took a few editions to find something more innocuous. There was a lot of coverage of CSA investigations at the time. However right through the paper there were stories of "adult themes" peppered through.

If I was taking papers in to cover the tables at my youth group, I'd be checking p3 and for obviously gory material, but I'm not going to read 10 papers thoroughly to make sure nothing unsuitable goes through. They'd probably look like and be as useful as a doily if I did strictly vet them!

The news is more detailed and gory than it once was. In a way that's good; compared to growing up in an era where the likes of Jimmy Saville were going about their business unchallenged. You don't get the tame free local papers any more. The ratio of paper copies of broadsheets must be down. While the teacher's attitude was poor, it's just not practical to scruitinise the full content of papers being used as disposable table coverings.

DS1 is neurodiverse and takes a lot of interest in the news. I listen to the radio a lot and I am surprised that even from the hourly headlines, that I haven't had questions like "mummy, what's child sexual abuse?". I know some days I'll have to turn off detailed discussion shows, and to be fair they sometimes put out a warning about younger listeners, but I'm not blocking the headlines for 3 minutes hourly!

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 27/05/2022 06:59

KettrickenSmiled · 26/05/2022 14:43

I genuinely don't really know what you want from this.

Oh let me take a wild stab at it @Pixiedust1234

A teacher who doesn't chuckle in an indulgent "well, sex killers will be sex killers, what can you do eh?" way about seriously disturbing content being laid out for 8 year olds to read in detail?

A teacher who doesn't brush off parental concern with "I don't need to censor material that 8 year old children will see"?

A teacher who doesn't display blatant contempt for the most basic of Safeguarding practices?

Yes, that will do for starters! Good grief.

fUNNYfACE36 · 27/05/2022 06:55

*absurd

fUNNYfACE36 · 27/05/2022 06:54

I really think this is one of the most absird and precious threads i have read in a while.
Do you never have the news on at home? Have you never taken your child into a newsagent ? Or fo you blindfold him until you have censored u he articles on yhe front page? I think its a little poor that at 8 your child is not being exposed to current affairs .I.mean the news is on before the 9 pm watershed, so obviously most people are not in agreement with you

beautifulworldwhereareyou · 27/05/2022 06:39

I mean, I am a teacher and I do give the newspapers I use for this a once-over. It’s not actually hard to do so.

bk1981 · 27/05/2022 06:09

I'm a teacher and scan the page as I put it down over the tables to make sure the storied aren't inappropriate but it's easy to miss something when you're in a rush at lunch time. I agree the response from the head was wrong though! He should have apologised.

Maybebabyno2 · 27/05/2022 05:48

Pearlclutching · 26/05/2022 13:22

@HappyHappyHermit do you think they should actively be taught about it in school, say in a history lesson about the Vikings? If not, why not?

Not the point but I would have LOVED a true crime class in school!

youngwildandni · 27/05/2022 05:09

It sounds like an unfortunate slip up by the school. I agree with a previous poster however, who commented that the teacher's response is very unprofessional. As a teacher myself, I always try to make sure there's nothing inappropriate or controversial on newspapers that I use to cover the tables for art. It just makes everybody's life easier all round.

Thedogshouses · 27/05/2022 04:59

Pearlclutching · 26/05/2022 13:07

@Pixiedust1234 we don't have a telly, don't have newspapers at home and he doesn't have a computer,

Poor kid.

Pearlclutching · 26/05/2022 20:18

HighRiseMum · 26/05/2022 20:13

Agree with this 100%

Not to go into full life history but he's neurodiverse so it's going to take a bit more time and effort to improve his emotional resilience and maturity.

OP posts:
HighRiseMum · 26/05/2022 20:13

Sittingonabench · 26/05/2022 15:10

I can understand your concern and it seems like an oversight however I have always thought that if a child is old enough to read, understand and ask questions about what they’ve read then they are old enough to understand and are trying to take that step. You say he has a higher than expected reading age and is reading newspaper articles so I would expect that he will continue to do this wherever he can. You say that he is not as developed emotionally and perhaps is sheltered - is this something that you could work on to ensure he is emotionally ready for the things he will be reading (is already).

Agree with this 100%

Dinotour · 26/05/2022 20:10

I agree the response from the teacher wasn't very good. I'm sure the school will be receptive to suggestions you have though- fund raising for the wipe clean cloths or perhaps arranging donations of the financial Times etc would be a good place to start.

PeekAtYou · 26/05/2022 20:07

Yanbu but you're doing him a disservice by not discussing things like sex (8 is pretty old not to know) His peers may be watching Newsround (it's quite common to watch it at school) so aware of stuff like the situation in Ukraine.

In the 80s, we had school newspaper with page 3 girls.

Pearlclutching · 26/05/2022 20:03

PAFMO · 26/05/2022 19:54

No you didn't.
You said you had no TV and he had "no internet"

It's like those people who say "oh I never watch TV" and then tell you about the latest series they've "binged" on Netflix.

You also said you hadn't had "the sex" talk with him yet but now you apparently have.

I'm out.

I said we had no telly. We don't. That doesn't stop us from using streaming but we don't have Freeview or sky or whatever. I never said we don't watch things.

I didn't say he had no internet - where? I did say he has no unfettered access.

I haven't had the sex talk because he didn't seem bothered. I gave him a book about human biology with a bit in it about reproduction. I tried to discuss it a bit but he wasn't really bothered so I left it. I wouldn't call this the full birds and bees chat.

OP posts:
PAFMO · 26/05/2022 19:54

Pearlclutching · 26/05/2022 19:15

At school, on my computer, on his kindle fire...

He also reads the children's weekly papers, listens to the radio and erm, talks to people.

I never said we have no media or devices, just that he has no unfettered access to TV or internet at home.

We do watch TV programmes, we just don't have a telly and so it's never just on in the background.

No you didn't.
You said you had no TV and he had "no internet"

It's like those people who say "oh I never watch TV" and then tell you about the latest series they've "binged" on Netflix.

You also said you hadn't had "the sex" talk with him yet but now you apparently have.

I'm out.

Fruitteatime · 26/05/2022 19:35

I remember doing the same at around 10 years old and thinking to myself it was really appropriate Hmm

Pearlclutching · 26/05/2022 19:32

PAFMO · 26/05/2022 18:33

The child does apparently watch Newsround.

Lord knows how.

It's interesting that he didn't tell his parents about the news story on the day that he read it, but only after catching a glimpse of another newspaper headline about it some days later.

What books does he read OP if his reading age is 15? It must be very difficult to find age appropriate books, especially given your demanding criteria.

It's just something the school told us: reading age of 15. He mainly reads from the 9-12 section. Would you have him on Stephen King and John Grisham?

What demanding criteria? He reads children's murder mysteries like Fleur Hitchcock and Robin Stevens and could probably recite every Tintin word for word. He's just finished The Secret Detectives by Ella Risbridger which begins with someone being thrown into the sea from a mail ship. I draw the line at sex crimes. I think you'd struggle to find anything like that in the 9-12 bit at Waterstones, but do let me know what you come up with.

As for not telling us, he probably didn't realise it was taboo. I try not to make any topics off limits for discussion and I attempted to answer his questions in the best way I could. Doesn't mean I want to introduce those topics myself.

To pick up on a comment from someone earlier, I have talked to him about the biology of sex, but he didn't seem like he wanted to discuss it further, so I left it. Was planning to wait until he was more curious about it.

OP posts:
Maireas · 26/05/2022 19:27

No, it's not odd having unfettered access to the internet. I would say that it's good parenting.
However, your original post about this said you'd no TV, newspapers etc, not that you were accessing them in a different format. That point wasn't clear.

Pearlclutching · 26/05/2022 19:22

Maireas · 26/05/2022 18:28

That's quite unusual. Is this your strategy for limiting access to the internet and inappropriate TV content?

No. I haven't bought a newspaper for at least a decade because the internet exists, we watch TV on a screen and projector so we don't just have it on in the background and watch things we've chosen to see rather than by channel hopping. Has been like this at home for over 15 years - long before having our son. We have laptops and he has a children's kindle fire. I don't see anything odd in not giving an 8 year old the keys to the unfiltered interwebs. He's very aware of the news and we discuss it pretty much every day, just not the bits I think are beyond his understanding (paedophilia, rape etc.).

OP posts:
Pearlclutching · 26/05/2022 19:15

EinsteinaGogo · 26/05/2022 17:10

How does he watch Newsround, OP, if you don't have any media or devices?

At school, on my computer, on his kindle fire...

He also reads the children's weekly papers, listens to the radio and erm, talks to people.

I never said we have no media or devices, just that he has no unfettered access to TV or internet at home.

We do watch TV programmes, we just don't have a telly and so it's never just on in the background.

OP posts:
NippyWoowoo · 26/05/2022 19:08

I remember being around a similar age when magazines were splashed with the murder scene of Nicole Brown Simpson. I snuck them away to read the articles and looked at the pictures, I’ve always been curious and had an interest in crime. These days I just listen to podcasts though. I consider myself to be unharmed by it.