Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Expectation at work around working hours?

139 replies

Hop27 · 26/05/2022 09:11

We are back in the office FT and have been for a while. Contracted hours are 8:30-5, however EVERYONE works more as and when required to meet deadlines, get through workload.
My boss has started complaining about everyone's timekeeping, apparently coming in late (8:15) and leaving early (5:15/30), I walked in at 8:05 and it was noted that I was 'late' lots of jibes about working part time if you leave at 5.
He wants to sit everyone down and explain the expectation is that everyone works 8-5:30/6pm - everyday and that it's respectful to ask permission to leave early or arrive late. He keeps going on about how flexible he is and will support everyone to work flexibly. Confused
If he isn't in the office he'll call after hours to see how your day was. I was on the train at 5:45, he called I answered and you could hear the disdain in his voice 'so you can't really talk because you've already left for the day and your on public transport' ....
AIBU (I doubt very much I am), I love my job but seriously how is this the way to treat people it's archaic. We are trying to hold an intervention about how ridiculous he is being!
(FWIW he is unhappy at home, it's common knowledge and uses work as an excuse not to go home)

OP posts:
orwellwasright · 26/05/2022 11:17

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 26/05/2022 10:04

You shouldn't judge how other employers value their staff from how you value yours.

I value all of my staff greatly, look after them as well as I can, and yes, they all tend to do more than their contracted hours.

Professions with a culture of extra hours also tend to be those with the highest pay. My staff, I think, put in 50-60 hours per week each on a 37 hour contract (there's no clocking in or out so I can't be certain), but even at the higher end of that scale they are still getting at least £50 per hour.

I can't see that someone doing 37 hours per week on £12 an hour is really winning the "game" as you put it.

What are you going on about? Who said anything about £12 an hour? You have no idea what my profession is or was nor what my hourly rate is like.

But I'm enjoying your insistence that you value your staff who you expect to work 60 hours even though they're only contracted to work 37 but that's ok because 'they get £50 an hour'.

Lol, bosses like you are a nightmare.

Viviennemary · 26/05/2022 11:13

I agree with everyone who says new contracts must be issued otherwise there cannot be this expectation and pressure to work longer hours on a regular basis. Occasionally is usually acceptable to most folk

balalake · 26/05/2022 11:13

Regardless of the business needs, it seems to me that he is using his personal issues and taking it out on those who work for him.

If he mentions flexibly again, suggest one or two days a week working from home, so that you have some time back.

MsMarch · 26/05/2022 11:11

brookstar · 26/05/2022 10:57

In all these jobs where unpaid overtime is expected and necessary week in, week out - why isn't it in the contract?
Can you imagine having a contract stating you had 30 days annual leave and then someone saying, oh but it's only expected you take 20 of them otherwise you won't get promoted?

I can only speak for my sector ( academia) but they'd never get a contract that actually reflected the hours we work agreed by the unions or HR!!
And although we get very generous annual leave it's actually very difficult to take it all.

I worked in professional and financial services in the City for years - my contracts all said that my contracted hours were 37 hours but that I would be expected to work more as needed.

Having said that, NOT doing so would reduce bonuses/promotions. No one would ever be disciplined or accused of being late if they came in at 8:15 when official start was 8:30. I did work somewhere once were contracted hours were 9:00-17:30, but a longer day was totally standard. For me, pre-kids, it made sense to be in early so I was usually at my desk by 8:00 but would leave fairly promptly and was almost never there after 18:00 and often left at 17:30. It took my boss a while to realise that i wasn't slacking as most people (including her) tended to come in at 9:00 or even a bit later but then stay until 19:00. That didn't work for me but it took her a while to realise I wasn't slacking.

FeelTheRush · 26/05/2022 11:09

I agree with a PP - is this a 15k a year job or a 150k job? Cos the expectations will be different

Bramshott · 26/05/2022 11:09

Your boss sounds like a twat.
However, I think it also slightly depends on how much you get paid (though it probably shouldn't). An admin job on 20k - YADNBU. A professional job on 100k, maybe not so much...

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 26/05/2022 11:08

Of course I do. I'll tell you what, champ, when you run your own division of your company, you organise it how you like. Until then, please don't try to tell others that they are doing it wrong.

Yes, you organise it how you like, but however high up you get, that still doesn't mean that you can treat your employees as pawns, without needs, concerns and respect due to them as humans. I'm not necessarily saying that you are of this opinion or behaviour, but a lot of people who might have phrased it in the way that you just did would be.

I think that a lot of rot set in when 'Personnel' (suggesting 'the individual humans who work here together and make everything function') became 'Human Resources' (suggesting 'the things that we own and control, just like the buildings, desks, computers and air con, but that happen to be human').

Triffid1 · 26/05/2022 11:06

I have always worked in industries were working extra is fairly standard, particularly if you are ambitious and career driven, which I am. It's also a well paid industry.

Having said that, while I routinely arrived earlier than contracted hours and left elater, I would have taken issue with any manager commenting on me being "late" for work if I was there before my official tart time and ditto if I left at official end time. Part of the trade off of this type of working is that you do it because you want to get ahead etc but your boss knows that you're doing it and that is acknowledged. So even in super aggressive, high pressure environments where only doing your contracted hours might be career limiting, there's absolutely no call for accusing someone of being late or leaving early.

SatinHeart · 26/05/2022 10:59

OP your manager will only change if you are all on board with telling them its unreasonable (and even then its no guaranteed). If some are willing to go along with the unpaid presenteeism then your boss will just gradually replace the dissenters with bright young things who'll toe the line.

Is the salary good? I'm public sector these days and no way would you get people working outside their contracted hours like that, but that's because the pay is rubbish.

brookstar · 26/05/2022 10:57

In all these jobs where unpaid overtime is expected and necessary week in, week out - why isn't it in the contract?
Can you imagine having a contract stating you had 30 days annual leave and then someone saying, oh but it's only expected you take 20 of them otherwise you won't get promoted?

I can only speak for my sector ( academia) but they'd never get a contract that actually reflected the hours we work agreed by the unions or HR!!
And although we get very generous annual leave it's actually very difficult to take it all.

Mary46 · 26/05/2022 10:56

Same lily. I do my hours no more. Our boss a builder used to comment a guy rushing out at 5pm. To be fair he had young kids in childcare. These people must have no lives lol. I feel I put in my hours. No extra or extra monies

Dinotour · 26/05/2022 10:55

I work my hours and nothing more, nothing less. I used to stay on but I realised if you do that you just get more and more work and the scope of your work creeps upwards as it appears you can do it. Different to an over bearing boss doing it for the sake of it, but equally unacceptable. I also don't agree that just because someone is paid a lot they should deal with this either. Its one thing to acknowledge you may have to do x, y out of standard hours or be on call- another for someone to just decide to check in and change the goalposts for no real reason.

I'd go for the meeting and take your contract. Depending what you do though I'd look for something else, for many things the job market is pretty good right now.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 26/05/2022 10:54

The idea here though that the attitude that's appropriate on a low-paid job that's paid by the hour is also automatically appropriate in a high-paying profession is imbecilic.

I'm not seeing that here at all. If you're contracted to do a job, with core office hours stated as a starting point, then everybody knows where they stand. One thing that is usually the case for people in high-paying professions, though, is that they tend to be given responsibility and trust to make plans and decisions themselves as to how they work to get the job done.

It's far more commonly those on low pay who have the bosses who just see them as fleshy robots and commodities, without valuing them as people or trusting them at all. There's no culture of negotiating a fair working relationship with give and take and mutual benefit: they watch over and monitor them like hawks, determined to get every last penny's worth for what they grudgingly pay them. Respect and loyalty are a two-way street, as you rightly say.

LilyKitten · 26/05/2022 10:52

Someone has just left my workplace, and others were heard saying "The problem with X is he wants the money but only wants to work 9 - 5:30". I have also previously been told that "it's the nature of the job to work longer hours to catch up" when I was massively overworked and totally stressed. At first I really bought into that but then realised some weeks I was working an extra 4 hours a week for no extra money and no thanks. So I won't do it now. I arrive on time and leave on time.

minipie · 26/05/2022 10:52

Yes, I absolutely agree this is about controlling rather than business needs.

However if her contract does contain the “business needs” type wording, it will make it harder for her to complain about the extra time or refuse to do it, if her boss is saying it’s necessary. Not impossible, but harder. So it’s worth knowing which it is before advising what she should do.

Edderkop · 26/05/2022 10:50

In all these jobs where unpaid overtime is expected and necessary week in, week out - why isn't it in the contract?

Can you imagine having a contract stating you had 30 days annual leave and then someone saying, oh but it's only expected you take 20 of them otherwise you won't get promoted?

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 26/05/2022 10:49

TrashyPanda · 26/05/2022 10:42

I'm going to go out on a limb here, and assume that you aren't an employer yourself?

im going to go out on a limb here and suggest you don’t care much about employment law?

Of course I do. I'll tell you what, champ, when you run your own division of your company, you organise it how you like. Until then, please don't try to tell others that they are doing it wrong.

buttercuplizzy · 26/05/2022 10:48

Unacceptable. You are paid to work your contracted hours. If you occasionally need to work outside of these hours to meet business needs, this should be compensated through flexi time or overtime pay- regular uncompensated extra hours is not acceptable.

TrashyPanda · 26/05/2022 10:45

It doesn't woerk only one way. A healthy working relationship works both ways, with flexibility on both sides

the whole point of this thread is that employer is expecting the workers to be flexible and work extra hours without giving anything in return - overtime, salary increase, enhanced pension contributions, time off in lieu etc.

and that is exploitative.

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 26/05/2022 10:45

When I had a boss who was trying to enforce a requirement to do 7.5 hours work when our contracted hours were 7 a day it was resolved via an "innocent query" to HR.

HR were horrified and had a word.

I would start by asking HR to confirm core hours for your department as there seems to be some inconsistency regarding expectations around start and finish times. Hopefully HR will clarify and it will be sorted.

TheKeatingFive · 26/05/2022 10:44

Even if it is that - and many jobs indeed are - it's hardly a business need, just because a controlling boss likes to dictate that you be at your desk for regular extended hours, regardless of the workload.

Exactly.

This isn't about business needs, but extending contracted office hours 'just because'.

brookstar · 26/05/2022 10:44

Why does 'loyalty' and 'dedication' only go one way?

Exactly. I work above my contracted hours. It's very much an expectation in my role at my level. However, not only do I get paid well ( for the sector ) I get a huge amount of annual leave plus a flexibility to make the job work around my commitments.

If I was being told I had to work an additional 90mins a day, without pay at a time dictated by the company then I wouldn't be so generous with my unpaid overtime that's for sure!

TrashyPanda · 26/05/2022 10:42

I'm going to go out on a limb here, and assume that you aren't an employer yourself?

im going to go out on a limb here and suggest you don’t care much about employment law?

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 26/05/2022 10:41

Or is it “working hours are 8.30-5 but you may be expected to work different or additional hours to fulfil business needs” or something like that?

Even if it is that - and many jobs indeed are - it's hardly a business need, just because a controlling boss likes to dictate that you be at your desk for regular extended hours, regardless of the workload.

I can't speak for OP's boss, but I've worked with controlling, arrogant people in the past who make a massive play of being present. An awful lot of these people will exaggeratedly greet others, send a basic email first and last thing (as proff that they were there) and then spend ages eating, chatting to their mates, making endless personal phone calls and playing Solitaire.

Some of them would also daily berate as 'latecomers' the people who, by agreement, do 9-5, whilst they (by choice) do 8-4 and always have their coats on and bag in hand ready to go by 3:50.

Edderkop · 26/05/2022 10:41

I've worked weekends, I've logged on to do work at 9pm at night so we could complete deployments outside of business hours. I don't work extra hours for free. That's what 'extra hours to meet the needs of the business' should mean.

If that's a problem for an employer they can get rid of me with no notice (contractor). I don't have a problem finding work and don't give away my labour for free. This attitude hasn't held me back at all.