Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Expectation at work around working hours?

139 replies

Hop27 · 26/05/2022 09:11

We are back in the office FT and have been for a while. Contracted hours are 8:30-5, however EVERYONE works more as and when required to meet deadlines, get through workload.
My boss has started complaining about everyone's timekeeping, apparently coming in late (8:15) and leaving early (5:15/30), I walked in at 8:05 and it was noted that I was 'late' lots of jibes about working part time if you leave at 5.
He wants to sit everyone down and explain the expectation is that everyone works 8-5:30/6pm - everyday and that it's respectful to ask permission to leave early or arrive late. He keeps going on about how flexible he is and will support everyone to work flexibly. Confused
If he isn't in the office he'll call after hours to see how your day was. I was on the train at 5:45, he called I answered and you could hear the disdain in his voice 'so you can't really talk because you've already left for the day and your on public transport' ....
AIBU (I doubt very much I am), I love my job but seriously how is this the way to treat people it's archaic. We are trying to hold an intervention about how ridiculous he is being!
(FWIW he is unhappy at home, it's common knowledge and uses work as an excuse not to go home)

OP posts:
SlightlyGeordieJohn · 26/05/2022 10:41

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 26/05/2022 10:32

I'm with TrashyPanda.

Why does 'loyalty' and 'dedication' only go one way? Why can an employer freely say that they'll need you to do X extra hours free, because the job needs it; but an employee (who may well already be doing that when asked, on a regular basis) saying that they'll need an extra couple of hundred pounds this month, because they had an unexpected car repair bill would be laughed at and mocked?

Being an employee doing a job is just an exchange of labour and skills for money, like any other transaction. If you've agreed and signed a contract, based on number of hours, why would you expect anything different that gives either party an unfair advantage at the expense of the other one?

That's not to say that a working relationship has to be rigidly adhered to, to the letter of the contract, but it has to work both ways. The kind of boss who will happily give you time off to see your child's school play or tell you to knock off and go home in the middle of a very quiet afternoon (with no difference to your salary/wages) is usually also the kind of boss for whom employees are willing to step up in return and come in early or stay later when there's a big workload on.

It doesn't woerk only one way. A healthy working relationship works both ways, with flexibility on both sides.

The idea here though that the attitude that's appropriate on a low-paid job that's paid by the hour is also automatically appropriate in a high-paying profession is imbecilic.

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 26/05/2022 10:39

TrashyPanda · 26/05/2022 10:32

OP isn’t getting recompense

if someone is doing their job well, it is prejudice (and bloody stupid) not to consider them for promotion because they don’t want to work extra hours for no pay.

I'm going to go out on a limb here, and assume that you aren't an employer yourself?

IncognitoAF · 26/05/2022 10:38

I've reported my own post...am an idiot!

IncognitoAF · 26/05/2022 10:36

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

TrashyPanda · 26/05/2022 10:35

What about workers who need to leave on time because of caring arrangements?

are they going to be prejudiced against too?

or should they just leave their kids standing outside the school, cos they can’t afford to pay for a childminder, because - wait for it - their employer expects them to work extra hours without extra pay?

brookstar · 26/05/2022 10:34

The informal comments are bad but a formal meeting laying out expectations of 90 minutes non-contracted hours every day breaches all kinds of employment law.

Absolutely. And they're running the risk of indirect discrimination as I imagine those additional hours would be difficult for those (predominantly women) relying on paid childcare.

Rainbowshit · 26/05/2022 10:34

What about people that need to drop off/pick up children?

Where work is expected beyond contracted hours they need to realise it's an act of goodwill and needs to be around other needs. Trying to formalise and make demands on when it is done will backfire.

Foolsrule · 26/05/2022 10:33

He’s having a laugh. Do I see a claim for constructive dismissal on the horizon?

TrashyPanda · 26/05/2022 10:32

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 26/05/2022 10:24

Without recompense? As I wrote above, my employees are still getting about £80 an hour, even if they are up towards 60 hours a week.

You are perfectly entitled to do the minimum that your contrat states, and in exchange you should expect to get back exactly what your contract states. No promotions, not front of the queue for paid overtime, and likely to be top of the list if there are job losses.

OP isn’t getting recompense

if someone is doing their job well, it is prejudice (and bloody stupid) not to consider them for promotion because they don’t want to work extra hours for no pay.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 26/05/2022 10:32

I'm with TrashyPanda.

Why does 'loyalty' and 'dedication' only go one way? Why can an employer freely say that they'll need you to do X extra hours free, because the job needs it; but an employee (who may well already be doing that when asked, on a regular basis) saying that they'll need an extra couple of hundred pounds this month, because they had an unexpected car repair bill would be laughed at and mocked?

Being an employee doing a job is just an exchange of labour and skills for money, like any other transaction. If you've agreed and signed a contract, based on number of hours, why would you expect anything different that gives either party an unfair advantage at the expense of the other one?

That's not to say that a working relationship has to be rigidly adhered to, to the letter of the contract, but it has to work both ways. The kind of boss who will happily give you time off to see your child's school play or tell you to knock off and go home in the middle of a very quiet afternoon (with no difference to your salary/wages) is usually also the kind of boss for whom employees are willing to step up in return and come in early or stay later when there's a big workload on.

BellePeppa · 26/05/2022 10:30

Unless it’s optional (and paid) I’m in at the start time and out at the end time and couldn’t care less what some tyrannical boss makes of it. I’ve learnt over the years there is no such thing as loyalty from a company so they won’t be getting an unpaid minute more from me.

minipie · 26/05/2022 10:29

What exactly does the contract say?

Is it “working hours are 8.30-5” end of?

Or is it “working hours are 8.30-5 but you may be expected to work different or additional hours to fulfil business needs” or something like that?

Mine is the latter. I am a lawyer and contractual hours are kind of irrelevant tbh, everyone knows that the real hours are whatever it takes to get the job done.

I expect many professional/managerial roles have similar contractual wording unless you’ve specifically negotiated fixed hours.

So what does yours say..?

bridgetreilly · 26/05/2022 10:26

Is there an HR department and are you in a union?

The informal comments are bad but a formal meeting laying out expectations of 90 minutes non-contracted hours every day breaches all kinds of employment law.

Namenic · 26/05/2022 10:26

Personally I think we do too much ‘standard’ contract with a lot unsaid. The truth is, the same contract will not work for everyone - some people are ambitious, saving for a house deposit; some people have other responsibilities (pick kids up, look after relatives). It doesn’t mean that those who need to be out on time are worse workers (the work they do may be equivalent quality of other people) - they may just want a different type of contract.

in order to set expectations, retain staff, increase productivity, we should offer different types of contract. People don’t just fit into a uniform mould.

Blaze1886 · 26/05/2022 10:26

I finish at 5:30, my computer is switched off by 5:25

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 26/05/2022 10:24

TrashyPanda · 26/05/2022 10:20

It's a bit sad how some poeople will do the absolute minimum that they can at work, be happy to make clear that they hate management, and would prefer not to be there at all, and then complain that they aren't very well paid, aren't being considered for promotion, and are fist out of the door when there are job losses

it’s incredibly sad that some bosses are still able to screw their employees over, forcing them to work unpaid. Who wouldn’t hate an employer that does that?

Loads of folk work because they have, not because they love their jobs - and that is perfectly fine. You don’t have to love your job to want to do a good job.

and putting in all the hours god sends without recompense doesn’t mean you are good at your job either

Without recompense? As I wrote above, my employees are still getting about £80 an hour, even if they are up towards 60 hours a week.

You are perfectly entitled to do the minimum that your contrat states, and in exchange you should expect to get back exactly what your contract states. No promotions, not front of the queue for paid overtime, and likely to be top of the list if there are job losses.

TiddleyWink · 26/05/2022 10:22

How much are you paid and what type of job is it? If you’re in a highly qualified professional role on £100k then of course working longer hours is part of that. If you’re in an admin role on £15k then he can go fuck himself.

Context is everything here.

TrashyPanda · 26/05/2022 10:20

It's a bit sad how some poeople will do the absolute minimum that they can at work, be happy to make clear that they hate management, and would prefer not to be there at all, and then complain that they aren't very well paid, aren't being considered for promotion, and are fist out of the door when there are job losses

it’s incredibly sad that some bosses are still able to screw their employees over, forcing them to work unpaid. Who wouldn’t hate an employer that does that?

Loads of folk work because they have, not because they love their jobs - and that is perfectly fine. You don’t have to love your job to want to do a good job.

and putting in all the hours god sends without recompense doesn’t mean you are good at your job either

TrashyPanda · 26/05/2022 10:16

Consult your union. And if you aren’t in a union, join one. They exist to stop crap like this happening.
There is power in numbers.

now retired, but I only worked the hours I was paid for.

its not just about increasing your wage, but also increasing your employers pension contributions, which will something you are very grateful for when you retire.

this is exploitation of workers, pure and simple.
have you considered everyone doing a work to rule - which is only working the hours you are contracted for?

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 26/05/2022 10:13

Divebar2021 · 26/05/2022 10:09

Is it a sales environment? I used to work in recruitment and the hours were long and that expectation was very clear from the start. Other environments ( banking etc ) are going to have long hours and you’d be expected to buy into that culture when you joined. Corporate lawyers aren’t clocking off at 5.00pm and saying “fuck the man”. So it slightly depends on your current job and what the industry culture is like.

It's a bit sad how some poeople will do the absolute minimum that they can at work, be happy to make clear that they hate management, and would prefer not to be there at all, and then complain that they aren't very well paid, aren't being considered for promotion, and are fist out of the door when there are job losses.

That's not about the OP, by the way, but some of the responses here. The difference in value to a company between someone who comes in each day and tries to make everything wirk just that little bit better, and someone who's obstructive, argumentative, and just difficult is huge.

TheKeatingFive · 26/05/2022 10:11

Corporate lawyers aren’t clocking off at 5.00pm and saying “fuck the man”. So it slightly depends on your current job and what the industry culture is like.

True but that's slightly different to what's going on here. The boss seems to want them in the office outside of their contracted hours, regardless of whether it's necessary for workload purposes

Divebar2021 · 26/05/2022 10:09

Is it a sales environment? I used to work in recruitment and the hours were long and that expectation was very clear from the start. Other environments ( banking etc ) are going to have long hours and you’d be expected to buy into that culture when you joined. Corporate lawyers aren’t clocking off at 5.00pm and saying “fuck the man”. So it slightly depends on your current job and what the industry culture is like.

Sally872 · 26/05/2022 10:08

I would be expect to be there in time to have jacket off and computer on by 8.30am (so 8.25) and not switch off until 5pm. Anything more is goodwill which I am happy to do a bit more in busy periods now and then so long as not obligated to, it is appreciated and not often.

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 26/05/2022 10:04

orwellwasright · 26/05/2022 09:38

So what? This is how employers take the piss frankly and it's up to employees not to play the game.

If you give your time for free you don't value yourself and you employer certainly won't.

You shouldn't judge how other employers value their staff from how you value yours.

I value all of my staff greatly, look after them as well as I can, and yes, they all tend to do more than their contracted hours.

Professions with a culture of extra hours also tend to be those with the highest pay. My staff, I think, put in 50-60 hours per week each on a 37 hour contract (there's no clocking in or out so I can't be certain), but even at the higher end of that scale they are still getting at least £50 per hour.

I can't see that someone doing 37 hours per week on £12 an hour is really winning the "game" as you put it.

thenewduchessoflapland · 26/05/2022 09:53

Are you job hunting because if you're not you should be.

This man is taking the p*ss.Where I use to work the shifts were 8 hours with a 30 minute unpaid lunch break meaning our working day was 7.5 hours long.This CF is expecting you to work the equivalent of a whole extra shift for free each week;that's an additional 52 days or based on a 5 day working week;an additional 10.2 working weeks per year;what's the equivalent of 10 weeks additional pay?